X-ray-induced quenching of the 229 Th clock isomer in CaF 2

Ming Guan, Michael Bartokos, Kjeld Beeks, Hiroyuki Fujimoto, Yuta Fukunaga, Hiromitsu Haba, Takahiro Hiraki, Yoshitaka Kasamatsu, Shinji Kitao, Adrian Leitner, Takahiko Masuda, Nobumoto Nagasawa, Koichi Okai, Ryoichiro Ogake, Martin Pimon, Martin Pressler, Noboru Sasao, Fabian Schaden, Thorsten Schu · 2025

Read X-ray-induced quenching of the 229 Th clock isomer in CaF 2 by Ming Guan, Michael Bartokos, Kjeld Beeks, Hiroyuki Fujimoto, Yuta Fukunaga, Hiromitsu Haba, Takahiro Hiraki, Yoshitaka Kasamatsu, Shinji Kitao, Adrian Leitner, Takahiko Masuda, Nobumoto Nagasawa, Koichi Okai, Ryoichiro Ogake, Martin Pimon, Martin Pressler, Noboru Sasao, Fabian Schaden, Thorsten Schu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-03852.txt.

Introduction

Ming Guan and co-authors study how X-rays switch off the excited state at the heart of the thorium nuclear clock. Their 2025 letter concerns thorium-229, whose nucleus holds an unusually low-energy excited state that tabletop lasers can reach, the basis of a future clock far steadier than atomic ones. Inside a crystal, how that state dies away was unresolved.

Crystals of calcium fluoride carrying the thorium were dosed with X-rays, and the team watched the quenching that followed. Pinning down what kills the state, and how fast, matters because a clock crystal must protect its tick. The work is one step in turning a physics curiosity into an instrument.

Catalog record

CREATORMing Guan, Michael Bartokos, Kjeld Beeks, Hiroyuki Fujimoto, Yuta Fukunaga, Hiromitsu Haba, Takahiro Hiraki, Yoshitaka Kasamatsu, Shinji Kitao, Adrian Leitner, Takahiko Masuda, Nobumoto Nagasawa, Koichi Okai, Ryoichiro Ogake, Martin Pimon, Martin Pressler, Noboru Sasao, Fabian Schaden, Thorsten Schu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE52 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-03852

