Reevaluating UMa3/U1: star cluster or the smallest known galaxy?

Scot Devlin, Holger Baumgardt, Sarah M. Sweet · 2025

Read Reevaluating UMa3/U1: star cluster or the smallest known galaxy? by Scot Devlin, Holger Baumgardt, Sarah M. Sweet (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-21301.txt.

Introduction

Scot Devlin, Holger Baumgardt, and Sarah Sweet wrote this 2025 paper asking whether the faintest known companion of the Milky Way is a star cluster or a tiny galaxy. The object is very small, with a span of only a few light years across its bright core. Past work called it a galaxy, based on how fast its stars move.

The team modeled the object as a plain star cluster, with no dark matter, using detailed simulations. Their models let stars age, lose mass, and feel the pull of the Milky Way. The cluster could last about 2.7 billion years more, they find, because heavy dead stars sink and stay while light stars drift away.

Catalog record

CREATORScot Devlin, Holger Baumgardt, Sarah M. Sweet
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE70 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-21301

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Reevaluating UMa3/U1: star cluster or the smallest known galaxy? Scot Devlin, Holger Baumgardt, Sarah M. Sweet Abstract Ursa Major III/UNIONS 1 (UMa3/U1) is the faintest Milky Way satellite discovered to date, exhibiting a half-light radius of 3 ± 1 ​ pc 3\pm 1\,\text{pc} and an absolute V-band magnitude of + 2.2 ± 0.4 +2.2\pm 0.4 . Previous studies suggest UMa3/U1 is a dwarf galaxy, based on its large internal velocity dispersion and the improbability—indicated by dynamical cluster simulations—of its long-term survival if it were a dark-matter-free star cluster. In this paper, we model the evolution of UMa3/U1 as a star cluster using collisional N-body simulations that include a description of stellar evolution and the external tidal field of the Milky Way, with some simulations including primordial binaries. We find that UMa3/U1 has a substantial remaining lifetime of 2.7 ± 0.4 ​ Gyr 2.7\pm 0.4\,\text{Gyr} , primarily due to the retention of compact stellar remnants within the cluster. This retention is facilitated by mass segregation and the preferential loss of low-mass stars. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the observed large velocity dispersion of UMa3/U1 can be successfully reproduced. These results support the possibility that UMa3/U1 is a self-gravitating star cluster. Our simulations reveal that modelling UMa3/U1 as a dark matter–free star cluster produces a markedly altered present-day mass function, driven by a strong depletion of low-mass stars. However, the degree of mass segregation among the visible stars is not statistically significant. We therefore recommend that future observations of UMa3/U1 and other very small Milky Way satellites focus on measuring their present-day mass functions to determine their nature. 2026 Reevaluating UMa3/U1: star cluster or the smallest known galaxy? – References 1 Introduction Dwarf galaxies and star clusters are of significant cosmological interest as they are among the most numerous and smallest bound stellar systems in the Universe, providing key insights into galaxy formation and evolution. While they share similarities in size and stellar populations, they differ significantly in their dark matter content. Star clusters are largely devoid of dark matter and exhibit low mass-to-light ratios ( 1.4<M/L_{V}<2.5 ) ( Baumgardt et al., 2020 ) . Globular clusters, a type of star cluster typically found in the halos of galaxies, are believed to be ancient systems that have not undergone substantial chemical enrichment, making them valuable probes of the interstellar medium at the time of their formation ( Krumholz et al., 2019 ) . These dense stellar systems can have central densities exceeding 10^{5}\,\mathrm{stars\,pc^{-3}} , making them among the densest known stellar environments in the Universe ( Harris, 1996 ) . In contrast, open clusters, which are younger and typically less massive systems located in the disks of galaxies, have much lower stellar densities, often ranging from 1\,\mathrm{star\,pc^{-3}} to 100\,\mathrm{stars\,pc^{-3}} , and serve as tracers of recent star formation and the ongoing chemical evolution of their host galaxies ( Lada & Lada, 2003 ) . More recently, low-density star clusters, resembling open clusters, have