On recovering intragranular strain fields from grain-averaged strains obtained by high-energy X-ray diffraction microscopy

C. K. Cocke, A. Akerson, S. F. Gorske, K. T. Faber, K. Bhattacharya · 2025

Read On recovering intragranular strain fields from grain-averaged strains obtained by high-energy X-ray diffraction microscopy by C. K. Cocke, A. Akerson, S. F. Gorske, K. T. Faber, K. Bhattacharya (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-00834.txt.

Introduction

Cocke, Akerson, Gorske, and two colleagues ask whether the full strain field inside each crystal grain can be recovered from grain averages, in a paper published in two thousand twenty-five. X-ray diffraction microscopy maps polycrystalline materials grain by grain and reports each grain's average elastic strain, but engineers want the pointwise field.

The key insight is that averages are not free numbers: they must come from an actual solution of the elasticity equations under the imposed loads. Recovery is therefore a constrained reconstruction: find the elastic field whose grain averages match the measurements. The authors formulate that problem within elasticity theory. If it works, diffraction experiments gain a new product, a full-field strain map from existing data. Internal strain concentrations are where cracks are born, so the upgrade matters for predicting material failure. The paper supplies the theoretical footing for the reconstruction.

Catalog record

CREATORC. K. Cocke, A. Akerson, S. F. Gorske, K. T. Faber, K. Bhattacharya
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-00834

