Democratizing Differential Privacy: A Participatory AI Framework for Public Decision-Making Conference: Emerging Practices in Participatory AI Design in Public Sector Innovation; April 27, 2025; Yokohama, Japan

Wenjun Yang, Eyhab Al-Masri · 2025

Read Democratizing Differential Privacy: A Participatory AI Framework for Public Decision-Making Conference: Emerging Practices in Participatory AI Design in Public Sector Innovation; April 27, 2025; Yokohama, Japan by Wenjun Yang, Eyhab Al-Masri (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-21297.txt.

Introduction

Wenjun Yang and Eyhab Al-Masri build a conversational system that lets citizens help design privacy-preserving AI for public decisions in a 2025 paper. Differential privacy gives hard math guarantees, yet its settings are usually chosen by experts alone.

Three parts anchor the framework. An adaptive protocol picks the privacy budget by weighing citizen preferences through multi-criteria decision analysis. An explanation layer shows live error charts and AI-written impact notes as noise is injected, so trade-offs stay visible. A compliance module adjusts budgets as regulations evolve. The authors argue this mix keeps public-sector privacy tools both mathematically sound and democratically accountable, turning an abstract parameter into a public choice.

Catalog record

CREATORWenjun Yang, Eyhab Al-Masri
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE13 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-21297

