On the total derivative divergence for a nonminimal vector operator

2025

Read On the total derivative divergence for a nonminimal vector operator (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-00214.txt.

Introduction

Thomas Sangy, Tibério de Paula Netto, and Ilya Shapiro compute a contested term in the quantum corrections for a vector field in curved spacetime. The term, a total derivative involving the curvature, feeds into the effective action used in conformal quantum gravity and may decide whether that theory can be renormalized. Earlier derivations disagreed on whether it depends on gauge fixing, which would clash with general theorems.

Using Riemann normal coordinates, the authors redo the calculation and confirm the earlier results that raised the puzzle. They discuss how gauge-dependent regulators in the infrared might create the apparent ambiguity. The work sharpens a known tension in quantum field theory in curved space.

Catalog record

YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE51 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-00214

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the total derivative divergence for a nonminimal vector operator Abstract We report on the calculation of the total derivative □ ⁡ R \cx R term in the divergence of vacuum effective action for the nonminimal vector field operator in a curved space background. This term led to an interesting discussions in the literature, in particular because it defines the local part of anomaly-induced effective action in conformal quantum gravity and may be decisive for the renormalizability of this theory. The divergent term of our interest was previously derived several times. One of the main results is that the mentioned local term is gauge-fixing dependent in the case of electromagnetic field, that contradicts the general theorems about quantum corrections. We perform the derivation by using Riemann’s normal coordinates and confirm the previous results. The discussion includes the possible role of the gauge-dependent IR regulators and the related ambiguity. Keywords: One-loop divergences, Nonminimal operator, Effective action, Curved space, Local momentum representation MSC: 81T10, 81T15, 81T20, 81T50 Thomas M. Sangy 1 1 1 E-mail: [email protected] , Tibério de Paula Netto 2 2 2 E-mail: [email protected] and Ilya L. Shapiro 3 3 3 E-mail: [email protected] Departamento de Física, ICE, Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora - UFJF Juiz de Fora, 36036-900, MG, Brazil Introduction The nonminimal vector operators emerge in the gauge theories of vector fields, either Abelian or non-Abelian, under the use of the DeWitt-Faddeev-Popov method with the “nonminimal” gauge fixing conditions. The same operators gain notorious importance for the one-loop calculations in higher derivative quantum gravity, emerging in the action of Faddeev-Popov ghosts and in the weight operator [ 1 ] . In this case, the heat-kernel representations of vector operators contribute to the one-loop divergences, which may be of the types C^{2} (square of the Weyl tensor), E_{4} (Gauss-Bonnet topological term), R^{2} and \cx R . The last term is a total derivative and is apparently irrelevant. However, there is a big difference between the status of this term in the general theory of fourth-derivative gravity and in its reduced conformal sibling [ 2 ] . In the general model, this term is irrelevant. On the other hand, the situation may be quite different in the conformal C^{2} -based quantum gravity, which is free from the unphysical ghosts at the tree level. If being multiplicatively renormalizable, conformal quantum gravity would be also ghost-free at the quantum level, which would be an interesting feature. The main obstacle is that the integration of the \cx R -term in the anomaly produces an R^{2} -term in the finite one-loop contribution to the effective action, violating conformal symmetry. If such a term appears, this means the number of degrees of freedom of the theory changes under the first quantum correction, the Källén-Lehmann representation gets broken, one can expect the R^{2} -type divergences in higher loops, such that the theory becomes non-unitary. Thus, it is important to understand the status of \cx R in the one-loop divergences and whether this term is ambiguous or not. The functional trace of the Schwinger-DeWitt coefficient \hat{a}_{2} for a nonminimal vector field operator was first obtained in [ 1 ] using Feynman diagrams. The result has been confirmed as an important application of the generalized Schwinger-DeWitt technique [ 3 ] . However, in both works [ 1 ] and [ 3 ] there was no evaluation of the total derivative term \cx R . The first derivation of this term for the Maxwell theory in a one-parameter gauge was given in [ 4 ] . This work concluded that the trace anomaly for the Maxwell field depends on the gauge fixing, which led to an alternative consideration with an opposite conclusion in [ 5 ] . After this, for a general vector-field operator, the trace of \hat{a}_{2} was independently obtained in [ 6 ] and subsequently verified in [ 7 , 8 ] . Recently, the coefficients of the surface terms appearing in the trace of \hat{a}_{2} were independently derived in [ 2 ] using a modification of the generalized Schwinger-DeWitt technique [ 3 ] , as a part of the first calculation of the \cx R -divergence in conformal quantum gravity. All these works confirmed the original result [ 4 ] . However, regardless of the methods of [ 4 ] , [ 6 ] , [ 7 , 8 ] and [ 2 ] were qualitatively different, we decided to perform one more independent derivation of the same quantity following the approach of Refs. [ 9 ] and [ 10 ] , i.e., using the local momentum representation and normal coordinates. The paper is organized as follows. The content of Sec. 2 serves as a motivation for the rest of the paper. We show the simple derivation of the desired \cx R -divergence that is based on the two postulates, namely, the gauge-fixing independence of the trace anomaly for the Maxwell field, assuming the irrelevance of the Jacobian of the linear constant change of variables, and on the absence of multiplicative anomaly (MA) in the divergences of the vector operators. Both postulates may be incorrect, but in our opinion, it is worth seeing how they can be applied. Sec. 3 describes the local momentum representation for the propagator of the nonminimal vector operator. Sec. 4 describes the coincidence limit in the propagator, the derivation of one-loop divergences, and the potentially important gauge-fixing dependence in the IR regulator. Finally, in Sec. 5 we present the concluding discussions, mainly concerning MA. Simple logic for the nonminimal vector operator In this section, we discuss a simple indirect derivation of the divergences of the \,\mbox{Tr}\,\log\hat{H} of the nonminimal second-order vector operator \displaystyle\hat{H}\,=\,H^{\mu}_{\nu}=\delta^{\mu}_{\nu}\cx-\lambda\nabla^{\mu}\nabla_{\nu}+P^{\mu}_{\nu}. (1) Here P_{\mu\nu} is an arbitrary tensor and \lambda is an arbitrary parameter. In the case \lambda=0 , we have a minimal operator, but our interest is to elaborate the general nonminimal case with \lambda\neq 0 , and establish the \lambda -dependence in the one-loop contribution \,\,\mbox{Tr}\,\log\hat{H}\, of the operator ( 1 ). As we have already mentioned in the Introduction, this section is based on the assumptions that i) There is no MA for the one-loop divergences; ii) There is no effect on the divergences from the linear constant change of variables, opposite to the statement of [ 5 ] . Both statements may be incorrect, but let us use these assumptions, just to see how it works. In this section, we first formulate the test for the correctness of \,\mbox{Tr}\,\log\hat{H} for the operator ( 1 ), and then show how this test can be used in practice. Gauge fixing test According to the general QFT theorems, the one-loop divergences of effective action do not depend on the gauge fixing or parametrization of quantum fields on the classical mass shell. This theorem was proved in many works; let us mention, in particular, [ 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 ] for the proof of gauge-independence on shell in the Yang-Mills theories and [ 15 ] for the Maxwell theory, which is our present case. We can also mention the proof in [ 16 ] for the same statement in the background field formalism, [ 17 ] for the extension to a curved spacetime, and the proof for

Read the complete text