On the self-consistency of compact objects in Lorentz-violating gravity theories

Leandro A. Lessa, Renan B. Magalhães, Manoel M. Ferreira Junior · 2025

Read On the self-consistency of compact objects in Lorentz-violating gravity theories by Leandro A. Lessa, Renan B. Magalhães, Manoel M. Ferreira Junior (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-01374.txt.

Introduction

Leandro Lessa, Renan Magalhães, and Manoel Ferreira Junior examined in twenty twenty-five when compact objects can truly exist in gravity theories that break Lorentz symmetry. A claimed solution must satisfy three sets of equations at once: Einstein's, the matter fields', and the Lorentz-violating field's own. In vacuum, the extra field's dynamics can collapse into pure geometric constraints.

Those constraints rule out whole families of metrics that clash with the preferred directions the symmetry breaking induces. The authors map when such constraints arise and what they forbid. Their framework shows several published solutions in these models are physically inadmissible. The paper serves as a consistency filter for a literature where exotic stars and black holes are proposed faster than they are checked.

Catalog record

CREATORLeandro A. Lessa, Renan B. Magalhães, Manoel M. Ferreira Junior
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE34 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-01374

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the self-consistency of compact objects in Lorentz-violating gravity theories Leandro A. Lessa, Renan B. Magalhães, Manoel M. Ferreira Junior Abstract Self-consistent solutions in Lorentz-violating gravity theories require the simultaneous satisfaction of: (i) the corresponding Einstein field equations, (ii) the matter field equations, and (iii) the Lorentz-violating field equations. In vacuum states, the dynamics of Lorentz-violating tensor fields may reduce to geometric constraints, potentially precluding entire classes of compact objects. These constraints are crucial for ensuring physical consistency in Lorentz-violating frameworks, as they eliminate metric families incompatible with the anisotropies induced by spontaneous Lorentz symmetry breaking. We investigate the criteria governing the emergence of these geometric constraints and analyze their consequences. Our analysis establishes a consistency framework for evaluating compact objects in these theories, demonstrating that several previously reported solutions in Lorentz-violating gravity models are physically inadmissible. Introduction. General relativity (GR) remains the most successful theory for describing gravitational interaction at classical scales, grounded in the symmetries of diffeomorphism and local Lorentz invariance. However, the unification of GR with Quantum Mechanics still represents one of the greatest unsolved challenges in theoretical physics. This motivates the plausible conjecture that modifications to the foundations of GR may pave the way toward a unified theory. The typical energy scale at which such a unified framework should becomes relevant is at the so-called Planck scale ( M_{\text{Pl}}=\sqrt{\hbar c/G}\approx 1.22\times 10^{19}\text{ GeV}/c^{2} ), far exceeding any observational regime accessible today. Nevertheless, theoretical extensions of GR predict the existence of low-energy “relic signatures” mattingly2005modern ; liberati2009lorentz . These signatures, which might arise from quantum gravitational effects, could manifest as subtle deviations either in experiments of the Standard Model or GR. In this context, the possibility of Lorentz symmetry violation in an underlying theory—such as string theory kostelecky1989spontaneous ; kostelecky1989phenomenological —becomes particularly relevant, especially in the search for observational signatures of new physics. These questions can be investigated independently of specific models through effective