On the difficulty of capturing the distribution function of neutrinos in neutron star merger simulations

Francois Foucart · 2025

Read On the difficulty of capturing the distribution function of neutrinos in neutron star merger simulations by Francois Foucart (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-21822.txt.

Introduction

Francois Foucart wrote this 2025 paper on a stubborn problem in simulating two neutron stars as they merge. Such crashes teach us about dense matter and about how heavy elements form. The light signal after a crash, called a kilonova, depends on the flood of tiny particles called neutrinos.

Most simulations track only sums of the neutrino flow, not the full spread of their energies and paths. That shortcut blocks a needed effect: crowded states that slow new neutrino creation. A random sampling method could track the full spread, the author notes. The paper weighs the costs and limits of each route for merger models.

Catalog record

CREATORFrancois Foucart
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE40 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-21822

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the difficulty of capturing the distribution function of neutrinos in neutron star merger simulations Francois Foucart Abstract The collision of two neutron stars is a rich source of information about nuclear physics. In particular, the kilonova signal following a merger can help us elucidate the role of neutron stars in nucleosynthesis, and informs us about the properties of matter above nuclear saturation. Approximate modeling of neutrinos remains an important limitation to our ability to make predictions for these observables. Part of the problem is the fermionic nature of neutrinos. By the exclusion principle, the expected value f ν f_{\nu} for the number of neutrinos in a quantum state is at most 1. Any process producing neutrinos is suppressed by a blocking factor ( 1 − f ν ) (1-f_{\nu}) . Recent simulations focused on neutrino physics mostly use a gray two-moment scheme to evolve neutrinos. This evolves integrals of f ν f_{\nu} over momentum space, preventing direct calculations of blocking factors. Monte Carlo methods may be an attractive alternative, providing access to the full distribution of neutrinos. Their current implementation is however inadequate to estimate f ν f_{\nu} : in our most recent simulations, a single Monte Carlo packet causes, in the worst cases, estimates of f ν f_{\nu} to jump from f ν = 0 f_{\nu}=0 to f ν ∼ 10 5 f_{\nu}\sim 10^{5} . While this is concerning, this brazen violation of the fermionic nature of neutrinos has been largely inconsequential as the interactions used in simulations avoid direct calculations of f ν f_{\nu} . We are however reaching a level of modeling at which this problem can no longer be ignored. Here, we discuss the relatively simple origin of this issue. We then show that very rough estimates of f ν f_{\nu} can in theory be obtained in merger simulations, but that they will require a combination of unintuitive weighting schemes for Monte Carlo packets and smoothing of the neutrino distribution at coarser resolution than what the merger simulation uses. I Introduction Neutrino-matter interactions play a crucial role in the modeling of the merger and post-merger evolution of neutron star binaries. While not directly important to the dynamics of the merger on short time scales, neutrinos are crucial to understand the thermodynamics of the post-merger evolution and the composition of the matter ejected during and after the collision Sekiguchi 2010 ; Deaton et al. 2013 ; Wanajo et al. 2014 . The latter is particularly important as it greatly impacts the properties of the UV-optical-infrared transient following the merger ( kilonova ), as well as the outcome of nucleosynthesis in the ejecta Wanajo et al. 2014 ; Barnes and Kasen 2013 . Accurate evolution of neutrinos runs into two major issues. One is that neutrinos are trapped inside hot neutron stars, nearly free streaming in low-density matter outflows, and partially coupled in dense accretion disks. Accordingly, they require the evolution in time of Boltzmann’s equation of radiation transport for the distribution function of neutrinos f_{\nu} , the expected occupation number of quantum states in a given region of phase space. The distribution function depends on the position, energy, and direction of propagation of the neutrinos. It is a 6-dimensional function for each species of neutrinos. This high dimensionality makes direct discretization of the problem onto a computational grid very costly without further approximations. The second issue is the complexity of neutrino-matter and neutrino-neutrino interactions. These interactions can act extremely fast in hot regions, creating stiff source terms for Boltzmann’s equation and potential numerical instabilities. They also couple non-linearly the distribution function of neutrinos with different momenta and neutrinos of different species (e.g. through neutrino-antineutrino annihilation). Attempting to capture flavor conversion can increase the complexity of the problem even further, requiring us to go beyond Boltzmann transport and into quantum kinetics (see e.g. Foucart 2023 for a review of neutrinos in neutron star mergers). Recent neutron star merger simulations focused on capturing neutrino-matter interactions have relied on one of two distinct transport methods: either a gray (energy-integrated) two-moment formalism Shibata et al. 2011 ; Wanajo et al. 2014 ; Foucart et al. 2016 ; Radice et al. 2022 , in which we evolve moments of the distribution function (energy density, momentum flux) integrated over neutrino energies, or Monte Carlo methods Foucart et al. 2021 ; Miller et al. 2019 ; Kawaguchi et al. 2025 , in which the distribution function of neutrinos is statistically sampled by ‘packets’ each representing a large number of neutrinos. Moments methods require the use of an approximate analytical closure for higher moments of the neutrino distribution function, which is likely inaccurate in low-density regions. They also suffer from the lack of energy and momentum space information about the distribution function when calculating neutrino-matter interactions. Monte Carlo methods, in theory, capture the full 6-dimensional distribution function of neutrinos. However, they require an approximate treatment of neutrino-matter interactions in regions where neutrinos are strongly coupled to the matter (where moments methods excel), and suffer from significant shot noise and a slow convergence rate to the correct solution. For the limited neutrino physics currently implemented in merger simulations, the two methods appear to agree within \sim(10-20)\% relative errors on the main observables: luminosity, outflow masses and composition, remnant properties. This is likely a smaller source of error than missing physics in the simulations, e.g. flavor conversion Qiu et al. 2025 , interactions with muons Ng et al. 2024 , neutrino-antineutrino pair production and annihilation Fujibayashi et al. 2018 , scattering of neutrinos on electrons Cheong et al. 2024 . How to implement more advanced neutrino physics for each of these two methods is an active area of research. We also note that methods combining Monte Carlo and moments algorithms show some promises Foucart 2018 ; Izquierdo et al. 2024 , but have yet to be applied to full merger simulations. Direct, on-the-fly computation of the distribution function of neutrinos would be extremely valuable for the implementation of more advanced neutrino physics. First, neutrinos are fermions and thus subject to Pauli’s exclusion principle. Their distribution function has to satisfy 0<f_{\nu}<1 (no more than one neutrino per state). When calculating neutrino matter interactions, the production of neutrinos is then suppressed by a blocking factor (1-f_{\nu}) . For some reactions (charged current reactions, elastic scattering), it is possible to rewrite the interaction terms to avoid on-the-fly calculations of f_{\nu} (see e.g. Burrows et al. 2006 ). For others (inelastic scattering, pair processes), no such method is available. This is the main reason pair productions are only very approximately accounted for in merger simulations, while inelastic scattering on electrons is generally ignored. Neutrino flavor conversions are also very sensitive to the angular distribution of neutrinos; the fast flavor instability for example, which may have an important impact on post-merger remnants, occurs when the net angular lepton flux changes signs as we vary the angular direction of the neutrinos Banerjee et al. 2011 ; Wu et al. 2017 . In a gray two-moment scheme, the angular and spectral information is explicitly integrated over, and thus inevitably lost. Models approximating that information from the evolved moments are needed to estimate f_{\nu} . Monte Carlo methods, in theory, offer more hope. We

Read the complete text