A stochastic Gordon-Loeb model for optimal cybersecurity investment under clustered attacks
Giorgia Callegaro, Claudio Fontana, Caroline Hillairet, Beatrice Ongarato · 2025
Read A stochastic Gordon-Loeb model for optimal cybersecurity investment under clustered attacks by Giorgia Callegaro, Claudio Fontana, Caroline Hillairet, Beatrice Ongarato (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-01221.txt.
Introduction
Giorgia Callegaro and co-authors model how firms should invest in cyber defense when attacks come in clusters, in a paper from two thousand twenty-five. Real attacks bunch together, with one hit raising the chance of more. A classic model of security spending is extended to capture that bunching.
Each attack may breach the system, with odds tied to how exposed the system is. Spending cuts that exposure, and the team solves for the best spending path over time. Policies that heed clustering reacted faster and worked better than static plans or plans that assume random, even attack timing.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Giorgia Callegaro, Claudio Fontana, Caroline Hillairet, Beatrice Ongarato |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 64 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-01221
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A stochastic Gordon-Loeb model for optimal cybersecurity investment under clustered attacks Giorgia Callegaro, Claudio Fontana, Caroline Hillairet, Beatrice Ongarato Abstract We develop a continuous-time stochastic model for optimal cybersecurity investment under the threat of cyberattacks. The arrival of attacks is modeled using a Hawkes process, capturing the empirically relevant feature of clustering in cyberattacks. Extending the Gordon-Loeb model, each attack may result in a breach, with breach probability depending on the system’s vulnerability. We aim at determining the optimal cybersecurity investment to reduce vulnerability. The problem is cast as a two-dimensional Markovian stochastic optimal control problem and solved using dynamic programming methods. Numerical results illustrate how accounting for attack clustering leads to more responsive and effective investment policies, offering significant improvements over static and Poisson-based benchmark strategies. Our findings underscore the value of incorporating realistic threat dynamics into cybersecurity risk management. 1 Introduction Cyber-risk is nowadays widely acknowledged as one of the major sources of operational risk for organizations worldwide. The 2024 ENISA Threat Landscape Report [ 1 ] documents ‘‘a notable escalation in cybersecurity attacks, setting new benchmarks in both the variety and number of incidents, as well as their consequences’’. According to the AON 9th Global Risk Management Survey 1 1 1 Source: https://www.aon.com/en/insights/reports/global-risk-management-survey . , cyberattacks and data breaches represent the foremost source of global risk faced by organizations, with the second biggest risk being business interruption, which is itself often a consequence of cyber-incidents. A recent poll on Risk.net confirms information security and IT disruption as the top two sources of operational risk for 2025. 2 2 2 Source: https://www.risk.net/risk-management/7961268/top-10-operational-risks-for-2025 . According to IBM, the global average cost of a data breach has reached nearly 5M USD in 2024, an increase of more than 10% over the previous year. 3 3 3 Source: https://www.ibm.com/reports/data-breach . The rapid and widespread emergence of cyber-risk as a key source of operational risk has led to a significant increase in cybersecurity spending. In the 2025 ICS/OT cybersecurity budget survey of the SANS Institute [ 2 ] , 55% of the respondents reported a substantial rise in cybersecurity budgets over the previous two years. This trend underscores the importance of adopting effective cybersecurity investment policies that balance risk mitigation with cost efficiency. The problem of optimal cybersecurity investment has been first addressed in the seminal work of Gordon and Loeb [ 3 ] . In their model, reviewed in Section 2.1 below, the decision maker can reduce the vulnerability to cyberattacks by investing in cybersecurity. The optimal expenditure in cybersecurity is determined by maximizing the expected net benefit of reducing the breach probability. The Gordon-Loeb model laid the foundations for a rigorous quantitative analysis of cybersecurity investments and has been the subject of numerous extensions and generalizations: we mention here only some studies that are closely related to our context, referring to [ 4 ] for a comprehensive overview. The