From Concept to Measurement: A Survey of How the Blockchain Trilemma Is Analyzed
Mansur Masama Aliyu, Niclas Kannengießer, Ali Sunyaev · 2025
Read From Concept to Measurement: A Survey of How the Blockchain Trilemma Is Analyzed by Mansur Masama Aliyu, Niclas Kannengießer, Ali Sunyaev (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-03768.txt.
Introduction
Mansur Masama Aliyu, Niclas Kannengießer, and Ali Sunyaev sort how the blockchain trilemma gets weighed, in a survey from 2025. The trilemma says a chain can not max spread, speed, and guard at once. Scores of gauges claim to weigh each leg, but they clash and split, so chain picks can not be set side by side.
The trio sifted the press on the trilemma and on chain tests. Twelve frames, weighed by fifteen gauges, take in the three legs. The map shows how each frame fits chain kinds from coin nets to log books. Past chains, spread books that sync by vote share the same trade. One shared scale, they argue, lets builders hunt the sweet front with eyes open.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mansur Masama Aliyu, Niclas Kannengießer, Ali Sunyaev |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 80 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-03768
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
From Concept to Measurement: A Survey of How the Blockchain Trilemma Is Analyzed Mansur Masama Aliyu, Niclas Kannengießer, Ali Sunyaev Abstract The blockchain trilemma highlights the difficulty of simultaneously achieving a high degree of decentralization (DoD), scalability, and security in blockchain systems. While numerous constructs and metrics have been proposed to analyze these subconcepts, existing guidance is fragmented and inconsistent, limiting comparability across studies. This lack of clarity hinders practitioners in identifying Pareto-optimal blockchain system designs that meet common non-functional requirements. We systematically reviewed literature on the blockchain trilemma and blockchain benchmarks to synthesize constructs and their operationalizations through metrics to analyze the trilemma’s subconcepts. We identified 12 constructs, operationalized through 15 metrics, that capture DoD, scalability, and security. We explain how these constructs apply across different blockchain systems and provide a structured overview that supports benchmarking and blockchain system design. Beyond blockchain, the findings offer insights for distributed database systems that rely on consensus and state machine replication. This work contributes a harmonized foundation for quantitative analyses of the blockchain trilemma, guiding both researchers in developing analysis approaches and practitioners in evaluating real-world systems. I Introduction Blockchain systems are commonly designed and evaluated against non-functional requirements spanning degree of decentralization (DoD), scalability, and security–the subconcepts of the blockchain trilemma concept. The ‘blockchain trilemma’ posits that these subconcepts cannot be maximized simultaneously; in practice, productive blockchain systems are designed toward Pareto-optimality that balances these subconcepts to meet requirements [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] . For a general intuition about the trade-offs: increasing DoD typically involves more independent validating nodes and more evenly distributed influence on consensus, but this raises coordination and network overhead, which can increase latency and reduce throughput. Pursuing scalability via larger blocks, shorter block intervals, or higher hardware baselines can improve throughput and latency, yet it tends to favor well-resourced participants, thereby reducing DoD. Strengthening security (e.g., through larger committees, additional verification, or redundancy) can harden the system against faults and attacks, but often adds computational and networking costs that also pressure scalability. In short, improving one subconcept can impose costs on the others. Identifying Pareto-efficient configurations, therefore, requires a systematic approach to quantifying DoD, scalability, and security, and to assessing the strengths of trade-offs between these subconcepts [ 5 ] . A variety of analysis approaches, such as BBSF [ 6 ] , BLOCKBENCH [ 7 ] , Diablo [ 8 ] , and the simulator SimBlock [ 9 , 2 ] , operationalize these subconcepts using different constructs and metrics. 