Universality of Colored Scalars from the Stringy KLT Kernel

Christoph Bartsch 1, Karol Kampf 1 \,{}^{1}, Jiří Novotný 1, Jaroslav Trnka 2 · 2025

Read Universality of Colored Scalars from the Stringy KLT Kernel by Christoph Bartsch 1, Karol Kampf 1 \,{}^{1}, Jiří Novotný 1, Jaroslav Trnka 2 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-01501.txt.

Introduction

Three unlike particle theories give scattering answers that look unrelated, yet one kernel may birth them all. Christoph Bartsch, Karol Kampf, Jiří Novotný, and Jaroslav Trnka argue that unity in a 2025 paper. The kernel inverts a classic string theory bridge.

Colored scalars, pions, and their mixed cases all arise from it. A shift in the kernel's tension swaps one theory's answers for another's. Cubic scalars and pions become two faces of one function. The shift joins an earlier one in the toolkit. Scattering, they show, has fewer independent rules than thought.

Catalog record

CREATORChristoph Bartsch 1, Karol Kampf 1 \,{}^{1}, Jiří Novotný 1, Jaroslav Trnka 2
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE33 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-01501

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Universality of Colored Scalars from the Stringy KLT Kernel Christoph Bartsch 1, Karol Kampf 1 \,{}^{1}, Jiří Novotný 1, Jaroslav Trnka 2 Abstract A new perspective on the inverse string theory Kawai-Lewellen-Tye (KLT) kernel is provided which establishes the universality of scattering amplitudes in the bi-adjoint scalar (BAS) theory, pions in the Non-linear sigma model (NLSM), and mixed amplitudes (NLSM+ ϕ 3 \phi^{3} ) recently studied in the literature. We show that all these amplitudes can be viewed as equivalent, arising from a single function, the inverse string theory KLT kernel, evaluated at different kinematic points. In this way cubic colored scalars and pions become interchangeable through a procedure we call the α ′ \alpha^{\prime} -shift. The latter complements the δ \delta -shift proposed by Arkani-Hamed et al., and demonstrates an inherent equivalence of scattering amplitudes in different quantum field theories by embedding them in a common stringy framework. I. Introduction String-inspired techniques play an important role in discovering new properties of scattering amplitudes for point particles. In particular, a lot of progress was made recently in understanding close relationships between amplitudes of bi-adjoint scalars (BAS), pions in the non-linear sigma model (NLSM) and gluons in Yang-Mills theory from the kinematic surface picture Arkani-Hamed et al. 2024a ; Arkani-Hamed et al. 2025 ; Arkani-Hamed et al. 2024b . At the heart of their unity lies a kinematic deformation, the \delta -shift, which parametrizes a family of worldsheet integrals yielding the desired amplitudes in various limits Arkani-Hamed et al. 2024c ; Arkani-Hamed et al. 2024d . The connection is particularly immediate for scalars as field theory amplitudes for pions can be directly extracted from those of cubic scalars in the BAS theory, even at loop-level Arkani-Hamed and Figueiredo 2024a ; Arkani-Hamed et al. 2024e . Another well-studied connection between BAS and NLSM amplitudes is via their stringy extensions into (non-)abelian Z -functions Broedel et al. 2013 ; Mafra and Schlotterer 2017 ; Carrasco et al. 2017a ; Carrasco et al. 2017b . There, relations between cubic scalars and pions, as well as mixed amplitudes involving both (NLSM+BAS) are established via a procedure known as (semi-)abelianization. All the aforementioned amplitudes share another string-derived property: the duality between color and kinematics. As a consequence, amplitudes of cubic scalars, pions and gluons, among others, can be used as input in a procedure known as the double copy to generate permutationally invariant amplitudes for gravity, the special Galileon and more Bern et al. 2024 . A central object in this context is the string theory KLT kernel Bjerrum-Bohr et al. 2011 \mathcal{S}_{\alpha^{\prime}}\!