On weak solutions in Einstein theory and beyond
Francesco Fazzini, Hassan Mehmood · 2025
Read On weak solutions in Einstein theory and beyond by Francesco Fazzini, Hassan Mehmood (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-01846.txt.
Introduction
Francesco Fazzini and Hassan Mehmood argue that a popular mathematical fix for extending Einstein's equations past a certain singularity does not hold up, in a paper from twenty twenty-five. When dust collapses under gravity in a spherical setup, particle shells can cross, creating a singularity. Physicists have pushed spacetime beyond that point using weak solutions of the averaged equations.
The authors contend the paradigm rests on a hidden assumption that fails for the shock waves involved. Taken seriously, it would let dust shock waves outrun light, which physics forbids. Their critique questions whether such extensions describe anything real, and presses for a sounder way to treat shell-crossing collapse.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Francesco Fazzini, Hassan Mehmood |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 35 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-01846
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On weak solutions in Einstein theory and beyond Francesco Fazzini, Hassan Mehmood Abstract In spherical symmetry, gravitational collapse of dust may give rise to the so-called shell-crossing singularities, beyond which spacetime can be extended using weak solutions to the integrated version of the equations of motion. We argue that the paradigm of weak solutions is ill-suited for dynamical extension beyond shell crossings through shock waves, because it is based implicitly on the assumption that the Painlevé-Gullstrand time remains continuous across the shock, and leads to the unwanted prospect of shock waves of dust particles moving faster than light. I Introduction The problem of gravitational collapse of matter has drawn significant interest since the inception of general relativity. One of the earliest attempts at understanding the problem was the pioneering work of Oppenheimer and Snyder Oppenheimer:1939ue , in which they showed that a spherically symmetric and homogeneous distribution of pressureless fluid (i.e. dust) continues to collapse until it forms a black hole with a singularity at the center. Since then, this picture of gravitational collapse as an ill-fated journey unto a singularity has been confirmed from a number of perspectives, ranging from the time-honored singularity theorems to numerical studies of matter collapse using different types of matter. Within the context of dust collapse, the Oppenheimer-Snyder model can be generalized to inhomogeneous distributions of dust in the framework of Lemaitré-Tolman-Bondi (LTB) spacetimes Bondi:1947fta ; Tolman:1934za . It is widely believed that quantum gravity can resolve the singularities that are endemic to general relativity. However, what should replace the singularity in a gravitational collapse scenario is a matter of open debate Fazzini:2023ova ; Fazzini:2023scu . One interesting possibility is that the singularity is replaced by a bounce: matter falls inward, crosses an apparent horizon, thus forming a black hole, and then reaches a minimal radius, at which point it starts expanding and eventually exits the apparent horizon. The idea is inspired by loop quantum gravity (LQG), which predicts the geometry of spacetime to be discrete at a microscopic level and hence posits the existence of a minimal length. It has been concretely realized in phenomenological or effective models of gravitational collapse Husain:2022gwp ; Husain:2021ojz ; Cipriani:2024nhx ; Giesel:2023hys which incorporate LQG-inspired quantum corrections to classical models of inhomogeneous dust collapse in the framework of LTB spacetimes. One curious feature of collapsing dust in LTB spacetimes is the existence of the so-called shell-crossing singularities (SCS) chao-hao ; hu ; yodzis1973occurrence . These are points where spherical shells of matter collide with each other. At such points, the energy density of matter diverges, and the Einstein equations break down. A way out of this problem, both in the classical theory Nolan:2003wp ; Lasky:2006hq and in the effective theory Husain:2022gwp ; Cipriani:2024nhx , is to study the problem in generalized Painlevé-Gullstrand (PG) coordinates Martel:2000rn . In these coordinates, the equations of motion turn out to be hyperbolic balance laws and SCS are nothing but crossings of characteristics for these equations. Thus, familiar techniques from the theory of hyperbolic balance laws leveque-92 ; Dafermos:1315649 can be used to extend the spacetime beyond SCS. These methods consist in finding weak solutions to the equations of motion, i.e., solutions to the integrated version of the equations. As a result, the SCS are replaced by shock waves, which are propagating discontinuities in the variables entering the equations of motion. While this is a quite reasonable approach to dynamical extension beyond SCS, it suffers from a rather serious ambiguity. As pointed out by its progenitor Nolan:2003wp in the classical theory, and by Fazzini:2023ova in the effective theory, weak solutions are not unique. In particular, different ways of writing down the integrated equations of motion may lead to distinct weak solutions to the same initial data, despite the fact that smooth solutions to those equations are identical. This is a familiar phenomenon in the theory of hyperbolic conservation laws leveque-92 ; Dafermos:1315649 , and is connected with the mathematical impossibility of defining a product of distributions colombeau-92 . In typical applications of the theory, such as in fluid dynamics, this type of non-uniqueness is not a problem 1 1 1 There is another type of non-uniqueness that is endemic to hyperbolic conservation laws as well: it concerns the existence of distinct weak solutions given the same initial data for one particular conservation equation written in terms of one particular set of variables . Finding the unique solution in this case has constituted an area of deep and intense mathematical research in the twentieth century, bringing together insights from physics, functional analysis, distribution theory, and so on. For a detailed exposition of the subject, see Dafermos:1315649 . , since the equations of motion are formulated as physically motivated integral equations to begin with; thus, changing the variables and getting different integral equations would be ad hoc. However, in gravitational dust collapse, the equations of motion are fundamentally differential equations, and different ways of arriving at them result in their differing up to multiplicative factors Fazzini:2025hsf . There is no a priori justification for picking one of these differential equations over others for the purpose of integrating them to find weak solutions. As a way out of this problem, one might recall the adage “gravity is geometry” and attempt to find a geometrical criterion to pick one weak solution out of a zoo of them. As pointed out above, weak solutions consist of propagating discontinuities in the variables that enter the equations of motion. This suggests that there is a discontinuity in the metric as well. However, the metric contains these variables in a particular combination, and it is not necessary that a combination of discontinuous functions be discontinuous too. Thus, one can insist that only those formulations of the integrated equations of motion are to be favored which lead to the metric being continuous. This is the proposal put forth in Husain:2025wrh ; Liu:2025fil , and leads to a unique weak solution. However, this comes at a price: we shall show that a continuous weak solution to the equations of dust collapse in spherical symmetry gives rise to a shock wave that can move faster than light. In the classical theory, the shock, whatever its speed, has to eventually countenance oblivion in the central singularity of the black hole. However, in the effective theory, crucial details of a star’s life, such as its lifetime, its post-bounce fate (whether it will form a regular black hole remnant, undergo a black-hole-to-white-hole transition, etc.) depend sensitively on the speed of the shock wave. This raises doubts as to the viability of weak solutions. In addition to pointing out the unwanted feature of superluminal shocks in weak solutions, we will also explore the reason for it. The problem, we shall find out, is intimately connected with the fact that one is attempting to use a single PG chart to describe the entire spacetime. In particular, we shall show that implicit in the weak formulation is the assumption that the PG time coordinate stays continuous across the shock as a function of the proper time of an observer comoving with the shock. This suggests that one cannot perhaps use PG coordinates to describe the entire spacetime during dust