Enhanced simultaneous quantum-classical communications under composable security

Nicholas Zaunders, Ziqing Wang, Robert Malaney, Ryan Aguinaldo, Timothy C. Ralph · 2025

Read Enhanced simultaneous quantum-classical communications under composable security by Nicholas Zaunders, Ziqing Wang, Robert Malaney, Ryan Aguinaldo, Timothy C. Ralph (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-03145.txt.

Introduction

Nicholas Zaunders and co-authors improve a protocol that sends quantum and classic data on the same light pulse, in work from 2025. Sharing one pulse saves hardware for secure key exchange. Mixing the two signals can also open security holes if the coupling is modeled loosely.

The team revises the coupling model and backs it with Monte Carlo tests. Key rates are then tuned over the free settings of the scheme. For a fixed classic error rate, quantum throughput improves over past models. A finite-key version is built to meet strict composable security rules. Gains hold under realistic operating conditions in their analysis.

Catalog record

CREATORNicholas Zaunders, Ziqing Wang, Robert Malaney, Ryan Aguinaldo, Timothy C. Ralph
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE80 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-03145

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Enhanced simultaneous quantum-classical communications under composable security Preprint: APS/123-QED Nicholas Zaunders, Ziqing Wang, Robert Malaney, Ryan Aguinaldo, Timothy C. Ralph Abstract Simultaneous quantum-classical communications (SQCC) protocols are a family of continuous-variable quantum key distribution (CV-QKD) protocols which allow for quantum and classical symbols to be integrated concurrently on the same optical pulse and mode. In this work, we present a revised analysis of simultaneous quantum-classical communications in Gaussian-modulated coherent-state CV-QKD protocols. We address security concerns inherently associated with SQCC schemes and provide an updated model of the coupling between the classical and quantum channels. We provide evidence for our model via Monte Carlo simulation. We compute the performance of our revised SQCC protocol in terms of the secret-key generation rate optimised over free parameters and demonstrate improved quantum efficiency for a given classical bit-error rate. Lastly, we extend our analysis into the finite-key regime, where we propose a scheme for composably-secure SQCC under realistic operating conditions and demonstrate that our scheme retains the advantage in quantum performance over previous models. I Introduction Quantum key distribution (QKD) is a contemporary quantum technology that exploits quantum uncertainty to offer unconditionally information-theoretic secure key exchange between two parties, regardless of an eavesdropper’s resources Bennett and Brassard 2014 ; Shor and Preskill 2000 . In QKD protocols, random one-time-pad Shannon 1949 bits are encoded into nonorthogonal quantum states Bennett 1992 , which cannot be measured by a malicious attacker without introducing a detectable error onto the signal. While QKD can in principle be performed with a variety of different basis states, the choice of basis in which secret-key bits are encoded can have a significant impact on the effectiveness of a specific protocol, and a number of different protocols have been proposed with the aim of exploiting the advantages and minimizing the disadvantages associated with any particular scheme. Examples include the discrete-variable (DV-QKD) protocols Pirandola et al. 2020 , such as BB84 Bennett and Brassard 2014 and the Lo-Chau protocol Lo and Chau 1999 as well as more modern protocols such as the twin-field protocol Lucamarini et al. 2018 , which encode quantum data into finite-dimensional Hilbert spaces such as photon polarisation. Alternatively, continuous-variable (CV-QKD) protocols encode secret bits in the basis of some infinite-dimensional Hilbert space, most commonly the continuous quadrature phase space of the quantized electromagnetic field Ralph 1999 . Of the continuous-variable protocols, the most ubiquitous are those which encode quantum information via a Gaussian ensemble of coherent states Grosshans and Grangier 2002 . CV protocols offer a practical advantage over DV protocols: coherent state generation is efficient, fast, simple and robust, with stable states able to be generated at up to 100 MHz repetition rates in practical protocols Zhang et al. 2020 ; Kumar et al. 2019 ; Jain et al. 2022 ; Tang et al. 2014 using existing off-the-shelf telecommunications components and without requiring cryogenic temperatures. Similarly, state measurement in these protocols is performed via homodyne or heterodyne detection, which can also be done efficiently at high repetition rates using off-the-shelf components without the need for cryogenics. A second advantage of Gaussian coherent-state QKD protocols is their capacity for integration with classical coherent-state communications protocols, termed simultaneous quantum-classical communication (SQCC) Qi 2016 . SQCC operates by encoding classical data via the mean value of the Gaussian distribution encoding the quantum symbols, where the small random phase-space fluctuation containing the quantum information is appended onto the much larger pre-determined phase-space displacement representing the classical symbol. This combined scheme is unique to CV-QKD and offers an invaluable advantage to any practical deployment of a QKD network using continuous variables, as SQCC effectively increases the number of available channels in any network without incurring any additional overhead. This advantage is especially salient when considering the possibility of freely appending quantum key capabilities onto existing classical communications networks, or performing QKD on satellite platforms where constraints on physical size and energy consumption motivate using the same channel and optical mode to perform both the quantum and classical signalling Zaunders et al. 2024 . Despite these advantages, the current body of work on SQCC protocols shows much potential for further development. Previous proposals Qi 2016 ; Qi and Lim 2018 ; Pan et al. 2020 ; Zaunders et al. 2024 ; Winnel et al. 2024 consider a simplified model of the quantum-classical channel coupling, sufficient to capture protocol performance only at a high classical quality-of-service, and do not explicitly present a full security analysis. Furthermore, all contemporary works only present results for the simplified case of a shared key of infinite size, which is not a realistic model of practical implementations of QKD protocols Pirandola et al. 2020 . In this work, we propose an improved model for SQCC CV-QKD protocols under the requirement of composable security in the finite-size regime, and show that our scheme presents an improved security analysis relative to the previous leading SQCC model. We then proceed to provide an analytic description of the manner in which the errors associated with the classical measurement affects both the security requirements and numerical behaviour of the combined protocol. We demonstrate that the net effect of classical bit errors is to reduce the variance of the quantum measurement distribution in a non-Gaussian manner, in contradiction to previous models suggesting a Gaussian broadening, and show that directly implementing SQCC protocols without proper consideration of the output state can produce non-physical statistics, potentially rendering the protocol insecure. We confirm the predictions of our analytic model via Monte Carlo simulation, and subsequently close the security loophole posed by the non-physical data by physicalising the SQCC process via the introduction of an additional renormalisation step. We use our now-secure model to numerically derive the optimal secret key generation rate in the asymptotic regime and demonstrate a clear advantage in the quantum performance for a given classical quality-of-service when compared to the previous scheme. We also present equivalent results for the finite-key regime and demonstrate the security of the improved model under realistic conditions. The advantage of the model over previous works is also maintained in the finite-key regime. The remainder of this paper is structured as follows. In Section II , we briefly summarise the general operation of SQCC protocols and propose the specific scheme which we intend to analyse. We also address specific security concerns and propose appropriate solutions. In Section III , we present firstly the analytic results associated with our model, detailing the explicit effect of the classical signal on the quantum data and the need and implementation of the subsequent renormalisation (Sections III.2 , III.3 ), and then provide evidence for the analytic model via simulation (Section III.1 ). We then present the optimized key rate of the protocol in both the asymptotic (Section III.4 ) and finite-size regimes (Section III.5 ). We present some concluding remarks in Section IV . Further mathematical detail and additional arguments relevant to the main body are included in Appendices A - D . II Protocol description and security analysis In this section, we will first briefly illustrate the general operating procedure of SQCC protocols in the continuous-variable space and describe the method by which the classical and quantum protocols are conjoined, measured, and processed at the

Read the complete text