Coping with Uncertainty in UX Design Practice: Practitioner Strategies and Judgment Conference: Creativity and Cognition; June 23–25, 2025; Virtual, United Kingdom Creativity and Cognition (C&C ’25), June 23–25, 2025, Virtual, United Kingdom DOI: 10.1145/3698061.3726913 ISBN: 979-8-4007-1289-0/2025/
Prakash Chandra Shukla, Phuong Bui, Paul Parsons · 2025
Read Coping with Uncertainty in UX Design Practice: Practitioner Strategies and Judgment Conference: Creativity and Cognition; June 23–25, 2025; Virtual, United Kingdom Creativity and Cognition (C&C ’25), June 23–25, 2025, Virtual, United Kingdom DOI: 10.1145/3698061.3726913 ISBN: 979-8-4007-1289-0/2025/ by Prakash Chandra Shukla, Phuong Bui, Paul Parsons (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-21397.txt.
Introduction
Prakash Shukla, Phuong Bui, and Paul Parsons examine how user experience designers cope with uncertainty on real projects. Their work goes beyond the open-endedness of design problems themselves. Priorities shift, teams churn, resources run thin, and build constraints bite, all while the design is in motion. The team ran a multi-week diary study with ten designers and followed up with interviews.
Designers answered uncertainty with a kit of strategies, including reframing the problem as facts changed and negotiating with stakeholders. Judgment sat at the center of the responses. The authors name two less-studied forms of it: temporal judgment, about when to decide, and sacrificial judgment, about what to give up. They argue uncertainty in this field is not a passing glitch but a constant feature of the work. Their findings extend earlier accounts of design practice into the daily reality of UX teams.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Prakash Chandra Shukla, Phuong Bui, Paul Parsons |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 56 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-21397
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Coping with Uncertainty in UX Design Practice: Practitioner Strategies and Judgment Conference: Creativity and Cognition; June 23–25, 2025; Virtual, United Kingdom Creativity and Cognition (C&C ’25), June 23–25, 2025, Virtual, United Kingdom DOI: 10.1145/3698061.3726913 ISBN: 979-8-4007-1289-0/2025/06 CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI CCS: Human-centered computing HCI theory, concepts and models Prakash Chandra Shukla, Phuong Bui, Paul Parsons Abstract . The complexity of UX design practice extends beyond ill-structured design problems to include uncertainties shaped by shifting stakeholder priorities, team dynamics, limited resources, and implementation constraints. While prior research in related fields has addressed uncertainty in design more broadly, the specific character of uncertainty in UX practice remains underexplored. This study examines how UX practitioners experience and respond to uncertainty in real-world projects, drawing on a multi-week diary study and follow-up interviews with ten designers. We identify a range of practitioner strategies—including adaptive framing, negotiation, and judgment—that allow designers to move forward amid ambiguity. Our findings highlight the central role of design judgment in navigating uncertainty, including emergent forms such as temporal and sacrificial judgment, and extend prior understandings by showing how UX practitioners engage uncertainty as a persistent, situated feature of practice. † † cc-license: by 1. Introduction Uncertainty is common across many professional fields, shaping the complex and dynamic environments in which practitioners operate ( Griffin and Grote 2020 ) . In design, it is both a persistent challenge and a potential catalyst for innovation. Daalhuizen et al. ( Daalhuizen et al. 2009 ) argue that contemporary design research must better equip practitioners to navigate uncertainty in practice. Scholars from diverse disciplines, including management research ( Sniazhko 2019 ; Frishammar et al. 2011 ) , policy-making ( Walker and Marchau 2003 ) , medicine ( O’Riordan and Dahinden 2011 ) , engineering ( Pelz et al. 2021 ) , industrial practice ( Rocquigny et al. 2008 ) , and decision sciences ( Ove Hansson 1996 ) , have explored how uncertainty influences professional practice. Yet, despite its centrality, design lacks a standardized approach to managing uncertainty or fostering innovation. Stolterman ( Stolterman 2021 ) highlights the inherent challenges of attempting to control design processes, urging researchers to address this complexity more directly. This positions the study of uncertainty as foundational to advancing design research and practice. Design research has long grappled with the uncertainties inherent in defining and addressing design problems. A central concern has been the indeterminate nature of design situations and the challenges they pose for practitioners ( Simon 1973 ; Rittel and Webber 1973 ; Suchman 1987 ; Buchanan 1992 ; Dorst and Cross 2001 ; Stolterman 2008 ) . Simon ( Simon 1973 ) described design problems as ‘ill-structured’ , requiring ‘satisficing’ rather than optimizing. Schön ( Schön 1983 ) instead argued that design problems are not definable from the outset, underscoring the designer’s role in framing the problem and managing the inherent complexity. Rittel and Webber ( Rittel and Webber 1973 ) characterized design problems as ‘wicked’ due to their complexity and resistance to straightforward solutions. Building on this, Dorst ( Dorst 2003 ) suggested that understanding design behavior in practice requires acknowledging the situated nature of design problems, and further emphasized ( Dorst 2004 ) the importance of viewing these problems through the eyes of the designer. From this perspective, problem and solution spaces often co-evolve ( Dorst and Cross 2001 ) , meaning that uncertainty is not an anomaly but a defining condition of design practice. While uncertainty is intrinsic to design problems ( Rittel 1967 ) , the realities of contemporary design practice introduce additional and often compounding forms of uncertainty. UX practitioners commonly juggle multiple projects; coordinate with various stakeholders; advocate their own value within organizations; and work with new and changing tools, all in resource-constrained environments ( Stolterman 2008 ; Tracey and Hutchinson 2016 ; Jones and Thoma 2019 ; Crescenzi et al. 2016 ) . These practical demands generate new pressures not fully captured by traditional theories of design cognition and practice. For instance, Goodman et al. ( Goodman et al. 2011 ) describe how practitioners face uncertainty in managing and appeasing clients. Norouzi et al. ( Norouzi et al. 2015 ) discuss communication challenges and the resulting uncertainty in client-architect relationships. Fedosov et al. ( Fedosov et al. 2021 ) articulate the challenges in transferring UX designs across products due to coordination difficulties among diverse teams with conflicting goals. This work points to the entangled, collaborative, and often unstable contexts in which UX work is embedded—contexts that shape how uncertainty is produced, perceived, and negotiated in practice. While researchers have examined some factors that contribute to uncertainty faced by practitioners across design fields, there remains a lack of inquiry into how uncertainty manifests in UX practice specifically. This gap is increasingly consequential given recent shifts in UX design practice, including evolving roles, expanded responsibilities, and the changing nature of what constitutes UX knowledge ( Branch et al. 2021 ; Kou and Gray 2019 ; MacDonald et al. 2022 ) . Researchers in fields such as product design ( de Weck et al. 2007 ) , project management ( Saunders et al. 2015 ) and decision sciences ( Lipshitz and Strauss 1997 ) have developed typologies and structured frameworks to account for uncertainty. These efforts have helped clarify the conditions under which uncertainty arises and how it can be productively managed. Yet in UX, no equivalent conceptual scaffolding exists, despite the profession’s growing complexity and increasing entanglement with legal, organizational, and technological constraints. As UX continues to evolve, there is a pressing need to understand not just that uncertainty exists, but how practitioners perceive, interpret, and respond to it in practice. In this research, we investigated how UX designers experience and respond to uncertainty in their everyday practice. We employed a four-week-long diary study with 10 UX professionals, followed by semi-structured interviews that explored the contextual dynamics, decision points, and perceived stakes surrounding moments of uncertainty. Our aim is not only to document the types of uncertainty that arise, but to understand how practitioners interpret and work through these conditions in situ. This study is guided by the following research questions: • What uncertainties do UX designers encounter in their everyday practice? • What strategies do UX practitioners employ to handle uncertain situations? We contribute a practice-grounded account of how uncertainty is encountered and managed. We extend prior design research by characterizing the forms of judgment, framing, and negotiation that practitioners rely on—not simply as responses to disruption, but as constitutive elements of design work under real-world conditions. 2. Background 2.1. Design as Situated Practice under Uncertainty At its core, design represents a practice of ‘intentional change’ ( Nelson and Stolterman 2012 ) , where practitioners aim to create new realities that do not yet exist. Unlike traditional scientific methods, design processes are emergent and contingent, unfolding in response to evolving constraints, goals, and interpretations ( Stolterman 2008 ; Schön 1984 ; Cross et al. 1981 ) . Designers often operate in what Schön termed “messy situations” ( Schön 1983 ) , which are typically complex and under-determined with potentially infinite sources of information, constraints, and possibilities ( Rittel and Webber 1973 ; Buchanan 1992 ) .