Energy Transduction in Complex Networks with Multiple Resources: The Chemistry Paradigm

Massimo Bilancioni, Massimiliano Esposito · 2025

Read Energy Transduction in Complex Networks with Multiple Resources: The Chemistry Paradigm by Massimo Bilancioni, Massimiliano Esposito (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-01176.txt.

Introduction

Massimo Bilancioni and Massimiliano Esposito extend, in a 2025 paper, the theory of how energy is transduced from one process to another inside chemical reaction networks. In the classic view, one input drives one output against its spontaneous direction. Real networks, such as the core pathways of cell life, juggle many inputs and outputs through shared steps, which blurs which process drives which.

Their fix starts from elementary processes, steps that cannot be decomposed further. From those, they pick out the true set of processes at play in transduction. The method mirrors how efficiency is defined for heat engines working between several heat baths. Choosing a reference equilibrium environment shows that efficiency is relative, tied to a stored quantity called exergy. Waste outputs can be left out of the count. Applied to core cell pathways, the framework separates true efficiency from plain output share.

Catalog record

CREATORMassimo Bilancioni, Massimiliano Esposito
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE108 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-01176

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Energy Transduction in Complex Networks with Multiple Resources: The Chemistry Paradigm Massimo Bilancioni, Massimiliano Esposito Abstract We extend the traditional framework of steady state energy transduction—typically characterized by a single input and output—to multi-resource transduction in open chemical reaction networks (CRNs). Transduction occurs when stoichiometrically balanced processes are driven against their spontaneous directions by coupling them with thermodynamically favorable ones. However, when multiple processes (resources) interact through a shared CRN, identifying the relevant set of processes for analyzing transduction becomes a critical and complex challenge. To address this, we introduce a systematic procedure based on elementary processes, which cannot be further decomposed into subprocesses. Our theory generalizes the methodology used to define transduction efficiency in thermal engines operating between multiple heat baths. By selecting a reference equilibrium environment, it explicitly reveals the inherently relative nature of transduction efficiency and ties its definition to exergy. This framework also allows one to exclude unusable outputs from efficiency calculations. We further extend the concept of chemical gears to multi-process transduction, demonstrating their versatility as an analytical tool in complex settings. Finally, we apply our framework to central metabolic pathways, uncovering deep insights into their operation and highlighting the crucial difference between thermodynamic efficiencies and stoichiometric yields. Introduction Free energy transduction is a fundamental process underlying a wide range of phenomena in both natural and engineered systems. While theoretical frameworks have mostly focused on energy transduction with a single input and output [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] , many real-world systems deviate from this simplicity, performing transduction across multiple resources. For example, cells metabolize a variety of substrates—such as glucose, proteins, and fatty acids—to extract free energy, which drives essential processes like biosynthesis, transport, and signaling. Similarly, in food webs, organisms derive energy from diverse resources—ranging from specific prey to plant matter—and allocate it to essential functions such as metabolism, growth, reproduction, and ecological interactions. In engineered systems, power grids integrate energy inputs from fossil fuels, nuclear power, and renewables, distributing it to industrial operations, residential applications, transportation, and energy storage systems. Defining efficiency in these systems requires a rigorous framework to address conceptual challenges—such as identifying inputs and outputs, accounting for maintenance costs, recycling, and downstream losses—while ensuring consistency across studies, avoiding case-specific, non-generalizable definitions. In this paper, we present a comprehensive framework for analyzing energy transduction in open chemical reaction networks (CRNs), focusing on stationary conditions. Open CRNs provide an ideal platform for studying multi-resource transduction in complex networks for several key reasons. First, they are ubiquitous in nature, with examples spanning different fields and scales, including biochemistry [ 7 ] , combustion [ 8 ] , ecology [ 9 ] , geochemistry [ 10 ] , biogeochemistry [ 11 , 12 ] , atmospheric chemistry [ 13 , 14 ] , and astrochemistry [ 15 ] . Second, they are inherently complex because, unlike