\left[\sigma|\rho\right] which was first discovered by observing the double-copy structure of closed and open string amplitudes Kawai et al. 1986 , \displaystyle M^{\text{closed}}=\!\!\!\!\sum_{\sigma,\rho\in S_{n-3}}\!\!\!\!A^{\text{open}}\left[\sigma\right]\mathcal{S}_{\alpha^{\prime}}\!\left[\sigma|\rho\right]A^{\text{open}}\left[\rho\right]. In this letter we set out to connect the world of the \delta -shift and that of the (semi-)abelianization procedures established in the context of (non-)abelian Z -theory. This will be accomplished by studying the simplest known stringy extension of BAS amplitudes provided by the inverse m^{\alpha^{\prime}}\equiv\mathcal{S}_{\alpha^{\prime}}^{-1} of the string theory KLT kernel Mizera 2017a ; Mizera 2017b . Consequently, we will establish that the KLT kernel encodes not only the scattering of cubic scalars but also pion and mixed amplitudes in the NLSM+BAS theory. To extract this information we will first study their connection by analogy to Z -theory using (semi-) abelianization to obtain stringy functions related to the scattering of pions. A simple general structure observed in these functions then naturally suggests the construction of a stringy variant of the \delta -shift, which we call the \alpha^{\prime} -shift. We will argue that the \alpha^{\prime} -shift establishes a fundamental equivalence between cubic scalars and pions which may be most succinctly summarized as \text{BAS}_{\alpha^{\prime}}=\text{NLSM}_{\alpha^{\prime}}=(\text{NLSM}+\text{BAS})_{\alpha^{\prime}}=\text{KLT}_{\alpha^{\prime}}^{-1}. That is to say, all amplitudes for scalars and pions can be obtained from the same function , the inverse string theory KLT kernel, evaluated on appropriately \alpha^{\prime} -shifted kinematics. II. The Inverse String Theory KLT Kernel In Mizera 2017a ; Mizera 2017b Mizera initiated the study of the matrix inverse of the KLT kernel m^{\alpha^{\prime}}\!\equiv\mathcal{S}_{\alpha^{\prime}}^{-1} and showed that its matrix elements m^{\alpha^{\prime}}\!\left[\sigma|\rho\right] are simple kinematic functions. Explicit examples for these matrix elements include the three-point function m_{3}^{\alpha^{\prime}}\left[\mathds{1}|\mathds{1}\right]=1 as well as \displaystyle\begin{split}&\hskip-5.69046ptm_{4}^{\alpha^{\prime}}\!\!\left[\mathds{1}|\mathds{1}\right]=\frac{1}{t_{13}}{+}\frac{1}{t_{24}},\hskip 2.84544ptm_{5}^{\alpha^{\prime}}\!\!\left[\mathds{1}|\mathds{1}\right]=\left(\!\frac{1}{t_{13}t_{14}}{+}\text{cyc.}\!\right){+}1,\\ &\hskip-5.69046ptm_{4}^{\alpha^{\prime}}\!\!\left[\mathds{1}|1243\right]=-\frac{1}{s_{13}},\hskip 2.84544ptm_{5}^{\alpha^{\prime}}\!\!\left[\mathds{1}|13245\right]=\frac{1}{s_{14}}\!\left(\!\frac{1}{t_{13}}{+}\frac{1}{t_{24}}\!\right)\!,\end{split} (1) at four and five points. We denote by \mathds{1} the identity permutation of n labels and introduce the \alpha^{\prime} -dependent planar Mandelstam variables \displaystyle t_{ij}=\tan\left(\pi\alpha^{\prime}X_{ij}\right),\hskip 14.22636pts_{ij}=\sin\left(\pi\alpha^{\prime}X_{ij}\right), (2) which are stringy versions of the field theory X -variables X_{ij}=(p_{i}+\dots+p_{j-1})^{2} . From ( 1 ) we see that diagonal matrix elements m_{n}^{\alpha^{\prime}}\!\left[\mathds{1}|\mathds{1}\right] depend only on t_{ij} whereas off-diagonal elements m_{n}^{\alpha^{\prime}}\!\left[\mathds{1}|\rho\right] , \rho\neq\mathds{1} generically involve t_{ij} and s_{ij} . Taking the infinite tension limit \alpha^{\prime}{\to}\,0 of m_{n}^{\alpha^{\prime}} yields partial amplitudes of the bi-adjoint scalar (BAS) theory, \displaystyle m_{n}^{\alpha^{\prime}}\!