The hidden truth of ideal relativistic fluids: the matter Lagrangian is its total energy density, not its pressure!
Sergio Mendoza, Sarahí Silva · 2025
Read The hidden truth of ideal relativistic fluids: the matter Lagrangian is its total energy density, not its pressure! by Sergio Mendoza, Sarahí Silva (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-01631.txt.
Introduction
Sergio Mendoza and Sarahí Silva settle a long-running choice in the theory of fluids and gravity, in a 2025 paper. Models of an ideal fluid in Einstein's theory need a quantity called the matter Lagrangian. Textbooks have used either the fluid's pressure or its total energy density, treating the two as interchangeable. The authors show the pressure choice leads to physical inconsistencies.
Once the fluid is coupled to the gravitational field, only the energy density choice stays consistent. The conclusion is firm: for an ideal fluid, the matter Lagrangian must be the total energy density. The result cleans up a quiet ambiguity that sits inside models of stars and of the early universe.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sergio Mendoza, Sarahí Silva |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 23 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-01631
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The hidden truth of ideal relativistic fluids: the matter Lagrangian is its total energy density, not its pressure! Sergio Mendoza, Sarahí Silva Abstract It has been established in the literature that the matter Lagrangian of an ideal fluid can be expressed either as its total energy density or as its pressure. In this work, we demonstrate that identifying the matter Lagrangian with the pressure leads to physical inconsistencies, which are resolved when the fluid is coupled to the gravitational field. In such a scenario, the matter Lagrangian necessarily assumes the value of the total energy density. We thus conclude that, for an ideal fluid, the only physically consistent choice for the matter Lagrangian is its total energy density. I Introduction As mentioned by Mendoza and Silva [1] , over the years it has become a fact that the value of the matter Lagrangian for an ideal fluid given by either its total energy density, i.e. the sum of rest energy density plus its internal energy density, or by its pressure yield the same energy momentum tensor in relativistic theories of gravity. Our intention in this article is to show that the pressure value of the matter Lagrangian of an ideal fluid is incorrect and that the only allowed value is the total internal energy of the fluid. We define the matter action S as follows [ 2 , see e.g.] : S=\pm\int{\mathcal{L}_{\text{matt}}\,\sqrt{-g}\,\mathrm{d}^{4}x}, (1) where \mathcal{L}_{\text{matt}} represents the matter Lagrangian and g is the determinant of the metric tensor g_{\alpha\beta} . The Hilbert energy-momentum tensor is defined as [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , see e.g.] : T_{\alpha\beta}=\pm\frac{2}{\sqrt{-g}}\frac{\delta\left(\sqrt{-g}\,\mathcal{L}_{\text{matt}}\right)}{\delta g^{\alpha\beta}}, (2) or equivalently: T_{\alpha\beta}=\pm 2\frac{\delta\mathcal{L}_{\text{matt}}}{\delta g^{\alpha\beta}}\mp g_{\alpha\beta}\mathcal{L}_{\text{matt}}. (3) Throughout the article we use Greek space-time indices from 0 to 4 , Einstein’s summation convention, a (+,-,-,-) signature for the metric tensor, units where the velocity of light c=1 and as usual, we assume that the matter Lagrangian is independent of the spatial derivatives of the metric tensor [ 2 ] . The 4-velocity vector u_{\alpha} is normalised such that: u^{\alpha}u_{\alpha}=1. (4) The article is organised as follows. In section II we describe the basic concepts of an ideal fluid used throughout the article and explain how the value of the matter Lagrangian yields the total internal energy density as explained by Mendoza and Silva [1] . In section III we describe how a potential flow non-coupled with the gravitational field yields the pressure as the value of the matter Lagrangian for an ideal fluid. Section IV shows that if a potential flow is coupled to the gravitational field, the matter Lagrangian for an ideal fluid is its total energy density. Later on, in Section V we show some very general hydrodynamical results that show how the only possible solution to the matter Lagrangian is its internal energy density. Additionally it will be clear in Section VI that the well known result of the nullity of the variations of Taub’s current, which immediately yields the fact that the matter Lagrangian of an ideal fluid is its pressure, is incorrect, showing additionally that the correct non-null variations of this current yield the total energy density as the value of the matter Lagrangian of a perfect fluid. Also, in Section VI we discuss our results and show that an ideal fluid for