Mutual compatibility/incompatibility of quasi-Hermitian quantum

observables · 2025

Read Mutual compatibility/incompatibility of quasi-Hermitian quantum by observables (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-00791.txt.

Introduction

Miloslav Znojil asks when two slightly nonstandard quantum observables can be measured together, in a 2025 paper. In quasi-Hermitian quantum mechanics, observable operators need not equal their own adjoints. A shared inner-product metric can restore the usual probability reading, and for one observable many such metrics exist.

The two-observable case is the paper's focus. Znojil presents and discusses criteria for a single metric that serves both operators at once, making the pair compatible. When no shared metric exists, the observables clash in a way this framework makes precise. The analysis extends the toolkit of a theory used for systems with balanced gain and loss, where such nonstandard observables arise naturally.

Catalog record

CREATORobservables
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE36 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-00791

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Mutual compatibility/incompatibility of quasi-Hermitian quantum observables Abstract 1 The Czech Academy of Sciences, Nuclear Physics Institute, Hlavní 130, 250 68 Řež, Czech Republic, e-mail: [email protected] 2 Department of Physics, Faculty of Science, University of Hradec Králové, Rokitanského 62, 50003 Hradec Králové, Czech Republic 3 Institute of System Science, Durban University of Technology, Durban, South Africa Abstract In the framework of quasi-Hermitian quantum mechanics the eligible operators of observables may be non-Hermitian, A_{j}\neq A_{j}^{\dagger} , j=1,2,\ldots,K . In principle, the standard probabilistic interpretation of the theory can be re-established via a reconstruction of physical inner-product metric \Theta\neq I guaranteeing the quasi-Hermiticity A_{j}^{\dagger}\,\Theta=\Theta\,A_{j} . The task is easy at K=1 because there are many eligible metrics \Theta=\Theta(A_{1}) . In our paper the next case with K=2 is analyzed. The criteria of the existence of a shared metric \Theta=\Theta(A_{1},A_{2}) are presented and discussed. Keywords . quantum mechanics of unitary systems; quasi-Hermitian representations of observables; constructions of physical inner product metrics; the criteria of existence of the shared metric for more observables; 1 Introduction It used to be widely accepted that a consistent picture of a unitary quantum system can only be based on our knowledge of its observable quantities represented by a set of operators A_{1} , A_{2} , …which are all self-adjoint in a suitable Hilbert space (cf., e.g., [ 1 ] ). More than thirty years ago, Scholtz, Geyer and Hahne [ 2 ] pointed out that such a statement may lead to misunderstandings because in some fairly realistic models, the operators of observables could be defined as acting, simultaneously, in two different Hilbert spaces, viz., in spaces {\cal H}_{mathematical} and {\cal H}_{physical} . By construction, the latter two spaces have to coincide as the sets of ket vectors |\psi\rangle . Still, they may be unitarily non-equivalent because they may differ by the use of the two alternative forms of the respective inner products. Thus, in order to avoid misunderstandings, one has to speak, first, about a maximally user-friendly inner product which specifies a manifestly unphysical Hilbert space {\cal H}_{mathematical} . At the same time, one also has to speak about the second, correct physical inner product which must be used to specify the other, presumably user-unfriendly Hilbert space of states {\cal H}_{physical} which is still the only one which provides their correct probabilistic interpretation. The technical details of the idea may be found in [ 2 ] . A decisive advantage of keeping the two spaces different has been found in the possibility of reduction of the difference to the mere redefinition of the inner product, \langle\psi_{a}|\psi_{b}\rangle_{mathematical}\ \to\ (\psi_{a}|\psi_{b})_{physical}\ \equiv\ \langle\psi_{a}|\Theta|\psi_{b}\rangle_{mathematical}\,. (1) The amended (often called physical) inner-product metric \Theta\neq I should be a positive-definite and bounded operator which is self-adjoint in {\cal H}_{mathematical} and has a bounded inverse [ 3 ] . Under these assumptions, the “obligatory” requirement of Hermiticity of A_{j} s in {\cal H}_{physical} can be