\left[\sigma|\rho\right]=(\pi\alpha^{\prime})^{3-n}\big(m_{n}\left[\sigma|\rho\right]+\mathcal{O}(\alpha^{\prime})\big). (3) A crucial feature of the stringy matrix elements m_{n}^{\alpha^{\prime}} is the presence of an infinite tower of odd-point interactions Mizera 2017a (c.f. the five-point contact term in ( 1 )). In fact, diagonal matrix elements m_{n}^{\alpha^{\prime}}\!\left[\mathds{1}|\mathds{1}\right] can be computed as sums over all Feynman diagrams constructed from the given odd-point vertices and propagators t_{ij}^{-1} . For instance, at six points, the diagonal matrix element is schematically given by the diagrams \displaystyle\begin{matrix}\hskip-7.96674pt\vskip 0.0pt\includegraphics[width]{figures/6ptDiags.pdf}\end{matrix} (4) In the limit \alpha^{\prime}\to 0 only the cubic topologies contribute to the field theory BAS amplitude m_{6}\left[\mathds{1}|\mathds{1}\right] by ( 3 ), while the topology involving the five-point vertex is sub-leading. Nevertheless, sub-leading- \alpha^{\prime} corrections in the inverse string theory KLT kernel m_{n}^{\alpha^{\prime}} will be essential to connect to pions and mixed amplitudes. Given the diagram topologies for m_{n}\left[\mathds{1}|\mathds{1}\right] , off-diagonal matrix elements m_{n}^{\alpha^{\prime}}\!\left[\mathds{1}|\rho\right] then correspond to subsets of those diagrams which are planar with respect to both orderings \mathds{1} and \rho , analogous to off-diagonal BAS amplitudes Cachazo et al. 2014 . In addition, certain stringy propagators t_{ij}^{-1} are replaced by s_{ij}^{-1} for the off-diagonal matrix elements. III. Pions via Abelianization Let us now define an abelianized function \displaystyle A_{n}^{\alpha^{\prime}}\!\left[\sigma\right]\equiv\frac{1}{2}\!\sum_{\rho(2\dots n)}\!\!m_{n}^{\alpha^{\prime}}\!\left[\sigma|1\,\rho\right], (5) as a sum over one of the orderings of the inverse KLT kernel. Here we adopt the nomenclature of the Z -theory literature Broedel et al. 2013 ; Mafra and Schlotterer 2017 ; Carrasco et al. 2017a ; Carrasco et al. 2017b , where the notion of abelianization relates so-called non-abelian and abelian Z -functions. Both are closely related to the inverse KLT kernel Mizera 2017a . A simple example of ( 5 ) is provided by the abelianized four-point function, \displaystyle A^{\alpha^{\prime}}_{4}\!\left[\mathds{1}\right]=\!\left(\!\frac{1}{t_{13}}{-}\frac{1}{s_{13}}\!\right){+}\left(\!\frac{1}{t_{24}}{-}\frac{1}{s_{24}}\!\right)=-\left(\tau_{13}+\tau_{24}\right). (6) Here we introduce the half-angle variables \displaystyle\tau_{ij}=\tan\left(\frac{\pi}{2}\alpha^{\prime}X_{ij}\right), (7) which are the natural kinematic variables for abelianized functions, as we will see. They are related to the variables t_{ij},\,s_{ij} of the inverse KLT kernel via trigonometric half-angle identities \displaystyle\frac{1}{t_{ij}}+\frac{1}{s_{ij}}=\frac{1}{\tau_{ij}},\hskip 14.22636pt\frac{1}{t_{ij}}-\frac{1}{s_{ij}}=-\tau_{ij}. (8) Expanding the four-point function ( 6 ) in powers of \alpha^{\prime} we obtain A^{\alpha^{\prime}}_{4}=-\frac{\pi\alpha^{\prime}}{2}(X_{13}+X_{24})+\mathcal{O}(\alpha^{\prime 3}) at leading order which is the four-pion NLSM amplitude. This holds true more generally. For even multiplicity n=2k the low-energy limit of the abelianized functions ( 5 ) is given by NLSM pion amplitudes, \displaystyle A_{2k}^{\alpha^{\prime}}=\frac{\pi\alpha^{\prime}}{2}A_{2k}^{\text{NLSM}}+\mathcal{O}(\alpha^{\prime 3}). (9) An analogous statement to ( 9 ) also holds for the leading- \alpha^{\prime} contribution to abelian Z -functions Carrasco et al. 2017b . However, the abelianized functions A_{2k}^{\alpha^{\prime}} provide a stringy completion of pion amplitudes that is distinct from abelian Z -theory

Read the complete text