Comparative biosignatures with systemic retrievals

Tereza Constantinou, Oliver Shorttle, Miles Cranmer, Paul B. Rimmer · 2025

Read Comparative biosignatures with systemic retrievals by Tereza Constantinou, Oliver Shorttle, Miles Cranmer, Paul B. Rimmer (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-01512.txt.

Introduction

Tereza Constantinou and three co-authors propose a new way to judge claims of life on planets around other stars in a 2025 paper. Telescopes like JWST can detect gases that might signal life, but the hard part is ruling out ordinary chemistry as the source. For a single planet, that judgment is shaky because lifeless processes vary a lot.

Their plan compares planets within one system. Lifeless planets in the same system set a baseline for what plain chemistry does there, since siblings share a birth disk, a star, and a linked history. A gas pattern that stands out from that baseline, and fits a living-world model better than a lifeless one, counts as a comparative biosignature. Cases where neither model fits get flagged for more work.

Catalog record

CREATORTereza Constantinou, Oliver Shorttle, Miles Cranmer, Paul B. Rimmer
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE139 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-01512

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Comparative biosignatures with systemic retrievals Tereza Constantinou, Oliver Shorttle, Miles Cranmer, Paul B. Rimmer Abstract The discovery of inhabited exoplanets hinges on identifying biosignature gases. JWST can reveal biosignature gases, though current discoveries have yet to evidence life. The central challenge is attribution: how can we confidently identify biogenic sources while ruling out, or deeming unlikely, abiotic explanations? Attribution is particularly difficult for individual planets, especially given the stochastic abiotic processes that can set atmospheric conditions. To address this, we propose a comparative multi-planet approach centred on systemic retrievals: the analysis of multiple planets within a system to empirically define the ‘abiotic baseline’. This baseline, constructed from obligate uninhabited planets, serves as a local reference point. Systemic retrievals enable marginalisation over inaccessible, latent, shared abiotic parameters within planet evolution models. This is possible because planets within a system are linked by their birth in the same natal disk, have been irradiated by the same evolving star, and have a linked dynamical history. Observations aligning with the abiotic baseline, where the locally-informed abiotic planet evolution models demonstrate high out-of-sample predictive accuracy, are likely non-biological. Potentially biological anomalies are identified as statistical outliers from the abiotic baseline using Bayesian leave-one-out cross-validation. A comparative biosignature is thus defined: an anomaly where a biotic planetary evolution model provides a superior fit than its abiotic counterpart. Where both abiotic and biotic models yield poor predictive accuracy, the anomaly is flagged as an “unknown unknown”; a signature of either unconstrained abiotic processes, or life as we don’t yet know it. 2025 Comparative biosignatures with systemic retrievals – D.2 1 Introduction While Earth remains our only known example of an inhabited planet, it provides the only information on what life’s signals might be like. Observable signals of biological origin, biosignatures ( Des Marais et al., 2008 ) , may come in several forms ( Schwieterman et al., 2018 , and references therein) . One biosignature that has long been the focus of the search for life is radio emission. Radio searches represent a search specifically for technologically capable (‘intelligent’) life, through its active transmission of electromagnetic radiation into the galaxy ( Cocconi and Morrison, 1959 ; Tarter, 2001 ; Choza et al., 2024 ) . However, intelligent life represents only a brief moment in the history of the Earth’s biosphere. Looking towards Earth at a random point over its history, our ability to identify the presence of its biosphere through remote observation is more likely to rest on identifying passive biosignatures: those signals a biosphere imprints on its environment through core metabolic function ( Seager et al., 2012 ; Seager et al., 2016 ) . Passive biosignatures are, however, rarely indisputable evidence of life; abiotic processes may generate the same signals, or modulate the biotic signal. When searched for as gases in a planet’s atmosphere, biosignatures need careful