Heisenberg Uncertainty Inequality and Breaking of Isospin Symmetry in Atomic Nuclei

Sandro Stringari · 2025

Read Heisenberg Uncertainty Inequality and Breaking of Isospin Symmetry in Atomic Nuclei by Sandro Stringari (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-04191.txt.

Introduction

Sandro Stringari used a bedrock rule of quantum physics in 2025 to bound how impure the isospin symmetry of certain atomic nuclei can be. Nuclei with equal protons and neutrons should respect that symmetry, but the electric force breaks it slightly. Stringari turns Heisenberg's uncertainty limit into a hard floor on the impurity.

The floor depends on the size gap between the neutron and proton clouds and on measured charge-exchange strength. Heavy computer models of nuclei must respect it or confess error. A second bound ties the impurity to a dipole property, linking two symmetry breakings.

Catalog record

CREATORSandro Stringari
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE19 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-04191

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Heisenberg Uncertainty Inequality and Breaking of Isospin Symmetry in Atomic Nuclei Sandro Stringari Abstract The Heisenberg uncertainty inequality is used to derive a rigorous lower bound to the amount of isospin impurities, caused by the violation of isospin symmetry in N = Z N=Z atomic nuclei, in terms of the difference between the neutron and proton radii and the sum of the charge exchange monopole strengths. We show that the inequality reduces to an identity if one employs a simplified mean field expression for the isovector component of the Coulomb force in first order perturbation theory. The uncertainty inequality is also employed to derive an upper bound to the isovector dipole moment in terms of the amount of isospin impurities, thereby providing an insightful connection between the violation of parity and isospin symmetries. After the discovery of the neutron, Heisenberg introduced in 1932 Heisenberg 1932 (for the English translation see Brink 1965 ) the formalism of isospin to describe neutrons and protons as two distinct quantum states of the same particle, in analogy with the spin formalism. The question whether isospin represents a symmetry of the nuclear interaction soon became of fundamental interest in both nuclear and particle physics. While charge conservation is ensured in isolated systems, reflecting the commutativity of the Hamiltonian with the third component T_{z} of the isospin operator ( [H,T_{z}]=0 ), isospin symmetry is violated because of the non commutativity of H with the transverse isospin components ( [H,T_{\pm}]\neq 0] ) where T_{\pm}=T_{x}\pm iT_{y} . The non commutativity implies that the eigenstates of the Hamiltonian are not eigenstates of the isospin operator {\bf T}^{2}=T_{x}^{2}+T_{y}^{2}+T_{z}^{2} , with the consequent occurrence of isospin impurities in the ground state of atomic nuclei. The best known origin of such an effect is provided by the Coulomb force Bohr and Mottelson 1969 , but the role of the strong force in breaking isospin symmetry is not yet well understood. Actually, the origin of isospin violation and its consequence on measurable observables is still the object of intense research activity (for recent discussions and reviews see, for example, Bączyk et al. 2018 ; Loc et al. 2019 ; Naito et al. 2022 ; Naito et al. 2023 ; Smirnova 2023 ; Sheikh et al. 2024 and references therein). Major motivations are given by the relevance of isospin mixing in the study of parity violation effects Moreno et al. 2009 , the availability of novel theoretical and experimental studies concerning charge exchange reactions and the excitation of the corresponding nuclear giant resonances (see, for example Yako et al. 2006 ; Colò et al. 2014 ; Frekers, D. and Alanssari, M. 2018 ; Zegers 2023 ), the growing interest in neutron skin effects Yako et al. 2006 ; Colò et al. 2014 ; Kumar et al. 2024 , in isobaric analogue states Bentley and Lenzi 2007 and in general in nuclei far from stability Auerbach 1983 ; Mizutori et al. 2000 ; Lee 2005 , including Halo nuclei Frederico et al. 2012 ; Signorini et al. 2020 . Such efforts also reflect the need of a better understanding of the consequences of isospin violation on the equation of state of highly asymmetric nuclear matter, including the astrophysical implications for neutron stars (see, for example, Roca-Maza and Paar 2018 ; Chatziioannou et al. 2024 and references therein). Recent experiments with high energy collisions of atomic nuclei and in kaon production have in particular pointed out the occurrence of unexpectedly large isospin symmetry breaking effects Adhikary et al. [NA61/SHINE Collab.] 