Chirality-bolstered quantum Zeno effect enhances radical pair-based magnetoreception
Luke D. Smith 1,2, Sukesh Tallapudi 3, Matt C. J. Denton 1,2, Daniel R. Kattnig 1,2,∗ · 2025
Read Chirality-bolstered quantum Zeno effect enhances radical pair-based magnetoreception by Luke D. Smith 1,2, Sukesh Tallapudi 3, Matt C. J. Denton 1,2, Daniel R. Kattnig 1,2,∗ (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-01519.txt.
Introduction
Smith, Tallapudi, Denton, and Kattnig present a study from twenty twenty-five on chirality effects in radical pair magnetoreception. Radical pairs in a bird protein are central to the proposed compass sense. The protein's chirality may sharpen magnetic sensitivity through a spin selectivity effect. The mechanism behind that boost was unresolved. The team model two radical pair setups, one making spin polarization and one making coherence. Polarization from chirality boosts sensitivity markedly in their sums. It does so by adding triplet character and reinforcing a quantum Zeno effect.
Coherence from chirality gives no real gain in sensitivity. The authors warn the effect is not a universal enhancer. They provide a unified scheme to model chirality-shaped starting states. Each case must be judged on its own terms.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Luke D. Smith 1,2, Sukesh Tallapudi 3, Matt C. J. Denton 1,2, Daniel R. Kattnig 1,2,∗ |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 50 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-01519
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Chirality-bolstered quantum Zeno effect enhances radical pair-based magnetoreception Luke D. Smith 1,2, Sukesh Tallapudi 3, Matt C. J. Denton 1,2, Daniel R. Kattnig 1,2,∗ Abstract Radical pairs in the flavoprotein cryptochrome are central to various magnetically sensitive biological processes, including the proposed mechanism of avian magnetoreception. Cryptochrome’s molecular chirality has been hypothesized to enhance magnetic field effects via the chirality-induced spin selectivity (CISS) effect, yet the mechanism underlying this enhancement remains unresolved. In this work, we systematically investigate the impact of CISS on the directional magnetic sensitivity of prototypical radical pair reactions, analyzing two distinct models–one generating spin polarization and, for the first time, one generating coherence. We find that CISS-induced spin polarization significantly enhances magnetic sensitivity by introducing triplet character into the initial state and reinforcing the quantum Zeno effect, paralleling enhancements observed in triplet-born radical pairs subject to strongly asymmetric recombination. In contrast, CISS-generated spin coherence does not provide a significant improvement in sensitivity. These findings indicate that CISS is not itself a universal enhancer of sensitivity or coherence in radical-pair reactions, and its influence must be evaluated case by case, particularly in relation to the quantum Zeno effect. Additionally, we provide a unified interpolation scheme for modeling CISS-influenced initial states and recombination dynamics, encompassing the principal models currently discussed in the literature for singlet and triplet precursors. Introduction The radical pair mechanism (RPM) provides the most compelling explanation for magnetic field effects (MFEs) in biology, including the proposed visual magnetoreception of migratory birds Wiltschko and Wiltschko 2019 ; Mouritsen 2018 ; Johnsen and Lohmann 2008 . The RPM describes how spin dynamics within radical pairs, appearing as short-lived intermediates in electron transfer reactions, acquire magnetic field sensitivity as a result of their coherent spin dynamics Hore and Mouritsen 2016 . A particularly actively researched field in this context is (avian) magnetoreception, which is considered a prime example of quantum biology Alvarez et al. 2024 ; Kim et al. 2021 . The flavoprotein cryptochrome is the leading candidate for hosting this sensory function Ritz et al. 2000 . In cryptochrome, two radical pairs are widely considered. The FAD ∙- /W {}_{\mathrm{C}}^{\bullet+} radical pair is generated via a photo-induced electron transfer from a tryptophan residue ( \mathrm{W_{C}} ) to a flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD) cofactor Ramsay et al. 2024 ; Frederiksen et al. 2023 ; Wong et al. 2021 ; Kattnig et al. 2016a ; Nohr et al. 2016 ; Müller et al. 2015 ; Liedvogel et al. 2007 ; Giovani et al. 2003 . The second, FADH ∙ /O {}^{\bullet-}_{2} , forms in the dark during flavin reoxidation with molecular oxygen Deviers et al. 2024 ; Salerno