Impact of random monetary shock: a Keynesian case

Paramahansa Pramanik, Lambert Dong · 2025

Read Impact of random monetary shock: a Keynesian case by Paramahansa Pramanik, Lambert Dong (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-00800.txt.

Introduction

Paramahansa Pramanik and Lambert Dong studied in 2025 how a firm should set its pricing strategy when random money shocks hit a Keynesian market. Their model tracks two state variables: the firm's own price gap and the consumer price index gap from a symmetric balance point. The firm's response strategy to money shocks acts as the control. A mean-field take on the classic Calvo staggered-pricing frame yields a closed-form best strategy.

Theory says more volatility should soften the optimal response. The team then read four leading consumer goods firms. In practice the strategy fell with uncertainty far more steeply than the model foretells. The pair reads that gap as proof of how hard market swings sway real firms.

Catalog record

CREATORParamahansa Pramanik, Lambert Dong
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE144 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-00800

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Impact of random monetary shock: a Keynesian case Paramahansa Pramanik, Lambert Dong Abstract This study investigates the optimal strategy for a firm operating in a dynamic Keynesian market setting. The firm’s objective function is optimized using the percent deviations from the symmetric equilibrium of both its own price and the aggregate consumer price index (CPI) as state variables, with the strategy in response to random monetary shocks acting as the control variable. Building on the Calvo framework, we adopt a mean field approach to derive an analytic expression for the firm’s optimal strategy. Our theoretical results show that greater volatility leads to a decrease in the optimal strategy. To assess the practical relevance of our model, we apply it to four leading consumer goods firms. Empirical analysis suggests that the observed decline in strategies under uncertainty is significantly steeper than what the model predicts, underscoring the substantial influence of market volatility. Keywords: Keynesian economy, monetary shocks, path integral control. 1 Introduction: Although recent advancements have deepened our understanding of general equilibrium models with price rigidity, many existing frameworks still sacrifice realism for analytical ease, often neglecting how firms’ pricing strategies influence one another. These interactions are not merely theoretical curiosities, they are essential to explaining how nominal shocks can produce outsized effects on the real economy, as emphasized by Klenow and Willis, 2016 and Nakamura and Steinsson, 2018 . Nonetheless, a large share of the literature either sidesteps these complexities by relying on computational methods ( Nakamura and Steinsson, 2018 ; Klenow and Willis, 2016 ; Mongey, 2021 ) , oversimplifies timing mechanisms ( Wang and Werning, 2022 ) , or omits firm-specific randomness altogether ( Caplin and Leahy, 1991 ) . As a result, the mutual feedback between individual firms’ behavior and overall economic dynamics is often underrepresented in existing theoretical models. To address these gaps, this study presents a novel analytical model that embeds both strategic pricing complementarities and firm-level shocks within a state-dependent sticky price setting. By building on the driftless Calvo pricing structure and incorporating a mean field approach, the model yields a closed-form characterization of optimal firm behavior in response to macroeconomic conditions. This setup allows firms’ decisions to be shaped by, and to simultaneously influence-aggregate variables, capturing the reciprocal relationship between microeconomic heterogeneity and macro-level fluctuations. The resulting framework not only enhances our understanding of how sticky prices behave in general equilibrium but also establishes a versatile analytical foundation for future work in macroeconomic modeling, including monetary policy analysis and business cycle research ( Alvarez et al., 2023 ) . Analyzing strategic complementarities within a comprehensive equilibrium framework introduces significant challenges: individual decisions depend on aggregate conditions, which themselves are shaped by those decisions. This interdependence creates a fixed-point problem, particularly in models with abrupt transitions, where optimal choices are nonlinear and evolve over time. Wang et al. (2022) Wang and Werning, 2022 explores this complexity by providing analytical solutions for a dynamic oligopoly model, achieving tractability by assuming exogenous timing of firm price adjustments, similar to the Calvo framework ( Calvo, 1983 ) . Our approach aligns with the goals of Caplin and Leahy, 1991 and Wang and Werning, 2022 in pursuing analytical tractability. However, it diverges by examining a setting where firm-level decisions are endogenously determined by prevailing conditions and where idiosyncratic shocks play a significant role in shaping firm behavior. Our treatment of strategic complementarities builds on the foundational work of Caplin and Leahy, 1991 , where a firm’s profit function depends on both its own markup and the average markup across firms. A key distinction in our approach is the inclusion of idiosyncratic shocks, a feature absent in their framework. While Caplin and Leahy analyzed equilibrium under aggregate nominal shocks modeled as a drift-less Brownian motion, our focus shifts to studying the impulse response to a one-time shock with a non-zero drift. This adaptation allows for greater flexibility in exploring a more generalized economic system ( Pramanik, 2016 ; Pramanik, 2021b ) . Our work is closely related to Klenow and Willis, 2016 and Nakamura and Steinsson, 2018 , both of which develop Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium (DSGE) models with an input-output framework. These models incorporate the sticky prices of other industries into each industry’s costs, highlighting macro strategic complementarities . Like these studies, our analysis includes a frictionless labor market, firm-level idiosyncratic shocks, and menu costs associated with price adjustments. Notably, Nakamura and Steinsson, 2018 account for random menu costs, a feature also present in our model, while Klenow and Willis, 2016 incorporate variable demand elasticity at the firm level, referred to as micro-strategic complementarities , which we also consider. We establish that, to a second-order approximation, the combined influence of micro and macro complementarities can be summarized by a single parameter. While Klenow and Willis, 2016 and Nakamura and Steinsson, 2018 rely on numerical methods to analyze the effects of monetary shocks on aggregate output, our research provides analytical insights into these dynamics. Our study shares relevance with the work of Wang and Werning, 2022 , who examine shock propagation in a sticky-price economy characterized by strategic complementarities. Their analytical solution is based on firms following a time-dependent pricing rule similar to the Calvo framework. Several elements of their model align with ours, such as the role of factors like variable demand elasticity, diminishing returns, and non-zero Frisch elasticity, which are summarized by a single parameter. However, key differences distinguish the two approaches. First, Wang and Werning, 2022 analyze a dynamic oligopoly without idiosyncratic shocks, whereas our model focuses on oligopolistic competition with idiosyncratic shocks—a feature that improves consistency with observed price change distributions in empirical data. Second, their framework assumes exogenous timing of price adjustments, while ours allows firms to endogenously determine both the timing and magnitude of their price changes. The absence of idiosyncratic shocks and the simplification of exogenous timing in their model facilitate connections to the New Keynesian Phillips curve and enable an exploration of the role of strategic complementarities. Bertucci, 2018 adds to the mean field game (MFG) literature by examining an impulse control problem. However, his study focuses on a more straightforward scenario involving a decision-maker who considers a single adjustment with a fixed adjustment target. Furthermore, his work primarily centers on proving the existence and uniqueness of solutions, using a slightly different concept of what constitutes a solution. 2 Preliminaries: 2.1 Basic Calvo Model: This section explores an issue concerning strategic complementarities and pricing, as originally discussed by Calvo, 1983 . This particular scenario garners frequent attention in studies on sticky prices owing to its practical significance. The model offers a clear-cut framework for elucidating the core elements of the analysis and for scrutinizing crucial outcomes such as the existence, uniqueness, and non-monotonic characteristics of impulse response profiles, which also bear relevance to the state-dependent problem ( Hua et al., 2019 ) . Let at time s , Z(s) be the consumer price index (CPI), V_{i}(s) be a consumer preference shock corresponding to i^{th} variety and the price set by a firm on consumer good of i^{th} variety be \hat{Z}(s) such that z(s)\equiv\hat{z}(s)/V_{i}(s) . Define \tilde{x}(s):=\frac{z(s)-\hat{Z}(s)}{Z(s)} and \tilde{X}(s):=\frac{Z(s)-\hat{Z}(s)}{Z(s)} as percent deviation from symmetric equilibrium of a firm’s own and the aggregate

Read the complete text