Extracting local velocity from cosmic dipole using simulations
Mohit Panwar, Akash Gandhi, Pankaj Jain · 2025
Read Extracting local velocity from cosmic dipole using simulations by Mohit Panwar, Akash Gandhi, Pankaj Jain (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-04602.txt.
Introduction
Mohit Panwar, Akash Gandhi, and Pankaj Jain propose a simulation method to extract our local velocity from the cosmic dipole, in a 2025 paper. Our motion against the cosmic rest frame creates a lopsided pattern in galaxy counts. Reading velocity from it needs two source parameters, usually handled with averages and assumed curve shapes.
Their simulation uses each source's own spectrum value and avoids assuming the shape of the number count curve near the survey limit. Applied to a large quasar catalog, the method's velocity estimate differed from the standard approach by about one standard deviation. The authors present the shift as a caution for precision cosmology.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mohit Panwar, Akash Gandhi, Pankaj Jain |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 24 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-04602
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Extracting local velocity from cosmic dipole using simulations Mohit Panwar, Akash Gandhi, Pankaj Jain Abstract Our velocity with respect to the cosmic frame of rest leads to a dipole in the number count distribution of galaxies. The dipole depends on the source spectrum, which is usually assumed to be a power law, S ( ν ) ∝ ν − α S(\nu)\propto\nu^{-\alpha} and on the flux dependence of the number density of sources. The latter is also generally assumed to be a power law, parametrised with exponent x x . The velocity can be extracted from the observed dipole once the two parameters x x and α \alpha are known. The standard procedure uses the mean value of α \alpha across the entire sample, and the parameter x x is inferred by fitting the cumulative number count, d N d Ω ( > S ∗ ) ∝ S ∗ − x \frac{dN}{d\Omega}(>S_{*})\propto S_{*}^{-x} , near the flux limit S ∗ S_{*} of the survey. Here, we introduce a simulation procedure to extract the velocity which directly uses the α \alpha values of each source rather than their mean and does not rely on the functional form of the cumulative number count near the flux limit. We apply this to the quasar sample in CatWISE2020 data and find that the final results differ from the standard procedure by approximately one sigma. 2026 Extracting local velocity from cosmic dipole using simulations – References 1 Introduction The \Lambda CDM model is based on the hypothesis that the Universe is statistically homogeneous and isotropic at sufficiently large length scale of order 100 Mpc. This hypothesis is generally known as the Cosmological Principle (CP). The Universe is expected to appear isotropic in a special frame, called the Cosmic Rest Frame (CRF). The relative velocity of the solar system with respect to this frame leads to a dipole anisotropy in the matter distribution and in the temperature field of the Cosmic Microwave Radiation (CMB). The observed dipole anisotropy in the CMB observations ( Kogut et al., 1993 ; Bennett et al., 2003 ; Planck Collaboration et al., 2014a ; Planck Collaboration et al., 2014b ) leads to a velocity (v_{\mathrm{CMB}}) of 369.82\pm 0.11 km s -1 in the direction (l_{\mathrm{CMB}},\>b_{\mathrm{CMB}})=(264.021^{\circ}\pm 0.011^{\circ},\>48.253^{\circ}\pm 0.005^{\circ}) ( Planck Collaboration et al., 2014c ) . The dipole in the matter distribution arises due to the Doppler and aberration effects. In any flux-limited all-sky survey, sources above some limit flux S_{*} are detected. Therefore, sources having flux density in the vicinity of S_{*} will move in or out of the survey depending on the observer’s velocity \mathbf{v} and position of the source relative to \mathbf{v} . The source spectrum typically follows a power law S(\nu)\propto\nu^{-\alpha} , where \alpha is the spectral index and \nu is frequency. The resulting dipole signal in the number count due to these two physical effects is known as the kinematic dipole \boldsymbol{D}_{\mathrm{kin.}} ( Ellis & Baldwin, 1984 ) . Assuming that the cumulative or integral number count i.e., number of sources per unit solid angle having flux density S greater than the limiting flux density is given by, \frac{dN}{d\Omega}{\small(S>{S_{*}})}\propto{S_{*}}^{-x} , then the kinematic dipole is given by, {\mathcal{\boldsymbol{D}}}_{\mathrm{kin.}}=[2+x(1+\alpha)]\mathbf{v}/c\,, (1) where c is the speed of light in a vacuum. Here, the factor 2 arises due to the aberration effect, and the factor x(1+\alpha) due to the Doppler effect. The kinematic dipole (equation 1 ) holds if the integral number count near the flux limit and the spectral distribution follow a simple power law. It is also assumed that we can simply use the mean value of \alpha in the distribution. Generally, these distributions may not obey a simple power law. Furthermore, in some surveys, we see a wide range of values of \alpha . For example, the spectral index (\alpha) distribution comprising the quasar sample in CatWISE2020 data ( Marocco et al., 2021 ) is displayed in Fig. 1 ( Secrest et al., 2021 ) and exhibits values from 0.46 to 11.24 with an average value of 1.26 . The distribution has different slopes above and below \alpha\sim 2 . We point out that it is the sources close to the flux limit that really contribute to the dipole. Given the large variation in the value of \alpha , it is not clear that one can use the sample mean, and the integral number count distribution need not be a simple power law. In this paper, we propose a procedure to directly estimate the velocity using simulations rather than equation 1 . This eliminates the need to use the mean value of \alpha and to estimate the parameter x . The basic idea is that, given our local velocity, we can determine whether a particular source will move in or out of our flux limit. Hence, assuming a value for the local velocity, we can eliminate the contribution of the Doppler effect on our data sample. The resulting dipole in the data sample will arise entirely due to the aberration effect and must be consistent with the input velocity. This procedure can be iterated till we find a consistent value of the local velocity. We point out that the NVSS radio sources deviate from a simple power law and instead support a modified differential power law, \left(\frac{{d}^{2}N}{{dS}\,{d}\Omega}\right)\propto{S}^{-1-x-\beta\ln{S}} ( Tiwari et al., 2015 ) . Similarly, a power law does not provide a good fit to the full CatWISE2020 quasar population ( Panwar & Jain, 2024 ) . In principle, one only requires the power law fit near the flux limit. However, if the full data do not show a power law distribution, the results may depend on the upper cut imposed, and also the error in the extraction of parameter x may increase due to the decrease in the number of sources. We point out that there is another interesting observable, namely flux-weighted number count, which samples the entire distribution rather than the sources close to the flux limit ( Singal, 2011 ; Tiwari et al., 2015 ) . Observationally, the matter dipole has proven to be more complicated. The expected dipole anisotropy in number count, estimated from various flux-limited sky survey catalogues that span the frequency range from radio to infrared, has been found to be in disagreement with kinematic interpretations ( Baleisis et al., 1998 ; Singal, 2011 ; Tiwari et al., 2015 ; Rubart, M. & Schwarz, D. J., 2013 ; Bengaly et al., 2018 ; Secrest et al., 2021 ) . The dipole direction roughly matches the CMB dipole, but the amplitude is significantly larger than the CMB-inferred dipole amplitude. The highest departure from the \Lambda CDM cosmology was reported at infrared frequency at approximately 4.9\sigma significance level ( Secrest et al., 2021 ) . The results also indicate a redshift dependence of the dipole ( Panwar & Jain, 2024 ) . These observations indicate potential deviations from the widely accepted \Lambda CDM model of the Universe. Furthermore, these are not the only observations that indicate such deviation; several others, including those related to the large-scale structure (LSS) and the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) radiation, also suggest discrepancies. Some of these observations include the dipole anisotropy in the radio polarization offset