Cosmic strings and domain walls of the QCD quark condensate with and without a hidden axion.

Gia Dvali, Lucy Komisel, Anja Stuhlfauth · 2025

Read Cosmic strings and domain walls of the QCD quark condensate with and without a hidden axion. by Gia Dvali, Lucy Komisel, Anja Stuhlfauth (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-03542.txt.

Introduction

Gia Dvali, Lucy Komisel, and Anja Stuhlfauth examined the string and wall structures that arise from the quark condensate of quantum chromodynamics. That theory covers the strong force. When the condensate settles, it twists the theory's axial symmetry. It leaves behind thread-like strings and sheet-like walls, much as an axion field would. If a hidden Peccei-Quinn axion exists, the condensate winds around those strings in one of two directions. It may go through the eta-prime particle or through the pion.

That choice changes the particle modes living on the strings and how anomalies flow, with consequences for astrophysics. The trio stress that these systems exist in plain QCD with no hidden axion at all. They may even have dominated the early universe, shaping the QCD phase transition.

Catalog record

CREATORGia Dvali, Lucy Komisel, Anja Stuhlfauth
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE78 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-03542

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Cosmic strings and domain walls of the QCD quark condensate with and without a hidden axion. Gia Dvali, Lucy Komisel, Anja Stuhlfauth Abstract The chiral quark condensate of QCD, which spontaneously breaks the anomalous axial symmetry, gives rise to axionic type global string-wall systems. If a Peccei-Quinn type axion exists in the theory, the axionic strings are in general accompanied by winding of the QCD quark condensate. Depending on the axion model the winding can proceed either in the η ′ \eta^{\prime} or in the pion direction. This determines the structure of fermionic zero modes and the anomaly inflow which has important astrophysical consequences. We point out that η ′ \eta^{\prime} and pion string-wall systems exist in pure QCD, independently of the hidden axion. Strikingly, even if a hidden axion exists, the early cosmology can be entirely dominated by string-wall systems formed by the QCD quark condensate. We also discuss their role in the QCD phase transition and in heavy-ion physics. I Introduction The chiral symmetry of quarks is spontaneously broken by the chiral quark condensate. At the same time, this chiral symmetry is explicitly broken by quark masses as well as by the chiral anomaly. Due to the explicit breaking, the would-be massless Nambu-Goldstone bosons, such as the pions and the \eta^{\prime} -meson, gain non-zero masses. Since no spontaneously broken discrete subgroup survives this explicit breaking, the vacuum of the chiral symmetry is topologically trivial without truly stable topological defects. However, from the point of view of various cosmological and phenomenological implications the unstable defects are no less interesting. In this work, we point out that, despite the above limitations, there exist non-trivial winding configurations corresponding to 2\pi -domain walls bounded by strings. The windings take place in two major flavor directions corresponding to the pseudo-Nambu-Goldstone bosons \eta^{\prime} or \pi^{0} . However, winding in other directions such as the \eta -meson is also possible. If a hidden Peccei-Quinn QCD axion exists in nature, the axionic strings and walls are in general accompanied by windings of the phases of the QCD quark condensate. This has important implications for the zero mode content of axionic strings and, correspondingly, for their superconductivity properties [ 1 ] as well as the dynamics of the anomaly inflow [ 2 ] . However, more importantly, the QCD 2\pi -string-wall systems can exist regardless of the hidden axion. As we shall explain in detail, a simple way to understand this is that the \eta^{\prime} -meson of QCD represents an axion, albeit of poor quality, which directly probes the physics of the QCD \theta -vacuum. In particular, in the limit of a vanishing quark mass, the \eta^{\prime} -meson fully cancels the vacuum \theta -angle [ 3 ] . The non-zero quark mass offsets this cancellation but does preserve the axion-like nature of the \eta^{\prime} -meson. Correspondingly, the \eta^{\prime} -meson mirrors the structures usually discussed only in the context of a hidden axion, such as domain walls bounded by cosmic strings. Since the vacuum of QCD is 2\pi -periodic in the phases of the quark condensate, the phases change across the wall by multiples of 2\pi . We shall refer to such domain walls as 2\pi -walls. A planar infinite wall is classically