field theory approaches Kostelecky:2003fs . Thus, experimental tests of Lorentz violation in gravity not only validate extensions of GR but may also reveal evidence of physics beyond the current paradigm kostelecky2011data ; tasson2014we . A promising approach to investigate Lorentz violation in pure gravity involves analyzing anisotropy effects induced in compact objects by tensor fields that acquire a preferred spacetime direction—a phenomenon arising from spontaneous Lorentz symmetry breaking Bluhm:2007bd . In this mechanism, a potential term drives the dynamic evolution of the tensor field, leading to a nonzero vacuum expectation value (VEV). While being spontaneous, this violation preserves the Bianchi identities, despite implying both local Lorentz and diffeomorphism violation Kostelecky:2003fs . This compatibility with the geometric structure of GR makes spontaneous Lorentz symmetry breaking a natural candidate for exploring violation effects in strong gravity regimes, such as those found in neutron stars or black holes. The aim of this letter is to stress out a point, sometimes missing in the discussion on compact objects in Lorentz-violating gravity models, namely the self-consistency of compact objects in these frameworks. Crucially, self-consistent solutions of Lorentz-violating scenarios must simultaneously satisfy: (i) the corresponding Einstein field equations, (ii) the matter field equations, and (iii) the Lorentz-violating field equations. Remarkably, under certain conditions, the latter in a vacuum state can reduce to geometric constraints governing the metrics of compact objects. These constraints impose stringent requirements that rule out the emergence of families of compact objects and invalidate some previously reported solutions of Lorentz-violating gravity models. In the following, we analyze the emergence and implications of geometric constraints induced by spontaneous Lorentz violation in two prominent frameworks: (i) via a vector field (the bumblebee field) Kostelecky:2003fs ; Bluhm:2007bd , and (ii) through an antisymmetric rank-2 tensor field (sometimes known as the Kalb-Ramond field) Altschul:2009ae . The non-zero VEV of these fields introduces spacetime anisotropies, leading to small deviations in compact object solutions—including black holes Casana:2017jkc ; Yang:2023wtu ; Liu:2024oas ; Maluf:2020kgf , neutron stars ji2024neutron , and wormholes Maluf:2021ywn —compared to standard GR predictions. Our analysis plays a crucial role in the search for viable compact objects within Lorentz-violating gravity, as it allows us to probe various families of metric functions (including those mentioned above) and determine which are permitted by the anisotropies induced by Lorentz-violating fields. Lorentz-violating framework. The action that encodes Lorentz-violating effects from a vector field (bumblebee field) Kostelecky:2003fs and from an antisymmetric rank-2 tensor Altschul:2009ae in Riemann-spacetime limit can be written as S=\int d^{4}x\sqrt{-g}\left[\frac{1}{2\kappa}(R-2\Lambda)+\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{B}}+\mathcal{L}_{B}\right]+S_{m}, (1) where S_{m}=S_{m}[g_{\mu\nu},\psi_{m}] is the matter action, R is the Ricci scalar and \Lambda is the cosmological constant. \mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{B}} and \mathcal{L}_{B} are, respectively, the Lagrangians of the bumblebee and of the antisymmetric rank-2 tensor, given by \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{B}}= \displaystyle-\frac{1}{4}\mathfrak{B}_{\mu\nu}\mathfrak{B}^{\mu\nu}-\tilde{V}(Y) \displaystyle+\frac{\tilde{\xi}_{1}}{2\kappa}\mathfrak{B}_{\mu}\mathfrak{B}^{\mu}R+\frac{\tilde{\xi}_{2}}{2\kappa}\mathfrak{B}^{\mu}\mathfrak{B}^{\nu}R_{\mu\nu}, (2) \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{B}= \displaystyle-\frac{1}{12}H_{\lambda\mu\nu}H^{\lambda\mu\nu}-V(X)+\frac{\xi_{1}}{2\kappa}B^{\mu\nu}B_{\mu\nu}R \displaystyle+\frac{\xi_{2}}{2\kappa}B^{\mu}{{}_{\alpha}}B^{\alpha\nu}R_{\mu\nu}+\frac{\xi_{3}}{2\kappa}B^{\mu\nu}B^{\alpha\beta}R_{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}, (3) where \mathfrak{B}_{\mu\nu}=\partial_{\mu}\mathfrak{B}_{\nu}-\partial_{\nu}\mathfrak{B}_{\mu} and H_{\lambda\mu\nu}=\partial_{\lambda}B_{\mu\nu}+\partial_{\mu}B_{\nu\lambda}+\partial_{\nu}B_{\lambda\mu} are, respectively, the field strength of the bumblebee and of the antisymmetric rank-2 tensor, \tilde{V}(Y) and V(X) are self-interaction potentials that drive the breaking of the Lorentz symmetry with Y=\mathfrak{B}_{\mu}\mathfrak{B}^{\mu}\pm\mathfrak{b}^{2} , X=B_{\mu\nu}B^{\mu\nu}\pm b^{2} , where \mathfrak{b}^{2} and b^{2} are positive real constants and the \pm sign denotes whether the nature of the vector \mathfrak{B}^{\mu} and of the antisymmetric tensor {B}_{\mu\nu} is timelike or spacelike. Furthermore, the additional terms in the above Lagrangians account for all possible non-minimal couplings between the Lorentz-violating fields and spacetime curvature, with R_{\alpha\beta\mu\nu} and R_{\alpha\beta} denoting, respectively the Riemann and Ricci tensors and \tilde{\xi}_{1,2} and {\xi}_{1,2,3} are coupling constants. We recall that the bumblebee field does not couple to the Riemann tensor, as established in Ref. Kostelecky:2003fs . Moreover, we do not consider any coupling between the Lorentz-violating fields and the matter sector. We assume that the self-interaction potentials V and \tilde{V} drive the formation of a nonzero vacuum value \langle\mathfrak{B}_{\mu}\rangle=\mathfrak{b}_{\mu},\quad\langle B_{\mu\nu}\rangle=b_{\mu\nu}, (4) which breaks local Lorentz and diffeomorphism symmetry. The minimum condition, i.e., \langle V\rangle=0 and \langle\tilde{V}\rangle=0 , is guaranteed when \mp\mathfrak{b}^{2}\equiv g^{\mu\nu}\mathfrak{b}_{\mu}\mathfrak{b}_{\nu},\quad\mp b^{2}\equiv g^{\mu\alpha}g^{\nu\beta}b_{\mu\nu}b_{\alpha\beta}, (5) where \langle\mathfrak{B}_{\mu}\mathfrak{B}^{\mu}\rangle=\mathfrak{b}_{\mu}\mathfrak{b}^{\mu} and \langle B_{\mu\nu}B^{\mu\nu}\rangle=b_{\mu\nu}b^{\mu\nu} . It is worth emphasizing that in the vacuum state, the terms coupling the Lorentz-violating fields to the curvature scalar ( On the self-consistency of compact objects in Lorentz-violating gravity theories )-( On the self-consistency of compact objects in Lorentz-violating gravity theories ) can be disregarded, as they can be absorbed into the Einstein-Hilbert term through a rescaling of the gravitational constant, i.e., \kappa\to\kappa(1\pm\tilde{\xi}_{1}\mathfrak{b}^{2}\pm\xi_{1}b^{2})^{-1} . Since the focus of this Letter is on the solutions influenced by the anisotropies induced by the VEV of the Lorentz-violating fields, henceforth \xi_{1}=\tilde{\xi}_{1}=0 . By varying the action ( 1 ) with respect to the metric, one obtains the corresponding Einstein field equations, namely G_{\mu\nu}+\Lambda g_{\mu\nu}=\kappa T_{\mu\nu}, (6) where T_{\mu\nu}=T_{\mu\nu}^{M}+T_{\mu\nu}^{LV} is the (total) energy-momentum tensor, with T_{\mu\nu}^{M} and T_{\mu\nu}^{LV} denoting the energy-momentum tensor of the matter fields and of the Lorentz-violating fields, respectively. We remark that T_{\mu\nu}^{LV} is constructed by varying S_{LV}=\int d^{4}x\sqrt{-g}(\mathcal{L}_{\mathfrak{B}}+\mathcal{L}_{{B}}) , containing, therefore, all the terms depending on \mathfrak{B}_{\mu} , B_{\mu\nu} and their derivatives, along with all the non-minimal curvature-couplings controlled by \tilde{\xi}_{2} and \xi_{2,3} . Additionally, by varying the action ( 1 ) with respect to the matter fields (collectively denoted by \psi_{m} ), one obtains the equations of motion of the matter fields. Independently, by varying the action ( 1 ) with with respect to the Lorentz-violating fields, namely \mathfrak{B}_{\mu} and B_{\mu\nu} , one obtains the field equations for the bumblebee field and for the antisymmetric rank-2

Read the complete text