Activation entropy helps explain anomalous flow stress temperature dependence in copper
Mohammadhossein Nahavandian, Liam Myhill, Enrique Martinez · 2025
Read Activation entropy helps explain anomalous flow stress temperature dependence in copper by Mohammadhossein Nahavandian, Liam Myhill, Enrique Martinez (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-21246.txt.
Introduction
Mohammadhossein Nahavandian, Liam Myhill, and Enrique Martinez wrote this physics paper, published in 2025. It helps explain a long-standing oddity in copper: within a certain temperature range, the metal gets harder to deform as it warms, the opposite of normal behavior.
Deformation in metals proceeds by line defects, called dislocations, hopping over energy barriers with heat's help. The team simulated pairs of dislocations escaping each other's pull, varying temperature, friction, and stress. Their dynamic rates matched a classic escape-rate theory and grew as friction weakened. A separate static calculation traced entropy, the disorder term, along the escape path. It showed strong entropy effects that raise the stress needed as temperature climbs. The authors say this entropy term can account for the strange hardening seen in copper and similar metals.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mohammadhossein Nahavandian, Liam Myhill, Enrique Martinez |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 45 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-21246
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Activation entropy helps explain anomalous flow stress temperature dependence in copper Mohammadhossein Nahavandian, Liam Myhill, Enrique Martinez Abstract Thermal activation of dislocations is critical for predicting the mechanical response of materials under common experimental conditions. According to transition state theory (TST), the rate for the system to overcome free energy barriers depends on an attempt frequency, activation free energy, and temperature. We computed the rate for edge and screw dislocation dipoles to overcome their interaction fields at various temperatures, Langevin friction coefficients, and shear stresses using Molecular Dynamics (MD), Schoeck’s entropy formalism and compared with Kramers rate theory [ 1 ] . Kramers theory matches the rates computed dynamically, which depend on Langevin friction, increasing with weaker friction. Statically, using Schoeck’s formalism to compute the entropy along the minimum energy path (MEP), we found significant entropic effects that lead to an increase of the critical resolved shear stress ( τ C R S S \tau_{CRSS} ) with temperature and could help explain the long-standing anomaly observed at low to intermediate temperatures in copper and other metals, where the flow stress increases with temperature. Journal: …. † † highlights: Activation entropy helps explain anomalous flow stress temperature dependence in copper Langevin friction affects the rate but does not change the energy barrier Intermediate domain close to the \tau_{CRSS} at 0 K is dominated by entropy Kramers’ transition state theory reproduces atomistic rates dependence on Langevin friction 1 Introduction Dislocations [ 2 , 3 ] are the primary carriers of permanent deformation in metals and alloys. To glide and accommodate deformation, dislocations need to overcome long and short-range interactions with other dislocations and obstacles of diverse nature [ 4 ] . The role of dislocation lines on the permanent deformation process of metallic materials as a function of temperature and stress has been vastly studied. However, the influence of friction and thermal fluctuations on the rate at which dislocations overcome energy barriers is not fully understood. Moreover, many experimental studies have seen an abnormal flow stress increase with temperature in face-centered cubic (FCC) metals like Cu, Al, Ni, and Ag [ 5 ] , which has not been fully explained. In the work by Turnage et al. [ 6 ] , the normalized flow stress at 10% strain in nanocrystalline Cu-%10Ta shows an increase in flow stress with increasing temperature from 298 to 1073 K, highlighting the existence of a non-Arrhenius regime of deformation. In Cu-%20Zn, an increase in critical stress for twining is reported at 50<T<300 K [ 7 ] . Takeuchi and Kuramoto [ 8 ] show that the flow stress in Ni under different strain rates increases for T<700K . In Cu 3 Au, the CRSS value increases for T<660 K [ 9 ] due to cross-slip and diffusion processes that also lead to dynamic strain aging [ 10 ] . Parkhomenko