SAPPHIRES: Extremely Metal-Poor Galaxy Candidates with 12 + log ( O / H ) < 7.0 12+{\rm log(O/H)}<7.0 at z ∼ 5 − 7 z\sim 5-7 from Deep JWST/NIRCam Grism Observations
Tiger Yu-Yang Hsiao, Fengwu Sun, Xiaojing Lin, Dan Coe, Eiichi Egami, Daniel J. Eisenstein, Yoshinobu Fudamoto, Andrew J. Bunker, Xiaohui Fan, Yuichi Harikane, Jakob M. Helton, Koki Kakiichi, Yichen Liu, Weizhe Liu, Roberto Maiolino, Masami Ouchi, Wei Leong Tee, Feige Wang, Yunjing Wu, Yi Xu, Jinyi · 2025
Read SAPPHIRES: Extremely Metal-Poor Galaxy Candidates with 12 + log ( O / H ) < 7.0 12+{\rm log(O/H)}<7.0 at z ∼ 5 − 7 z\sim 5-7 from Deep JWST/NIRCam Grism Observations by Tiger Yu-Yang Hsiao, Fengwu Sun, Xiaojing Lin, Dan Coe, Eiichi Egami, Daniel J. Eisenstein, Yoshinobu Fudamoto, Andrew J. Bunker, Xiaohui Fan, Yuichi Harikane, Jakob M. Helton, Koki Kakiichi, Yichen Liu, Weizhe Liu, Roberto Maiolino, Masami Ouchi, Wei Leong Tee, Feige Wang, Yunjing Wu, Yi Xu, Jinyi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-03873.txt.
Introduction
Hsiao and co-authors report a search, published in 2025, for the most metal-poor galaxies ever seen. The first stars in the universe were made of pure hydrogen and helium, with no heavier elements, called metals by astronomers. No such star has been found. Even the faintest early galaxies found so far carry a floor of metals. The team hunted for galaxies below that floor in deep images from a space telescope.
They picked out candidates whose light shows very weak oxygen signals, a sign of extreme metal poverty. The candidates date to when the universe was a small fraction of its present age. If confirmed, they would be the closest look yet at the first generation of star making. The search also tests whether the metal floor is real or a side effect of looking only at bright galaxies. Follow-up spectra will judge the candidates.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Tiger Yu-Yang Hsiao, Fengwu Sun, Xiaojing Lin, Dan Coe, Eiichi Egami, Daniel J. Eisenstein, Yoshinobu Fudamoto, Andrew J. Bunker, Xiaohui Fan, Yuichi Harikane, Jakob M. Helton, Koki Kakiichi, Yichen Liu, Weizhe Liu, Roberto Maiolino, Masami Ouchi, Wei Leong Tee, Feige Wang, Yunjing Wu, Yi Xu, Jinyi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 57 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-03873
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
SAPPHIRES: Extremely Metal-Poor Galaxy Candidates with 12 + log ( O / H ) < 7.0 12+{\rm log(O/H)}<7.0 at z ∼ 5 − 7 z\sim 5-7 from Deep JWST/NIRCam Grism Observations Tiger Yu-Yang Hsiao, Fengwu Sun, Xiaojing Lin, Dan Coe, Eiichi Egami, Daniel J. Eisenstein, Yoshinobu Fudamoto, Andrew J. Bunker, Xiaohui Fan, Yuichi Harikane, Jakob M. Helton, Koki Kakiichi, Yichen Liu, Weizhe Liu, Roberto Maiolino, Masami Ouchi, Wei Leong Tee, Feige Wang, Yunjing Wu, Yi Xu, Jinyi Yang, Yongda Zhu Abstract Population III stars (Pop iii ), the hypothetical first generation metal-free stars, have yet to be discovered. Even after three years of successful JWST operations, studies have shown that most galaxies identified to date at z > 5 z>5 exhibit a metallicity floor of Z ≳ 2 % Z ⊙ Z\gtrsim 2\%\,Z_{\odot} , possibly due to unknown selection biases toward bright galaxies or rapid metal enrichment. To address this question, we search for galaxies with low R3 = = [O iii ] λ \lambda 5008/H β \beta ratios as part of the JWST Cycle-3 large treasury program, the Slitless Areal Pure-Parallel HIgh-Redshift Emission Survey ( SAPPHIRES ). Using deep NIRCam Wide-Field Slitless Spectrscopy (WFSS) data, we report the discovery of seven extremely metal-poor galaxy candidates in the SAPPHIRES Early Data Release (EDR) field, with estimated 12 + log ( O / H ) < 7.0 12+{\rm log(O/H)}<7.0 at z ∼ 5 − 7 z\sim 5-7 , including two sources with 12 + log ( O / H ) < 6.7 12+{\rm log(O/H)}<6.7 ( Z < 1 % Z ⊙ Z<1\%\,Z_{\odot} ), significantly breaking the metallicity floor observed both locally and at high redshift. These candidates appear extremely faint ( ∼ 28 − 30 \sim 28-30\, F200W AB mag) and low-mass ( log ( M ∗ / M ⊙ ) ∼ 6.8 − 7.8 {\rm log}(M_{*}/M_{\odot})\sim 6.8-7.8 ), as expected from the mass–metallicity relation. They also exhibit very blue UV slopes ( − 2.6 ≲ β ≲ − 2.0 -2.6\lesssim\beta\lesssim-2.0 ), likely due to low dust content A V ≲ 0.2 mag A_{V}\lesssim 0.2\,{\rm mag} or young stellar ages ∼ 5 − 20 Myr \sim 5-20\,{\rm Myr} . Compared to galaxies at similar redshift, they appear exceptionally bursty in their star formation activity. Our results highlight the power of NIRCam/WFSS in identifying extremely metal-poor galaxies, from just a single pointing, with more data to come in SAPPHIRES . This underscores the potential of pure-parallel programs towards achieving JWST’s primary