2024 ; Brylinski, Wojciech 2024 . So it is interesting to identify model independent relations involving the amount of isospin impurities and other physical (and in principle measurable) quantities. The main purpose of this Letter is to provide a rigorous inequality for the isospin fluctuations of quantum origin. We show that in N=Z nuclei the inequality provides an explicit lower bound to the amount of isospin impurities present in the ground state in terms of the difference between the neutron and proton square radii and of the sum of the charge exchange monopole strengths. We also derive an inequality for the isospin fluctuations in terms of the permanent value of the isovector dipole moment. Our starting point is the generalized expression Pitaevskii and Stringari 1991 ; Pitaevskii and Stringari 1993 \langle\{A^{\dagger},A\}\rangle\langle\{B^{\dagger},B\}\rangle\geq|\langle[A^{\dagger},B]\rangle|^{2} (1) of the Heisenberg uncertainty inequality Heisenberg 1927 ; Robertson 1929 ; Schrodinger 1930 , providing rigorous constraints on the quantum fluctuations of non hermitian A and B operators, herafter assumed to have vanishing average values ( \langle A\rangle=\langle B\rangle=0 ). Here \{A^{\dagger},A\}\equiv A^{\dagger}A-AA^{\dagger} and [A^{\dagger},B]\equiv A^{\dagger}B-BA^{\dagger} are the usual anticommutator and commutator combinations, respectively. Even if the operators A and B are not hermitian, the corresponding fluctuations represent observables, in many cases of high physical interest. The averages entering Eq.( 1 ) can be taken on a generic quantum state, usually (but not necessarily) chosen to be the ground state of the system and the validity of the inequality does not require any specific assumption for the Hamiltonian of the system. In the case of hermitian operators ( A^{\dagger}=A and B^{\dagger}=B ) Equation ( 1 ) reduces to the usual uncertainty relation \Delta A\Delta B\geq(1/2)|\langle[A,B]| , with \Delta A\equiv\sqrt{\langle A^{2}\rangle} (and analogously for B ), first identified by Heisenberg in 1927 Heisenberg 1927 for the position and momentum operators (see also Robertson 1929 ; Schrodinger 1930 ). The inequality ( 1 ) was employed in Pitaevskii and Stringari 1991 ; Pitaevskii and Stringari 1993 to reveal the consequences of quantum fluctuations in systems characterized by the spontaneous breaking of continuous symmetries and to rule out the occurrence of diagonal long range order in a class of low dimensional systems (Bose-Einstein condensates, antiferromagnets, quantum crystals and fractional quantum Hall effect), thereby providing the zero temperature generalization of the Hohenberg-Mermin-Wagner theorem Hohenberg 1967 ; Mermin and Wagner 1966 ; Mermin 1968 , which holds only at finite temperature 1 1 1 The Hohenberg-Mermin-Wagner theorem was actually derived using the Bogoliubov inequality (see Wagner66 ) \langle\{A^{\dagger},A\}\rangle\langle[B^{\dagger},[H,B]]\rangle\geq k_{B}\it{T}|\langle[A^{\dagger},B]\rangle|^{2} , where T is the temperature, which accounts for the effects of the thermal fluctuations and becomes useless at zero temperature . In Pitaevskii and Stringari 1991 ; Pitaevskii and Stringari 1993 the operators A and B were chosen in order to ensure that the average of the commutator [A^{\dagger},B] reflects the explicit signature of the breaking of the corresponding symmetries. In the present work, applied to nuclear systems, we will employ a similar procedure, where the isospin symmetry is not broken spontaneously, but dynamically, i.e. by the presence of symmetry breaking terms in the Hamiltonian. We make the choice A=T_{-}\equiv\sum_{j}t_{-,j} and B=M_{-}\equiv\sum_{j}r^{2}_{j}t_{-,j} for the relevant operators entering the uncertainty inequality ( 1 ), where the suffix j runs over the constituents (nucleons) of the nucleus ( j=1,..,A ) and t_{-}=t_{x}-it_{y} is the lowering component of the single particle isospin operator, transforming a neutron ( t_{z}=+1/2 ) into a proton ( t_{z}=-1/2) . Here and in the following the spatial coordinate {\bf r}_{j} of the j -th nucleon refers to the center of mass of the system. The choice for the operator A is motivated by the fact that the fluctuation \{A^{\dagger},A\} fixes the total amount of isospin for a

Read the complete text