Numerical modeling for trapped-ion thermometry using dark resonances
Muriel Bonetto, Nicolás Adrián Nuñez Barreto, Christian Tomás Schmiegelow, Cecilia Cormick · 2025
Read Numerical modeling for trapped-ion thermometry using dark resonances by Muriel Bonetto, Nicolás Adrián Nuñez Barreto, Christian Tomás Schmiegelow, Cecilia Cormick (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-04459.txt.
Introduction
Muriel Bonetto and three co-authors modeled trapped-ion thermometry in twenty twenty-five. Trapped ions serve as simulators of heat transport and quantum thermodynamics, but reading their temperature is delicate. One tool fits dark resonances — dips in the ion's fluorescence spectrum — yet that fit needs simulations of coupled electronic and motion dynamics that trade speed against accuracy.
The authors compare simplified simulation techniques, starting from a three-level model and moving to the realistic eight-level calcium ion. A cheap shortcut, mimicking thermal motion with extra dephasing, proves convenient but can bias the temperature estimate significantly. Proper calibration can counteract the bias. The study maps when each shortcut is safe, supporting dark resonances as a practical ion thermometer.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Muriel Bonetto, Nicolás Adrián Nuñez Barreto, Christian Tomás Schmiegelow, Cecilia Cormick |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 49 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-04459
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Numerical modeling for trapped-ion thermometry using dark resonances Muriel Bonetto, Nicolás Adrián Nuñez Barreto, Christian Tomás Schmiegelow, Cecilia Cormick Abstract The accurate simulation of vibrational energy transport and quantum thermodynamics with trapped ions requires good methods for the estimation of temperatures. One valuable tool with this purpose is based on the fit of dark resonances in the fluorescence spectrum. However, the reliability of the procedure is still unclear. Here, we discuss several techniques with simplified dynamical equations for the numerical simulation of the spectrum of a trapped ion undergoing thermal motion, identifying advantages and limitations of each method. We start with a simplified three-level model to provide a better insight into the approximations involved and then move on to tackle the experimentally relevant case of an eight-level calcium ion. We observe that mimicking the effect of thermal motion by means of additional dephasing is computationally very convenient but can lead to significant errors in the estimation of the temperature. However, this can be counteracted by a proper calibration, supporting the use of dark resonances as a practical thermometer. I Introduction Trapped ions constitute a versatile platform for exploring thermodynamic processes at the microscopic scale. Their ability to form various crystalline structures, such as linear chains, zigzag configurations, or more complex geometries, makes them ideal for investigating heat transport Freitas et al. 2015 ; Bermudez et al. 2013 ; Ruiz et al. 2014 ; Ruiz-García et al. 2019 ; Timm et al. 2023 , out-of-equilibrium thermodynamics Ramm et al. 2014 ; Onishchenko et al. 2024 ; Meir et al. 2018 , and thermal engines Von Lindenfels et al. 2019 ; Roßnagel et al. 2014 . For example, by tuning the coupling between ions, these systems can exhibit transitions between ballistic and diffusive transport regimes Freitas et al. 2015 ; Ruiz et al. 2014 , offering valuable insights into the emergence of macroscopic thermodynamic behavior, such as Fourier’s law, at microscopic scales. The exploration of such phenomena requires accurate thermometry of each trapped ion. For an ergodic and fully thermalized system, temperature is a measure of the mean kinetic energy. However, in trapped ion systems, the kinetic energy may vary across different degrees of freedom, leading to direction-dependent effective temperatures, which occurs due to an inexistent, or low, coupling of these variables. Furthermore, temperature measurements typically rely on ensemble averages, but in trapped ion systems measurements are often performed over multiple trials of the same system in interaction with its environment. Several methods have been developed for temperature determination in trapped ions. For temperatures above a few Kelvin, spatial spreading of the ions can be used effectively Neuhauser et al. 1980 ; Norton et al. 2011 ; Boldin et al. 2018 ; Mao et al. 2022 . For lower temperatures, in the sub Kelvin range, Doppler broadening of spectral lines offers temperature estimates constrained by the linewidth of the selected