stable. Although via a quantum tunneling process a hole can be punched through it, the probability is highly suppressed. Of course, in reality, infinite walls never form. Instead, they materialize during phase transitions in the form of closed bubbles or as walls bounded by cosmic strings. Such structures collapse and radiate energy in various modes, including electromagnetic radiation as well as gravitational waves. String-wall systems formed by the QCD condensate can have particularly important cosmological implications in scenarios with an early epoch QCD phase transition [ 4 ] . From the low energy perspective of the theory of mesons, the QCD condensate string-wall systems represent solitonic states. We discuss their potential manifestations in heavy-ion experiments. II Strong-CP puzzle In the standard discussion (which ignores gravity) the strong- CP puzzle is formulated as the following naturalness problem. QCD has a continuum of vacua conventionally labeled by the CP -violating vacuum angle \theta [ 5 , 6 ] . These vacua belong to different superselection sectors. The choice of the vacuum is accounted for by the following term in the Lagrangian, \frac{g^{2}}{32\pi^{2}}\,\bar{\theta}\,G_{\mu\nu}\tilde{G}^{\mu\nu}\,, (1) where G_{\mu\nu} is the gluon field strength and \tilde{G}^{\mu\nu}\equiv\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}G_{\alpha\beta} is its dual. In the rest of this paper, we will drop the constants in front, including the strong coupling constant g . In a theory with massive quarks, the physically measurable parameter is the quantity \bar{\theta}\equiv\theta+{\rm arg(det\ M_{q}}) , where {\rm arg(det\ M_{q})} is the phase of the determinant of the quark mass matrix. In the quantum theory, the \bar{\theta} -term induces an electric dipole moment of the neutron (nEDM) [ 7 , 8 ] , denoted as d_{n} . The comparison of the resulting theoretical value with the current experimental limit, |d_{n}|<2.9\times 10^{-26}e cm [ 9 , 10 , 11 ] , gives the bound |\bar{\theta}|\lesssim 10^{-9}\,. (2) Notice that there exists an additional contribution to the nEDM coming from the breaking of CP -symmetry by the weak interaction [ 12 , 13 , 14 ] . However, this correction is too small to affect the current bound ( 2 ). Thus, observations indicate that we live in a sector with a minuscule or zero \bar{\theta} . This is puzzling. III Peccei-Quinn solution Let us consider the Peccei-Quinn solution [ 15 , *Peccei:1977ur ] which is based on removing \bar{\theta} by an anomalous chiral symmetry U(1)_{PQ} . For simplicity, let us consider a single quark flavor, \Psi , that transforms under the symmetry as \Psi\rightarrow{\rm e}^{i\frac{1}{2}\alpha\gamma_{5}}\Psi\,. (3) Due to the chiral anomaly, the current exhibits an anomalous divergence: \partial^{\mu}(\bar{\Psi}\gamma_{\mu}\gamma_{5}\Psi)\ \propto G\tilde{G}. (4) Correspondingly, the Lagrangian shifts as \delta\mathcal{L}\,\propto\,\alpha\,G\tilde{G}. (5) Thus, the \bar{\theta} -term can be removed by the chiral U(1)_{PQ} transformation, \bar{\theta}\rightarrow\bar{\theta}-\alpha. (6) This indicates that \bar{\theta} is unphysical. The fact that, in the presence of an anomalous chiral symmetry, the \bar{\theta} -term is unphysical can also be understood in the language of instanton zero modes. According to the index theorem, each spin- 1/2 quark deposits a chiral zero mode in the instanton background. These modes kill the instanton effect. However, in nature there exist no massless quarks. Therefore, the U(1)_{PQ} -symmetry must be spontaneously broken by the vacuum expectation value (VEV) of a complex scalar field \Phi(x)=\rho(x){\rm e}^{i\theta_{\phi}(x)} , which under the U(1)_{PQ} transforms as \Phi\rightarrow{\rm e}^{i\alpha}\Phi\,. (7) The modulus of the scalar gets a VEV, \langle\rho\rangle=f_{\phi} , from the Mexican-hat (Goldstone) potential V(\Phi)=\lambda^{2}(\Phi^{*}\Phi-f_{\phi}^{2})^{2}\,, (8) where \lambda is a coupling constant. This gives a mass, M_{\Psi}=g_{\Psi}f_{\phi} , to the fermion through a Yukawa coupling in the fermion Lagrangian \mathcal{L}_{\Psi}\,=\,i\bar{\Psi}_{L,R}\gamma^{\mu}D_{\mu}\Psi_{L,R}-g_{\Psi}\Phi^{*}\,\bar{\Psi}_{L}\Psi_{R}\,+{\rm h.c}., (9) where we have written the Dirac spinors \Psi=\Psi_{L}+\Psi_{R} in terms of left-right components, g_{\Psi} is the Yukawa coupling constant and D_{\mu} is the covariant derivative with respect to the gauge symmetry. The Nambu-Goldstone phase, \theta_{\phi}(x) , is the axion [ 17 , *Wilczek:1977pj ] , which in terms of a canonically normalized field \phi(x) can be written as \theta_{\phi}(x)\equiv\frac{\phi(x)}{\sqrt{2}f_{\phi}} . Taking the anomaly into account, the effective theory of the axion is 1 1 1 Notice that, since in this simplified

Read the complete text