On the justification of Koiter’s model for elliptic membranes subjected to an interior normal compliance contact condition
Paolo Piersanti · 2025
Read On the justification of Koiter’s model for elliptic membranes subjected to an interior normal compliance contact condition by Paolo Piersanti (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-21637.txt.
Introduction
Paolo Piersanti wrote this paper in two thousand twenty-five as the sole author. It puts Koiter's model for thin elastic shells on firm ground when the shell meets a soft contact rule inside its span.
Such shells are widely used, yet the simple model needs proof that it truly fits the full three-dimensional laws. The first gain here is a new density result for closed convex sets in Lebesgue spaces, covering cases past work missed. With that in hand, the model's use is shown to be sound. The paper also proves the shell's bend gains higher smoothness across the whole domain. A side trick gives a sound trace for the cross-wise part of the shift, whose trace was not even defined before.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Paolo Piersanti |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 119 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-21637
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On the justification of Koiter’s model for elliptic membranes subjected to an interior normal compliance contact condition Paolo Piersanti Abstract . The purpose of this paper is twofold. First, we rigorously justify Koiter’s model for linearly elastic elliptic membrane shells in the case where the shell is subject to a geometrical constraint modelled via a normal compliance contact condition defined in the interior of the shell. To achieve this, we establish a novel density result for non-empty, closed, and convex subsets of Lebesgue spaces, which are applicable to cases not covered by the “density property” established in [Ciarlet, Mardare & Piersanti, Math. Mech. Solids , 2019]. Second, we demonstrate that the solution to the two-dimensional obstacle problem for linearly elastic elliptic membrane shells, subjected to the interior normal compliance contact condition, exhibits higher regularity throughout its entire definition domain. A key feature of this result is that, while the transverse component of the solution is, in general, only of class L 2 L^{2} and its trace is a priori undefined, the methodology proposed here, partially based on [Ciarlet & Sanchez-Palencia, J. Math. Pures Appl. , 1996], enables us to rigorously establish the well-posedness of the trace for the transverse component of the solution by means of an ad hoc formula. Keywords. Obstacle problems ⋅ \cdot Variational Inequalities ⋅ \cdot Elasticity theory ⋅ \cdot Finite Difference Quotients August 24, 2026 1. Introduction In solid mechanics, shells are defined as three-dimensional structures characterised by a thickness that is significantly smaller than their in-plane dimensions. These structures have garnered considerable attention across Engineering, Physics, and Mathematics due to their remarkable ability to sustain external loads far exceeding what their thin geometry might suggest. This mechanical advantage arises from their intrinsic curvature and the specific boundary conditions they experience. Additionally, their efficiency in material usage, requiring minimal material for construction while offering lightweight and cost-effective solutions, makes them ubiquitous in both natural and industrial contexts. Examples in nature include eggshells, snail shells, turtle carapaces, and blood vessels, while engineered applications span ship hulls, aircraft fuselages, arched roofs, eyeglass lenses, and tyres. In this paper, we focus on linearly elastic elliptic membrane shells with thickness 2\varepsilon>0 . Such shells, under appropriate boundary conditions, can sustain applied body forces of order \mathcal{O}(1) relative to \varepsilon (i.e., independent of the thickness parameter). This behaviour aligns with established mechanical principles, as elliptic geometries - owing to their curvature-driven stress distribution - are inherently resistant to deformation and buckling. The first objective of this paper is the justification of Koiter’s model for linearly elastic elliptic membrane shells subjected to an obstacle. All the variational problems here considered take the form of a set of variational inequalities posed over a non-empty, closed and convex subset of a suitable space. The constraint associated with the obstacle is formulated in terms of an interior normal compliance contact condition , whose formulation depends on the nature of the problem considered. The interior normal compliance contact condition here considered for modelling the constraint introduced by the presence of the obstacle has the advantage of being applicable to a larger class of surfaces than those for which the “density property” introduced by Ciarlet, Mardare & Piersanti [ 17 , 18 ] applies, and has the advantage of not suffering from the limitations deriving from appearing as a surface integral as originally considered in [ 28 ] . In order to establish the justification of Koiter’s model for linearly elastic elliptic membrane shells subjected to the interior normal compliance contact condition, we first depart from the natural three-dimensional formulation of the obstacle problem under consideration, and we study the asymptotic behaviour of the solution as the thickness approaches zero, so as to identify a set of two-dimensional variational inequalities characterised by the arising of the mode of deformation that is dominant in the three-dimensional formulation of the obstacle problem. According to the classical theory of shells, cf., e.g., [ 7 ] , which mode of deformation (stretching or bending) is dominant depends on the geometry of the middle surface of the shell, the boundary conditions applied on the lateral face of the shell, as well as on the relation between the magnitude of the applied forces (typically, applied body loads and tractions) and the shell thickness. Second, akin to the classical theory of shells (cf., e.g., [ 7 ] ) and the recent papers [ 15 , 14 ] , we formulate Koiter’s model subjected to the interior normal compliance contact condition and we show that the solution of Koiter’s model converges to the solution of the same two-dimensional model recovered upon completion of the rigorous asymptotic analysis departing for the three-dimensional formulation of the obstacle problem. By so doing, we can assert that Koiter’s model and the original three-dimensional formulation of the obstacle problem asymptotically behave in the same way. The formulation of the interior normal compliance contact condition and the justification of Koiter’s model subjected to one such condition constitute the first main novelty in this paper. The remarkable properties of the asymptotic behaviour of Koiter’s model are the starting point for designing convergent numerical schemes for gaining insight into the average deformation of the original three-dimensional shell. The main advantage of this approach is that the effect of the locking phenomenon is attenuated as the thickness parameter appears, in Koiter’s model, as a multiplicative parameter of the bulk energy terms instead of appearing in the geometry of the definition domain, as it happens for the three-dimensional formulation. The numerical analysis of Koiter’s model subjected to the confinement condition was addressed in the case of linearly elastic elliptic membrane shells in [ 22 , 23 ] by means of the Finite Element Method (cf., e.g., [ 5 ] ). It could be worth investigating, in future works, whether the interior normal compliance contact condition ensures faster convergence. Paramount to establish the convergence of numerical approximations of solutions via the Finite Element Method is the higher regularity of the solutions for the models under consideration. In the last part of the paper we investigate the higher regularity of the solution of the two-dimensional limit model; this constitutes the second main novelty here proposed. The main difficulty we have to deal with for bringing this item to fruition consists in establishing a trace formula for the transverse component of the displacement, as this function is, a priori , only of class L^{2} . We will show, in particular, that the trace formula established by Ciarlet & Sanchez-Palencia [ 16 ] for the transverse component of the displacement of the solution of the two-dimensional limit model holds in the case where the normal compliance contact condition is taken into account [ 24 ] . In relation to this, we recall that one such conclusion could not be inferred, in general, for the confinement condition considered in [ 14 , 15 , 17 , 18 , 24 ] , as the geometry of the constraint prevents us from applying the techniques in [ 16 ] . Apart from the recent work [ 24 ] which was developed in a vectorial framework, for the augmentation of regularity of the solutions of variational inequalities, we recall the main contribution by