1 1 1 A metric is a mapping from inputs (e.g., counts, shares, or times) to a quantitative output used to operationalize a construct. For DoD, examples include the construct of block-proposal randomness [ 10 , 11 , 12 ] and the construct of wealth distribution [ 13 , 2 , 14 , 15 ] , each with multiple candidate metrics. However, heterogeneous operationalizations hinder comparability across studies and leave practitioners with limited guidance when selecting constructs and metrics aligned with their questions. Selecting suitable constructs and metrics is further complicated by conceptual ambiguities around the trilemma. Some works map the trilemma’s subconcepts to distributed systems, such as the CAP theorem [ 16 , 17 ] , but such mappings are necessarily partial, as they address only subsets of the subconcepts or blend constructs across them. This makes it difficult to argue, in a principled way, why a particular construct or metric is appropriate for a given analysis. To support more consistent, defensible choices, we pose the following research question: Which constructs and associated metrics are suitable to quantify the blockchain trilemma’s subconcepts? We conducted a systematic literature search to identify publications that propose constructs or metrics for analyzing DoD, scalability, or security [ 18 ] . Using abductive thematic analysis, we iteratively synthesized constructs and their associated metrics [ 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 ] . This process was guided by the interplay between empirical findings and conceptual framing, supplemented by targeted theoretical sampling to address gaps and validate emerging insights. Based on this analysis, we developed an overview of analysis approaches that apply these constructs and metrics to investigate the blockchain trilemma. This work contributes to purposeful evaluation of blockchain systems under the trilemma in three ways. First, we synthesize common constructs and their operationalization through metrics, explaining their applicability, interpretability, and limitations for analyzing DoD, scalability, and security. Second, by clarifying the input variables of these metrics, we support data collection in benchmarks (e.g., which system characteristics must be monitored to feed relevant metrics). Third, by comparing analysis approaches based on their choice of constructs and metrics, we guide the selection of suitable approaches for future investigations. The remainder of this work is structured as follows. Section II introduces the foundations of blockchain technology, including the manifestation of the blockchain trilemma and existing conceptual and empirical attempts to operationalize its subconcepts. Section III describes our literature search and analysis. Section IV presents principal constructs and metrics for operationalizing the blockchain trilemma’s subconcepts, alongside analysis approaches that implement them. Section V discusses our findings, contributions to practice and research, limitations, and open research directions. Finally, Section VI concludes with key takeaways. II Theoretical Foundations and Related Research The blockchain trilemma has been identified for blockchain systems, in which a high DoD, scalability, and security are desirable. This section introduces the system model to which the blockchain trilemma applies and explains how design choices shape its manifestation. Subsection II-A briefly explains the foundations of such distributed databases, including a system model upon which this work mainly relies. Using the system model, we introduce the blockchain trilemma’s subconcepts and describe trade-offs between them. Subsection II-C gives an overview of related research on the blockchain trilemma. II-A Blockchain Technology and System Model Blockchain technology enables the operation of blockchain systems, a class of replicated databases with consensus. The database is maintained by multiple validating nodes , which contribute to one or more consensus-critical tasks, such as processing transactions and maintaining the ledger state. We use validating node as a generic umbrella term rather than a protocol-specific role name. Not all validating nodes necessarily perform every function: some participate only in ordering, whereas others also validate blocks, execute transactions to update the ledger state, and store the resulting data. Across blockchain system designs, the specialization of validating nodes differs, particularly in terms of how they are involved in executing the consensus protocol and ledger replication. In the Bitcoin system, miners (block producers) assemble candidate blocks by selecting and ordering pending transactions; the canonical global order of blocks then emerges from proof-of-work (PoW) competition and the longest-work fork-choice rule [ 23 , 24 ] . Full nodes, which may or may not be miners, validate blocks and maintain the ledger, based on unspent transaction outputs (UTXOs). In the Ethereum system 2 2 2 Unless otherwise specified, “Ethereum” refers to the post-Merge system (often called “Ethereum 2.0” in earlier literature). , validators are assigned to propose blocks in time slots, while other validators in committees attest to proposed blocks. Ethereum nodes typically run paired consensus and execution clients : the consensus client manages fork choice and finality, while the execution client processes transactions