been discovered in the halo of the Milky Way ( Balbinot et al., 2013 ; Kim et al., 2015 ; Price-Whelan et al., 2019 ) . Dwarf galaxies are dark matter dominated; their dynamical masses far exceed their baryonic masses, as demonstrated by their exceptionally high mass-to-light ratios, typically around M/L\sim 10^{3}\left(\frac{M_{\odot}}{L_{\odot}}\right) ( Simon, 2019 ) . Dwarf galaxies are excellent small-scale dark matter probes because they contain just enough visible matter to trace the distribution of invisible dark matter, without having so much visible matter that it significantly contributes to the total galaxy mass. The ability to trace the dark-matter distribution without significant baryonic mass contribution is especially true for the smallest dwarf galaxies, known as ultra-faint dwarf galaxies (UFDs). UFDs provide crucial information on the minimum dark-matter halo mass required for galaxy formation ( Bode et al., 2001 ) . Moreover, the absolute number of UFDs places constraints on star formation theories ( Munshi et al., 2019 ) and on the mass of the dark matter particle ( Simon, 2019 ) . In addition, the position of UFDs within the Milky Way halo helps to constrain the “Satellite Plane Problem” ( Kroupa et al., 2005 ; Pawlowski et al., 2012 ; Pawlowski et al., 2013 ) . Because UFDs are less influenced by baryonic processes than larger galaxies, their density profiles offer robust tests of the cusp-core problem, thereby probing the validity of various cosmological models ( Sánchez Almeida et al., 2024 ) . Distinguishing between star clusters and UFDs is an important task, especially given the rapid increase in the discovery rate of faint Milky Way satellites since the early 2000s, driven by wide-field photometric surveys ( Simon, 2019 ) . For stellar systems in the Milky Way halo brighter than M_{V}\approx-5 , a clear size difference generally exists between star clusters and dwarf galaxies. Bright star clusters have half-light radii r_{h}<20\,\mathrm{pc} , while dwarf galaxies typically have r_{h}>100\,\mathrm{pc} ( Simon, 2019 ) . For slightly fainter stellar systems, the magnitude-size plane can still be useful, as star clusters are known to be more compact than dwarf galaxies, which allows for a rough classification of stellar systems based on their surface or 3D density; see figure 2 of Simon (2019) , figure 6 of Baumgardt et al. (2022) , and figure 9 of Smith et al. (2024) . However, it has become increasingly challenging to distinguish between star clusters and dwarf galaxies at the fainter end of the distribution based solely on their radii and luminosities, prompting the need for additional classification criteria. In addition to having a dynamical mass that far exceeds their baryonic mass, UFDs are distinguished from star clusters by exhibiting a non-zero spread in metallicities ( Willman et al., 2011 ) . The metallicity spread seen in UFDs arises because the dark matter halo creates a deeper gravitational potential well, which raises the escape velocity for gas in these systems. The higher escape velocity allows UFDs to more effectively retain chemically enriched gas (e.g., supernova ejecta) released during stellar explosions. Enhanced gas retention, in turn, supports extended star formation periods and sustained chemical self-enrichment. The recently identified Ursa Major III/UNIONS 1 system (UMa3/U1 or U1 if referring to the system as a star cluster and UMa3 if referring to the satellite as an ultra-faint dwarf galaxy), discovered through the deep, wide-field Ultraviolet Near Infrared Optical Northern Survey (UNIONS), is the least luminous known satellite of the Milky Way. It has an absolute V-band magnitude of M_{V}=2.2^{+0.3}_{-0.4} and is located at a heliocentric distance of 10\pm 1 kpc ( Smith et al., 2024 ) . It is 1.5 magnitudes fainter than the next faintest Milky Way satellites discovered so far, the ultrafaint dwarfs Kim 3 ( M_{V}=+0.7 mag; Kim et al. 2016 ) and DELVE 5 ( M_{V}=+0.4 mag; Cerny et al. 2023 ). The small size of UMa3/U1, with a half-light radius of r_{h}=3\pm 1\ \text{pc} , is well within the size range of known star clusters and is an order of magnitude smaller than the smallest confirmed ultra-faint dwarf galaxy, Willman 1, which has a half-light radius of approximately, r_{h}\approx 20\ \text{pc} ( Willman et al., 2011 ) . However, Smith et al. (2024) argue that the high line of sight velocity

Read the complete text