Emergence of wind ripples controlled by mechanics of grain–bed impacts

C. W. Lester, A. B. Murray, Orencio Duran, B. Andreotti, P. Claudin · 2025

Read Emergence of wind ripples controlled by mechanics of grain–bed impacts by C. W. Lester, A. B. Murray, Orencio Duran, B. Andreotti, P. Claudin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-00154.txt.

Introduction

Lester and colleagues ask what sets the size of wind ripples in sand. Impact ripples cover beaches and deserts on Earth. They also show on Mars at the same size, even though the air there is much thinner. That match raises a clear question about how the ripples form.

In computer models, the team finds that ripple size is set by how grains hit the bed. It is not set by how grains fly above the bed. Those flight paths have no fixed scale, so they cannot pick a ripple size. When a grain hits the bed, the grains it knocks loose add a shared length scale. That scale fixes the ripple size. Their model holds ripple size near constant for most planet types. It also says that in thick air, like on Venus, ripples should move upwind.

Catalog record

CREATORC. W. Lester, A. B. Murray, Orencio Duran, B. Andreotti, P. Claudin
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE91 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-00154

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Emergence of wind ripples controlled by mechanics of grain–bed impacts C. W. Lester, A. B. Murray, Orencio Duran, B. Andreotti, P. Claudin Abstract Abstract Periodic sediment patterns have been observed on Earth in riverbeds and sand and snow deserts, but also in other planetary environments. One of the most ubiquitous patterns, familiar wind or ‘impact’ ripples, adorns sand beaches and arid regions on Earth. The observation of aeolian impact ripples on Mars the same size as their terrestrial counterparts despite a thinner atmosphere raises questions about their formation. Here we show in a numerical simulation that the emergent wavelength of impact ripples is controlled by the mechanics of grain–bed impacts and not the characteristic trajectories of grains above the bed. We find that the distribution of grain trajectories in transport is essentially scale-free, invoking the proximity of a critical point and precluding a transport-related length scale that selects ripple wavelengths. By contrast, when a grain strikes the bed, the process leading to grain ejections introduces a collective granular length scale that determines the scale of the ripples. We propose a theoretical model that predicts a relatively constant ripple size for most planetary conditions. In addition, our model predicts that for high-density atmospheres, such as on Venus, or for sufficiently large sand grains on Earth, impact ripples propagate upwind. Although wind-tunnel and field experiments are needed to confirm the existence of such ‘antiripples’, we suggest that our quantitative model of wind-blown sediment transport may be used to deduce geological and environmental conditions on other planets from the sizes and propagation speeds of impact ripples. This is a preprint; it has not been peer reviewed by a journal. A version of this preprint was published at Nature Geoscience on April 8th, 2025. See https://doi.org/10.1038/s41561-025-01672-w . Many approximately periodic sedimentary patterns result from the interaction between bedform and flow, via modulation of transport Charru et al. 2013 ; Duran Vinent et al. 2019 . There is already a long scientific history of relating bedforms observed in different environments to physical parameters such as fluid density, viscosity and velocity, and grain density and size Bagnold 2012 ; Charru et al. 2013 ; Lapotre et al. 2016 ; Duran Vinent et al. 2019 . The search for analogs between different planets involves correctly identifying the dynamical mechanisms. For example, the meter scale dunes on Mars (Fig. 1 b) are not the counterparts of centimeter scale wind ripples on Earth (Fig. 1 a), but are more similar to ripples in water and sand dunes more broadly Lapotre et al. 2016 . While dunes, water ripples and meter-scale Martian bedforms arise because fluid forces on the bed vary across the bedform, wind ripples, or ‘impact ripples’, form under conditions in which grains at the bed surface are set in motion by high energy impacts of other grains in transport—as opposed to directly impelled by the fluid. On both Earth and Mars, impact ripples are centimeter scale (Fig. 1 a,b). However, experimental results