How one can assess the chaos?

Marat Akhmet ∗,a · 2025

Read How one can assess the chaos? by Marat Akhmet ∗,a (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-21352.txt.

Introduction

Chaos is easy to spot and hard to grade. Marat Akhmet proposes an uncertainty principle for chaos built on two of its hallmarks: alpha unpredictability and Lorenz sensitivity. The principle sets a limit on how two infinite sequences behind those concepts can relate. It applies to both deterministic and stochastic dynamics, which the author frames as a step toward unifying the two fields.

Early progress came through work on Markov chains with alpha labeling. Akhmet also suggests how the principle could grade the degree of chaos in a given process. He closes by listing open questions about how the many types of chaos connect, including a modification of the recurrence theorem.

Catalog record

CREATORMarat Akhmet ∗,a
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE16 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-21352

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

How one can assess the chaos? Marat Akhmet ∗,a Abstract We propose an uncertainty principle for chaos, focusing on two key characteristics: alpha unpredictability and Lorenz sensitivity. This principle outlines a limitation on the relationship between two infinite sequences that underpin these concepts. It is applicable to both deterministic and stochastic dynamics, marking a significant step toward integrating these two fields. Our initial progress in this area was achieved through research on Markov chains utilizing alpha labeling. Additionally, we offer suggestions on how this principle can assess the degree of chaos in specific processes. We also outline open questions regarding the relationships among various types of chaos, including a modification of the recurrence theorem. 1 Chaos and the principle as a unity of opposites Heraclitus was the first to articulate the law of the unity of opposites. Opposites exist within our minds and serve as tools for analysis. This law is connected to N. Bohr’s principle of complementarity and W. Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle. Consequently, it is useful to view opposites as related to chaos. The most common manifestation of this unity is found in the concepts of divergence and convergence. In various types of chaos, these concepts are evident in Lorenz sensitivity [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] . Ultra Poincaré chaos represents a new phenomenon in complexity [ 5 , 6 , 7 ] , characterized by alpha unpredictability and Poisson stability, which pertain to convergence and divergence respectively. Any form of uncertainty is a result of opposition. Drawing on ideas from conventionalism [ 8 ] , one could argue that opposites arise from the observation of uncertainty. Therefore, it is important to recognize that position and momentum are opposites, as described by Heisenberg’s law. It is not surprising that the uncertainty principle related to chaos, which is suggested for discussion, is grounded in these obvious opposites of convergence and divergence. In our research on chaos, we have identified uncertainty in dynamical chaos by employing the following inequalities: h_{\alpha}\leq s_{n}d(p_{n},p)\leq h_{\beta}, (1.1) where h_{\alpha} and h_{\beta} are positive numbers, s_{n} represents the time sequence of divergence, p_{n} denotes the converging space sequence, and d is a metric. This formula has been presented in the book [ 5 ] . We believe that these inequalities will provide insights into chaos that are akin to those found in quantum mechanics. Related topics concerning alpha unpredictability, ultra Poincaré and Lorenz chaos, artificial neural networks [ 9 ] , differential equations, deterministic and stochastic dynamical systems [ 5 ] , and synchronization [ 5 ] can be explored through this proposal. The concept of the alpha unpredictable point serves as the foundation for ultra Poincaré chaos [ 5 ] . A point p in a dynamic system is considered alpha unpredictable if there exists a positive number e and sequences t_{n} and s_{n} that both increase toward infinity. In this context, let p_{n}=f(t_{n},p) converge to p , while the points f(s_{n},p_{n}) maintain a distance greater than e from f(s_{n},p) for all n . The uncertainty inherent in alpha unpredictability arises from the inability to determine the infinite sequence of pairs (s_{n},p_{n}) for n=1,2,\ldots Consequently, chaos cannot be complitely observed in experiments and simulations. As we observe closer approximation points f(t_{n},p) , the moments of divergence s_{n} become larger. Conversely, as we fine-tune a large moment s_{n} , identifying the corresponding p_{n} becomes increasingly challenging. A more precisely determined s_{n} results in less accuracy for p_{n} . Therefore, we grapple with this uncertainty, and the sequences of points p_{n} and moments s_{n} are just as theoretical as position and momentum of Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle. Thus, we use the term "uncertainty" to imply that chaos, under our conditions, can only be established if complete information about the sequences t_{n},s_{n}, and p_{n} is collected. More specifically, we view (s_{n},p_{n}),n=1,2,\ldots as a chaotic pair. This discussion relates to alpha unpredictability in the context of ultra Poincaré chaos and the sensitivity characteristic of Lorenz chaos. Hence, we are addressing the principle of uncertainty of chaos as a phenomenon. In the following sections, we will elaborate on why this principle applies to all types of chaos. If we accept that we are dealing with the uncertainty of chaos concerning the sequences, it can be recognized that the inequalities in ( 1.1 ) establish a principle of uncertainty since they provide limits (estimates) for the phenomenon, which is encompassed within numerical laws. Algorithms to calculate these sequences have already been developed in [ 5 , 9 , 10 ] . The sensitivity is a source of uncertainty in Lorenz chaos, which is the main ingredient of the sophisticated dynamics. A motion f(q,t) is sensitive at a point p provided that there exists a positive number e , sequences of points p_{n} and moments s_{n},n=1,2,\ldots, such that p_{n}\to\textit{p}, and distance between f(p,s_{n}) and f(p_{n},s_{n}) is larger than e for all n. We have to look for points p_{n} arbitrarily close to point p to learn sensitivity, but this makes less observable moments where the divergence happens. Moreover, if one tries to determine large moments of the divergence, then precision for the location of corresponding points p_{n} decreases, and vice versa. Finally, the infinite couples (s_{n},p_{n}),n=1,2,\ldots can not be indicated ever. Thus, the principle of the uncertainty for chaos is based on Lorenz’s sensitivity. The separation number e can be an uncertainty constant for ultra Poincaré and Lorenz chaos since the smallness of error for the initial point does not affect the separation size. The discussions above suggest that deterministic chaos, similar to quantum mechanics, is related to the deep nature of reality. Furthermore, we believe that, based on the principle of chaos, one can identify analogs of wave functions and the Schrödinger equation for deterministic phenomena. We are confident that there are additional relationships between spatial and temporal sequences that should be acknowledged within the paradigm of uncertainty. What is the philosophical conclusion of our findings? The greater the uncertainties in dynamics, the more valuable they become. Uncertainty is a key factor that indicates a theoretical phenomenon is worth investigating, as it embodies the unity of opposites. Therefore, discovering the uncertainty inherent in chaos is a significant achievement. 2 More arguments for the principle Based on our findings, we assert that ultra Poincaré chaos represents the most advanced form of irregular dynamics in the field of science. While other types of chaos rely on dense closed orbits as a foundational framework, we focus on unclosed Poisson stable orbits, each of which is dense within the chaotic region. This implies that the alternatives to ultra Poincaré chaos do not depend on the principle to the same extent that alpha unpredictability does. This could potentially explain the uncertainty observed in our studies. Next, we will address the necessity of the positive constants, h_{\alpha} and h_{\beta} . One might inquire whether chaos can exist without these constraints. Below, we present two arguments to address this question. (a) Assume that a constant h_{\beta} for chaotic dynamics cannot be identified as a finite number. In this case, there is a possibility that a pair (s_{n},p_{n}) , for n=1,2,\ldots , satisfies s_{n}\to\infty , while the distance d(p_{n},p) remains bounded away from zero. This scenario

Read the complete text