Hamiltonian Analysis of Pre-geometric Gravity
Andrea Addazi, Salvatore Capozziello, Antonino Marcianò, Giuseppe Meluccio · 2025
Read Hamiltonian Analysis of Pre-geometric Gravity by Andrea Addazi, Salvatore Capozziello, Antonino Marcianò, Giuseppe Meluccio (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-01272.txt.
Introduction
Andrea Addazi and co-authors present a 2025 physics paper on gravity theories in which space-time itself emerges from a more basic gauge theory. In this view, Einstein's theory appears after a symmetry breaks, much like a phase change. The authors work out the step-by-step constraint analysis for such theories.
Linking their setup to the standard space-plus-time split of relativity, they show that all classic results return in the low-energy limit after the break. They then count the true degrees of freedom in the unbroken high-energy phase. The paper also sketches routes toward a fuller quantum version, including a pre-geometric form of a famous gravity equation.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Andrea Addazi, Salvatore Capozziello, Antonino Marcianò, Giuseppe Meluccio |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 57 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-01272
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Hamiltonian Analysis of Pre-geometric Gravity Andrea Addazi, Salvatore Capozziello, Antonino Marcianò, Giuseppe Meluccio Abstract The Einstein–Cartan theory of gravity can arise from a mechanism of spontaneous symmetry breaking within the context of pre-geometric gauge theories. In this work, we develop the Hamiltonian analysis of such theories. By making contact with the ADM formalism, we show that all the results of canonical General Relativity are correctly recovered in the IR limit of the spontaneously broken phase. We then apply Dirac’s algorithm to study the algebra of constraints and determine the number of degrees of freedom in the UV limit of the unbroken phase. We also discuss possible pathways toward a UV completion of General Relativity, including a pre-geometric generalisation of the Wheeler–DeWitt equation and an extended BF formulation of the pre-geometric theory. I Introduction As a result of the spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB) of a fundamental gauge symmetry of spacetime, a classical metric structure can emerge out of a pre-geometric four-dimensional spacetime. This can be achieved in a gauge theory à la Yang–Mills, in which neither the spacetime metric nor the tetrads are assumed to exist, corresponding to an unbroken phase addazi:pre-geometry . The pre-geometric field content of this formulation consists of the gauge field A_{\mu}^{AB} of the group SO(1,4) or SO(3,2) and a Higgs-like scalar field \phi^{A} . Once the latter acquires a nonzero vacuum expectation value (v.e.v.) because of its dynamics, the ensuing SSB reduces the gauge group of spacetime to the Lorentz group SO(1,3) , in compliance with the Einstein equivalence principle. This, in turn, allows recovering the Einstein–Cartan theory with a cosmological constant term after the identification of the spin connection \omega_{\mu}^{ab} and the tetrads e_{\mu}^{a} of the gravitational field addazi:pre-geometry ; randono:gauge ; westman:gauge ; westman:cartan ; westman:introduction . There exist two possible Lagrangian densities which can realise the emergence of Einstein gravity from a pre-geometric framework: the one proposed by Wilczek wilczek:gauge and the one proposed by MacDowell & Mansouri macdowell:unified . With a view to