Beyond the Mirror: Personal Analytics through Visual Juxtaposition with Other People’s Data
Sungbok Shin Inria, Sunghyo Chung Kakao Corp., Hyeon Jeon SNU, Hyunwook Lee UNIST, Minje Choi Amazon, Taehun Kim Samsung Electronics, Jaehoon Choi Konolabs. Inc., Sungahn Ko POSTECH, Jaegul Choo KAIST · 2025
Read Beyond the Mirror: Personal Analytics through Visual Juxtaposition with Other People’s Data by Sungbok Shin Inria, Sunghyo Chung Kakao Corp., Hyeon Jeon SNU, Hyunwook Lee UNIST, Minje Choi Amazon, Taehun Kim Samsung Electronics, Jaehoon Choi Konolabs. Inc., Sungahn Ko POSTECH, Jaegul Choo KAIST (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-00855.txt.
Introduction
Sungbok Shin and co-authors explore what people learn about themselves when their own data sits beside the data of others, in a 2025 paper. Self-tracking apps show a person only their own numbers, which can skew how they read their habits. A side-by-side view against peers may give a fairer mirror.
They build CALTREND, a visual tool that sets a person's anonymized online calendar logs against logs from other users of a booking app. Two experts, one in computing and one in Korean herbal medicine, test the tool and comment on sample cases. Each expert read the same charts through the lens of their own field, drawing quite different stories from one data set. The study shows that comparison does not settle meaning: it widens it, in ways shaped by who is looking.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sungbok Shin Inria, Sunghyo Chung Kakao Corp., Hyeon Jeon SNU, Hyunwook Lee UNIST, Minje Choi Amazon, Taehun Kim Samsung Electronics, Jaehoon Choi Konolabs. Inc., Sungahn Ko POSTECH, Jaegul Choo KAIST |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 24 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-00855
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Beyond the Mirror: Personal Analytics through Visual Juxtaposition with Other People’s Data Sungbok Shin Inria, Sunghyo Chung Kakao Corp., Hyeon Jeon SNU, Hyunwook Lee UNIST, Minje Choi Amazon, Taehun Kim Samsung Electronics, Jaehoon Choi Konolabs. Inc., Sungahn Ko POSTECH, Jaegul Choo KAIST Abstract An individual’s data can reveal facets of behavior and identity, but its interpretation is context dependent. We can easily identify various self-tracking applications that help people reflect on their lives. However, self-tracking confined to one person’s data source may fall short in terms of objectiveness, and insights coming from various perspectives. To address this, we examine how those interpretations about a person’s data can be augmented when the data are juxtaposed with that of others using anonymized online calendar logs from a schedule management app. We develop CalTrend , a visual analytics system that compares an individual’s anonymized online schedule logs with using those from other people. Using CalTrend as a probe, we conduct a study with two domain experts, one in information technology and one in Korean herbal medicine. We report our observations on how comparative views help enrich the characterization of an individual based on the experts’ comments. We find that juxtaposing personal data with others’ can potentially lead to diverse interpretations of one dataset shaped by domain-specific mental models. \onlineid 1045 \vgtccategory Research \vgtcinsertpkg Introduction Table 1: Works on calendar data analysis. We categorize the 18 papers that utilize schedule logs, or calendar data of a person for visualization, or use calendar-based visualizations. We look at the target task of each work, target users, and whether there was comparison of one’s data with others. The papers are listed in chronological order. We observe that there is not much work that focuses on providing analysis based on comparing with other users. Title (shortened) Year Target Task Target users Content comparison with others 1 Calendar Data Visualization [ 23 ] 1999 Visual analysis N/A No 2 Augmented Shared Personal Calendars [ 20 ] 2002 Event scheduling Small group No 3 CMRadar [ 12 ] 2004 Calendar management Personal No 4 FishCal [ 1 ] 2004 Calendar management Personal No 5 Shared Family Calendars [ 17 ] 2006 Information sharing Family Yes 6 Personal vs. private calendar interfaces [ 19 ] 2006 Understanding calendar use Personal No 7 The Calendar is Crucial [ 13 ] 2006 Calendar data analysis N/A No 8 Productivity Tools and Business [ 10 ] 2011 Calendar data analysis N/A No 9 I’d never get out of this !?