which its matter Lagrangian is given by the pressure cannot exist in nature. II Hydrodynamics of an ideal fluid An ideal fluid moves adiabatically [ 6 , 7 , 8 ] so that the first law of thermodynamics is given by: \mathrm{d}\left(\frac{e}{n}\right)=-p\mathrm{d}\left(\frac{1}{n}\right), (5) or equivalently: \mathrm{d}\left(\frac{\omega}{n}\right)=\frac{1}{n}\mathrm{d}p, (6) where e,\ p,\ and n represent the total (rest plus internal) energy density, the pressure and the particle number density of the fluid. The enthalpy per unit volume \omega is given by \omega:=e+p . In here and in what follows we use Landau and Lifshitz [7] formulation where extensive thermodynamic quantities are measured per unit volume. An ideal fluid satisfies a polytropic relation given by [ 9 , 7 , 10 , 11 ] : p=Kn^{\gamma}, (7) where K is a constant and so, the equation of state of an ideal fluid is given by [ 9 ] : e=mn+\frac{p}{\gamma-1}, (8) where m is average mass per particle and \gamma is a constant equal to the ratio of the fluid’s specific heats. The first term in equation ( 8 ) is the rest energy density and the second one is its pure internal energy density per unit volume which is obtained from equation ( 7 ). With the aid of equation ( 8 ), the first law of thermodynamics for an ideal fluid becomes: \frac{\mathrm{d}p}{p}=\gamma\frac{\mathrm{d}n}{n}. (9) The energy-momentum tensor T_{\alpha\beta} for an ideal fluid is given by [ 7 ] : T_{\alpha\beta}=\left(e+p\right)u_{\alpha}u_{\beta}-pg_{\alpha\beta}, (10) and satisfies the conservation equation: \nabla_{\alpha}T^{\alpha\beta}=0. (11) The contraction of equation ( 11 ) with the 4-velocity u_{\beta} and with the use of equations ( 10 ) and ( 5 ) yields the continuity equation: \nabla_{\alpha}\left(nu^{\alpha}\right)=0. (12) Contraction of equation ( 11 ) with the projection tensor h_{\mu\beta}:=g_{\mu\beta}-u_{\mu}u_{\beta} yields Euler’s equation given by: \omega u^{\mu}\nabla_{\mu}u_{\nu}-h^{\mu}_{\nu}\nabla_{\mu}p=0, (13) which can be rewritten as: u^{\alpha}\nabla_{\alpha}\left(\frac{\omega}{n}u_{\beta}\right)=\nabla_{\beta}\left(\frac{\omega}{n}\right) (14) with the help of equation ( 6 ). The previous relation can be rewritten as: u^{\alpha}\left(\nabla_{\alpha}\left(\frac{\omega}{n}u_{\beta}\right)-\nabla_{\beta}\left(\frac{\omega}{n}u_{\alpha}\right)\right)=0. or: u^{\alpha}\left(\frac{\partial}{\partial x^{\alpha}}\left(\frac{\omega}{n}u_{\beta}\right)-\frac{\partial}{\partial x^{\beta}}\left(\frac{\omega}{n}u_{\alpha}\right)\right)=0. (15) As shown by Mendoza and Silva [1] , the matter Lagrangian of an ideal fluid is obtained from the following three conditions: (i) the definition of the Hilbert energy-momentum tensor given by equation ( 3 ), (ii) the value ( 10 ) of the energy-momentum tensor for an ideal fluid and (iii) the variations with respect to the metric tensor of the continuity equation ( 12 ) 1 1 1 Let us consider a conservation equation of the form: \nabla_{\alpha}\left(A^{\alpha}\right)=0. (16) Integrating this relation over an arbitrary 4-hypersurface \Omega and using Gauss’s theorem, it follows that: \int\mathrm{d}{\Omega}A^{\beta}_{;\beta}\sqrt{-g}=\ointclockwise\mathrm{d}S_{\beta}A^{\beta}\sqrt{-g}=0, (17) over any 3-hypersurface with 3-volume element vector \mathrm{d}S_{\beta} that bounds the arbitrary 4-hypersurface \Omega which has a 4-volume element \mathrm{d}\Omega . So, performing the variation of the fixed 3-volume integral it follows that: \delta\ointclockwise\mathrm{d}S_{\beta}A^{\beta}\sqrt{-g}=\ointclockwise\mathrm{d}S_{\beta}\delta\left(A^{\beta}\sqrt{-g}\right)=0. Since this result is valid for any 3 -dimensional hypersurface which bounds any given arbitrary 4 -dimensional surface \Omega , then necessarily: \delta\left(A^{\beta}\sqrt{-g}\right)=0. (18) : \delta\left(\sqrt{-g}nu^{\alpha}\right)=0. (19) to finally obtain 2 2 2 The sign on equation ( 20 ) also depends on the chosen signature for the metric. With a chosen signature ( -,+,+,+ ) for the metric, the matter Lagrangian would be: \mathcal{L}_{\text{matt}}=\pm e, and the plus-minus will also depend on the definition of the matter action ( 1 ). : \mathcal{L}_{\text{matt}}=\mp e, (20) III Potential flow non-coupled to the gravitational field The first calculation that involves an ideal non-coupled potential flow to the gravitational field was performed by Taub [12] . In Appendix A we have reproduced such calculations using modern variational techniques. Later on, it was Schutz [13] who showed that the matter Lagrangian of a general potential flow non-coupled to the gravitational field is also given by this value. Concerning ideal potential flows non-coupled with the gravitational field that reproduce the equations of hydrodynamics, they are all essentially an extension of the non-relativistic pioneering work made by Clebsch [14] , later on improved by the work of Khalatnikov [15]