Reduced cloud cover errors in a hybrid AI-climate model through equation discovery and automatic tuning
Arthur Grundner, Tom Beucler, Julien Savre, Axel Lauer, Manuel Schlund, Veronika Eyring · 2025
Read Reduced cloud cover errors in a hybrid AI-climate model through equation discovery and automatic tuning by Arthur Grundner, Tom Beucler, Julien Savre, Axel Lauer, Manuel Schlund, Veronika Eyring (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-04358.txt.
Introduction
Arthur Grundner and co-authors cut cloud errors in a climate model in a 2025 paper. Cloud rules are a top source of doubt in climate outlooks. Pure data-driven rules can be hard to read and hard to fit into big models.
First, the team slot a clear cloud rule, found by symbolic search on fine storm simulations, into a global air model. Next, an automatic tuner resets the mixed model against Earth data in staged runs. Cloud bias fell sharply over the Southern Ocean and over low-cloud coasts. The tuned model stayed steady under strong warming. The work shows clear rules plus tuning can lift model trust.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Arthur Grundner, Tom Beucler, Julien Savre, Axel Lauer, Manuel Schlund, Veronika Eyring |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-04358
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Reduced cloud cover errors in a hybrid AI-climate model through equation discovery and automatic tuning Arthur Grundner, Tom Beucler, Julien Savre, Axel Lauer, Manuel Schlund, Veronika Eyring Abstract Climate models rely on parameterizations that account for the effects of small-scale processes on large-scale dynamics. Particularly cloud-related parameterizations remain a major source of uncertainty in climate projections. While hybrid Earth system models (ESMs) with machine learning-based parameterizations could improve current ESMs, deep learning approaches often lack interpretability, physical consistency, and computational efficiency. Furthermore, most data-driven parameterizations are trained in a stand-alone fashion and fail within ESMs, partly due to the difficulty of tuning the ESM to accommodate new, non-traditional schemes. In this study, we introduce a novel two-step pipeline for improving a climate model with data-driven parameterizations. First, we incorporate a physically consistent, data-driven cloud cover parameterization into the ICON global atmospheric model. The parameterization, a diagnostic equation derived from storm-resolving simulations via symbolic regression, retains the interpretability and efficiency of traditional parameterizations while improving fidelity. Second, we introduce an automated, gradient-free tuning procedure to recalibrate the new climate model with Earth observations. We employ the Nelder-Mead algorithm and progressively increase simulation length, making our approach simple, computationally efficient, and easily extendable to other ESMs. The tuned hybrid model significantly reduces some long-standing biases in cloud cover and radiative budgets, particularly over regions such as the Southern Ocean and the subtropical stratocumulus regions. Moreover, it remains robust under +4K surface warming. Our results highlight the potential of data-driven parameterizations when combined with model tuning. This framework is applicable to other parameterizations, offering an automatic, efficient and practical approach to enhancing climate models and projections without losing performance or interpretability. \dates This manuscript was compiled on August 8, 2026 www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.XXXXXXXXXX † † lead-author: Grundner † † author-contributions: A.G., T.B. and V.E. designed the research; A.G. and J.S. performed the research and analyzed the data; A.L. and M.S. created the concept and ESMValTool code used for the evaluation of the simulations; A.G. wrote the paper with contributions from all co-authors. † † author-declaration: The authors declare no conflict of interest. † † corresponding-author: 1 To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: [email protected] † † firstpage: [ 12]2 \dropcap When digitally modeling the dynamics of a physical field, it needs to be overlaid by a discrete grid. Processes that are happening inside individual grid cells and thus cannot be resolved may have a significant impact on the overall dynamics and must therefore be inferred from the available grid-scale information. In climate models, so-called parameterizations tackle this task stensrud2009 . It is natural to learn from data where (e.g., process) knowledge is lacking, therefore, the development of data-driven and machine learning based parameterizations has become widespread in recent years eyring2024pushing ; eyring2024pAIempowered ; gentine2018could ; grundner2022deep ; heuer2024interpretable ; o2018using . Because of their representation power, neural networks are a common choice for data-driven modeling rasp2018deep , despite coming with some clear