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

X-ray-induced quenching of the 229 Th clock isomer in CaF 2 Ming Guan, Michael Bartokos, Kjeld Beeks, Hiroyuki Fujimoto, Yuta Fukunaga, Hiromitsu Haba, Takahiro Hiraki, Yoshitaka Kasamatsu, Shinji Kitao, Adrian Leitner, Takahiko Masuda, Nobumoto Nagasawa, Koichi Okai, Ryoichiro Ogake, Martin Pimon, Martin Pressler, Noboru Sasao, Fabian Schaden, Thorsten Schumm, Makoto Seto, Yudai Shigekawa, Kotaro Shimizu, Tomas Sikorsky, Kenji Tamasaku, Sayuri Takatori, Tsukasa Watanabe, Atsushi Yamaguchi, Yoshitaka Yoda, Akihiro Yoshimi, Koji Yoshimura Abstract Recent studies have shown that the lifetime of the 229m Th isomer doped in crystals can be shortened by X-ray or laser irradiation, a phenomenon referred to as isomer quenching. We investigate the temperature dependence of X-ray-induced quenching in 229 Th:CaF 2 and identify a correlation with the afterglow of the host crystal. These results suggest a mechanism in which X-ray-induced electrons migrate through the lattice and are captured at Th sites, enabling isomer deexcitation via internal conversion through electron–nucleus coupling. This mechanism links nuclear decay to charge carrier dynamics in the host crystal, providing a new interface between nuclear and solid-state physics. The findings offer a pathway to optimize the performance of solid-state nuclear clocks. Introduction . Thorium-229 possesses the energetically lowest first nuclear excited state, an isomeric state at approximately 8.356\,\mathrm{eV} , denoted as 229m Th [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . It is the only nuclear level that can be excited with the state-of-the-art vacuum ultraviolet (VUV) lasers [ 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , xiao2025continuous ] , inspiring the concept of a nuclear clock [ 8 ] . In addition to the \mathrm{{}^{229}Th^{3+}} ion-trap schemes [ 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 ] , the thorium nuclear clock uniquely enables a solid-state implementation by doping \mathrm{{}^{229}Th^{4+}} into a VUV-transparent crystal [ 13 , 14 , 15 ] . These complementary approaches have enabled rapid experimental progresses in refining the spectroscopy parameters of 229m Th [ 16 , 17 , 18 ] . Recent global collaborative studies have reduced the 229m Th excitation frequency uncertainty from 6 THz [ 1 ] to 7 GHz [ 2 ] , 500 MHz [ 19 ] , and 2 kHz [ 3 ] within less than 4 years, demonstrating significant progresses towards realizing the solid-state nuclear clock. Meanwhile, it is observed that the 229m Th lifetime strongly depends on the environment. In the neutral atomic form, it was measured to be 10(1)~\mu\mathrm{s} [ 20 ] , whereas in an ionic state (within an ion trap), it increases to 2020^{+866}_{-433} s [ 11 ] . In solid-state environments, the Purcell effect [ 21 ] can alter the 229m Th lifetime; in \mathrm{CaF}_{2} , 641(4) s [ 3 ] , and in \mathrm{LiSrAlF}_{6} , 568(24) s [ 19 ] have been observed. In our prior work, we observed a tenfold acceleration of isomer decay in Th:CaF 2 crystal under 29.2 keV X-ray irradiation at room temperature [ 22 ] . We refer to this phenomenon as isomer quenching, specifically X-ray-induced quenching (XIQ), as it is caused by X-ray irradiation. Similarly, the UCLA group reported a lower-than-expected 229m Th yields in Th:LiSrAlF 6 , conjecturing the existence of quenching channels [ 19 ] . Meanwhile, the JILA group observed a short isomer lifetime of 150(11) s in a thin-film 229 ThF 4 target, compared to the aforementioned values, suggesting quenching or possible superradiance [ 23 ] . Additionally, the Leuven group found that the radiative decay fraction of \mathrm{{}^{229m}Th} varies with host material, influenced by the band gap and defect density [ 24 ] . These intriguing results stimulated further studies on the quenching mechanism. The UCLA group simulated the crystal’s band structure and proposed an internal conversion (IC) channel, where an intermediate electronic state facilitates isomer de-excitation [ 25 ] . They also observed photoinduced quenching in Th:LiSrAlF 6 and deduced its quenching cross-section [ 26 ] . Meanwhile, the TU Wien group reported laser-induced quenching (LIQ) of 229m Th in CaF 2 , showing that stimulation wavelengths below 420 nm were effective, while those above 700 nm were not, suggesting a spectral threshold. They further found that cooling the crystal mitigates LIQ and proposed leveraging it to enhance nuclear clock performance [ 27 ] . Although significant progress has been made, the microscopic quenching mechanism in solid-state hosts, especially how it varies with temperature, is still not well understood. In this work, we present a comprehensive experimental study on XIQ of 229m Th in CaF 2 together with measurements of X-ray-induced afterglow (AG) over a wide temperature range, indicating a close connection between nuclear and electronic degrees of freedom. We propose a mechanism in which the quenching of 229m Th occurs via an IC process facilitated by charge capture: electrons excited to conduction band by X-ray irradiation, then thermalized, migrating through the crystal (site-to-site hopping), and eventually trapped at thorium sites, enable IC-mediated relaxation of the isomer. In this regime, the quenching rate W_{q} for each Th isomer can be expressed as follows: W_{q}=n_{\mathrm{e^{-}}}^{\mathrm{qch}}\cdot\sigma_{\mathrm{qch}}\cdot v(T), (1) where the n_{\mathrm{e^{-}}}^{\mathrm{qch}} is the number density of quenching electrons; \sigma_{\mathrm{qch}} is the quenching cross-section; v(T) is the mean diffusion velocity of the thermalized low-energy electrons. The electron-capturing mechanism is analogous to the X-ray-induced charge reduction of Tm 4+ (Ce 3+ ) to Tm 3+ (Ce 2+ ) in CaF 2 via electron capture as observed in Refs. [ 28 , 29 ] . The v(T)=v_{0}\exp(-E_{a}/kT) denotes the diffusion velocity of the conduction-band electrons, with E_{a} representing the activation energy required for migration through the crystal lattice [ 30 , 31 ] . Here we focus solely on the temperature dependence of v [See discussion in Quenching model, Eq. ( 5 )]. The derivation of the relations connecting W_{q} to the experimental observables—the 229m Th photon yield and lifetime—is also provided in the End Matter. Figure 1: (a) Experimental setup overview. (b) An example of the expected \mathrm{{}^{229}Th^{4+}} doping configuration in the CaF 2 host crystal. (c) Enlarged view of the Th-setup, including a photo of the target crystal. (d) The isomer X-ray pumping scheme via the 29.2\,\mathrm{keV} second nuclear excited state. Methods. Fig. 1 (a) presents an overview of the experimental setup. The “Th-setup” is assembled in the BL19LXU beamline in SPring-8 (a synchrotron radiation facility in Hyogo, Japan). The X-ray beam produced by the 27 m undulator in the main ring is monochromatized by three pairs of monochromators [ 32 ] , resulting in a beam energy width of 31.5 meV (FWHM) and a photon flux of 10^{11} ph./s, which were measured by the absolute energy monitoring (AEM) system [ 33 ] and an ionization chamber, respectively. The X-ray beam ( \mathrm{1.2\times 0.8\,mm^{2}} ) is tuned to around 29.2\,\mathrm{keV} to populate the 229m Th states as indicated in Fig. 1 (d) [ 34 , 22 ] . In this work, we used a 229 Th doped CaF 2 crystal (1 mm 3 ) synthesized by modified vertical gradient freezing at TU Wien [ 35 ] . It was cut from the same ingot “X2”, as it was used for the PTB and JILA laser excitation experiments [ 2 , 23 ] . The thorium number density in the crystal can reach 4\cdot 10^{18} nuclei

Read the complete text