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Democratizing Differential Privacy: A Participatory AI Framework for Public Decision-Making Conference: Emerging Practices in Participatory AI Design in Public Sector Innovation; April 27, 2025; Yokohama, Japan Wenjun Yang, Eyhab Al-Masri Abstract . This paper introduces a conversational interface system that enables participatory design of differentially private AI systems in public sector applications. Addressing the challenge of balancing mathematical privacy guarantees with democratic accountability, we propose three key contributions: (1) an adaptive ϵ \epsilon -selection protocol leveraging TOPSIS multi-criteria decision analysis to align citizen preferences with differential privacy (DP) parameters, (2) an explainable noise-injection framework featuring real-time Mean Absolute Error (MAE) visualizations and GPT-4-powered impact analysis, and (3) an integrated legal-compliance mechanism that dynamically modulates privacy budgets based on evolving regulatory constraints. Our results advance participatory AI practices by demonstrating how conversational interfaces can enhance public engagement in algorithmic privacy mechanisms, ensuring that privacy-preserving AI in public sector governance remains both mathematically robust and democratically accountable. Reference Format Wenjun Yang and Eyhab Al-Masri. 2025. Democratizing Differential Privacy: A Participatory AI Framework for Public Decision-Making. Presented at CHI 2025 Workshop WS40: Emerging Practices in Participatory AI Design in Public Sector Innovation (non-archival workshop), Yokohama, Japan. 1. Introduction Public sector organizations face a critical challenge in adopting AI systems that balance statistical utility with provable privacy guarantees. As governments deploy AI-driven decision-making tools for public services, urban planning, and resource allocation, ensuring privacy protection while maintaining public trust and transparency is paramount ( Gritzalis et al. 2017 ) . Differential Privacy (DP) provides a mathematically rigorous framework for privacy-preserving analytics ( Dwork 2006 ) , preventing individual identification through controlled noise injection. However, its adoption in public sector applications is hindered by complex trade-offs involving: • \epsilon -Selection : Balancing privacy protection with data utility. • Data Sensitivity : Adjusting noise for different types of public data (e.g., census, health, mobility). • Public Accountability : Ensuring privacy decisions reflect democratic values and remain transparent. Existing approaches fail to democratize privacy decisions in public AI systems. Traditional methods either rely on expert-defined DP settings ( Zhang and Zhou 2020 ) or oversimplify privacy controls through binary opt-in/out interfaces ( Lau and Zimmerman 2018 ) , excluding meaningful public participation and eroding trust. To address these challenges, we propose a participatory AI approach that integrates civic engagement into DP decision-making via a conversational interface. This system enables stakeholders, including policymakers and the public, to explore and influence privacy configurations in real time, shifting privacy decisions from top-down expert control to democratic deliberation. Our system introduces three key innovations: (1) an adaptive \epsilon -selection mechanism leveraging TOPSIS-based multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA) ( Hwang and Yoon 1981 ) to align privacy settings with public priorities; (2) explainable noise injection with real-time Mean Absolute Error (MAE) visualizations and GPT-4-powered impact analysis to enhance transparency and trust; and (3) dynamic legal-compliance constraints that adjust privacy budgets to evolving regulations. By embedding participatory mechanisms into DP decision-making, our work operationalizes democratic values in privacy governance. This contributes to broader efforts to develop accountable, community-driven AI in public sector innovation, bridging the gap between technical privacy guarantees and citizen participation. 2. Related Work Recent research in human-computer interaction (HCI) and AI governance has emphasized co-design approaches in public sector AI, advocating for participatory frameworks that enhance citizen engagement ( Muller and Heidl 2021 ) . However, technical privacy mechanisms—particularly Differential Privacy (DP)—remain largely opaque to non-expert stakeholders. The mathematical complexity of DP and the lack of intuitive interfaces create a disconnect between privacy-preserving AI techniques and democratic governance. Zhang et al. ( Zhang and Zhou 2020 ) identify three key barriers to DP adoption in civic contexts: (1) mathematical complexity , which makes it difficult for policymakers and citizens to understand privacy protections; (2) opaque trade-offs , where the impact of privacy budgets ( \epsilon ) on data utility is unclear; and (3) lack of stakeholder input channels , preventing meaningful civic participation in privacy configurations. These barriers often result in top-down, expert-driven privacy decisions that exclude affected communities. To improve transparency, prior work has explored explainable privacy techniques that clarify DP mechanisms ( Lau and Zimmerman 2018 ) . However, most approaches rely on static visualizations rather than interactive tools that enable stakeholders to actively engage in privacy decisions. Chatbots in government services typically support informational queries ( Clarke and Park 2021 ) but rarely facilitate algorithmic co-design. Our system advances civic interaction paradigms by implementing a stateful dialogue manager that (1) tracks privacy budget allocations, (2) maintains versioned dataset states, and (3) enables collaborative \epsilon -tuning through natural language and visual sliders. This hybrid interface addresses gaps in participatory AI toolkits ( Muller and Heidl 2021 ) by integrating symbolic parameter controls with neural language explanations, enhancing transparency and stakeholder engagement. We propose a participatory DP framework that enhances democratic engagement via a conversational interface. Using a TOPSIS-based MCDA model for \epsilon -selection, it improves privacy trade-off interpretability through (a) constrained parameter spaces , (b) visual decision matrices , and (c) interactive weight sliders , embedding transparency and accountability in public sector AI. 3. System Design Our participatory DP system integrates web-based interaction with algorithmic privacy controls (Fig. 1 ). The Flask backend consists of three core components: • Preference Elicitation : Users specify priorities via sliders for privacy (1-5), accuracy (1-5), legal compliance (yes/no), and data sensitivity (1-3). • Adaptive \epsilon Selection : Implements TOPSIS multi-criteria decision analysis ( Hwang and Yoon 1981 ) to resolve trade-offs: (1) \epsilon^{*}=\underset{\epsilon\in\{0.1,0.5,1.0,1.5,2.0\}}{\arg\max}\frac{D^{-}}{D^{+}+D^{-}} where D^{+} / D^{-} denote distances to ideal/anti-ideal solutions. • Conversational Analysis : Uses GPT-4 to generate natural language explanations of DP impacts. Figure 1. System architecture showing the participatory DP workflow The participatory configuration framework for differential privacy (Algorithm 1 ) enables users to balance privacy-utility trade-offs through an interactive process. By translating user priorities for privacy, accuracy, and regulatory compliance into normalized mathematical weights, the system automates the selection of an optimal privacy budget \epsilon using multi-criteria decision analysis. Algorithm 1 Participatory DP Configuration 1. User uploads dataset and sets privacy, accuracy, and compliance priorities. 2. Normalize slider inputs to compute weights w_{i} . 3. Construct decision matrix for \epsilon alternatives. 4. Compute TOPSIS scores and select optimal \epsilon^{*} . 5. Apply Laplace noise \mathcal{N}\sim\text{Lap}(\Delta f/\epsilon^{*}) . 6. Generate MAE visualization and GPT-4 impact analysis. 7. Present interactive report with refinement suggestions. 4. Evaluation 4.1. Experimental Validation of Participatory DP We evaluated our framework using computational simulations on the Household Electricity Demand (HED) dataset ( Muratori 2017 ) , which provides power consumption profiles for 200 randomly selected households from the 2009 Midwest RECS dataset. The dataset captures realistic residential electricity usage patterns, validated against metered data. Each profile records power consumption (in watts) at a 10-minute resolution, accounting for household size and occupancy variations. Table 1. Impact of User Preferences on DP Outcomes Metric Privacy-First Balanced Utility-First Selected \epsilon 0.1 1.0 2.0 MAE (kWh) 83.2 9.6 3.3 Privacy Score * 4.8 3.2 2.1 * GPT-4 generated privacy ratings on a 1-5 scale. Our results confirm the expected trade-off between privacy and accuracy. The strong negative correlation between \epsilon and MAE ( r=-0.96 , p<0.01 ) aligns with DP principles, demonstrating that privacy-first configurations introduce 3.6 \times

Read the complete text