systems that process a single conserved quantity—such as energy in thermal engines or charge in electrical circuits—they function like a marketplace, where a large variety of molecular species exchange groups of atoms through reactions. These reactions naturally form a hypergraph, capturing the many-to-many relationships inherent in CRNs. Third, most CRNs exchange a multitude of molecular species with their environment. These species, known as chemostatted species, are maintained at fixed concentrations over relevant time scales by their respective environmental reservoirs, called chemostats , which set the CRN’s operating conditions . As we will show, the transformation induced on the environment by the chemical reactions can be decomposed into chemical processes, which are stoichiometrically balanced conversions among chemostatted species and can be viewed as effective reactions between them. Transduction occurs when free energy is transferred between chemical processes—specifically, when exergonic processes, running thermodynamically downhill, drive endergonic processes uphill. Simple transduction involves a single exergonic process coupled to a single endergonic one. However, in most cases, open CRNs perform multi-resource transduction , involving multiple interacting processes, which establishes them as paradigmatic multi-resource transducers. The first systematic framework for analyzing transduction in CRNs was pioneered by Hill [ 1 ] but was restricted to (pseudo)linear CRNs—the simplest type of CRNs, where the hypergraph structure reduces to a simple graph. More recently, a theoretical framework was developed to extend transduction analysis to nonlinear CRNs [ 16 ] . While this framework effectively handles simple transduction, it overlooks a crucial issue in the multi-resource case: it offers no clear guidelines for selecting the processes in terms of which transduction is analyzed. This selection is critical because there are numerous possible choices, each leading to distinct definitions of efficiency. Moreover, an incorrect selection can render transduction ambiguous or even undetectable. The first part of this work addresses this gap by outlining the key requirements for analyzing transduction and establishing a systematic procedure for selecting the correct set of processes. This procedure has two key conceptual highlights: First, it generalizes the framework for defining transduction in thermal engines connected to multiple heat baths [ 17 ] . As in that context, a reference equilibrium environment is specified, which defines the chemical exergy —that is, the maximum work extractable from out-of-equilibrium chemostats relative to that reference equilibrium. By adopting this approach, we adhere to a physically meaningful definition of efficiency, expressed as the ratio of output to input exergy. Second, we analyze transduction in terms of elementary processes—those that cannot be further decomposed into subprocesses—a new concept introduced in this work. These processes represent the smallest fundamental units of free energy that can be produced or consumed in the chemostats. They are defined exclusively by the atomic composition of chemical species, using the atomic composition matrix as the primary analytical tool. By basing our analysis on elementary processes, we ensure that all transduction occurring in the CRN is captured. Once the set of processes is selected, we prescribe a method for classifying them as input or output processes, enabling a well-defined measure of transduction efficiency. Unlike previous studies, our framework allows for the exclusion of ‘unusable’ outputs, accounting for potential downstream losses that are not captured within the CRN. Additionally, we emphasize the inherently relative nature of transduction efficiency, as it may depend on the choice of the reference equilibrium, the definition of ‘useful’ outputs, and the scope of the CRN analyzed. In the second part of this paper, we build on our previous work [ 18 ] , where we demonstrated that, like most human-made machines, CRNs possess chemical gears . These gears—representing multiple transduction pathways, each with a distinct efficiency—provide a refined understanding of the second law of thermodynamics. Specifically, they allow one to determine a CRN’s optimal efficiency and identify the specific gear responsible for achieving it as a function of the operating conditions. Remarkably, this analysis depends solely on the network’s topology. However, our earlier framework was limited to CRNs undergoing simple transduction. Here, we extend these findings to multi-resource transduction, demonstrating that chemical gears remain a powerful analytical tool even in this more general setting. Finally, in the last part of the paper, we demonstrate the practical relevance of our framework by applying it to multi-resource metabolic networks. We analyze a network encompassing glycolysis and gluconeogenesis pathways and a network representing the respiration

Read the complete text