A Communication-First Account of Explanation

Jacqueline Harding, Tobias Gerstenberg, Thomas Icard · 2025

Read A Communication-First Account of Explanation by Jacqueline Harding, Tobias Gerstenberg, Thomas Icard (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-03732.txt.

Introduction

Jacqueline Harding and co-authors offered in 2025 a communication-first theory of causal explanation. On their account, explaining is a conversational act built around what-if questions: what would differ if things had gone another way. The framework borrows that interventionist core and grounds it in a formal theory of how conversation works. Explanation thus answers an audience, not just a fact.

The test of the theory is whether known virtues of good explanations fall out of it naturally. They do, the authors show, along with subtle patterns in how social norms bend causal judgments. Earlier accounts had to bolt those patterns on. The authors argue philosophy of explanation should start from its communicative role. Their framework is meant as a bridge, letting cognitive science findings flow into philosophical models of explanation.

Catalog record

CREATORJacqueline Harding, Tobias Gerstenberg, Thomas Icard
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE103 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-03732

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Communication-First Account of Explanation Jacqueline Harding, Tobias Gerstenberg, Thomas Icard Abstract This paper develops a formal account of causal explanation, grounded in a theory of conversational pragmatics, and inspired by the interventionist idea that explanation is about asking and answering what-if-things-had-been-different questions. We illustrate the fruitfulness of the account, relative to previous accounts, by showing that widely recognised “explanatory virtues” emerge naturally, as do subtle empirical patterns concerning the impact of norms on causal judgments. This shows the value of a “communication-first” approach to explanation: getting clear on explanation’s communicative dimension is an important prerequisite for philosophical work on explanation. The result is a simple but powerful framework for incorporating insights from the cognitive sciences into philosophical work on explanation, which will be useful for philosophers or cognitive scientists interested in explanation. 1 Introduction The philosophical problem of explanation is usually taken to be a matter of locating the right explanatory relations in the world, with human interests and capacities offered a marginal role. Although philosophers of explanation will agree that some explanatory virtues are better accounted for in terms of ‘pragmatic’ factors (those involving background knowledge or downstream interests), they take this to show that these virtues are peripheral to the core of the explanatory project. Strevens (2008, p.7) gives clear voice to this perspective: “To discern the nature of explanation in the ontological sense, you must acquire the ability to see past the communicative conventions and strategies of scientists to the explanatory facts themselves. A philosopher of explanation will therefore occasionally discuss communicative conventions, just as an astronomer might study atmospheric distortion so as to more clearly see the stars”. It is tempting, then, to think of the philosophy of explanation and the psychology of explanation as separate subjects. While the philosophical literature has exerted considerable influence on the way psychologists investigate explanation ( Hilton, 1990 ; Lombrozo, 2006 ; Keil, 2006 ; Goddu and Gopnik, 2024 ) , philosophers have been more reluctant to incorporate insights from psychology and cognitive science into their accounts. Even interventionists, who motivate their account by gesturing to the downstream usefulness of causal information, eschew pragmatic factors in the account’s actual development ( Woodward, 2003 ; Woodward and Hitchcock, 2003 ) . Here’s the question, then, which motivates our paper: what would happen if we ‘put communication first’ ( Potochnik, 2016 ) in developing an account of explanation? Building on recent advances in cognitive science and formal pragmatics ( Frank and Goodman, 2012 ; Goodman and Frank, 2016 ; Degen, 2023 ; Sumers et al., 2023 ; Beller and Gerstenberg, 2024 ) , we direct attention to the question of what a speaker is doing when she offers an explanation to a listener. Our main claim is that several hallmarks of explanation – including key features that were explicitly built in to previous formalisations – simply (and softly) emerge from the dynamics of conversation together with the minimal assumption that “why” and “because” communicate relations of (typically causal) dependence. Many philosophers have stressed the relevance of conversational and cognitive considerations in characterising explanation ( Bromberger, 1965 ; Bromberger, 1984 ; van Fraassen, 1977 ; van Fraassen, 1980 ; Achinstein, 1983 ; Ylikoski and Kuorikoski, 2010 ; De Regt and Dieks, 2005 ; De Regt, 2017 ; Potochnik, 2016 ; Potochnik, 2017 ) , but these proposals have largely remained programmatic and informal. 1 1 1 Attempts to treat explanation formally have tended to ignore pragmatic factors. The first formal theories of explanation involved sets of sentences closed under logical deduction (that is, logical “theories”; see Hempel and Oppenheim (1948) ), statistical models and probability distributions ( Douven, 2022 ; Hempel, 1965 ; Salmon, 1971 ) , and even physical models of spacetime ( Dowe, 1992 ; Salmon, 1998 ) . Some of these accounts are given an ontic gloss (e.g. Salmon 1998 ), in that the components are intended to refer to objective features of the world; others are given a more epistemic gloss (e.g. Hempel and Oppenheim 1948 ), in that they are relative to a body of evidence. As Woodward and Ross (2021) have pointed out ( Woodward, 2021b , see also) , most prominent philosophical accounts of explanation that stress the importance of psychological facts and interests nevertheless engage very little with work in the cognitive sciences on how people in fact produce and interpret explanations. By contrast, our formal account is developed using tools from contemporary cognitive science; this suggests a promising future avenue for incorporating psychological work into the philosophy of explanation. 2 Preliminaries: Context and Causation The starting point for ‘pragmatic’ theories of explanation is a simple observation: explanations are acts of communication, paradigmatically answers to “why?” questions ( Hempel and Oppenheim, 1948 ; Bromberger, 1965 ) . This suggests that to analyse explanation, one must account for the context of communication. 2.1 Communicative Context Communicative context affects what is being explained. Asking “Why \mathsf{FACT} ?” (where \mathsf{FACT} is an explanandum , a proposition to be explained) is typically understood relative to a set of relevant alternatives to \mathsf{FACT} , which varies with context ( van Fraassen 1980 ; see also Woodward 2003, Section 5.12 and Ylikoski 2007 ). The question “Why did Adam eat the apple?” can – depending on whether stress is placed on “Adam” or “apple” ( Dretske, 1972 ) – be a request for information about why Adam (rather than someone else) ate the apple, or about why Adam ate the apple (rather than something else) ( van Fraassen, 1980 , p.127) . Most philosophers will grant this. Pragmatic theories, though, take this idea further: to judge whether a candidate explanation is successful, one must know what prompted the need for the explanation in the first place, and what it would take to satisfy that need. Consider a variant of an example from Gärdenfors (1980) . Example 1 (Holiday Tan) . Alice sees her friend Bob after returning from a work trip to Rome. She is noticeably more tanned than when Bob last saw her; he asks, ‘why are you so tanned?’. She replies, ‘I was just in Rome!’. We can make two observations here. First, given what Bob already knows, he can – upon hearing Alice’s answer – reasonably infer that it was sunny when she was in Rome, that she spent time outside while she was there, and so on. What makes it seem like a good explanation is, at least in part, that Bob is able to draw all of these conclusions from Alice’s answer. Second, if Bob also happens to know that it was raining in Rome all week, then it is not as good of an explanation. It may also be a poor explanation if Bob already knows that Alice was in Rome. In such contexts, the explanatory question evidently persists even after Alice’s statement. Both observations suggest that communicative context is relevant to assessing the explanation given. When successful, Alice’s answer to Bob’s question demystifies a fact that was initially surprising, or worthy of explanation. Given what Bob already knows, he is able to trace the sequence of events that led to Alice’s tan; rather than being peripheral to explanation, contextual facts (such as Bob’s

Read the complete text