Predictive processing frameworks for perception can explain recent drone sightings in the United States

Joel Frohlich, Leonardo Christov-Moore, Nicco Reggente · 2025

Read Predictive processing frameworks for perception can explain recent drone sightings in the United States by Joel Frohlich, Leonardo Christov-Moore, Nicco Reggente (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-03013.txt.

Introduction

Joel Frohlich, Leonardo Christov-Moore, and Nicco Reggente argue that a theory of how the brain predicts the world can explain recent drone sightings in the United States, in a paper from 2025. They stress that honest, healthy people can misread lights in the sky. The sky gives few cues to fix a wrong first guess.

Lights far away are sparse signals, so prior beliefs fill in the gaps and are hard to update. The authors also suggest humans evolved to treat the sky as deeply meaningful. Falling trust in science bodies may add to the effect. They close by urging stronger astronomy teaching, so public beliefs better support accurate seeing.

Catalog record

CREATORJoel Frohlich, Leonardo Christov-Moore, Nicco Reggente
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE19 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-03013

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Predictive processing frameworks for perception can explain recent drone sightings in the United States Joel Frohlich, Leonardo Christov-Moore, Nicco Reggente Abstract Late 2024 was marked by mass delusion on a scale echoing the notorious 1938 radio broadcast of “War of the Worlds”. Beginning on 18 November, over 5,000 reports of mysterious drones were submitted to the FBI across New Jersey, with similar sightings quickly spreading to other parts of the United States [ 1 ] . Now documented as the “2024 United States drone sightings”, the incident(s) accumulated thousands of witnesses, some of whom perceived hovering objects “the size of bicycles or small cars” that reportedly operated in coordinated patterns and could turn off their lights to evade detection [ 2 ] . The incident influenced mainstream political discourse, with President-elect Donald Trump posting on Truth Social that authorities should “Let the public know, and now. Otherwise, shoot them down!!!” [ 3 ] . While these objects were frequently discussed in a geopolitical context—including claims of Iranian “mothership” deployment, promptly refuted by the Pentagon [ 4 ] — the cultural undercurrents driving such reports echo those of UFO sightings. Many witnesses proved incorrigible despite federal agencies concluding many sightings were misidentified aircraft — indeed, some witnesses even directed laser pointers at commercial flights [ 5 , 6 ] . This steadfast adherence to misperception is particularly striking given that these lights in the sky are rather easily explained through conventional means. Nonetheless, the widespread and persistent misperception of planets, stars, and commercial passenger jets as mysterious drones by so many people seems baffling. While social media, confirmation bias, and mass “hysteria” have been put forward as partial explanations [ 7 ] , we believe that more fundamental principles of conscious perception — mainly, predictive processing and Bayesian inference — offer possible mechanisms. Here, we make a unique contribution to the discussion by drawing on the predictive processing theory of perception (Box 1) to explain why healthy, intelligent, honest, and psychologically normal people might easily misperceive lights in the sky as threatening or extraordinary objects, especially in the context of WEIRD (western, educated, industrial, rich, and democratic) societies. We argue that the uniquely sparse properties of skyborne and celestial stimuli make it difficult for an observer to update prior beliefs, which can be easily fit to observed lights. We briefly discuss the possible role of generalized distrust in scientific institutions [ 8 ] and ultimately argue for the importance of astronomy education for producing a society with prior beliefs that support veridical perception. Box 1: Predictive processing According to predictive processing (also known as “predictive coding”), our conscious experiences best correspond to an internal, prior model of the world generated by the brain [ 9 ] . This prior model is compared with sensory input and updated to minimize prediction errors. Because this process follows principles of Bayesian inference, predictive processing belongs to a broader collection of theories often referred to as the “Bayesian brain hypothesis”, which posits that “we are trying to infer the causes of our sensations based on a generative model of the world” [ 10 ] . The sky is uniquely challenging for perception Our first insight toward understanding the drone mass-sighting incident, as well as the broader phenomena of UFO and UAP (unidentified aerial phenomena) sightings, is that the sky and objects that appear against it have unique stimulus properties . Henceforth, we refer to this as the Principle of Skyborne Impoverishment (PSI) . This principle has three important dimensions; unlike objects that appear on land, objects which appear in the sky 1) lack context , as the sky often appears as a homogeneous field, 2) span many orders of magnitude in distance , from meters to light years, and 3) appear as approximately zero-dimensional points , precluding perceptual convergence based on shape, texture, or other stimulus properties that are useful at closer range. This represents a particularly exacerbated instance of the “Inverse Optics Problem” in vision science [ 11 ] as well as a breakdown of “size constancy” mechanisms– our visual system’s ability to maintain stable perception of object size despite variations in viewing distance [ 12 ] . Due to the PSI, one’s perception of lights that appear in the sky is largely top-down or prior heavy, i.e., strongly driven by one’s current generative model of the world. This is because visual afferent signals corresponding to a point-like light in the sky can be easily fit to many prior models without generating a substantial prediction error. The same visual signals might fit with a drone, an approaching airplane, the planet Jupiter, a star, or even a triple star system; see Figure 1. Figure 1: The principle of skyborne impoverishment (PSI). As viewed by eye from the ground, objects spanning many orders of magnitude in distance may appear as discrete points that are easily fit to different prior models without generating a prediction error. The photograph in panel A is an annotated 24 s exposure taken by author JF facing southwest from Joshua Tree, CA, USA on 19 October 2020 with a Canon 70D camera (f/5.6, iso 6400). While this photographic image demonstrates the PSI, note that the camera cannot capture exactly the same perspective as the human visual system, e.g., due to the long exposure, the plane’s blinking navigation lights appear as three separate points, and other objects are slightly elongated due to the Earth’s rotation. Panel B illustrates the distances of objects that may appear as pointlike lights to the unaided eye on a logarthmic distance scale. Humans view the sky as inherently meaningful Our pre-industrial ancestors looked to the sky to understand time, seasons, weather, and navigation, knowledge of which carries, in each case, strong survival value. As a result, humans have likely evolved to perceive the sky as deeply meaningful. Evolution by natural selection unfolds on a slow timescale relative to technological and societal progress. As a result, we continue to view the sky, rather than our computers or smartphones, as deeply meaningful. The sky offers a rare perceptual paradox: it is wholly visible yet utterly untouchable—an interface between the tangible and the ineffable, the known and the unknowable. Unlike the microscopic world of cells and molecules, which we can only see, at best, with special instruments, the sky reveals itself freely to the naked eye, yet resists grasp. And it is often at such boundaries—where observation collides with mystery, where we can see but not fully understand—that we are most compelled to assign meaning. We witness babies born yet cannot fully comprehend how life emerges from strands of DNA; we look to the stars with the same awe. This hypothesis may explain cross-cultural associations of the sky with heaven or an afterlife, as well as the longevity of belief in astrology, an ancient pseudoscience which puts forth the apparent positions of celestial objects to explain human affairs and, remarkably, has flourished in different forms across many cultures [ 13 ] . In a nutshell, we hypothesize that the sky is psychedelic . The psychiatrist Humphry Osmond originally coined the term “psychedelic” in 1956 to explain the ability of certain psychoactive drugs, such as LSD (lysergic acid diethylamide) and psilocybin, to

Read the complete text