Economic Inequality between Groups in an a priori Stratified Society
Thiago Dias, Sebastián Gonçalves · 2025
Read Economic Inequality between Groups in an a priori Stratified Society by Thiago Dias, Sebastián Gonçalves (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-21703.txt.
Introduction
Thiago Dias and Sebastian Goncalves model wealth swaps in a society split into two groups with distinct safety rules, in a paper from 2025. Agents trade in pairs under a fair stake rule, but one group gets extra shield in cross group trades, as a state plan to cut gaps might grant. Each agent is marked by wealth, risk stance, and group.
In runs of the model, the more shielded group ends richer, with a tighter spread of wealth and more churn in rank. The less shielded group lags on all three counts. The authors set the runs next to income by race in Brazil as a real world echo. The work shows how uneven rules alone can breed uneven wealth, even when each trade is fair.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Thiago Dias, Sebastián Gonçalves |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 23 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-21703
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Economic Inequality between Groups in an a priori Stratified Society Thiago Dias, Sebastián Gonçalves Abstract We present an agent-based model of economic exchange in a society composed of two groups, representing two social groups and with different internal protection rules for the poor agents. The goal is to address the emerging wealth distribution when economic rules are not the same for all individuals. Individuals exchange wealth in pairwise interactions with no underlying lattice. The wealth, risk aversion factor, and group of the agents characterize their state. The wealth exchanged between two agents obeys a fair rule: the quantities put at stake by them are the same regardless of who wins. One agent can interact with another agent in the same or the other group, controlled by a rate which is a parameter of the model. Inter-group exchanges obey an exclusive protection rule, which can be understood as a public policy to reduce inequality. We show that the most protected group accumulates more wealth, has less inequality, and has higher mobility than the other group. The results of simulations are compared with income distribution in Brazil discriminated by race as an example of the application our model. 1 Introduction When analyzing the wealth or income of different economies, one can notice similarities. A ubiquitous feature is the division of societies into two classes. A minority wealthy class, described by a Pareto power-law for the income distribution [ 1 , 2 ] , and a majority with incomes distributed in a way that can be fitted by a Gibbs distribution or log-normal functions [ 3 ] . Most of the time, these results are obtained by considering only the income or wealth of individuals. Nevertheless, societies have other forms of distinguishing their individuals. Inequalities among ethnicity, gender, and race are examples of divided societies where people belonging to a particular subgroup have status, power, and wealth [ 4 , 5 , 6 ] . Indeed, in many societies, dominant classes are composed of people associated with one of the groups, and economic inequality might be related to this non-economical classification [ 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] . Brazil is one example of how social stratification by race and gender affects economic inequality. According to the Brazilian Institute of Geography and Statistics (IBGE-2020) [ 11 ] , approximately 43% of the country population are White, and 56% consider themselves Afro-Brazilian (the racial group composed of Black and Brown individuals). The other 1% is formed by Yellow and Indigenous. We want to point out that, due to miscegenation, the race data is from self-declaration. From 2018 to 2020, the average income of Whites remained 50% larger than the average income of Afro-Brazilian. The disparity is even more considerable between White male and Black/Brown female incomes, the difference exceeding 150%. The field of econophysics has already proven to be very valuable with first principles and microscopic models of pairwise wealth exchange capable of reproducing important economic actual data [ 12 , 13 , 14 ] . These models consider ensembles of economic agents that interact, exchanging part of their wealth. Wealt h, in this case, can be understood as money given for some commodity or service [ 15 ] . Although simulations and analytical results using the econophysics approach can reproduce Gibbs distribution and Pareto tails in the so-called “two-class” regime, to our knowledge, no contribution makes a distinction among individuals besides the economic features. We study the economy of a society composed of two social groups, where individuals are characterized by their wealth, saving tendencies, and the group to which they belong. The transactions inter and intra-group obey different rules. In the next section, we describe the model in detail. 2 Kinetic exchange model with two social groups The dynamics of the economies run through agent-based simulations in which agents belong to one of two groups. Differently from work done by Lim and Min [ 16 ] , the groups here are not related to wealth; they represent different races, gender, or castes. We characterize the agents by their wealth w_{i} , risk-aversion factor \beta_{i} , and the group they belong to, labeled A and B . The risk-aversion factor sets the fraction of wealth that an agent puts at stake during a transaction, which is (1-\beta_{i})w_{i} [ 17 ] . At each Monte-Carlo step (MCS), pairs of agents are chosen, so every individual has one exchange on average. Taking agents i and j to make an exchange and assuming the former wins, we have \displaystyle w_{i}(t+1) \displaystyle=w_{i}(t)+\Delta w \displaystyle w_{j}(t+1) \displaystyle=w_{j}(t)-\Delta w, (1) where w_{i(j)}(t+1) represents the wealth of agent i(j) after, and w_{i(j)}(t) before the transaction. Different ways of determining \Delta w can be found in the literature [ 17 , 18 , 19 ] . To mimic actual wealth exchanges, the amount put at stake must be the same by the two individuals, which we guarantee using \Delta w=\min[(1-\beta_{i})w_{i}(t),(1-\beta_{j})w_{j}(t)]. (2) It is important to stress that while this represents theoretically “fair” exchanges, it leads the system to the condensate state [ 20 ] , where one or few agents have everything and the rest nothing. Condensation seems to be the path the global economy follows, since the inequality grows continuously [ 21 ] . Some modifications have been proposed to overcome condensation. Here we study the impact of the social protection that increases the probability of the poorest agent to win the trade, first proposed by Scafetta [ 14 , 18 , 22 ] , which depends on the wealth of the agents i and j prior to the exchange: p=\frac{1}{2}+f\frac{|w_{i}(t)-w_{j}(t)|}{w_{i}(t)+w_{j}(t)}. (3) In equation 3 , f represents a social protection factor which can be a governmental regulation or, as in the present case, different rules regarding trades between agents of the same group as compared with the other group. The protection factor can assume values from 0 to 0.5. The value 0 (no protection) corresponds to equal probabilities (0.5) of winning for both agents, while the value 0.5 (highest protection) always favors the poor agent. The richest agent has the complementary probability 1-p of win. Interactions between agents belonging to the same group have their own social protection factors. For example, when two agents of group A(B) exchange wealth, f_{A(B)} increases the probability of the poorer agent wins. Inter-group trades respect the protection given by the f , for A\rightarrow B and B\rightarrow A transactions. Once f corresponds to a public policy to reduce inequality, in real economies the minimum value of f_{A} and f_{B} must be f . We measure inequality of each group by using the Gini index, proposed by C. Gini in 1912, and calculated by G_{I}(t)=\frac{1}{2W_{I}(t)N_{I}}\sum_{ij}^{N_{I}}|w_{i}(t)-w_{j}(t)|, (4) where I=A,B indicates the group over which the index is calculated and W_{I}=\sum_{i}^{N_{I}}w_{i} the wealth of group I . G for the whole society can be calculated by doing the summations over all agents. The Gini index varies from 0 (perfect equality) to 1, which corresponds to the condensate state, where only one individual possesses all the available wealth [ 23 ] . The liquidity L is the amount of wealth that is being exchanged at each time step normalized by the total group wealth. Given