Bridging Statistical Scattering and Aberration Theory: Ray Deflection Function - II: Numerical Validation

Netzer Moriya · 2025

Read Bridging Statistical Scattering and Aberration Theory: Ray Deflection Function - II: Numerical Validation by Netzer Moriya (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-01026.txt.

Introduction

Netzer Moriya validates a new optics method in 2025 for modeling rough surfaces in mirrors and lenses. The method, called the Ray Deflection Function, aims to link two fields that are usually kept apart. One field treats light scatter with statistics, and the other treats image flaws as fixed terms.

Moriya ran ray tracing tests on a parabolic mirror with surface flaws. Three cases were compared: an ideal mirror, a standard statistical scatter model, and the new method. The new method matched the standard model closely near the focal plane. That match supports treating roughness as fixed flaw terms in design.

Catalog record

CREATORNetzer Moriya
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE50 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-01026

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Bridging Statistical Scattering and Aberration Theory: Ray Deflection Function - II: Numerical Validation Netzer Moriya Abstract This paper presents a comprehensive experimental validation of a recently developed Ray Deflection Function (RDF) approach, which offers a new framework for modeling surface roughness effects in optical systems. Through detailed geometrical ray tracing simulations, we demonstrate that the RDF methodology successfully bridges two traditionally separate domains: statistical scattering models and deterministic aberration analysis. We implement and compare the two approaches for modeling a parabolic mirror with surface imperfections with three cases: (1) an ideal parabolic mirror baseline, (2) the conventional Harvey-Shack (HS) statistical scattering theory applied to ray perturbations, and (3) the newly proposed aberration term method based on the RDF theory. Our results confirm the statistical equivalence between the HS approach and the RDF-based aberration term method, with both producing close near-focal-plane distributions and focal volume characteristics. By establishing this equivalence, we validate that surface roughness effects can be accurately represented as deterministic aberration terms while maintaining fidelity to established statistical scattering models. 1 Introduction Surface roughness significantly impacts the performance of optical systems, causing scattered light that degrades image quality and reduces contrast. Traditional approaches to modeling the effects of surface roughness typically follow one of two distinct methodologies [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] : detailed physical modeling of surface topography with direct ray-tracing, or statistical scatter models that operate primarily in the angular domain. Both approaches present significant limitations—the former is computationally intensive and requires detailed surface data with sophisticated beam-roughness interaction models. The latter, exemplified by Harvey-Shack theory, establishes a direct proportional relationship between the bidirectional reflectance distribution function (BRDF) of a rough surface and the power spectral density (PSD) of its height variations. While this provides a statistical framework for predicting angular light scattering, it remains fundamentally separate from conventional optical design workflows that use aberration formulations to handle smooth surface deviations but have no established mechanism for incorporating roughness effects. In our theoretical paper [ 5 ] , we introduced a new conceptual framework that recasts surface roughness effects as a “ray deflection function” (RDF), which can be statistically represented through a modified Zernike-Fourier hybrid approach. This transformation allows surface roughness to be seamlessly integrated with other optical aberration terms by expressing its effects through equivalent modifications to the ideal mirror shape. A theoretical analysis justifying the use of ray-based modeling for realistic optical systems with surface roughness is provided in A . The present paper focuses on the numerical validation of this theoretical framework through detailed simulations. We implement the RDF approach using statistical perturbations to rays reflected from an ideal parabolic mirror and compare the results with conventional Harvey-Shack scatter theory. By demonstrating the statistical equivalence between these approaches, we establish that our method maintains the physical accuracy of established scattering models while offering significant computational advantages and enhanced integration with traditional optical design frameworks. 2 Theoretical Foundation Prior to presenting our experimental implementation and results, we summarize the key aspects of the RDF theoretical framework to provide context for the validation study (see in [ 5 ] and references therein). 