interpretation, employing significant geological, atmospheric, and stellar context. Phosphine is usefully illustrative of this point: in the oxidising atmospheres of rocky planets, phosphine has been suggested to be a powerful biosignature ( Sousa-Silva et al., 2020 ) . However, in the cold reducing atmosphere of Jupiter, phosphine is expected to be abundant abiotically ( Prinn and Lewis, 1975 ; Howland et al., 1979 ) . For phosphine, and for biosignatures generally, context is key. 1.1 Finding biosignatures of biogenic origin Our ability to confidently identify a biosignature gas as biotic in origin depends on four crucial factors ( Seager et al., 2025 ) : 1. Establishing the presence of features in the data – i.e., precise observations, and characterisation of systematic sources of error ( Schlawin et al., 2021 , e.g.,) ; 2. Unambiguously linking features in the data to the presence of molecules – i.e., gases need to be sufficiently abundant at atmospheric heights that can be probed, spectral features need to be distinct from other molecules ( Sousa-Silva et al., 2019 ) , and robust data reduction and atmospheric retrieval approaches ( Constantinou et al., 2023 ) ; 3. Ruling in a biotic explanation for observed molecules – through knowledge of what biosphere-scale signals life produces through interaction with its environment ( Lovelock and Margulis, 1974 ; Seager et al., 2015 ) ; and, 4. Ruling out an abiotic explanation – requiring sufficient understanding of the abiotic processes on the planet that could also produce biosignature molecules ( Catling et al., 2018 ; Krissansen-Totton et al., 2022 ; Gillen et al., 2023 ) . Observational limits on biosignature detection are beginning to be overcome, addressing factors (i) and (ii). Advances in instrumentation, chiefly the launch of the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) ( Beichman et al., 2014 ; Tremblay et al., 2020 ; Gialluca et al., 2021 ; Constantinou et al., 2023 , e.g.,) and in the near future the first light of the Extremely Large Telescope ( Padovani and Cirasuolo, 2023 , ELT;) , herald a new era in our capacity to characterise exoplanet atmospheres. With JWST, biosignature gases are beginning to be reported in the atmospheres of sub-Neptunes, with an early example being methane detected in K2-18 b’s atmosphere ( Madhusudhan et al., 2023 ) . The same study also reported a possible dimethyl sulfide (DMS) feature, though its significance varied with the data reduction procedure and was questioned by Schmidt et al. (2025) . A subsequent claim of a DMS detection with JWST/MIRI ( Madhusudhan et al., 2025 ) has also been debated ( Taylor, 2025 ; Welbanks et al., 2025 ; Luque et al., 2025 ) . These discussions underscore that there are still important systematics to overcome factors (i) and (ii). Nonetheless, these developments begin to shift the challenge towards disentangling abiotic and biotic atmospheric processes in an effort to better identify the origin of observed gases. Factors (iii) and (iv) are key, as claiming biogenicity for a given observation will centre on whether abiotic processes can generate the same signature or not. E.g., for the case of biosignature gases, whether abiotic processes can supply them to the atmosphere at sufficient rates to maintain observed abundances, counteracting the species’ photolytic and geological sinks. Addressing this requires robust biogeochemical and photochemical models that can simulate abiotic gas production and destruction under varying planetary conditions. Beyond just biosignature gases , factors (iii) and (iv) are also critical for seeking objects, patterns or substances that could be created by life, and for distinguishing them from abiotic sources ( McMahon and Cosmidis, 2022 , e.g., assessing candidate biosignatures on Mars;) . Detecting a single biosignature gas is unlikely to provide strong evidence for the presence of life on a planet. For a single datum in a vast possibility space, there will exist many ambiguities in its interpretation and origin ( Krissansen-Totton et al., 2022 ; Meadows et al., 2022 ) . In the one-planet paradigm, a key approach to mitigate this ambiguity is to use more than a single datum: biosignature pairs, i.e,. sets of gases that together evidence disequilibrium chemistry. Observation of such an atmospheric chemical disequilibrium raises the probability of biological activity maintaining (one or more of) these gases to a non-equilibrium state ( Lovelock, 1965 ; Hitchcock and Lovelock, 1967 ; Lovelock, 1975 ; Sagan et al., 1993 ) . Otherwise, when left

Read the complete text