explore a novel path towards a theory of Quantum Gravity, in this work we address the Hamiltonian analysis of such proposals; in fact, this is key to studying the quantisation and the UV limit of the gravitational interaction. We also discuss a connection with BF theories, which can provide interesting tools for understanding gravity in the pre-geometric picture. The paper is organised as follows. In Sec. II we present the canonical analysis of the Wilczek theory, which in Sec. IV is extended by using Dirac’s algorithm for gauge theories. In Sec. III we make contact with the Hamiltonian analysis of the Einstein–Cartan gravity in the Arnowitt–Deser–Misner (ADM) formalism, showing how it is recovered in the spontaneously broken phase of the Wilczek theory. Sec. V contains a brief discussion of the generalisation of the Wheeler–DeWitt equation in the pre-geometric framework under consideration. Before drawing our conclusions in Sec. VII , we present, in Sec. VI , a formulation of the pre-geometric theory in terms of an extension of a topological BF theory. In the Appendix A we then reproduce the canonical analysis for the MacDowell–Mansouri theory. We adopt natural units along the paper. II The canonical analysis The Lagrangian density that we will focus on in this section is the sum of the Wilczek Lagrangian density wilczek:gauge and a potential term for the realisation 1 1 1 Compared to the paper addazi:pre-geometry , the kinetic terms for the pre-geometric fields will be excluded from this analysis for the sake of simplicity. Another reason to neglect these terms is that they are not essential except for the study of the Higgs mechanism associated with the SSB of the fundamental gauge symmetry of spacetime. of the SSB addazi:pre-geometry , respectively \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\textup{W}} \displaystyle=k_{\textup{W}}\epsilon_{ABCDE}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}F_{\mu\nu}^{AB}\nabla_{\rho}\phi^{C}\nabla_{\sigma}\phi^{D}\phi^{E}, (1a) \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\textup{SSB}} \displaystyle=-k_{\textup{SSB}}v^{-4}\lvert J\rvert(\phi^{2}\mp v^{2})^{2},\qquad\phi\equiv\sqrt{\eta_{AB}\phi^{A}\phi^{B}}, (1b) where F_{\mu\nu}^{AB} is the field strength of the connection A_{\mu}^{AB} , \nabla_{\mu} denotes the gauge covariant derivative and J is a pre-geometric quantity: \displaystyle F_{\mu\nu}^{AB} \displaystyle=2\partial_{[\mu}A_{\nu]}^{AB}+2A_{C[\mu}^{A}A_{\nu]}^{CB}, \displaystyle\nabla_{\lambda}\phi^{A} \displaystyle=\partial_{\lambda}\phi^{A}+A_{B\lambda}^{A}\phi^{B}, \displaystyle J \displaystyle\equiv\epsilon_{ABCDE}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}\nabla_{\mu}\phi^{A}\nabla_{\nu}\phi^{B}\nabla_{\rho}\phi^{C}\nabla_{\sigma}\phi^{D}\phi^{E}, with A^{A}_{B\mu}\equiv\eta_{BC}A_{\mu}^{AC} , k_{\textup{W}} and v nonzero constants and k_{\textup{SSB}} a positive constant. The v.e.v. of the field \phi^{A} is v\delta^{A}_{5} . Uppercase Latin indices A,B,C etc. run from 1 to 5 , lowercase Latin indices a,b,c etc. and Greek indices \lambda,\mu,\nu etc. run from 0 to 3 , Greek indices \alpha,\beta,\gamma etc. and lowercase Latin indices i,j,k etc. run from 1 to 3 . The internal space metric for the tangent spaces to the spacetime manifold is a generalised Minkowski metric \eta with signature (-,+,+,+,+) or (+,+,+,-,-) depending on the gauge group under consideration, 2 2 2 In what follows, whenever a double sign is encountered, the upper one will refer to the case of SO(1,4) , while the lower one to SO(3,2) . respectively