science goal: discovering the first pristine stars and galaxies. Deep JWST/NIRSpec follow-up observations will also be essential to confirm their nature and perform detailed chemical abundance analyses. I Introduction Where do we come from? What are we? Where are we going? These fundamental questions trace back to the first generation of stars (Population iii stars, or Pop iii ). All elements heavier than hydrogen and helium (commonly referred to as metals) are believed to have been firstly produced by these Pop iii stars [ 6 , 11 , 57 , e.g.,] . As a result, the first galaxies are expected to exhibit spectra characterized by strong Balmer lines (e.g., H \alpha , H \beta ) and He ii emission, but no metal lines [ 115 , e.g.,] . Prior to JWST, searches for such galaxies were limited, with only a few possible candidates proposed based on strong He ii \lambda 1640 emission, most notably, CR7 [ 93 ] . However, subsequent studies challenged this interpretation, citing the detection of [O iii ] \lambda 5008 suggesting that CR7 could instead be explained by an active galactic nuclei [ 8 , AGN; ] . JWST has revolutionized our ability to study galaxies at high redshift ( z>5 ), owing to its unique combination of wavelength coverage, unprecedented sensitivity, and high spatial resolution in the rest-frame optical [ 38 , 85 , 39 ] . Several novel strategies have been proposed and implemented to search for the first generation of objects. These include medium-band photometric selection [ 76 , 105 , 37 , e.g.,] , the detection of high-ionization helium recombination lines such as He ii , either within galaxies [ 109 ] or extended halos [ 67 ] , and indirect Pop iii signatures inferred from unusual carbon abundances [ 27 , 46 ] . While these approaches offer promising insights, they are inherently indirect and often rely on sophisticated modelling. Alternative interpretations, such as contributions from AGN, must also be considered and carefully modelled. A more direct and interpretable method is to estimate the gas-phase metallicity of these galaxies. Although the quest for the “Holy Grail” of metal-free galaxies in the early Universe has begun in earnest, results from the first two years of JWST spectroscopy, consistently show that nearly all galaxies at z>5 exhibit metallicities \gtrsim 2\% solar [ 74 , 24 , 88 , e.g.,] . Remarkably, despite being observed over 13 billion years earlier, these galaxies display oxygen abundances comparable to those of metal-poor galaxies in the local Universe [ 50 , e.g.,] . The reason for this apparent “metallicity floor” remains unclear. One simple explanation is the rapid chemical enrichment in the early epochs [ 41 ] . Another possibility is a selection bias introduced by conventional NIRCam color selection and NIRSpec follow-up strategies. To date, only one remarkable stellar system has shown evidence of ultra low metallicity in the early universe: LAP-1 at z=6.62 with Z\sim 0.004\,Z_{\odot} inferred from a low [O iii ] \lambda 5008/H \beta<0.2 ; [ 107 ] . Notably, LAP-1 was first identified through its strong Lyman- \alpha emission [ 106 ] , yet remains undetected in NIRCam imaging. This discovery raises the possibility that other similar metal-poor systems exist, but are either undetected or only marginally detected in NIRCam wide-band observations, and thus have not been targeted for spectroscopic follow-up. NIRCam Wide Field Slitless Spectroscopy (WFSS) enables the simultaneous acquisition of grism spectra for all galaxies within its \sim 10\,\rm{arcmin^{2}} field-of-view (FoV), thereby minimizing selection biases. As such, NIRCam grism has proven to be an efficient tool for detecting emission-line galaxies, particularly via luminous rest-frame optical lines such as [O iii ] \lambda 5008 and H \beta [ 98 , 99 , 100 , 52 , 69 , 108 , 77 , 5 , 40 , 16 , e.g.,] , which serve as key metallicity diagnostics. NIRCam’s grism mode allows for the detection of [O iii ] \lambda 5008 and H \beta at z=5-7 (using F356W) and z=7-9 (using F444W), enabling a systematic search for [O iii ] \lambda 5008 and H \beta at high redshifts without relying on pre-selection from broadband colors. In JWST Cycle 3, NIRCam WFSS became available in the pure parallel mode, enabling deep grism spectroscopy without primary observing time consumption. The Slitless Areal Pure-Parallel HIgh-Redshift Emission Survey ( SAPPHIRES ; GO 6434, PI: Egami) was designed for this purpose, representing one of the first pure-parallel JWST NIRCam WFSS programs. Sun et al. [101] presented the Early Data Release (EDR) from SAPPHIRES , which was attached to the GO 4750 program (PI: Nakajima, K.) for the NIRSpec MOS observations of the lensing cluster field MACS J0416.1–2403 (hereafter MACS0416), including LAP-1