and Pustovalov [ 5 ] show that in Al-based alloys, there is an abrupt increase in yield stress at T<30 K, and the same trend is observed in single-crystal Ag at T<75 K. Also, Fusenig and Nembach [ 11 ] show that in Cu-Co alloys, an increasing trend in CRSS with T<200 K occurs. Shim et al. [ 12 ] state that this behavior at 200 K and below needs to be understood. To the best of our knowledge, none of the mentioned studies have found a clear answer to this behavior. In this work, we study thermally activated dislocation glide and observe that activation entropy can help explain this anomalous behavior of the flow stress. In a seminal work, Granato and Luke [ 13 , 14 ] developed a theory of damping due to dislocations modeled as long vibrating strings L and line tension \Gamma , and the frequency response is classified based on small and large damping effects. Relying on a modified Granato-Lücke [ 14 ] string model, Churochkin et al. [ 15 ] studied the contribution to the low-frequency internal friction (IF) and the thermal conductivity of vibrating edge dislocation dipoles and showed that the presence of a reasonable density of vibrating dipoles provides a good fit to the thermal conductivity in superconducting samples, although, the internal friction experiments cannot be described within the standard fluttering string mechanism. Grabowski and Zotov [ 16 ] studied thermally-activated screw dislocation dipole mobility in Nb using accelerated MD at constant temperature and strain. Bitzek and Gumbsch [ 17 ] conducted atomistic simulations to investigate the effects of drag and inertia on an accelerating edge dislocation. They determined the Peierls stress and the effective mass of an edge dislocation across various temperatures and stresses within a simple slab geometry. Cerrai and Freidlin [ 18 ] established a large deviation principle for the Langevin equation with strong damping, describing the asymptotic behavior of the system as the damping parameter tends to zero. By simulating a 1-D shock impact problem, Blaschke and Luscher [ 19 ] assessed the significance of accurately modeling dislocation drag and dislocation density evolution under high-stress conditions. The simulations, which utilize a temperature, pressure, and character-dependent dislocation drag coefficient derived from first principles, indicate that the temperature dependence of dislocation drag results in a slight increase in the elastic precursor amplitude in single-crystal Al. In the study of IF of dislocations in ultra-low carbon bake-hardenable steel [ 20 ] , the dislocation segment length is found to be the main parameter affecting the IF peak amplitude. In addition to metallic materials, the movement of the edge dislocation dipoles in 2D structures can affect the mechanical properties of planar graphene at high temperatures, where it is found that annihilation of dipoles with arm length l>$16\text{\,}\mathrm{\SIUnitSymbolAngstrom}$ can easily occur at high temperatures employing MD simulations [ 21 ] . In an author’s recent study, it is shown that the activation entropy depends on both temperature and stress, and governs the rates for dislocations overcoming a long-range interaction with prismatic sessile loops at high stresses near \tau_{CRSS} [ 22 ] . Wang and Cai [ 23 ] resolved the discrepancy between TST and MD in the prediction of cross-slip of screw dislocations, pointing out that the source of large activation entropy is from anharmonic effects, although they use harmonic transition state theory to estimate the rate. Also, it has been reported that the critical Escaig stress on the glide plane for dipole annihilation rapidly decreases from the 0 K value of approximately 400 MPa in face-centered cubic (FCC) Cu and Ni, making dipole annihilation nearly athermal at room temperature [ 24 ] . A recent study using classical and machine-learned potentials shows a huge difference between harmonic and anharmonic approximation for the dislocation velocity [ 25 ] . Furthermore, entropic stabilization under tension and non-Arrhenius behavior at high temperatures was found for dislocation nucleation at free surfaces in Cu [ 26 ] . One way to determine the role of Langevin friction in the dislocation glide mechanism is to compute the rate at which a dislocation overcomes an energetic barrier. In 1940, Kramers [ 1 ] employed the Langevin equation to compute the rate of the system over a barrier, analyzing a one-dimensional model of a particle jumping over a double-well potential. This analysis provided insight