Bell’s Inequalities and Entanglement in Corpora of Italian Language
Diederik Aerts, Suzette Geriente, Roberto Leporini, Sandro Sozzo · 2025
Read Bell’s Inequalities and Entanglement in Corpora of Italian Language by Diederik Aerts, Suzette Geriente, Roberto Leporini, Sandro Sozzo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-02038.txt.
Introduction
Diederik Aerts and co-authors test a quantum physics idea inside the Italian language in a 2025 paper. In physics, Bell's inequalities mark the limit of classical behavior, and breaking them signals entanglement, a deep link between two things. The team asked whether linked concepts in language break the same limit.
They ran three retrieval tests on Italian text collections. Two used the phrase pair for 'The Animal Acts' and one used 'The Animal eats the Food'. All three tests broke Bell's inequalities by a clear margin. The pattern matched earlier English results, which hints the effect does not depend on the language. The authors built a quantum math model for the data. They read entanglement here as concepts updating each other in context.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Diederik Aerts, Suzette Geriente, Roberto Leporini, Sandro Sozzo |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 83 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-02038
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Bell’s Inequalities and Entanglement in Corpora of Italian Language Diederik Aerts, Suzette Geriente, Roberto Leporini, Sandro Sozzo Abstract We analyze the results of three information retrieval tests on conceptual combinations that we have recently performed using corpora of Italian language. The tests have the form of a ‘Bell-type test’ and were aimed at identifying ‘quantum entanglement’ in the combination, or composition, of two concepts. In the first two tests, we studied the Italian translation of the combination The Animal Acts , while in the third test, we studied the Italian translation of the combination The Animal eats the Food . We found a significant violation of Bell’s inequalities in all tests. Empirical patterns confirm the results obtained with corpora of English language, which indicates the existence of deep structures in concept formation that are language-independent. The systematic violation of Bell’s inequalities suggests the presence of entanglement and, indeed, we elaborate here a ‘quantum model in Hilbert space’ for the collected data. This investigation supports our theoretical hypothesis about entanglement as a phenomenon of ‘contextual updating’, independently of the nature, micro-physical or conceptual linguistic, of the entities involved. Finally, these findings allow us to further clarify the mutual relationships between entanglement, Cirel’son’s bound, and no-signaling in Bell-type situations. Keywords : concept combinations, linguistic corpora, Bell’s inequalities, quantum modeling, entanglement 1 Introduction The year 1935 saw the publication of two fundamental articles which illustrated the peculiarities of ‘quantum entanglement’. In one of these articles, Albert Einstein, Boris Podolsky and Nathan Rosen (EPR) showed that, whenever a composite quantum system, or ‘entity’, made up of two individual entities, is in an entangled state, the component entities exhibit a specific type of statistical correlations, known as ‘EPR correlations’ ( Einstein, Podolsky & Rosen, 1935 ) . In the other article, Erwin Schrödinger showed that two entangled quantum entities, though separated in space, behave as if they were actually ‘non-separated’ ( Schrödinger, 1935 ) . Then, in 1951, David Bohm introduced the archetypical situation of a composite bipartite quantum entity made up of two spin 1/2 quantum entities which fly apart when the composite entity is in the singlet spin state ( Bohm, 1951 ) . If one imagines that, (i) if one spin is forced “up” by the measurement apparatus applied to it, then, as a consequence, the other spin is ‘immediately’ forced “down”, even when no measurement is performed on it, and (ii) this process is independent of the distance between the two quantum entities, the phenomenon reveals a sort of ‘spooky action at-a-distance’, a locution coined by Einstein to stress the strange aspects of entanglement. Next, in 1964, John Bell put forward the idea of how an empirical test can be designed to detect the presence of entanglement in physical domains. More precisely, what Bell did was deriving an inequality that should not be violated