Real-time small area estimation of food security in Zimbabwe: integrating mobile-phone and face-to-face surveys using joint multilevel regression and poststratification
Sahoko Ishida, Adam Howes, Valerie Bradley, Elizaveta Semenova, Theo Rashid, Silinganisiwe Dzumbunu, Sumali Bajaj, Gaurav Singhal, Dino Sejdinovic, Herbert Zvirere, Duccio Piovani, Silvia Passeri, Kusum Hachhethu, Arif Husain, George D. Kembo, Terrence Kairiza, Seth Flaxman · 2025
Read Real-time small area estimation of food security in Zimbabwe: integrating mobile-phone and face-to-face surveys using joint multilevel regression and poststratification by Sahoko Ishida, Adam Howes, Valerie Bradley, Elizaveta Semenova, Theo Rashid, Silinganisiwe Dzumbunu, Sumali Bajaj, Gaurav Singhal, Dino Sejdinovic, Herbert Zvirere, Duccio Piovani, Silvia Passeri, Kusum Hachhethu, Arif Husain, George D. Kembo, Terrence Kairiza, Seth Flaxman (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-03517.txt.
Introduction
Sahoko Ishida and a large team of co-authors present a 2025 paper on tracking food security in Zimbabwe in near real time. Fast, local hunger data guide timely aid, in line with the global zero hunger goal. Phone surveys are frequent but thin at small scales, while yearly face-to-face surveys are representative but slow. The team joins both in one statistical method that corrects for how each survey mode skews answers.
Their approach blends the phone data's freshness with the yearly survey's local reach. It produces estimates for smaller areas and shorter spans than either source alone, with honest measures of uncertainty. A full Bayesian setup handles the blending. The authors show the method working on Zimbabwean data. They present it as a low-cost way to monitor food security where resources are tight and decisions cannot wait.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sahoko Ishida, Adam Howes, Valerie Bradley, Elizaveta Semenova, Theo Rashid, Silinganisiwe Dzumbunu, Sumali Bajaj, Gaurav Singhal, Dino Sejdinovic, Herbert Zvirere, Duccio Piovani, Silvia Passeri, Kusum Hachhethu, Arif Husain, George D. Kembo, Terrence Kairiza, Seth Flaxman |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 67 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-03517
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Real-time small area estimation of food security in Zimbabwe: integrating mobile-phone and face-to-face surveys using joint multilevel regression and poststratification Sahoko Ishida, Adam Howes, Valerie Bradley, Elizaveta Semenova, Theo Rashid, Silinganisiwe Dzumbunu, Sumali Bajaj, Gaurav Singhal, Dino Sejdinovic, Herbert Zvirere, Duccio Piovani, Silvia Passeri, Kusum Hachhethu, Arif Husain, George D. Kembo, Terrence Kairiza, Seth Flaxman Abstract Real-time, fine-grained monitoring of food security is essential for enabling timely and targeted interventions, thereby supporting the global goal of achieving zero hunger—a key objective of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. Mobile phone surveys provide a scalable and temporally rich data source that can be tailored to different administrative levels. However, due to cost and operational constraints, maintaining high-frequency data collection while ensuring representativeness at lower administrative levels is often infeasible. We propose a joint multilevel regression and poststratification (jMRP) approach that combines high-frequency and up-to-date mobile phone survey data, designed for higher administrative levels, with an annual face-to-face survey representative at lower levels to produce reliable food security estimates at spatially and temporally finer scales than those originally targeted by the surveys. This methodology accounts for systematic differences in survey responses due to modality and socio-economic characteristics, reducing both sampling and modality bias. We implement the approach in a fully Bayesian manner to quantify uncertainty. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our method using data from Zimbabwe, thus offering a cost-effective solution for real-time monitoring and strengthening decision-making in resource-constrained settings. 1 Introduction Food security remains a critical global challenge. According to the latest State of Food Security and Nutrition in the World report ( FAO et al.,, 2024 ) , approximately 733 million people experienced hunger in 2023, equivalent to one in eleven individuals globally and one in five in Africa. This emergency is driven by a complex interplay of factors, including climate and environmental shocks, economic instability, and political conflicts. As such, real-time, spatially granular monitoring of food security is essential for governments and organisations like the World Food Programme (WFP) to effectively plan aid, assistance, and preemptive actions to mitigate the impacts of food crises. Traditionally, face-to-face (F2F) surveys have been the gold standard for estimating food security indicators. However, they are resource-intensive and often too costly and impractical for frequent data collection, especially in remote or unstable areas. In contrast, mobile phone surveys offer a more scalable and cost-effective alternative. An example is the WFP’s mobile-phone surveys, extensively used in the Mobile Vulnerability Analysis and Mapping (mVAM) project to monitor food security in areas with