Effect of Rod Asymmetry on Field Distortions and Transmission Characteristics in Linear Quadrupole Mass Filters

Sukanya Jana, Santu Nath, Pintu Mandal, Nabanita Deb · 2025

Read Effect of Rod Asymmetry on Field Distortions and Transmission Characteristics in Linear Quadrupole Mass Filters by Sukanya Jana, Santu Nath, Pintu Mandal, Nabanita Deb (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-04217.txt.

Introduction

Sukanya Jana and co-authors bend a mass sorter by a hair and read what breaks in a 2025 paper. The sorter is a cage of four rods that lets one mass pass at a time, a work horse of chem labs.

In a true cage the field is clean. Shift one rod by a hair and ghost terms creep in, of the eight-fold and the six-teen-fold kind. A mock run shows those ghosts grow with the shift. Paired ghosts rise and fall as one across rod sizes. The flow of grains through the cage shifts with them, and the sharpness of the sort tracks the ghosts' joint weight. The authors give a map of how true a cage must be built.

Catalog record

CREATORSukanya Jana, Santu Nath, Pintu Mandal, Nabanita Deb
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE25 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-04217

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Effect of Rod Asymmetry on Field Distortions and Transmission Characteristics in Linear Quadrupole Mass Filters Sukanya Jana, Santu Nath, Pintu Mandal, Nabanita Deb Abstract This article reports the appearance of the octupole and hexadecapole components in the radial potential, which are otherwise absent in a linear quadrupole mass filter of symmetric round-rod configuration, if a small structural asymmetry is introduced in one electrode. Using the commercial ion simulation package SIMION, it is shown that the weightage of the octupole and hexadecapole potential increases with an increase in the asymmetry factor. A consistent correlation is observed between the octupole and dodecapole components, and between the hexadecapole and icosapole components with asymmetry added to different rod-to-field radius ratios. The transmission characteristics of the mass filter are studied for different asymmetry factors and rod-to-field radius ratios. The variation in the resolution parameter, as derived from the transmission contour, exhibits a strong correlation with the combined weightage of the multipole fields. keywords American Chemical Society, L a T e X † † affiliation: School of Chemical Sciences, Indian Association for the Cultivation of Science, Kolkata-700032, India † † affiliation: Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Hyderabad-500046, India † † email: [email protected] † † affiliation: Department of Physics, St. Paul’s Cathedral Mission College, Kolkata-700009, India † † email: [email protected] † † affiliation: School of Chemical Sciences, Indian Association for the Cultivation of Science, Kolkata-700032, India † † abbreviations: IR,NMR,UV 1 Introduction Since its introduction in 1953 by Paul et al. Paul and Steinwedel 1953 ; Paul and Raether 1955 , the quadrupole mass filter (QMF) has undergone significant advancements Douglas 2009 ; Richards et al. 1973 ; March and Hughes 1989 ; Paul and Steinwedel 1953 . While initial studies emphasized ideal hyperbolic electrodes, practical considerations favored circular rods due to fabrication constraints Dawson 1976 ; Denison 1971 ; Gibson and Taylor 2001 . QMF with circular rods appears with dodecapole and icosapole components as the dominating higher order potential terms which distort the desired quadrupole potential. The octupole and hexadecapole components are usually absent in symmetric circular rod configuration. Dawson 1976 Significant efforts were directed toward optimizing the rod-to-field radius ratio ( \eta ) to suppress higher-order field components, with critical contributions from Dayton, Denison, Lee-Whiting, Yamazaki, and Reuben Dayton et al. 1954 ; Denison 1971 ; Lee-Whiting and Yamazaki 1971 ; Reuben et al. 1994 . Several studies investigated conditions minimizing the dodecapole component, further explored by March and Stafford March 2000 ; Stafford Jr et al. 1984 . Douglas and Konenkov reported the optimal performance at \eta=1.13 , revising the previously accepted value of \eta=1.14511 Douglas and Konenkov 2002 ; Dayton et al. 1954 ; Denison 1971 ; Reuben et al. 1996 ; Lee-Whiting and Yamazaki 1971 . Konenkov proposed incorporating hexapole fields into QMF designs to enhance resolution Konenkov et al. 2006 . More recently, approaches to mitigate multipole distortions have been developed, including the harmonic balancing strategy by Konenkov et al. targeting dodecapole and icosapole terms Sysoev et al. 2022 , and Taylor and