SO(1,4) or SO(3,2) . The Hamiltonian analysis will then be reproduced for the MacDowell–Mansouri Lagrangian density macdowell:unified in the Appendix A , following the same steps as for the case of the Wilczek Lagrangian density. Observing that \displaystyle\frac{\delta J}{\delta\dot{\phi}^{E}} \displaystyle=4\epsilon_{ABCDE}\epsilon^{0ijk}\nabla_{i}\phi^{A}\nabla_{j}\phi^{B}\nabla_{k}\phi^{C}\phi^{D}, (2) \displaystyle\frac{\delta F_{\mu\nu}^{AB}}{\delta\dot{A}_{\lambda}^{CD}} \displaystyle=2\delta_{[\mu}^{0}\delta_{\nu]}^{\lambda}\delta_{[C}^{A}\delta_{D]}^{B}, (3) the conjugate momenta to the pre-geometric fields \phi^{A} and A_{\mu}^{AB} can be computed respectively as \displaystyle\begin{split}\Pi_{E}&=\frac{\delta(\mathcal{L}_{\textup{W}}+\mathcal{L}_{\textup{SSB}})}{\delta\dot{\phi}^{E}}=2\epsilon_{ABCDE}\epsilon^{0ijk}\nabla_{k}\phi^{C}\phi^{D}[k_{\textup{W}}F_{ij}^{AB}\\ &-2\sign(J)k_{\textup{SSB}}v^{-4}\nabla_{i}\phi^{A}\nabla_{j}\phi^{B}(\phi^{2}\mp v^{2})^{2}],\end{split} (4) \displaystyle\Pi^{\lambda}_{DE} \displaystyle=\frac{\delta(\mathcal{L}_{\textup{W}}+\mathcal{L}_{\textup{SSB}})}{\delta\dot{A}_{\lambda}^{DE}}=2k_{\textup{W}}\epsilon_{ABCDE}\epsilon^{0\lambda jk}\nabla_{j}\phi^{A}\nabla_{k}\phi^{B}\phi^{C}; in particular, \displaystyle\Pi^{i}_{DE} \displaystyle=2k_{\textup{W}}\epsilon_{ABCDE}\epsilon^{0ijk}\nabla_{j}\phi^{A}\nabla_{k}\phi^{B}\phi^{C}, (5a) \displaystyle\Pi^{0}_{DE} \displaystyle=0. (5b) In terms of the conjugate momenta, the total Lagrangian density can be recast as \mathcal{L}_{\textup{W}}+\mathcal{L}_{\textup{SSB}}=\Pi^{i}_{AB}F_{0i}^{AB}+\Pi_{A}\nabla_{0}\phi^{A}. (6) The corresponding Hamiltonian density does not depend on the time derivatives of the pre-geometric fields: \begin{split}\mathcal{H}_{\textup{W}}&=\Pi_{AB}^{i}\dot{A}_{i}^{AB}+\Pi_{A}\dot{\phi}^{A}-\mathcal{L}_{\textup{W}}-\mathcal{L}_{\textup{SSB}}\\ &=\Pi_{AB}^{i}(\partial_{i}A_{0}^{AB}-2A_{C[0}^{A}A_{i]}^{CB})-\Pi_{A}A_{B0}^{A}\phi^{B}.\end{split} (7) Performing an integration by parts and retaining the boundary term, the Hamiltonian is \begin{split}H_{\textup{W}}&=\int\mathcal{H}_{\textup{W}}\,d^{3}x=\int[-A_{0}^{AB}\partial_{i}\Pi^{i}_{AB}+\partial_{i}(\Pi^{i}_{AB}A_{0}^{AB})]\,d^{3}x\\ &+\int(-2\Pi^{i}_{AB}A_{C[0}^{A}A_{i]}^{CB}-\Pi_{A}A_{B0}^{A}\phi^{B})\,d^{3}x\\ &=-\int A_{0}^{AB}(\partial_{i}\Pi^{i}_{AB}+2\Pi^{i}_{BC}A_{Ai}^{C}+\eta_{BC}\Pi_{A}\phi^{C})\,d^{3}x\\ &+\int\partial_{i}(\Pi^{i}_{AB}A_{0}^{AB})\,d^{3}x,\end{split} (8) where in the last step we made use of the identity \Pi^{i}_{AB}A_{C[0}^{A}A_{i]}^{CB}=\Pi^{i}_{BC}A_{0}^{AB}A_{Ai}^{C}. III Recovering the Einstein–Cartan gravity in the ADM formalism The SSB of the vacuum state in the Wilczek theory of emergent gravity yields the following results (see Ref. addazi:pre-geometry for the details): \begin{split}\phi^{A}\xrightarrow{SSB}v\delta_{5}^{A},\qquad A_{\mu}^{ab}\xrightarrow{SSB}\omega_{\mu}^{ab}&,\qquad A_{\mu}^{a5}\xrightarrow{SSB}me_{\mu}^{a},\\ \mathcal{L}_{\textup{W}}\xrightarrow{SSB}k_{\textup{W}}v^{3}m^{2}\epsilon_{abcd}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}e_{\mu}^{a}&e_{\nu}^{b}R_{\rho\sigma}^{cd}\pm 48k_{\textup{W}}v^{3}m^{4}e,\\ \mathcal{L}_{\textup{SSB}}\xrightarrow{SSB}0,\qquad J&\xrightarrow{SSB}-24v^{5}m^{4}e,\\ F_{\mu\nu}^{AB}\xrightarrow{SSB}R_{\mu\nu}^{ab}\mp 2m^{2}e^{a}_{[\mu}e^{b}_{\nu]},&\quad\nabla_{\lambda}\phi^{A}\xrightarrow{SSB}\pm vme^{a}_{\lambda},\end{split} (9) where m is a nonzero constant, e is the tetrad determinant and the Riemann tensor is defined as