Integrated optimization of operations and capacity planning under uncertainty for drayage procurement in container logistics Journal: Omega
Georgios Vassos, Richard Lusby, Pierre Pinson · 2025
Read Integrated optimization of operations and capacity planning under uncertainty for drayage procurement in container logistics Journal: Omega by Georgios Vassos, Richard Lusby, Pierre Pinson (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-01808.txt.
Introduction
Georgios Vassos, Richard Lusby, and Pierre Pinson build one framework that joins daily trucking decisions with long-term capacity booking in container logistics. Drayage, the short-haul trucking of containers between ports and warehouses, is a critical link in intermodal transport. Studies usually treat the strategic and operational sides apart. Here, dynamic programming yields the best daily policy for splitting loads among carriers with limited capacity, under uncertain container flows and spot prices.
A sampling method keeps the computation manageable. Those daily policies then score candidate capacity deals. A quasi-Newton method tunes how much capacity to reserve with contract and spot carriers. Tests show a 21.2 percent cost cut in a four-period case. Simulations on unseen scenarios confirm the method generalizes well. The authors stress that joining the two decision levels is where the savings live.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Georgios Vassos, Richard Lusby, Pierre Pinson |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 73 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-01808
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Integrated optimization of operations and capacity planning under uncertainty for drayage procurement in container logistics Journal: Omega Georgios Vassos, Richard Lusby, Pierre Pinson Abstract We present an integrated framework for truckload procurement in container logistics, bridging strategic and operational aspects that are often treated independently in existing research. Drayage, the short-haul trucking of containers, plays a critical role in intermodal container logistics. Using dynamic programming, we identify optimal operational policies for allocating drayage volumes among capacitated carriers under uncertain container flows and spot rates. The computational complexity of optimization under uncertainty is mitigated through sample average approximation. These optimal policies serve as the basis for evaluating specific capacity arrangements. To optimize capacity reservations with strategic and spot carriers, we employ an efficient quasi-Newton method. Numerical experiments demonstrate significant cost-efficiency improvements, including a 21.2% cost reduction in a four-period scenario. Monte Carlo simulations further highlight the strong generalization capabilities of the proposed joint optimization method across out-of-sample scenarios. These findings underscore the importance of integrating strategic and operational decisions to enhance cost efficiency in truckload procurement under uncertainty. MSC 90C39 , 90B06 1 Introduction We study the complexities of truckload (TL) procurement for the short-haul transportation of laden containers, a critical process in managing the first-mile movement of Full Container Load (FCL) and Less-than-Container Load (LCL) shipments between ports, warehouses, or intermodal terminals. This stage, often referred to as container drayage or simply drayage , plays a pivotal role in bridging ocean freight with inland logistics [ 1 ] . Throughout this work, we use the terms TL and drayage interchangeably, as TL, while a broader category, refers exclusively to drayage in this context. First mile delivery refers to the initial phase of the logistics chain, where goods are collected from the shipper’s location and transported to a warehouse, sorting facility, or terminal as the starting point for further distribution. It primarily concerns the movement of goods from the point of origin to the beginning of the transportation network. FCL is a shipping mode where a container is exclusively used for one customer’s cargo, filling the entire container. In contrast, LCL is another shipping arrangement where cargo from multiple customers is consolidated into a single container. Intermodal container logistics refers to the integrated transportation of containers using multiple modes of transportation, such as vessels, trucks, and trains, without any handling of the freight itself when changing modes. Finally, drayage involves the short-distance trucking of containerized freight into and out of intermodal facilities, such as ports, rail terminals, and warehouses, facilitating the transition between transportation modes. Efficient TL procurement for drayage is crucial for maintaining smooth intermodal logistics operations, minimizing costs, and enhancing service levels. As global trade grows in complexity and volume, optimizing these processes has substantial implications for supply chain efficiency and economic performance [ 2 ] . However, much of the existing research focuses on strategic carrier selection and auction