Nonparametric Estimation of Matching Efficiency and Elasticity in a Marriage Agency Platform: 2014–2025

Suguru Otani · 2025

Read Nonparametric Estimation of Matching Efficiency and Elasticity in a Marriage Agency Platform: 2014–2025 by Suguru Otani (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-00607.txt.

Introduction

Suguru Otani, a solo author, studies how well a large marriage agency in Japan matches its clients over time. The platform is the largest of its kind in the land, with checked profiles and records of search, dating, and confirmed engagements.

The data cover about three percent of all marriages in the land each year, a rare window on real search behavior. Otani uses a method that makes few fixed claims about the shape of matching. He finds that matching grew about threefold in efficiency over the span from 2014 to 2025. The result shows how a digital go-between can change partner search.

Catalog record

CREATORSuguru Otani
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE16 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-00607

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Nonparametric Estimation of Matching Efficiency and Elasticity in a Marriage Agency Platform: 2014–2025 Suguru Otani Abstract This paper examines monthly matching efficiency in the Japanese marriage market using novel data from IBJ, the country’s largest structured matching platform. Unlike administrative or dating app data, IBJ provides full search, dating, and matching logs based on verified profiles and confirmed engagements. Users are highly selected into serious marriage search via costly screening. Covering 3.3% of national marriages annually, the data offer rare behavioral granularity. Using a nonparametric approach, I estimate time-varying matching functions and elasticities. Efficiency rises threefold over time, illustrating how digital intermediation transforms partner search in modern marriage markets. Keywords : matching function, matching efficiency, matching elasticity, marriage agency platform, dating JEL code : J12, J10, D83 1 Introduction Understanding how individuals find partners in modern marriage markets is central to the study of family economics ( Chiappori and Salanié 2023 ) . As marriage rates decline and matching technologies proliferate, questions surrounding search efficiency, partner availability, and market design have grown increasingly salient. While theoretical models of two-sided search abound, empirical research has been hampered by data limitations: traditional sources such as administrative records or surveys capture only realized marriages, omitting the entire search and matching process that precedes them, as well as the presence of singles who are not seriously seeking partners. Consequently, little is known about the dynamics of partner search, how modern platforms shape matching outcomes, or how efficiently modern markets operate. This study addresses these limitations by using novel data from IBJ, Japan’s largest structured marriage matching platform, which accounts for approximately 3.3% of all marriages in Japan in 2024. 1 1 1 Approximately 50% of engagements among IBJ users occur within the platform, while the remaining 50% result from relationships formed outside the platform. The dataset includes over 10,000 confirmed engagements annually and allows for behavioral analysis of the full matching process, including search, proposals, and formal engagements. In this note, we focus on documenting macro-level trends on the platform as a first step toward more detailed analysis, leaving in-depth investigations of user behavior and underlying mechanisms to future work. There are four distinctive and advantageous features of the IBJ data compared to dating apps ( Hitsch et al. 2010 , Ong and Wang 2015 , Bapna et al. 2016 , Egebark et al. 2021 , Rios et al. 2023 ) , speed date events ( Fisman et al. 2006 , Belot and Francesconi 2013 ) , and government records ( Chiappori et al. 2017 ) . First, the data contain rich and verified user demographics, which are linked to official records such as tax withholding documents and certified health checkup results. Second, users are highly selected into serious partnership search due to substantial screening and financial costs. Third, the dataset records full, time-stamped logs of search and interaction behavior linked to confirmed outcomes, and includes information on whether users were active or inactive in their marriage search at each point in time. Fourth, the data are observed at the level of individual user behavior logs, enabling high-frequency analysis. Importantly, the IBJ data’s richness and granularity, combined with its one-to-one matching structure, enable a direct analogy to labor market matching function estimation ( Petrongolo and Pissarides 2001 ) , allowing us to assess platform-level efficiency and responsiveness. Using this dataset, I estimate a matching function following the nonparametric approach of Lange and Papageorgiou 2020 to evaluate the platform’s performance. 2 2 2 Their approach is widely applied to labor market settings. See Otani 2024a , Otani 2024b and Kanayama and Otani 2024 . I find that matching efficiency increased threefold between 2014 and 2025, with sharp gains beginning in 2017, coinciding with major platform consolidation. Engagement formation also became more responsive to user composition, as indicated by rising elasticities. These results underscore the role of digital intermediation in shaping modern family formation. Unlike traditional arrangements mediated by kinship networks or local norms, platforms like IBJ provide structured, data-rich environments where frictions are minimized, outcomes are verified, and behavioral dynamics are observable, enabling new empirical insights. 2 Data I use confidential data from IBJ covering the period 2014–2025. In 2024, IBJ accounted for 3.3% of all marriages in Japan, with over 10,000 engagements annually. While this share is smaller than administrative marriage registers, IBJ offers unique visibility into the pre-marriage process. The platform collects verified user data, including age, income, education, and marital status, and tracks the full sequence of user actions: search, proposals, messages, and dates. All records are time-stamped and linked to observed engagement outcomes. IBJ users are highly selected into serious long-term partnership search. Entry requires screening and significant upfront, monthly, and exit fees, which effectively exclude casual users. In contrast to dating apps that rely on self-reported profiles and open-ended interactions, IBJ functions as a closed, consultant-mediated two-sided matching platform where mutual consent leads to a confirmed engagement. This structured environment makes the data well-suited for analyzing matching efficiency and responsiveness over time. (a) (b) (c) Figure 1 : Trends of key variables 2014-2025 Panels (a) and (b) in Figure 1 display trends in the number of active users and engagements on the IBJ platform from 2014 to 2025. Both female F and male M participation rise steadily, with male user growth outpacing that of females—particularly after 2020—leading to a gradual decline in market tightness, measured as the gender balance ratio \frac{F}{M} . Alongside this compositional shift, the number of engagements E , which is realized within the platform, remains relatively flat until around 2020, after which it increases sharply. This acceleration likely reflects improvements in platform performance, such as better algorithmic matching, increased user activity, or broader social adoption of digital matching services. Panel (c) illustrates the partner finding rates for female and male users per month, measured respectively as \frac{E}{F} and \frac{E}{M} . Both rates increase over time, with females consistently achieving higher matching rates. This suggests improved match formation efficiency on the platform, particularly for female users, despite the growing supply of male participants. The male rate displays greater month-to-month volatility, pointing to more sensitivity to changes in market conditions. 3 Empirical Framework This paper conceptualizes the marriage market as a two-sided search environment, where female users seek partners and male users are potential partners. 3 3 3 While an influential strand of the literature models marriage markets as stable, frictionless matching environments and estimates preference-based matching patterns using equilibrium assumptions (e.g., Chiappori and Salanié 2023 ), this study takes a different empirical approach. Rather than recovering structural preferences under the assumption of stable matching, I focus on the empirical measurement of platform-level matching efficiency and elasticity over time. Our interest lies in understanding how the IBJ platform transforms search input into actual matches. A successful match occurs when both parties agree to engage. Drawing on the matching function framework from labor economics, I estimate the number of engagements as a function of efficiency input and market tightness captured by the gender balance ratio. Let E_{t} denote the number of within-platform engagements at time t , F_{t} and M_{t} the number of active female and male users, and A_{t} a time-varying matching efficiency parameter. Let (A,F,M) denote random

Read the complete text