R_{\mu\nu}^{ab}=2\partial_{[\mu}\omega_{\nu]}^{ab}+2\omega^{a}_{c[\mu}\omega^{cb}_{\nu]}. For later convenience, we can introduce other two auxiliary quantities addazi:pre-geometry , namely \begin{split}P_{\mu\nu}&\equiv\eta_{AB}\nabla_{\mu}\phi^{A}\nabla_{\nu}\phi^{B},\\ w^{\mu}_{A}&\equiv\pm\epsilon_{ABCDE}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}\nabla_{\nu}\phi^{B}\nabla_{\rho}\phi^{C}\nabla_{\sigma}\phi^{D}\phi^{E},\end{split} their SSB being provided respectively by \begin{split}P_{\mu\nu}&\xrightarrow{SSB}v^{2}m^{2}\eta_{ab}e_{\mu}^{a}e_{\nu}^{b}=v^{2}m^{2}g_{\mu\nu},\\ w^{\mu}_{A}&\xrightarrow{SSB}v^{4}m^{3}\epsilon_{abcd}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}e_{\nu}^{b}e_{\rho}^{c}e_{\sigma}^{d}=-6v^{4}m^{3}ee^{\mu}_{a}.\end{split} (10) By identifying the reduced Planck mass and the cosmological constant respectively as \displaystyle M_{\textup{P}}^{2} \displaystyle\equiv-8k_{\textup{W}}v^{3}m^{2}, (11a) \displaystyle\Lambda \displaystyle\equiv\pm 6m^{2}=\mp\frac{3M_{\textup{P}}^{2}}{4k_{\textup{W}}v^{3}}, (11b) the SSB of the Wilczek Lagrangian density can be seen to reproduce the gravitational Lagrangian density in the Palatini formalism, that is \mathcal{L}_{\textup{W}}\xrightarrow{SSB}\mathcal{L}_{\textup{EH}}+\mathcal{L}_{\Lambda}, where the Einstein–Hilbert Lagrangian density and the cosmological constant term are defined respectively as \mathcal{L}_{\textup{EH}}=\frac{M_{\textup{P}}^{2}}{2}ee^{\mu}_{a}e^{\nu}_{b}R^{ab}_{\mu\nu},\qquad\mathcal{L}_{\Lambda}=-M_{\textup{P}}^{2}\Lambda e, with e\equiv\det(e_{\mu}^{a}) . This result is made possible by exploiting the identity \epsilon_{abcd}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}e_{\mu}^{a}e_{\nu}^{b}R_{\rho\sigma}^{cd}=-4ee^{\mu}_{a}e^{\nu}_{b}R^{ab}_{\mu\nu}, which holds true only if the tetrads are assumed to be invertible addazi:pre-geometry . After the SSB, the conjugate momenta ( 4 ) and ( 5 ) become respectively \Pi_{A}\xrightarrow{SSB}\Pi_{a}=\pm 2k_{\textup{W}}v^{2}m\epsilon_{abcd}\epsilon^{0ijk}e^{d}_{k}(R^{bc}_{ij}\mp 2m^{2}e^{b}_{i}e^{c}_{j}) (12) and \displaystyle\Pi^{i}_{AB}\xrightarrow{SSB}\Pi^{i}_{ab} \displaystyle=2k_{\textup{W}}v^{3}m^{2}\epsilon_{abcd}\epsilon^{0ijk}e^{c}_{j}e^{d}_{k}, (13a) \displaystyle\Pi^{0}_{AB}\xrightarrow{SSB}\Pi^{0}_{ab} \displaystyle=0. (13b) Note that Eqs. ( 9 ), ( 12 ) and ( 13a ) imply that \begin{split}\Pi^{i}_{AB}\dot{A}_{i}^{AB}&+\Pi_{A}\dot{\phi}^{A}=\Pi^{i}_{ab}\dot{A}_{i}^{ab}+2\Pi^{i}_{a5}\dot{A}_{i}^{a5}+\Pi_{A}\dot{\phi}^{A}\\ &\xrightarrow{SSB}\Pi^{i}_{ab}\dot{\omega}_{i}^{ab}\cancel{+2m\Pi^{i}_{a5}\dot{e}_{i}^{a}}\cancel{+\dot{v}\Pi_{A}\delta^{A}_{5}}.\end{split} (14) This result shows that the (spatial) spin connection plays a privileged role in the Hamiltonian formulation of the theory, as opposed to the (spatial) tetrads and the Higgs-like scalar field. Finally, the SSB of the Hamiltonian ( 8 ) is given by \begin{split}H_{\textup{W}}&\xrightarrow{SSB}-\int(\omega_{0}^{ab}\partial_{i}\Pi^{i}_{ab}+2\Pi^{i}_{ab}\omega_{c0}^{a}\omega_{i}^{cb})\,d^{3}x\\ &+\int[\pm 2m^{2}\Pi^{i}_{ab}e^{a}_{0}e^{b}_{i}\mp vm\Pi_{a}e^{a}_{0}+\partial_{i}(\Pi^{i}_{ab}\omega_{0}^{ab})]\,d^{3}x\\ &=\frac{M_{\textup{P}}^{2}}{4}\epsilon_{abcd}\epsilon^{0ijk}\biggl\{\int[\omega_{0}^{ab}\partial_{i}(e^{c}_{j}e^{d}_{k})+2\omega_{e0}^{a}\omega_{i}^{eb}e^{c}_{j}e^{d}_{k}]\,d^{3}x\\ &+\int[\mp 4m^{2}e^{a}_{0}e^{b}_{i}e^{c}_{j}e^{d}_{k}+e^{a}_{0}e^{b}_{i}R^{cd}_{jk}-\partial_{i}(\omega_{0}^{ab}e^{c}_{j}e^{d}_{k})]\,d^{3}x\biggr\}.\end{split} (15) Observe that the Hamiltonian H_{\textup{W}} is polynomial in the fields and