mechanisms, often overlooking the critical role of capacity planning [ 3 ] . In this study, we distinguish between carrier selection and capacity planning as two distinct yet complementary components of the procurement process. Carrier selection entails identifying and contracting carriers based on criteria such as cost, reliability, and service quality [ 4 ] , establishing the strategic foundation for aligning carriers with operational needs. In contrast, capacity planning focuses on determining the transportation capacity to reserve with both strategic and spot carriers, ensuring adequate resources are available to meet anticipated shipment volumes efficiently. While carrier selection has received significant attention for fostering long-term partnerships in TL transportation, capacity planning remains underexplored. Neglecting this component can impede the integration of strategic and operational considerations in TL procurement. Effective procurement should secure sufficient capacity with both strategic and spot carriers to meet operational needs [ 5 ] . This gap in the literature underscores the need for integrated models that can enhance strategic decision-making in TL procurement. Our study integrates strategic capacity planning, which involves the long-term reservation of carrier capacity to accommodate expected container flows, with operational volume allocation, which entails the periodic management of transportation volumes. Given a predefined capacity arrangement, we aim to identify the optimal policy for periodically assigning transportation volumes across capacitated carriers under uncertain flows of laden containers within the drayage system. To achieve this, we combine the well-established capacitated transportation problem [ 6 , 7 ] with dynamic programming. Additionally, we explore approximate methods to manage computational complexity, emphasizing its strong dependence on uncertain parameters. To address the gap in literature, we propose a joint optimization model, combining capacity planning with operational policies for volume allocation. We use the Markov Decision Process (MDP) framework to formulate a dynamic program for the Multiperiod Stochastic Transportation Problem (MSTP) . This method can readily factor in multiple uncertainties, such as the inflow and outflow of laden containers to and from our drayage system and the spot market variability. Our approach is convenient for practitioners who wish to experiment with empirical data, as the uncertain parameters can be fine-tuned and validated to match real-world mechanisms. Additionally, we adopt the option contract framework and the portfolio contract concept introduced by [ 5 ] to enable flexible sourcing, extending the capacity strategy to include the spot market. An option contract grants the buyer the right, but not the obligation, to procure a specified amount of capacity at a predetermined execution price in exchange for an upfront reservation fee. A portfolio contract combines multiple option contracts, providing flexibility to optimize operational efficiency. Finally, we leverage the theory therein to report the regularity conditions necessary to reduce the capacity optimization at the outset of operations to a concave maximization problem. The remainder of this paper is structured as follows: Section 2 reviews key contributions to truckload procurement and identifies existing gaps. Section 3 defines essential concepts and presents the mathematical formulation of the optimization model. Section 4 introduces an MDP framework for optimizing volume allocation under uncertainty, integrating strategic capacity planning. Computational complexity and scalability are analyzed using dynamic programming and approximation techniques. Section 5 presents numerical experiments that demonstrate the model’s effectiveness, followed by a discussion of the results, limitations, and future research directions. 2 Literature review The procurement of TL transportation services has been extensively studied from the perspectives of strategic carrier selection and operational execution. This section reviews the state-of-the-art research, highlighting key contributions and identifying gaps that this study seeks to address. Strategic carrier selection in TL procurement involves making long-term decisions about which carriers to contract and the terms of these contracts. This topic has garnered significant attention, with numerous studies exploring different aspects of the process. Researchers have developed models to determine the optimal set of carriers and allocate them to origin-destination (OD) pairs, highlighting the importance of auction mechanisms in achieving cost efficiency and maintaining service quality [ 8 ] . Further investigations into the TL reverse auction process have provided insights into bid construction and the complexities of carrier selection, showing how bid strategies influence procurement auction outcomes [ 2 , 9 ] . Subsequent studies have employed multi-attribute value theory and auction theory to address scenarios such as lane bundling and uncertain demand and capacity [ 10 , 11 , 12 ,