et al. 2023 ; Arthaut et al. 2017 ; van Wilderen et al. 2015 ; Müller and Ahmad 2011 ; Ritz et al. 2009 ; Massey 1994 . While the former is singlet-born and has demonstrated MFEs under moderate magnetic fields in vitro Xu et al. 2021 ; Kerpal et al. 2019 ; Maeda et al. 2008 ; Timmel et al. 1998 , its weak-field magnetosensitivity is attenuated by interradical interactions Babcock and Kattnig 2020 ; Efimova and Hore 2008 ; O’Dea et al. 2005 , spin relaxation Grüning et al. 2024 ; Worster et al. 2016 ; Kattnig et al. 2016b , and symmetrically distributed but misaligned hyperfine couplings Grüning et al. 2022 ; Smith et al. 2022 ; Atkins et al. 2019 . The latter, triplet-born FADH ∙ /O {}^{\bullet-}_{2} , benefits from an asymmetric distribution of hyperfine couplings over the two radicals Smith et al. 2024 ; Procopio and Ritz 2020 ; Lee et al. 2014 , but suffers from rapid spin relaxation via the spin-rotational mechanism when tumbling freely Player and Hore 2019 ; Karogodina et al. 2011 ; Hogben et al. 2009 , or strong interradical coupling when immobilized Deviers et al. 2024 ; Salerno et al. 2023 ; Mondal and Huix-Rotllant 2019 . For both systems, the mentioned adverse effects raise doubts about the viability of sensing the direction of the weak geomagnetic field. This has led to an active search for enhancing mechanisms over the past decade, which has hinted at remarkable possibilities. Several enhancements to RPM have been proposed to counter the sensitivity gap: J/D cancellation Efimova and Hore 2008 , three-radical mechanisms Babcock and Kattnig 2020 ; Keens et al. 2018 , radical scavenging Ramsay and Kattnig 2022 ; Deviers et al. 2022 ; Babcock and Kattnig 2021 ; Kattnig and Hore 2017 , relaxation-assisted mechanisms Luo 2024 ; Kattnig and Hore 2017 and both diffusive and driven-radical motion Ramsay and Kattnig 2023 ; Smith et al. 2022 . Although most of these extensions are effective in enhancing the magnetosensitivity of cryptochrome, they require additional features, the viability of which in real systems is yet to be determined. More recently, enhancements through asymmetrical kinetics and the quantum Zeno effect Burgarth et al. 2020 ; Dellis and Kominis 2012 ; Berdinskii and Yakunin 2008 ; Itano et al. 1990 ; Misra and Sudarshan 1977 have shown promise, particularly in tightly bound triplet-born radical pairs such as FADH ∙ /O {}^{\bullet-}_{2} Denton et al. 2024 . Among the various spin-dependent phenomena in chemistry, the chirality-induced spin selectivity (CISS) effect has recently gained significant attention for its proposed role in polarizing electron spins in both artificial and biological systems Chiesa et al. 2023 ; Aiello et al. 2022 ; Abendroth et al. 2019 ; Bloom et al. 2017 ; Michaeli et al. 2016 ; Wasielewski 2006 . Generally, CISS describes the coupling between chirality and electron spin in electron displacement currents and transmission, such as in electron transfer reactions, which can induce spin coherence Fay 2021 , and spin polarization Fay and Limmer 2023 ; Vittmann et al. 2023 ; Vittmann et al. 2022 ; Fay and Limmer 2021 ; Luo and Hore 2021 ; Chiesa et al. 2021 . A comprehensive review of CISS and its theoretical modeling can be found in Bloom et al. 2024 . However, the theoretical basis for the CISS effect remains incomplete. This notwithstanding, it has been suggested that CISS may influence radical pair dynamics, for example, through spin polarization during formation or recombination Luo and Hore 2021 . Observing that proteins, such as cryptochrome, are inherently chiral raises an intriguing question: Could the CISS effect play a role in quantum biology, especially in cryptochrome Alvarez et al. 2024 ; Kim et al. 2021 ? In fact, preliminary explorations appear to support this idea. Studies on FAD ∙- /W {}_{\mathrm{C}}^{\bullet+} radical pairs have demonstrated promising sensitivity and coherence enhancements Tiwari and Poonia 2023 ; Tiwari and Poonia 2022 using a phenomenological model that assumes spin polarization during the formation and recombination of the radical pair Luo and Hore 2021 . However, the model used is not supported by microscopic derivation and is not universal. Moreover, the predicted enhancements are, as of now, not supported by direct experimental validation, for which even the existence of the effect in cryptochrome has yet to be confirmed. Although often attributed to spin-orbit coupling, research suggests that chirality and spin-orbit coupling alone induce spin coherence but not spin polarization Fay 2021 , which also requires electron hopping and electronic exchange interactions Fay and Limmer