Gibson’s demonstration of improved performance through modified electrical configurations Taylor and Gibson 2008 . Mechanical asymmetries, such as inward displacement of a single rod, can generate spurious precursor peaks, which may be mitigated through voltage compensation Taylor and Gibson 2008 . Ding et al. introduced a controlled octupole component to improve resolution Ding et al. 2003 , while Bugrov investigated the role of octupole fields under a negative DC bias, showing notable resolution enhancements Bugrov et al. 2023 . A recent experimental study reports octupole nonlinear resonance in a linear ion trap with one asymmetric electrode Mandal and Mukherjee 2024 . The present work focuses on a systematic study of the multipole fields, their interplay and transmission characteristics in similarly asymmetric QMFs, an area that has not yet been explored. The general form of the electric potential inside the linear QMF is Dawson 1976 ; Ding et al. 2003 : \Phi(x,y,t)=\sum_{N=0}^{\infty}\phi_{N}(x,y)(U-V_{0}\cos\Omega t), (1) where \phi_{N}(x,y)=Re\ A_{N}\left(\frac{z}{r_{0}}\right)^{N},\,z=x+iy. (2) A_{N} is the coefficient of N^{th} order multipole and r_{0} is the radius of the inscribed circle as shown in fig. 1 . For a pure quadrupole field N=2 , A_{2}=1 and hence, \phi_{2}(x,y)=(x^{2}-y^{2})/r_{0}^{2} . The corresponding equations of motion of an ion of charge e and mass m in the radial plane are described by the Matheiu differential equation as \frac{d^{2}u}{d\xi^{2}}+(a_{u}-2q_{u}\cos 2\xi)u=0, (3) where u=x,y and a_{x}=-a_{y}=\frac{8eU}{mr_{0}^{2}\Omega^{2}},\quad q_{x}=-q_{y}=\frac{4eV}{mr_{0}^{2}\Omega^{2}},\quad\xi=\Omega t/2. (4) A rigorous analysis of field distortions and their effects on ion dynamics requires an explicit formulation of the time-dependent electric potential within the QMF. This formulation enables decomposition into multipole components, allowing quantitative assessment of deviations from the ideal quadrupolar field. Ion trajectory simulations typically employ either direct numerical integration of the equations of motion or matrix-based stability analysis Douglas 2009 ; Konenkov et al. 2002 ; Titov 1998 ; Dawson 1976 . Harmonic amplitudes ( A_{N} ) are extracted using established numerical techniques Douglas et al. 1999 ; Konenkov et al. 2010 . Alternatively, commercial ion simulation package SIMION can also be used to simulate the potential surface in linear quadrupole mass filter. It uses a potential array approach, where potentials are arranged as mesh points or grids. Electrode boundaries are defined by assigning fixed potentials to selected array points, and higher points densities are taken near the boundaries to improve simulation accuracy. The potential at other grid points are computed by solving Laplace’s equation using the finite difference method. Brkić et al. 2009 ; Blaum et al. 1998 ; Hu and Gundlach-Graham 2024 ; Shinholt et al. 2014 ; Yang et al. 2023 In this work, the effect of asymmetry or imperfection in the QMF design on the higher order multipole field contribution and consequently its transmission characteristic is studied using SIMION. The simulated potential surface is fitted to eq. 2 and the coefficients of different order terms have been determined thereby. The results thus obtained are corroborated with the results reported earlier for some symmetric setups corresponding to \eta=1.12,1.13,1.14 and 1.15 . Douglas and Konenkov 2002 A similar approach is followed to determine the weightage of the multipole terms present in the QMF with one asymmetric electrode. The octupole ( N=4 ) and hexadecapole ( N=8 ) potential terms are found to appear in such asymmetric setups, and the corresponding coefficients A_{4} and A_{8} increase with increasing the asymmetry parameter. The transmission characteristics of symmetric and asymmetric QMFs are reported in the following sections for various geometric factors, stability parameters, driving frequency, and asymmetric designs. Figure 1 : (a) Schematic of the quadrupole mass filter setup. Electrode arrangements in the xy plane in (b) symmetric and (c) asymmetric setup. r and r_{a} represent the radius of the symmetric and asymmetric electrode respectively. 2 Symmetric QMF Fig. 1 (a) depicts schematic of conventional linear QMF with symmetric circular rod structure. Four identical electrodes are placed symmetrically on xy plane as shown in fig. 1 (b). The key geometric parameter is defined as \eta=r/r_{0} , the ratio of the electrode radius r and the inscribed circle radius or the field radius r_{0} which is set as 5.0 mm in our work. The setup is housed inside a grounded chamber of radius 4r_{0}=20 mm. For potential surface simulations, a

Read the complete text