key ingredient of the Gordon-Loeb model is represented by the security breach probability function (see Section 2.1 ), which has been further analyzed in [ 5 ] and [ 6 ] . The risk-neutral assumption of [ 3 ] has been relaxed to accommodate risk-averse preferences in [ 7 ] . The original Gordon-Loeb model is a static model and, therefore, does not allow to address the crucial issue of the optimal timing of investment decisions. Adopting a real-options approach, [ 8 ] and [ 9 ] have proposed dynamic versions of the model that allow analyzing the optimal timing and level of cybersecurity investment. Closer to our setup, a dynamic extension of the Gordon-Loeb model has been developed in [ 10 ] , considering the problem of optimal cybersecurity investment over an infinite time horizon and assuming that cybersecurity assets are subject to depreciation over time, while future net benefits of cybersecurity investment are discounted. An effective cybersecurity investment policy must be adaptive and evolve in response to changing threat environments. As noted by [ 11 ] , a key feature of cyber-risk is its dynamic nature, due to the rapid technological transformation and the evolution of threat actors. Similarly, [ 12 ] emphasize the need for adaptable and responsive cybersecurity policies in order to face the challenge of dynamic cyberattacks. The framework of [ 10 ] is based on a deterministic model and, therefore, cannot capture the dynamic behavior of cyber-risk. Addressing this need, the main contribution of this work consists in proposing a modeling framework for optimal cybersecurity investment in a dynamic stochastic setup, allowing for investment policies which respond in real time to randomly occurring cyberattacks. Our work therefore contributes both to cyber-risk modeling and to cyber-risk management, as categorized in the recent survey by [ 13 ] . Moreover, our stochastic modeling framework takes into account the empirically relevant feature of temporally clustered cyberattacks, as discussed in the next subsection. 1.1 Modeling Cyberattacks with Hawkes Processes A distinctive feature of our modeling framework, which will be described in Section 2.2 , is the use of a Hawkes process to model the arrival of cyberattacks. First introduced by Alan G. Hawkes in [ 14 ] , these stochastic processes are used to model event arrivals over time and are particularly suited to situations where the occurrence of one event increases the likelihood of subsequent events (self-excitation), thereby generating temporally clustered events. In our context, we denote by N_{t} the cumulative number of cyberattacks up to time t , modeled as a Hawkes process, and by \lambda_{t} the associated stochastic intensity (hazard rate), representing the instantaneous likelihood of an attack occurring. The self-exciting property of the Hawkes process (N_{t})_{t\geq 0} is captured by the specification of its stochastic intensity: \displaystyle\lambda_{t} \displaystyle=\alpha+(\lambda_{0}-\alpha)e^{-\xi t}+\beta\sum_{i=1}^{N_{t}}e^{-\xi(t-\tau_{i})}, (1) for all t\geq 0 , where • \alpha>0 is the long-term mean intensity; • \lambda_{0}>0 is the intensity at the initial time t=0 ; • \xi>0 is the exponential decay rate; • \beta>0 determines the magnitude of self-excitation; • (\tau_{i})_{i\in\mathbb{N}^{*}} are the random times at which attacks occur. Figure 1 shows a simulated trajectory of N and \lambda , showing the clustering behavior induced by the self-exciting mechanism described above. General presentations of the theory and the applications of Hawkes processes can be found in [ 15 , 16 ] . Fig. 1: One simulated trajectory of N (top) and \lambda (bottom), for \alpha=27 , \lambda_{0}=27 , \xi=15 , \beta=9 . This modeling choice is particularly relevant in the context of cyber-risk. Cyberattacks frequently occur in bursts, for instance following the discovery of a vulnerability or due to the propagation of malware across interconnected systems (see [ 17 ] ). Such clustered patterns are not adequately captured by memoryless models, such as those based on Poisson processes. Empirical evidence supports the appropriateness of the Hawkes framework for modeling cyber-risk. A contagious behavior in cyberattacks has been documented in [ 18 ] , analyzing the threats to key internet services using data from the SANS Institute. Using data from from the Privacy Rights Clearinghouse, it has been empirically demonstrated in [ 19 ] that Hawkes-based models provide a more realistic representation of the interdependence of data breaches compared to Poisson-based models. The recent work [ 20 ] reinforces this perspective by calibrating a two-phase Hawkes model