transition, which typically lies in the 10 MHz range for dipole-allowed transitions Wineland et al. 1978 ; Wesenberg et al. 2007 ; Epstein et al. 2007 . For even lower temperatures, in the micro-Kelvin range, sharper spectral features, such as motional sidebands observed in quadrupole transitions or Raman spectroscopy, with linewidths typically in the Hertz range, enable precise measurements of the thermal population of a given motion mode, but do not directly measure the mean kinetic energy of a given atom/ion Wineland et al. 1987 ; Monroe et al. 1995 ; Ivanov 2019 ; Vybornyi et al. 2023 . A particularly promising ion thermometry approach involves the use of Coherent Population Trapping (CPT), also known as Dark Resonance spectroscopy Roßnagel et al. 2015 ; Peters et al. 2012 ; Tugayé et al. 2019 . This method, which relies on a two-photon process, leverages narrow spectral lines to measure temperatures from a few milli-Kelvin down to the micro-Kelvin range. Fluorescence spectra displaying so-called “dark resonances” have been shown to provide a path for the characterization of thermal motion in this regime. These dark resonances are sharp reductions in fluorescence due to partial coherent population trapping (CPT) between different atomic sublevels. As thermal motion leads to a Doppler shift of the laser fields, thermal effects lead to a broadening and blurring of the resonances, so that CPT spectra can constitute useful thermometers. More precisely, from a fit of the depth and width of such spectral features one can obtain estimations of the temperature. Although powerful, a precise temperature measurement from a CPT spectrum requires computationally intensive fits of experimental data to theoretical spectra. As a full simulation of the coupled dynamics of all electronic levels and motional states is too costly to be practical, alternative, more economical approximations are convenient. As we show in this paper, while these approximations make calculations more manageable, they also introduce errors, causing different numerical methods to yield varying results. In this work, we analyze and compare various approximation techniques that can be used to determine the temperature from a CPT spectrum. In doing so, we determine the quality and regime of applicability of different methods in their ability to model the effect of thermal motion and to extract reliable temperatures from CPT spectra in an accurate and economical fashion, and provide practical recipes for calibration and use of these methods. For simplicity, we focus on the case of a single trapped ion. We consider the following approaches, which are detailed in section III , A) the “driven motion approximation” where we do a numerical simulation of the electronic evolution with a time-dependent Doppler shift and neglect back action of the electronic state on the motion, B) the “instantaneous relaxation approximation”, which assumes that the time scale associated with the electronic relaxation is negligible with respect to the motional dynamics, so the electronic state is calculated as the asymptotic internal state corresponding to the instantaneous velocity; C) the “sidebands approximation”, where the internal state is assumed to be periodic and the coupled equations for the different Fourier/Floquet components are solved; D) the “effective dephasing approximation”, in which the thermal broadening of the spectral lines is introduced as an additional dephasing mechanism. Each of these methods has advantages and problems and each has a certain regime of applicability, which we will discuss in detail. As a benchmark we will use the direct numerical simulation of the electronic dynamics driven by the atomic motion. This is, we will consider that the effective detuning oscillates at the trap frequency and numerically integrate the time evolution of the optical equations until the system reaches the stationary state. By taking a temporal average of the excited state population, we estimate the fluorescence of the ion. This approach assumes that the motional degrees of freedom are not affected by the interaction with the lasers, a good approximation once the ions reach thermal equilibrium at temperatures above the Doppler limit. Within this approximation, all relevant dynamics are captured by the model. However, the resulting calculation is too demanding to be practical for spectral fits; instead, it can be used to “calibrate” the computationally more affordable methods. We will assume that the motional state is thermal and can be described semiclassically. The exploration of non-thermal and quantum-mechanical regimes of the motion is beyond the scope of the