suggest that under some conditions wind modulation in response to bed undulations can lead to the coevolution of impact and hydrodynamic ripples of similar scale Yizhaq et al. 2024 . To disentangle these effects we choose to analyze impact-ripple formation in the absence of wind modulations. The current understanding of impact ripples often attributes their size (wavelength) to the characteristic hoplength of sand grains in transport Bagnold 2012 ; Anderson 1987 ; Prigozhin 1999 ; Csahók et al. 2000 ; Durán et al. 2014 , thought to be the only relevant length scale. However, this explanation implies that impact ripple wavelengths should tend to be larger on planets where lower density atmospheres lead to larger hoplengths, such as Mars, and smaller for thicker atmospheres with smaller hoplengths, such as Venus—in contrast with observations Lapotre et al. 2016 ; Andreotti et al. 2021 ; Miller et al. 1987 ; Andreotti et al. 2006 ; Greeley et al. 1984 . We investigate ripple emergence using a discrete element model (DEM) with a two way coupling between grains and hydrodynamics Durán et al. 2012 , able to reproduce observed transport characteristics and impact ripples over a wide range of atmospheric environments Pähtz and Durán 2020 ; Pähtz and Durán 2023 ; Durán et al. 2014 ; Yizhaq et al. 2024 (see Supplemental Videos). Simulations show that the hoplength distribution is essentially scale-free over nearly the whole range of hoplengths \ell (Fig. 1 d; Durán et al. 2014 ). This implies that no characteristic hoplength scale relevant for ripple wavelength selection exists Anderson 1987 , and that our understanding of ripple formation and aeolian sediment transport is flawed. In this paper we explore the consequences of the scale-free nature of sediment transport and propose a new dynamic length scale resulting from grain-bed impacts that determines impact ripple wavelengths across planetary environments. Figure 1: Wind ripple patterns have been explained by a two population model, but transport is better described by a continuous scale-free population. (a) Photos of centimeter scale impact ripples on Earth (photo by Marli Miller from Death Valley, CA, USA: geologypics.com) and (b) meter scale “megaripples” with superimposed centimeter scale impact ripples (zoomed panel) on Mars (photo from NASA’s Curiosity Rover). The “megaripple” bedforms on Mars are dynamically distinct from the superimposed impact ripples—as the dunes on Earth are dynamically distinct from the super imposed impact ripples in (a) Lapotre et al. 2016 ; Duran Vinent et al. 2019 . (We note that impact ripple sizes in (a) are mature and around a factor of two or so larger than the initial wavelengths modeled in this paper Andreotti et al. 2006 . And ripples in (b) seem to show a range of sizes, the smallest being the incipient wavelengths addressed here.) (c) The widely used model for sediment transport and ripple formation that separates transport into two distinct populations, saltons and reptons. (d) DEM trajectories over a rippled surface and (e) hoplength distribution P_{0}(\ell) versus hoplengths \ell rescaled by the grain size d (data from the DEM for Earth like conditions; \langle\ell\rangle\simeq 100d ). DEM simulations (panels d,e) show that the population of trajectories forms one continuous distribution—much of it scale free as P_{0}\sim 1/\ell —rather than distinct, scale-separated populations as would be observed in the salton-repton model (panel c). Inset in (e) shows the exceedance probability of hoplengths F(L>\ell) compared with wind tunnel experiments of Ho et al. 2014 —for all wind speed runs for 230\ \mu m (blue) and 630\ \mu m (red) grain sizes–and wind-tunnel experiments of Rasmussen et al. 2015 (red) for 320\ \mu m for all wind speed tested. Figure 2: Trajectory-ripple interactions lead to flux modulations, and impact-ejection lag phase shifts the modulated flux. (a) DEM trajectories over a rippled surface showing only hoplengths \ell around one wavelength \lambda —illustrating the modulation of the impact flux via trajectory amplification. Panels (b) show the processes that lead to trajectory and resulting flux modulations. (b1) The mechanism for amplification and focusing of trajectories around the upwind inflection point due to geometrical modulations of hoplengths \Delta\ell(\ell,x,t) . Red amendments to trajectories show positive or negative changes to hoplengths \ell based on where the grain impacts for a given take off location. Note that the

Read the complete text