2.1 The Ray Deflection Function Concept We define the Ray Deflection Function (RDF), denoted by \mathbf{D}(\mathbf{r}_{0}) , as the local angular deflection experienced by a ray upon reflection due to a height perturbation at the surface point. For small perturbations under the scalar wave approximation, this deflection can be expressed in terms of the local phase gradient [ 5 ] : \mathbf{D}(\mathbf{r}_{0})=-\frac{\lambda}{4\pi}\nabla\Phi(x,y) (1) where \Phi(x,y) is the phase delay induced by surface height variations, and \lambda is the wavelength of light. This relationship is derived from the eikonal approximation and is valid when surface perturbations are smooth and differentiable, incident and reflected angles are small, and the wavefront phase is well-described by scalar field theory. The applicability of this geometric ray approach versus diffraction-based modeling for different optical system parameters is analyzed quantitatively in A , where we demonstrate that for practical telescope mirror specifications, geometric effects dominate diffraction effects by several orders of magnitude. 2.2 Relationship to Harvey-Shack Theory The Harvey-Shack theory [ 6 ] establishes that the bidirectional reflectance distribution function (BRDF) is directly proportional to the power spectral density (PSD) of surface height variations: \text{BRDF}(\alpha_{s}-\alpha_{i},\beta_{s}-\beta_{i})\propto\text{PSD}\left(\frac{\alpha_{s}-\alpha_{i}}{\lambda},\frac{\beta_{s}-\beta_{i}}{\lambda}\right) (2) where \alpha and \beta are direction cosines, and subscripts i and s refer to incident and scattered directions, respectively. Our approach leverages this relationship to derive a ray deflection function that produces the same statistical distribution of scattered rays as would be produced by the physical surface roughness. The key insight is that for many practical applications, the exact physical roughness pattern is less important than its statistical effect on the reflected light distribution. 2.3 Aberration Term Formulation A central contribution of our theoretical framework is the transformation of statistical surface roughness into equivalent deterministic aberration terms that directly modify the ideal mirror shape. The magnitude of this effective shape change scales with the RMS roughness while preserving the statistical characteristics of the original PSD model. For a surface with a given PSD, the phase function \Phi(x,y) can be represented using a modified Zernike-Fourier hybrid approach: \Phi(x,y)=\sum_{j=1}^{N}C_{j}Z_{j}(x,y) (3) where Z_{j}(x,y) are Zernike polynomials and the coefficients C_{j} are statistically determined by the spectral overlap between the PSD and the Fourier transform of each Zernike term: C_{j}=\sqrt{\omega_{j}}\cdot\xi_{j} (4) with \xi_{j} representing uncorrelated random variables drawn from a standard normal distribution, and \omega_{j} being the spectral weight of each Zernike mode calculated through: \omega_{j}=\iint\text{PSD}(f_{x},f_{y})|F_{j}(f_{r},\phi_{f})|^{2}df_{x}df_{y} (5) where F_{j}(f_{r},\phi_{f}) is the Fourier transform of the j -th Zernike polynomial. This approach ensures that the statistical properties of the original surface PSD are preserved in the phase function representation. For computational implementation, the series is truncated at N terms based on a variance capture criterion, where the cumulative spectral weight reaches a prescribed fraction of the total surface variance: \frac{\sum_{j=1}^{N}\omega_{j}}{\sigma^{2}}\geq 1-\epsilon (6) with \epsilon being a small tolerance parameter (typically 0.01-0.05). The number of required terms depends on the spatial frequency characteristics of the surface roughness, with N\approx 2\pi R/l_{c} providing a practical guideline for many common PSDs, where R is the aperture radius and l_{c} is the characteristic correlation length. This formulation allows roughness effects to be treated as deterministic aberration terms that can be directly integrated with conventional optical design methods, while maintaining statistical fidelity to the underlying roughness model and preserving the spatial correlation structure implied by the original PSD. 3 Ray-Tracing Simulation Principles The ray-tracing simulation employed in this study systematically evaluates the optical performance of modified mirror surfaces by numerically tracing light rays through defined optical paths. The underlying framework is structured around the precise geometrical representation of mirror surfaces, computation of surface normals, and subsequent calculation of reflected rays. The mathematical principles governing this simulation are outlined below. 3.1 Surface Definition The mirror surface S is defined as a rotationally symmetric function incorporating a classical parabolic term augmented by higher-order spherical aberrations up to the 12th order 1 1 1 In what follows we simulate a parabolic mirror’s surface so c_{2n,0}=0\forall n . . Explicitly, the surface height function z(\rho) in cylindrical coordinates (\rho,\theta,z) is represented as: z(\rho)=\frac{\rho^{2}}{4f}+\sum_{n=2}^{6}c_{2n,0}\rho^{2n}+\xi(\rho,\theta) (7) where f is the focal length of the parabolic reference surface,

Read the complete text