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On recovering intragranular strain fields from grain-averaged strains obtained by high-energy X-ray diffraction microscopy C. K. Cocke, A. Akerson, S. F. Gorske, K. T. Faber, K. Bhattacharya Abstract We address an unusual problem in the theory of elasticity motivated by the problem of reconstructing the strain field from partial information obtained using X-ray diffraction. Referred to as either high-energy X-ray diffraction microscopy (HEDM) or three-dimensional X-ray diffraction microscopy (3DXRD), these methods provide diffraction images that, once processed, commonly yield detailed grain structure of polycrystalline materials, as well as grain-averaged elastic strains. However, it is desirable to have the entire (point-wise) strain field. So we address the question of recovering the entire strain field from grain-averaged values in an elastic polycrystalline material. The key idea is that grain-averaged strains must be the result of a solution to the equations of elasticity and the overall imposed loads. In this light, the recovery problem becomes the following: find the boundary traction distribution that induces the measured grain-averaged strains under the equations of elasticity. We show that there are either zero or infinite solutions to this problem, and more specifically, that there exist an infinite number of kernel fields, or non-trivial solutions to the equations of elasticity that have zero overall boundary loads and zero grain-averaged strains. We define a best-approximate reconstruction to address this non-uniqueness. We then show that, consistent with Saint-Venant’s principle, in experimentally relevant cylindrical specimens, the uncertainty due to non-uniqueness in recovered strain fields decays exponentially with distance from the ends of the interrogated volume. Thus, one can obtain useful information despite the non-uniqueness. We apply these results to a numerical example and experimental observations on a transparent aluminum oxynitride (AlON) sample. 1 Introduction Over the last 30 years, X-ray diffraction–based methods have become a powerful tool for the 3D characterization of crystalline materials. Unlike destructive techniques such as serial sectioning, X-ray diffraction-based methods are nondestructive and allow for in situ characterization of materials during mechanical testing. Of particular interest here is high-energy X-ray diffraction (HEDM) [ 3 ] , which is generally performed at synchrotron light sources that offer high spectral brightness. Typically, two types of HEDM experiments are performed: far-field (ff-HEDM) and near-field (nf-HEDM), and the precise experimental and data processing details can be found elsewhere [ 20 , 2 , 12 , 18 , 17 , 3 ] . In both methods, the sample is illuminated by a monochromatic X-ray beam and rotated. As the sample rotates, lattice planes within constituent crystallites diffract the incident beam as the Bragg condition is satisfied. Plane detectors placed downstream of the sample then measure the summed intensity of all diffraction events during a rotational increment. The difference between ff-HEDM and nf-HEDM is the detector distance, which controls how crystallite position manifests itself in diffraction measurements. Performing reconstruction from both measurement techniques and combining the data yields a complete three-dimensional grain orientation map and the grain-averaged elastic strain. Although these measurements are insightful, it would be very useful to recover the actual (point-wise) elastic strain field. This has led to the development of a point-focused HEDM (pf-HEDM) (also known as scanning 3DXRD) technique that uses a 1D pencil beam to probe small volumes to obtain voxelized intragranular elastic strains [ 6 , 7 , 9 , 11 , 8 ] . Improved algorithms have also been developed to locally recover voxelized intragranular strains from near-field measurements [ 19 , 15 ] . While these methods provide intragranular strains, they still average over the volume of the pencil beam, so the problem of obtaining the actual (point-wise) elastic strain field remains. There have been attempts to address this as a post-processing step by incorporating additional physics. Since the elastic moduli of the constituent materials are known, the voxel-averaged elastic stresses can be obtained from the corresponding strains. These do not satisfy equilibrium, and so Zhou et al. [ 24 ] sought to reconstruct the actual stress field by projecting the grain-averaged stresses to the nearest stress field satisfying equilibrium. This work did not address strain compatibility, and therefore it is unclear whether the reconstructed stress field is physically meaningful. A more complete reconstruction by Naragani et al. [ 14 ] in the context of plasticity used an iterative approach aiming to satisfy equilibrium, compatibility, and an elastic–plastic constitutive relation. However, this required a guess for the boundary condition and left the effects of nonuniqueness unexplored. A difficulty in both works is that X-ray techniques can measure only the elastic strain, so the total strain is unknown. Figure 1: High-energy X-ray diffraction provides the grain structure (middle) and the grain-averaged strains (upper right) of a small cylindrical region of the specimen (left). We seek the full strain field, or equivalently the traction distribution on the top and bottom of the gauge section which induces a strain field satisfying the equations of elasticity (lower right). In this paper, we examine the mathematical status of the inverse problem of obtaining the actual (pointwise) strain field from the grain- or voxel-averaged values and the macroscopic applied load. We limit ourselves to the simpler problem of elasticity, since one can measure the actual grain-wise elastic strains. Additionally, we study grain-averaged strains, although our methods may also be applied to voxel-averaged strains. The problem is shown schematically in Figure 1 . Note that the X-ray measurements are confined to a small region of the gauge section highlighted in the figure. Specifically, we assume that we have a cylindrical domain with a square cross section that is loaded at the ends with an unknown traction distribution but with a known macroscopic force. We also assume that we know the elastic modulus at each point and the strain averaged over a series of subdomains (grains). We ask whether, given the grain-averaged strains and macroscopic force, we can find a strain field consistent with the equations of elasticity. To this end, the problem is cast as a problem of finding the boundary traction distribution that, through the equations of elasticity, induces the measured grain-averaged strains. We have two main results. First, we show that this problem either has no solution or infinite solutions (see Theorem 1 ). Trivially, one needs a consistency condition between the applied load and grain-averaged strains to show the existence of solutions. Less trivially, we show the existence of an infinite number of kernel fields, or traction distributions with zero macroscopic force constructed such that their associated strain fields have zero grain-averaged strains. This follows from a counting argument. The equations of elasticity give rise to a linear operator that maps (equilibrated) traction distributions to grain-averaged strains, and we show that this operator has an infinite-dimensional kernel. We provide numerical examples of these kernel fields. We also define a best-approximate reconstruction and apply it to experimental results on aluminum oxynitride (AlON). Our second result characterizes the non-uniqueness in the solution, i.e., the kernel fields. We observe from numerical results that the kernel tractions are highly oscillatory with the associated kernel strains decaying away from the ends of the cylinder. This is a manifestation of Saint-Venant’s principle [ 22 ] , though in a heterogeneous medium, and we seek to characterize these kernel strains in a central segment

Read the complete text