Synthetic Emotions and Consciousness: Exploring Architectural Boundaries
Hermann Borotschnig · 2025
Read Synthetic Emotions and Consciousness: Exploring Architectural Boundaries by Hermann Borotschnig (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-01462.txt.
Introduction
Hermann Borotschnig asks whether a machine can show emotion-like behavior without building in the features that leading theories link to consciousness, in this 2025 paper. As artificial agents act more emotional, tools for judging the risk that they might be conscious in some sense are scarce. Borotschnig proposes a design that aims to keep that risk low on purpose.
The design joins two sources of guidance: current needs that push for action, and memories of similar past situations that carry an emotional tint. Four guardrails define the boundary: no global broadcast of content, no self modeling, no lifelong self story, and bounded learning. The paper shows the design can meet all four, maps safe ways to extend it, and traces gradual changes that would raise the risk step by step.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hermann Borotschnig |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 88 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-01462
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Synthetic Emotions and Consciousness: Exploring Architectural Boundaries Hermann Borotschnig Abstract As artificial agents display increasingly sophisticated emotion-like behaviors, frameworks for assessing whether such systems risk instantiating consciousness remain limited. This contribution asks whether synthetic emotion-like control can be implemented while deliberately excluding architectural features that major theories associate with access-like consciousness. We propose architectural principles ( A1 – A8 ) for a hierarchical, dual-source implementation in which (i) immediate needs generate motivational signals and (ii) episodic memory provides affective guidance from similar past situations; the two sources converge to modulate action selection. To operationalize consciousness-related risk, we distill predictions from major theories into four engineering risk-reduction constraints: ( R1 ) no content-general, workspace-like global broadcast, ( R2 ) no metarepresentation, ( R3 ) no autobiographical consolidation, and ( R4 ) bounded learning. We address three questions: ( Q1 ) Can emotion-like control satisfy R1–R4? We present a concrete architecture as an existence proof. ( Q2 ) Can the architecture be extended without introducing access-enabling features? We identify stable modifications that preserve compliance. ( Q3 ) Can we trace graded paths that plausibly increase access risk? We map gradual transitions that progressively violate the constraints. While we cannot resolve questions about consciousness, our contribution operates at three levels: on the engineering side, we present a modular, biologically motivated control architecture; on the theoretical side, we propose a control model of emotions and a methodological template for converting consciousness-related questions into auditable architectural tests; on the safety side, we sketch preliminary audit indicators that may inform future governance frameworks. The architecture functions independently as an emotion-like controller, while the risk-reduction criteria may extend to other AI systems. We offer no definitive answers about phenomenology, but we provide starting points for navigating uncertainty—tools intended to evolve as understanding advances. keywords Synthetic Emotion, Consciousness, AI Safety, Affective Computing, Heuristic Control 1 Introduction Artificial systems now exhibit flexible decision-making, memory, and context-sensitive behavior at a scale that brings long-standing questions about machine consciousness, emotion, and moral status into practical focus ( Seth, 2025 ; Butlin et al., 2025 ) . This contribution asks a focused question of public and policy relevance—and of philosophical interest: Can artificial systems implement emotion-like control as a practical control layer while deliberately avoiding architectural features that major theories associate with access-like consciousness? Artificial architectures offer a tractable domain for probing such questions. We argue that an agent need not self-ascribe feelings in order to operate via affect-like mechanisms. In our operational sense, emotion-like control constitutes a specific family of heuristics for resource-bounded action selection. More concretely, it is a biologically motivated control architecture (A1–A8) in which need-based appraisal and episodic affective memory jointly generate affective states that bias action selection. Affect is not peripheral in this design: affective variables pervade need appraisal, memory encoding, retrieval, fusion, and decision-making, such that the system can neither be understood nor coherently specified without them. The double risk. The relationship between such systems and access-like consciousness carries practical urgency because the risks are asymmetric. On the one hand, emotionally expressive but non-conscious systems may deceive users into forming