Morphological Regimes of Rotating Moist Convection

Whitney T. Powers, Adrian Fraser, Evan H. Anders, Jeffrey S. Oishi, Benjamin P. Brown · 2025

Read Morphological Regimes of Rotating Moist Convection by Whitney T. Powers, Adrian Fraser, Evan H. Anders, Jeffrey S. Oishi, Benjamin P. Brown (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-01626.txt.

Introduction

Whitney T Powers and co-authors map the shapes that spinning wet air flow can take in a 2025 paper. Wet flow gains lift when vapour turns to liquid and frees heat, most in rising zones. Spin can reshape that flow more than it reshapes dry flow, so the team runs a suite of models.

Three shape zones turn up: a cell zone, a plume zone, and a new funnel zone with no dry match. The funnel zone moves heat and damp far better with no matching rise in spin speed. That split shows its shapes link heat and upward speed in a rich way.

Catalog record

CREATORWhitney T. Powers, Adrian Fraser, Evan H. Anders, Jeffrey S. Oishi, Benjamin P. Brown
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE48 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-01626

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Morphological Regimes of Rotating Moist Convection Whitney T. Powers, Adrian Fraser, Evan H. Anders, Jeffrey S. Oishi, Benjamin P. Brown Abstract Moist convection is a physical process where the latent heat released by condensation acts as a buoyancy source that can enhance or even trigger an overturning convective instability. Since the saturation temperature often decreases with height, condensation releases latent heat preferentially in regions of upflow. Due to this inhomogeneous heat source, moist convection may be more sensitive to changes in flow morphology, such as those induced by rotation, than dry Rayleigh-Bénard convection. In order to study the effects of rotation on flows driven by latent heat release, we present a suite of numerical simulations that solve the Rainy-Bénard equations [ 25 ] . We identify three morphological regimes: a cellular regime and a plume regime broadly analogous to those found in rotating Rayleigh Bénard convection, and a novel funnel regime that lacks a clear analog within the regimes exhibited by dry convection. We measure energy fluxes through the system and report rotational scalings of the Reynolds and moist Nusselt numbers. We find that moist static energy transport, as measured by a moist Nusselt number, is significantly enhanced in the funnel regime without a corresponding enhancement in Reynolds number, indicating that this funnel regime produces structures with more favorable correlations between the temperature and vertical velocity. Preprint: APS/123-QED I Introduction Condensation releases latent heat which increases the buoyancy of a fluid parcel. Under certain conditions, the latent heat release is sufficient to drive convection in the absence of an unstable potential temperature gradient. The driving force behind this moist convective instability can be highly localized as condensation only occurs in those portions of the fluid which rise into regions where the saturation level is reduced. Thus, unlike dry Rayleigh-Bénard convection, moist convection lacks up-down symmetry and may be more sensitive to changes in flow morphology, such as those induced by rotation. One such region where moist convection occurs and may be influenced by rotation is Jupiter’s weather layer. This region is a thin region in the outer atmosphere with prominent ammonia and water clouds, and is where the planet’s characteristic banded structure and stable geometrically arranged vortexes at the poles are observed [ 1 ] . Moist convection occurs in this region and has been linked to an upscale energy cascade in Jupiter’s polar regions [ 20 ] . Additionally, moist convection may contribute to jet formation in the mid-latitudes [ 12 , 16 ] and the dearth of moist-convective activity near the equator may be responsible for the overabundance of ammonia in this region [ 9 ] . Upflows driven by moist convection can cause storms, and the location of these storms can then be mapped by observations of lightning strikes. Observations from the Galileo and Juno missions found that lightning strikes, and thus moist convective motions, are more common at latitudes above 40 degrees and are more common in the northern hemisphere [ 3 , 17 ] . This hemispherical asymmetry is present in both data sets, and is present throughout the Juno observations, suggesting that this is not an artifact from an anomalously strong storm. Furthermore, these studies found that moist convection is more prevalent in regions of cyclonic shear. The mechanisms behind the global distribution of moist convection are not fully known, and study of the fundamental properties of latent heat-driven convection is an important step towards understanding the dynamics of Jupiter’s atmosphere. Jupiter’s dynamics are strongly influenced by rotation. Jupiter has a rotation period of approximately eight hours, and estimates place the Rossby number, the ratio of inertial and Coriolis forces, in the interior at 10^{-5} to 10^{-4} and in the weather layer at 0.4 [ 8 ] . Since the Rossby number of the weather layer is less than one, the effects of rotation are significant and must be included in models that aim to study this region. Dry, rotating, Rayleigh-Bénard convection has been studied in great detail. As the reduced Rayleigh number, \mathcal{R} (a dimensionless measure of buoyant driving relative to the stabilizing effects of viscosity, diffusion, and rotation) is increased, the system transitions through several morphological regimes, each with their own characteristic structures, force balances, and energetics. At reduced Rayleigh numbers just above onset, rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection exhibits a cellular regime characterized by laminar upflow and downflow columns packed in a regular hexagonal pattern [ 5 , 13 , 23 ] . At higher values of supercriticality, and for Prandtl numbers above unity, the flows transition to the convective-Taylor-column regime [ 22 ] . In this regime, the flow morphology is characterized by upflow and downflow columns each sheathed by counter-rotating fluid of the opposite sign of thermal fluctuation. Since these sheathed columns have zero net vorticity, they are non-interacting and freely drift throughout the domain. Thus, they do not organize into a stable geometric packing [ 7 , 15 , 23 ] . At yet higher values of \mathcal{R} , the cellular structure is lost and the flows enter a plume regime characterized by the breakdown of vertically coherent columns [ 15 , 23 ] . This breakdown occurs as the thermal boundary layer destabilizes and launches thermal plumes. Finally, at even higher values of supercriticality, vertical coherence breaks down further and the flows enter a geostrophic turbulence regime where pressure locally balances the Coriolis force [ 23 , 14 , 15 ] . There are several proposed models that aim to study moist convection at a fundamental level [ 19 , 10 , 21 , 6 , 24 , e.g.,] . The “Rainy-Bénard” model from Vallis et al. [25] (hereafter VPT19) is a particularly simple example, designed to focus study on the buoyancy released from condensation. This model assumes that all condensed fluid coalesces into rain, falls out rapidly, and does not form clouds or experience re-evaporation. The set of equations from VPT19 has been used in several studies of moist convection [ 25 , 18 , 2 ] which explored 2D domains without rotation. Prior studies of rotating moist convection used a quasi-geostrophic system Smith & Stechmann [21] , Chen et al. [6] which assumes the limit of rapid rotation (small Rossby number). In this paper we present a suite of simulations of rotating moist convection without using a quasi-geostrophic system allowing us to study systems of more moderate rotation like Jupiter’s weather layer. We use the the Rainy-Bénard model of VPT19 and discuss the effects of rotation on flow morphology and scaling laws of the heat transport and degree of turbulence. We explain the equations and our numerical methods in section II . We ran a suite of simulations across Rayleigh-Ekman space, and identify several morphological regimes which we discuss in section III . We then measure energy fluxes through the system, and report Nusselt and Reynolds number scalings in section IV . Finally, we discuss the implications of these results for further study of rapidly rotating planets such as Jupiter in section V . II Methods Figure 1: The suite of simulations is shown on a plot of reduced Rayleigh number ( \mathcal{R}\equiv\rm{Ra}\,\rm{Ek}^{4/3} ) against Ekman number \rm{Ek} as well as the critical reduced Rayleigh number curve

Read the complete text