$%# office [ 3 ] 2012 Calendar data analysis personal No 10 Survey on Personal Vis [ 6 ] 2015 Survey N/A N/A 11 TimeAware [ 8 ] 2016 Tracker personal No 12 Calendar.help [ 2 ] 2017 Event scheduling Small group Yes 13 T.Cal [ 5 ] 2018 Work pattern analysis Small group Yes 14 Pervasive Wall Calendar [ 24 ] 2018 Calendar augmentation Personal No 15 Neural event scheduling assistant [ 7 ] 2018 Event scheduling Small group No 16 DayClo [ 9 ] 2020 Calendar augmentation Personal No 17 Personalized Calendar at a care center [ 18 ] 2020 Collaborative event scheduling Small group No 18 Shift scheduling system for healthcare workers [ 22 ] 2021 Shift scheduling Small group No Understanding self stands as a cornerstone for personal and professional development. Marking the everyday progress, observing changes and evaluating self-improvements enable us to self-reflect and better strategize our ways of living [ 11 ] . Consequently, personal-tracking services for productivity, time management, and health have gained wide popularity. However, the inherently societal aspects of human life 1 1 1 “A man is by nature, a social animal” , Aristotle, Politics, Book 1 , section 1253a [ 14 ] might imply that considering only an individual’s personal data could constrain the interpretative power of personal analytics. In many scenarios, comparative context is essential; for instance, while a 20% salary increase may initially seem substantial, understanding whether it is truly competitive requires knowledge of peers’ earnings. Similarly, establishing whether consistently sleeping 10 hours per night aligns with typical social norms demands data from the wider population. Despite the broader potential of personal analytics, existing work remains predominantly centered on analyzing an individual’s own historical data. This observation is supported by a review of 18 studies on schedule logs and calendar visualization (see \autoref table:taxonomy_table), most of which emphasize self-comparison rather than comparative analysis involving other individuals. In this work, we explore how juxtaposing multiple users’ records can enrich the interpretation of an individual’s own tracked data. To that end, we introduce CalTrend , a visual analytics system that employs t-SNE, a dimension reduction technique and topic modeling to provide temporal and textual pattern analysis for both single and multiple online calendar users. We then present CalTrend to two professional analysts from different domains (Korean herbal medicine, and human resources management team at an IT company) as a probe, asking them to interpret individual user behavior within the dataset and provide actionable insights. We utilize anonymized online schedule logs from an online scheduling service. We report on the findings from the observations that these experts have made while analyzing the data using CalTrend . 1 Design Requirements for CalTrend CalTrend serves as an analytical probe that illustrates how examining an individual’s data in the context of others’ datasets can yield deeper and more nuanced insights. For this purpose, we denote four design requirements for CalTrend . DR1 Contrastive. As we aim to compare and contrast the difference between selected groups of the analyst’s interest, the tool should be able to effectively highlight the differences. DR2 Multi-faceted data analysis. As an analytical tool, the tool should provide analysis of the datasets from multiple angles. DR3 Catching different temporal patterns. In an individual’s schedule logs, various temporal patterns emerge at multiple levels of granularity (for example, weekly, daily, etc.). Hence, for a close investigation, we need to effectively present these temporal patterns. DR4 Effective summary of contexts. Schedule logs often contain extensive textual content. For effective analysis, we need to effectively summarize these texts. 2 CalTrend Implementation and Design We present the implementation and design of CalTrend . First, we present the overview, how the data is processed, functionalities in 2.1 CalTrend Overview \autoref fig:overview illustrates the overall workflow of CalTrend . We begin by deidentifying the schedule logs, replacing personally identifiable information, such as phone numbers, emails, and addresses—with arbitrary values and removing names. Next, we preprocess the data to facilitate the analysis of online calendar users’ life patterns, including labeling schedules by life modes and quantifying relevant features. We then apply Machine Learning techniques and frequency-based analyses to extract insights from the data. Finally, CalTrend visualizes these results and provides interactive tools to aid in exploring individual user behaviors. Below, we first provide a brief introduction of online schedule logs (§ 2.2 ), describe the preprocessing steps used (§ 2.3 ), and describe the CalTrend interface (§ 2.4 , § 2.5 ). Figure 1: The overall workflow of CalTrend . CalTrend is developed in three stages: first, we deidentify information from the schedule logs. Second, we preprocess the data by annotating life modes and defining features reflecting each user’s scheduling patterns. Finally, we apply