Deterministic Scheduling over Wi-Fi 6 using Target Wake Time: An Experimental Approach

Govind Rajendran and Samar Agnihotri · 2025

Read Deterministic Scheduling over Wi-Fi 6 using Target Wake Time: An Experimental Approach by Govind Rajendran and Samar Agnihotri (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-00447.txt.

Introduction

Govind Rajendran and Samar Agnihotri test deterministic scheduling over Wi-Fi 6 using its Target Wake Time feature in 2025. Normal Wi-Fi channel access is random and competitive, which causes delays and gives no performance guarantees in busy networks.

Target Wake Time was built to save power, but the authors use it to plan access in a fixed way. Experiments on a testbed with off-the-shelf gear revealed what shapes its performance. They then solved an optimization problem to set the best schedule and system values. With those settings, scheduled clients and the whole system beat standard access consistently.

Catalog record

CREATORGovind Rajendran and Samar Agnihotri
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE52 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-00447

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Deterministic Scheduling over Wi-Fi 6 using Target Wake Time: An Experimental Approach Govind Rajendran and Samar Agnihotri Abstract Wi-Fi networks traditionally use Distributed Coordination Function (DCF) that employs CSMA/CA along with the binary backoff mechanism for channel access. This causes unavoidable contention overheads and does not provide performance guarantees. In this work, we outline some issues that occur with the probabilistic channel access in highly congested scenarios and how those can be mitigated using deterministic scheduling. Towards this, we propose to use Target Wake Time (TWT) - a feature introduced in Wi-Fi 6 as a power-saving mechanism, to improve the performance of Wi-Fi. To gain insights into the workings of the TWT over commercially available off-the-shelf components and to analyze the factors that affect its performance, we carry out various experiments with it over our Wi-Fi 6 testbed. Using these insights and analysis, we formulate and solve an optimization problem to synthesize deterministic schedules and obtain the optimal values of various system parameters. Lastly, we configure our testbed with these optimal parameter values and show that the TWT based deterministic scheduling consistently results in better performance of the TWT-capable clients and overall system performance compared to traditional CSMA/CA based scheduling. Correspondence Email: [email protected] and [email protected] I Introduction Wireless communication technologies have played an important role in the current information age and Wi-Fi is an integral part of this revolution. Allowing easy deployment and better indoor performance makes it the de-facto method to connect consumer devices to the Internet nowadays, replacing traditional wired connection. It is estimated that approximately 200 exabytes of global monthly IP traffic is transmitted through Wi-Fi [ 1 ] . Along with the major role it plays in smart devices, Internet of Things (IoT) infrastructure and enterprise deployments have made Wi-Fi a common utility. Wireless Local Area Network (WLAN), which is based on the IEEE 802.11 suite of standards and is commonly known as Wi-Fi, is a popular choice for network connectivity. However, its popularity comes at the cost of efficiency and performance as Wi-Fi devices share an unlicensed and unregulated band. As Wi-Fi, traditionally, uses contention as its primary channel access method, it can incur a significant penalty in terms of throughput and delay, affecting the Quality of Service (QoS) experienced by the users. Airtime is a scarce resource, more so in a congested scenario, and the need for its optimal utilization to provide QoS guarantees to the end-users and to improve the overall system performance cannot be overstated. A newer generation of Wi-Fi, known as High Efficiency Wireless or Wi-Fi 6, built according to the specifications of the IEEE 802.11ax standard [ 2 ] , focuses on more efficient spectrum utilization and providing QoS rather than higher throughput. Wi-Fi 6 introduces 1024-QAM, Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiple Access (OFDMA), 8-stream multi-user multiple input multiple output (MU-MIMO), and spatial reuse among other features to improve the end-user performance and increase spectral efficiency even in dense deployment scenarios. Additionally, it also has Target Wake Time , a feature initially introduced in 802.11ah standard [ 3 ] to reduce signal overhead and network energy consumption. Carrier-Sense Multiple Access with Collision Avoidance (CSMA/CA) is a channel access method traditionally used by Wi-Fi devices. A CSMA/CA client listens to check for an idle channel before transmission. If the channel is indeed busy, it waits till the end of the transmission plus the Distributed Inter Frame Space (DIFS) duration before choosing a random delay. This delay is uniformly chosen from the contention window. If any other client transmits during this period, the countdown is paused and resumed after the transmission is completed. In case there is a collision, the client uses a binary exponential back-off mechanism before trying again, wherein the contention window is doubled, and a new delay is sampled from it. The back-off, on average, doubles after every failure, thus reducing the collision probability. However, the CSMA/CA based channel access may cause significant penalties in terms of delay and throughput, while reducing the overall efficiency of the system due to airtime wasted because of the back-off mechanism. The CSMA/CA also impacts the fairness of the transmission. In a scenario where the traffic is downlink biased, yet a few clients with uplink traffic may receive a higher proportion of transmit time. This is because over a period of time the odds of every device winning the channel average out to be the same and when the Access Point (AP) wins the channel, its transmit time must be further divided among multiple downlink clients. This is often referred to as the uplink/downlink disparity of probabilistic channel access [ 4 ] . The CSMA/CA due to its inherent randomness in providing the channel access, cannot provide guarantees on airtime, throughput, or delay jitter, and it suffers significantly as the number of associated clients increases. Another issue with the probabilistic access arises with the hidden terminal problem [ 5 ] , when clients are within range of the AP, but out of range with each other. It is tackled with the RTS/CTS mechanism which adds to the transmission overhead. I-A Deterministic channel access Scheduling packets to be transmitted at predefined time slots, without contending for channel access, unlike CSMA/CA, is defined as deterministic channel access. This allows us to give guarantees on channel access, which may lead to guarantees on throughput and jitter while also taking into consideration the QoS demands and fairness. In commercial enterprise deployments like office and residential spaces, channel usage patterns of applications and clients can be captured and analyzed, along with fine-grained information such MCS index, signal strength, to build spatio-temporal models of usage. This can be leveraged effectively to set up different operational Wi-Fi parameters/schedules to handle the expected demands [ 6 ] . While mobility of clients is a practical feature of wireless networks, scheduling can still allow some guarantees/increase in performance, for example in scenarios such as legacy channel access and limited mobility. We propose to use the Target Wake Time feature in Wi-Fi 6 to provide a predetermined channel access schedule, allowing transmission of packets at specific predefined intervals and show its effectiveness over legacy CSMA/CA based channel access. To the best of our knowledge, our work is the first demonstration of this idea on an experimental WLAN testbed, composed of only consumer-grade off-the-shelf components. I-B Contributions In this work, we • study the throughput characteristics of Wi-Fi traffic with the variation of airtime through a series of experiments performed on our Wi-Fi 6 testbed designed with commercially available off-the-shelf TWT-capable Wi-Fi 6 clients and other components, • propose an optimization problem to create deterministic schedules in a WLAN with TWT-capable clients and to optimize various system parameters to maximize the throughput of such a system, subject to the constraints of fairness and minimum throughput guarantees, • deploy the deterministic schedules and optimum values of various system parameters in our Wi-Fi 6 testbed, and evaluate the resulting performance and compare it with a system with only legacy CSMA/CA clients, • and experimentally show that in a hybrid environment with a mix of TWT-capable and traditional clients, the proposed approach not only results in higher throughput for the individual TWT-capable clients, but also consistently provides higher

Read the complete text