under the assumption, reasonable in classical physics, of ‘local separability’, or ‘local realism’, whereas the inequality is violated in quantum mechanics ( Bell, 1964 ) . After the seminal article by Bell, it became clear that, due to entanglement, quantum entities exhibit genuinely non-classical aspects, such as ‘contextuality’, ‘non-separability’, and ‘non-locality’. Bell’s work was also relevant for the so-called ‘hidden variables program’, initiated after the EPR article, because these results entail that any hidden variables completion of quantum mechanics must be non-local. Finally, one can prove that the EPR correlations cannot be modeled in a classical Kolmogorovian probability framework ( Accardi & Fedullo, 1982 ; Pitowski, 1989 ) . In the last two decades, research on entanglement has flourished in physics. Indeed, at a theoretical level, several variants of Bell’s original inequality have been derived, now generally called ‘Bell’s inequalities’ (see, e.g., Horodecki et al., 2009 ; Brunner et al., 2014 ). At an empirical level, several tests on micro-physical entities have been performed which confirm the predictions of quantum mechanics (see, e.g., Genovese, 2005 ; Giustina et al., 2013 ; Christensen et al., 2013 ). Among Bell’s inequalities, the ‘Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt (CHSH) inequality’ ( Clauser et al., 1969 ) is particularly suited, not only for empirical tests of non-locality in quantum physics, but also as a test to detect the presence of entanglement, within and beyond physical domains. Concerning the latter point, several theoretical and empirical studies have appeared that investigate the presence of entanglement in conceptual-linguistic domains, mainly in the combination of two concepts (see, e.g., Bruza et al., 2009a ; Bruza et al., 2009b ; Aerts & Sozzo, 2011 ; Aerts & Sozzo, 2014 ; Gronchi & Strambini, 2017 ; Aerts Arguëlles, 2018 ; Aerts et al., 2019 ; Beltran & Geriente, 2019 ; Aerts Arguëlles & Sozzo, 2020 ; Aerts et al., 2021 ; Aerts et al., 2023b ; Bertini, Leporini & Moriani, 2023 ; Aerts, Leporini & Sozzo, 2025 and references therein). This investigation fits a growing research program, the ‘quantum cognition program’, that applies the mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics in the modeling of high-level cognitive processes, such as perception, categorization, language, judgement, and decision-making (see, e.g., Aerts, 2009a ; Khrennikov, 2010 ; Piwowarski et al., 2010 ; Busemeyer & Bruza, 2012 ; Aerts et al., 2013 ; Aerts, Gabora & Sozzo, 2013 ; Haven & Khrennikov, 2013 ; Dalla Chiara, Giuntini & Negri, 2015 ; Dalla Chiara et al., 2015 ; Kwam er al., 2015 ; Melucci, 2015 ; Aerts et al., 2018 ; Aerts, Haven & Sozzo, 2018 ; Pisano & Sozzo, 2020 ; Aerts et al., 2021 and references therein). In particular, some of us have put forward a ‘realistic-operational approach’ for human concepts and their combinations. 1 1 1 Throughout this article, we write concepts using capital letters and italics, e.g., Animal , Fruit , Vegetable , etc. This is often the way to refer to concepts in cognitive psychology. In it, a concept is an entity in a defined state that incorporates the meaning of the concept and can change under the influence of a context ( Aerts, Sassoli de Bianchi & Sozzo, 2016 ) . The realistic-operational approach enables the modeling of conceptual entities using the mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics in Hilbert space ( Aerts, 2009a ; Aerts, Gabora & Sozzo, 2013 ; Pisano & Sozzo, 2020 ; Aerts et al., 2021 ) . Regarding specifically the identification of entanglement in conceptual combinations, we have performed various ‘Bell-type tests’ in which we have tested the presence of entanglement by means of a violation of the CHSH inequality. These tests include text-based ( Aerts & Sozzo, 2011 ; Aerts & Sozzo, 2014 ; Aerts et al., 2023b ; Bertini, Leporini & Moriani, 2023 ) and video-based ( Aerts, Leporini & Sozzo, 2025 ) cognitive tests on human participants, information retrieval tests on corpora of documents of English language ( Beltran & Geriente, 2019 ; Aerts et al., 2021 ) , and image retrieval tests on web search engines ( Aerts Arguëlles, 2018 ; Aerts Arguëlles & Sozzo, 2020 ) . We have particularly tested the combination The Animal Acts , meant as a composite bipartite conceptual entity made up of the individual conceptual entities Animal and Acts , where the term “acts” refers to the action of emitting a sound by the animal. We have also