re-expressed, in the preferred representation space {\cal H}_{mathematical} , as their quasi-Hermiticity [ 4 ] alias \Theta- pseudo-Hermiticity [ 5 ] , A_{j}^{\dagger}\,\Theta=\Theta\,A_{j}\,,\ \ \ \ \forall j\,. (2) Needless to add that the two Hilbert spaces would coincide in the limit of \Theta\to I . Within the generic theory with \Theta\neq I , nevertheless, the “hidden Hermiticity” constraint ( 2 ) will still imply the reality of the spectrum. In most applications the model-building process proceeds in opposite direction. In a way sampled in [ 2 ] or [ 6 ] , one is just given a set \{A_{j}\} of the candidates for observables. All of these operators have to be treated, in {\cal H}_{mathematical} , as non-Hermitian, A_{j}\neq A_{j}^{\dagger} . For all of them, the reality of the spectrum is merely necessary, but not sufficient, condition of their observability and mutual compatibility. One has to prove the mathematical consistency of the theory by showing that all of the preselected operators of observables share the quasi-Hermiticity property ( 2 ). A clarification of these items is also the main purpose of our present paper. In our preceding study [ 7 ] of the problem we have shown that even when one decides to work with the mere doublet of the “input” operators A_{1} and A_{2} , the acceptable inner-product metric need not exist at all. The essence of such a no-go theorem was that the two “arbitrary” operators A_{1} and A_{2} had to be quasi-Hermitian with respect to a single, subscript-independent metric \Theta . This simply imposes too many constraints upon \Theta in general. In what follows we will outline a continuation of the latter study. We will introduce and describe an efficient strategy of the construction of \Theta whenever it does exist. 2 Self-adjoint Hamiltonians in quasi-Hermitian form The innovative two-Hilbert-space reformulation of quantum theory as offered in paper [ 2 ] may be called quasi-Hermitian quantum mechanics (QHQM). In its original formulation, unfortunately, most of the mathematical as well as phenomenological roots of such a theory seemed to be rather specific, aimed just at nuclear physicists. Indeed, the authors themselves were nuclear physicists so that they decided to illustrate the merits of the formalism via a rather complicated many-particle example. In a broader physics community, therefore, the more abstract theoretical message as provided by paper [ 2 ] remained more or less unnoticed. In the words of a recent review paper [ 5 ] , “the main problem with this formalism is that it is generally very difficult to implement” (cf. p. 1217 in loc. cit. ). A properly amended version of the idea of QHQM appeared, fortunately, just a few years later. 2.1 Quantum models with single quasi-Hermitian observable An ultimate and successful version of the QHQM approach to quantum systems has been proposed by Bender with co-authors [ 8 , 9 ] . Their upgrade of the theory has been simpler, better motivated, better presented and much more widely accepted. Almost immediately, the modified theory (currently known under a nickname of {\cal PT}- symmetric quantum mechanics [ 10 ] ) became truly popular, partly also due to the methodically very fortunate restriction of attention to specific quantum systems characterized by the use (i) of a single non-Hermitian operator A_{1} serving phenomenological purposes and yielding, typically, bound-state energies as its eigenvalues [ 11 ] ; (ii) of the most common formulation the theory called Schrödinger picture in which the observable plays the role of quantum Hamiltonian, A_{1}=H [ 5 ] ; (iii) of the mere ordinary-differential Hamiltonians H=-d^{2}/dx^{2}+V(x) in which even the local interaction potentials themselves were kept maximally elementary [ 12 ] ; (iv) of an auxiliary antilinear parity times time-reversal symmetry ( {\cal PT}- symmetry). This made the Hamiltonians tractable as self-adjoint in an ad hoc Krein space [ 13 , 14 ] . All of these well-invented simplifications contributed to the enormous growth of popularity of the non-Hermitian representations of quantum systems exhibiting {\cal PT}- symmetry. What followed was a highly productive and fruitful transfer of the related mathematics to several non-quantum areas of physics (cf., e.g., [ 15 ] ). Nevertheless, we believe that it is now time to remove or weaken at least some of the above-listed simplifications while turning attention (i) to the models using at least two observables, i.e., not

Read the complete text