restricted humanitarian access. Following successful pilots in the Democratic Republic of Congo and Somalia, the project expanded, becoming operational in multiple countries and a vital tool for WFP, exemplified during the 2014 Ebola Virus Disease emergency response. The project subsequently evolved to incorporate a continuous, real-time monitoring system built on systematic daily data collection ( World Food Programme,, 2021 ) . This transformation enhanced WFP’s capacity to trigger timely interventions, mitigate risks, and respond more effectively to future shocks. The design of mVAM surveys varies across countries based on operational priorities and resource constraints. These factors determine key aspects of survey implementation, including geographic coverage, frequency, and the administrative level at which the survey is designed to produce reliable estimates. In many cases, collecting sufficiently large samples at high frequency to cover all lower administrative areas is financially infeasible. As a result, some countries collect data at finer spatial scales (e.g., the second or third administrative level) only for specific areas rather than nationwide or conduct surveys at these levels less frequently. In other cases, surveys are designed for frequent data collection at the first administrative level to support high-level surveillance, while other data sources are used for local-level targeting. Given these constraints, developing methodologies that provide reliable lower administrative-level estimates from surveys originally designed for higher administrative-level analysis is beneficial, allowing for more efficient use of limited resources and enabling real-time food security monitoring at high spatial resolution. Additionally, mobile-phone-based surveys are subject to two types of biases: sampling bias and modality bias. Mobile phone surveys reach only individuals with phone access, which can contribute to sampling bias if phone ownership is linked to socio-demographic characteristics that influence food security, potentially leading to over- or under-representation of specific population groups. To mitigate this, WFP applies poststratification using demographic and geographic weights derived from nationally representative surveys. Households are weighted based on key socio-demographic characteristics, such as education level, to better align the sample with the target population. However, when attempting to obtain estimates at finer spatial scales than the survey was designed for, poststratification becomes less straightforward due to limited sample sizes, reducing the ability to adjust for multiple variables. Modality bias refers to potential differences in how people respond to phone surveys compared to F2F interviews, which can affect the accuracy of the data collected. Addressing both biases is crucial to ensure the reliability of food security estimates. 1.1 Overview of existing methodologies The small area estimation (SAE) literature provides methods for producing reliable estimates when sample sizes are insufficient for direct, design-based estimates at the desired level (see, e.g., Ghosh and Rao, (1994) ; Pfeffermann, (2002) ; Pfeffermann, (2013) ; Rao and Molina, (2015) for an overview). SAE methodologies have been further extended to incorporate spatial ( Ghosh and Rao,, 1994 ; Pratesi and Salvati,, 2008 ) and spatio-temporal correlations ( Mercer et al.,, 2015 ; Gao and Wakefield,, 2024 ) . When addressing sampling bias, the standard approach is poststratification ( Little,, 1993 ) . It adjusts survey estimates by applying weights to respondents, ensuring that the weighted sample better reflects the target population based on auxiliary variables, such as demographic characteristics. An approximation to poststratification is raking ( Deming and Stephan,, 1940 ; Deville and Särndal,, 1992 ; Skinner and Wakefield,, 2017 ) , an iterative algorithm that uses marginal totals to adjust for bias and can be used even when the joint distribution of auxiliary variables is unknown. A more modern approach for correcting non-representative samples is multilevel regression and poststratification (MRP), first introduced by Gelman and Little, (1997) , with growing literature on both methodology ( Gao et al.,, 2021 ; Gelman and Hill,, 2006 ; Ghitza and Gelman,, 2013 ; Kuh et al.,, 2024 ) and application ( Downes et al.,, 2018 ; Lax and Phillips,, 2009 ; Wang et al.,, 2015 ; Zhang et al.,, 2014 ) . MRP integrates hierarchical data modelling to borrow information across subgroups, adjusting for sample non-representativeness through poststratification. Since the estimates are computed as a weighted average of predictions for each subgroup, MRP does not suffer from the problem of empty cells, which is often encountered in simple poststratification methods when adjusting for many auxiliary variables. MRP also serves as a natural framework for the SAE problem ( Zhang et al.,, 2014 ) . Recently Gao et al., (2021) proposed using structured priors, such as autoregressive, or conditional auto-regressive (CAR) models ( Besag,, 1974 ) , which allow for non-uniform information borrowing and help reduce bias in temporally or spatially referenced data. One approach to addressing modality bias is to incorporate multiple modes of data collection in the modelling process ( Elliott and Davis,, 2005 ; Elliott and Haviland,,