and significant drawbacks: They often deteriorate the interpretability of climate models, making it difficult to prove their physical consistency, they degrade the climate model’s applicability to climate change scenarios reichstein2019deep , and they increase the computational burden when replacing a parameterization that used to be formulated as a simple equation grundner2024data . In the development of all types of data-driven parameterizations, the training and testing of a scheme is performed either ‘offline’ (i.e., in a stand-alone fashion on a reference dataset) or ‘online’ (i.e., implemented in and interacting with the dynamics of a climate model) grundner2022deep ; bracco2025 . Online training requires either a differentiable host climate model frezat2022posteriori or costly inverse methods ( christopoulos2024 ) , making offline training the dominant approach for data-driven parameterizations. However, these offline-trained parameterizations have yet to demonstrate consistent performance online, due to the need for a tuning step to adjust the climate model to its new parameterization chen2023neural ; morcrette2024scale . Such a tuning step usually requires a lot of time and expert knowledge. Its execution also becomes less straightforward as deep learning-based parameterizations no longer include such physics-related tunable parameters. Thus, many of the offline-trained models are never tested online, leading to increased doubts about their usefulness for climate modeling frezat2022posteriori . After all, it is not obvious that a data-driven parameterization can overcome this ‘optimization dichotomy’ rasp2021optimization of being trained in one setting while expected to perform well in a different setting. In this paper we do not only demonstrate the strong online skill of our offline-trained, data-driven parameterization, but also introduce a new automatic tuning pipeline that enables these results. More specifically, we consider an analytical equation (equation [ 1 ]) from grundner2024 that has been trained offline to parameterize cloud fraction, reducing related systematic model errors towards improved climate projections. The equation was derived from a high-resolution simulation using a symbolic regression library cranmer2023interpretable for equation discovery huntingford2025potential ; lai2024machine . It is the product of a data-driven approach that provides accuracy and yet retains the interpretability, physical consistency and computational efficiency of the traditional parameterization. However, its application in a climate model has not yet been demonstrated. To do so, we first implement the cloud cover equation into ICON-A giorgetta2018 , the atmospheric component of the ICOsahedral Non-hydrostatic (ICON) climate model. We then set up an automatic tuning procedure following a multi-objective approach neelin2010 to tune the model, hereafter called ‘ICON-A-MLe’ where MLe stands for Machine Learning enhanced. The basic idea is to tune as much as possible using simulations that are as short as possible. Here, we build on the finding that biases resulting from fast physical processes can already be identified in short simulations of a day, week or month xie2012 . Compared to other recent automated tuning methods for climate models (e.g., bonnet2024 ; roach2018 ), our tuning procedure is simpler and thus more efficient and better generalizable. We begin by detailing the tuning pipeline and its impact on ICON-A-MLe model results. We then compare the tuned ICON-A-MLe model with observations, as well as to models participating in the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 6 (CMIP6, eyring2016overview ) and to an automatically and manually tuned version of ICON-A. For the evaluation, we perform a historical Atmospheric Model Intercomparison Project (AMIP) simulation from 1979-1999, which has prescribed sea surface temperatures (SSTs) and sea ice concentrations, and evaluate it with Earth observations to assess its accuracy. For this we use the Earth System Model Evaluation Tool (ESMValTool), an established community diagnostic and performance metrics tool for the evaluation and analysis of Earth system models righi2020 ; eyring2020 ; lauer2020 ; weigel2021 ; esmvalcore ; esmvaltool ; lauer2025monitoring , recently extended to be able to process ICON output without model postprocessing schlund2023 . Finally, we demonstrate its robustness by applying ICON-A-MLe to a significantly warmer climate. Figure 1: The automatic tuning pipeline of ICON-A-MLe, i.e., the ICON atmospheric climate model including our data-driven cloud cover equation [ 1 ]. The only manual step involves selecting the climate metrics to be optimized, such as globally averaged cloud cover, and determining which tunable parameters should be adjusted. Reasonable target ranges for these metrics are derived from observational and reanalysis data. The core of the tuning pipeline consists of the Nelder-Mead algorithm iteratively searching