pseudo-relationships with simulacra, enabling manipulation and psychological harm without any moral patient being present. On the other hand, systems may gain functional sophistication that raises consciousness concerns—particularly when emotion-like mechanisms guide decision-making via standard machine-learning (ML) practices such as value tagging, episodic control ( Pritzel et al., 2017 ) , and deep reinforcement learning pipelines ( Mnih et al., 2015 ; Gershman and Daw, 2017 ) . The opacity of consciousness detection compounds both risks: we cannot easily verify whether an expressive system lacks experience (protecting users) or whether a functional system has acquired it (protecting the system). Understanding couplings between emotion-like control and consciousness-relevant architecture is therefore important for responsible development. Core Concepts Emotion-like control Hierarchical, dual-source architecture combining need appraisals and episodic memory to bias policy selection and action instantiation (see A1–A8 below). Not a claim about phenomenology. Separation witness A concrete implementation of emotion-like control A1–A8 that satisfies R1–R4, showing that affective control can be realized without introducing the access-enabling mechanisms targeted by our proxy (not a proof of non-consciousness). Plausibly access-excluding Systems satisfying constraints R1–R4; the target conservative design region under our multi-family proxy. Architectural Components (A1–A8) for control loop \mathcal{S} A1 Hierarchy Two-level control: behavioral modes or policies are selected by affect, then instantiated to concrete actions. Observed situations are mapped to categorical abstractions. A2 Need appraisal Transforms homeostatic discrepancies into drives, affect, and policy preferences. A3 Episodic memory Stores situation-categories with affect tags and policy hints; enables similarity-based retrieval. A4 Integration Combines need-based and memory-based signals into unified affect and policy preferences. A5 Policy instantiation Maps selected policy to preferences for concrete situation-dependent actions. A6 Action execution Performs instantiated action and observes state change from pre-act state to post-act situation. A7 Post-action reappraisal Observes outcome and generates post-action affect. Evaluates outcome based on need and affect changes. A8 Episode storage Stores categorical abstraction of pre-act situation, pre-/post-act affect, policy preferences, and post-action success. Design Constraints (R1–R4) R1 No shared workspace No content-general workspace/hub/router that makes internal representations flexibly reusable across heterogeneous subsystems (no workspace-like broadcast); allows narrow, typed control signals. R2 No metarepresentation No higher-order representations about having internal states. R3 No autobio. consolid. No construction, persistence, export, or re-ingestion of identity/time-anchored cross-episode summary state (no autobiographical “glue” or consolidation). R4 Bounded learning Credit assignment stays within module boundaries. Research Questions (Q1–Q3) Q1 Existence Can emotion-like control A1–A8 also satisfy R1–R4? Q2 Stability Are there design modifications preserving witness status? Q3 Gradualism Can we trace graded paths plausibly increasing access risk? Consciousness Framework Access-like consciousness Global availability, higher-order access, integration. Phenomenal consciousness Felt, valenced experience (normative anchor, not analyzed). Multi-family proxy GWT/GNW, HOT-like theories used to motivate R1–R4 constraints (see § 2.2 ). Table 1: Terminology at a Glance General Assumptions. We proceed under the following assumptions, fixing scope and interpretation (see Table 1 for terminology): • Functionalism. We adopt a functionalist stance: roles and causal organization of processing, rather than substrate, ground our analysis. Our claims concern architecture and information flow rather than implementation specifics. • Control role of emotion. We treat emotions as control processes biasing retrieval, evaluation, and action selection under uncertainty and resource limits ( Simon, 1967 ) . This is compatible with appraisal traditions that link core affect to behavior ( Scherer et al., 2001 ; Frijda, 1986 ; Russell, 2003 ) , with affective-neuroscience views emphasizing subcortical motivational circuitry ( Panksepp, 1998 ; Panksepp and Biven, 2012 ; LeDoux, 2003 ) , and with computational approaches treating value representations as goals for instrumental action ( Rolls, 2013 ; Rolls, 2014 ) . We explore whether emotions can function as simple heuristic shortcuts rather than requiring complex integrative machinery. • Architecture over taxonomies. We remain agnostic about full emotion taxonomies. 1 1 1 Rather than adjudicating between basic-emotion ( Ekman, 1992 ) , dimensional ( Russell, 2003 ) , appraisal ( Scherer et al., 2001 ) , or constructionist ( Feldman Barrett, 2017 ) frameworks, we focus on emotion’s control function: how affective states bias action selection under uncertainty. For concreteness, we use a minimal descriptive set (valence, arousal, drive) as control variables within an