Countering Underproduction of Peer Produced Goods

Kaylea Champion and Benjamin Mako Hill Department of Communication, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington · 2025

Read Countering Underproduction of Peer Produced Goods by Kaylea Champion and Benjamin Mako Hill Department of Communication, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-21240.txt.

Introduction

Popular but shoddy corners of Wikipedia do get attention, and a 2025 study by Kaylea Champion and Benjamin Mako Hill shows whose hands do the fixing. Peer-produced goods, from encyclopedias to open software, suffer underproduction: high demand paired with low quality, because volunteers pick their own tasks.

The team tracked years of English Wikipedia edits. Experienced contributors, including those editing without an account, gravitated toward underproduced articles. A within-person analysis showed individual editors drifted toward such pages over time rather than away. Keeping contributors around, the authors argue, is itself a remedy for underproduction. Retention, not just recruitment, is what steers free labor toward need.

Catalog record

CREATORKaylea Champion and Benjamin Mako Hill Department of Communication, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE36 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-21240

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Countering Underproduction of Peer Produced Goods Kaylea Champion and Benjamin Mako Hill Department of Communication, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington Abstract Peer produced goods such as online knowledge bases and free/libre open source software rely on contributors who often choose their tasks regardless of consumer needs. These goods are susceptible to underproduction : when popular goods are relatively low quality. Although underproduction is a common feature of peer production, very little is known about how to counteract it. We use a detailed longitudinal dataset from English Wikipedia to show that more experienced contributors—including those who contribute without an account—tend to contribute to underproduced goods. A within-person analysis shows that contributors’ efforts shift toward underproduced goods over time. These findings illustrate the value of retaining contributors in peer production, including those contributing without accounts, as a means to counter underproduction. keywords Peer production; knowledge gaps; computer-supported cooperative work; anonymity; privacy; collaboration; underproduction; public goods 1 Introduction Peer production is a collaborative technology-assisted process in which participants select and perform tasks in a self-directed way, then combine their work with others [ 5 ] . Peer production plays a critical role in today’s information ecosystem. From web servers to programming languages, Internet infrastructure is largely peer produced [ 12 ] . Much of the content we consume online is also peer produced. Peer produced websites such as Wikipedia, Reddit, and Fandom are among the most visited sites on the Internet. 1 1 1 https://perma.cc/K5VM-V99E Peer produced content includes map data, search results, digital assistants responses, AI training data, and more [ 36 ] . How do producers’ choices of what to make correspond to what consumers want to use? In a market-driven system, supply and demand are aligned via price. But in commons-based peer production, no such signal is available. This can lead to underproduction : the production of high-interest but low-quality goods [ 55 ] . This project seeks to understand the association between contributor experience, account use, and task selection. We first examine what is known about how tasks are selected to provide the rationale for several hypotheses. We then describe the setting, data, measures, and analytical plan. Next, we share empirical results. Finally, we discuss the limitations and implications of our results before concluding. 2 Background 2.1 Commons-based Peer Production and Underproduction Commons-based peer production is a term coined by Yochai Benkler to describe an emerging form of cooperative production made possible by new communication technology. Tasks are self-selected and combined through technology, resulting in information public goods. Examples of peer production include free/libre open source software (FLOSS) projects like GNU/Linux and Apache, Wikipedia, and OpenStreetMap (OSM). Benkler, [5] argues that because individuals know their interests, knowledge, availability, and skills, peer production creates the potential for diminished separation between producers and consumers and that self-assignment to tasks supports efficient matching between contributors and tasks. One way to assess the success of a peer production project is to examine how well it meets the needs of its users. Warncke-Wang et al., [55] found that over 40% of views to English Wikipedia were to articles that were lower quality than one might expect given their popularity. Countries, religions, LGBT topics, psychology, pop and rock music, the Internet and technology, comedy, and science fiction were found to be disproportionately affected. The misalignment of quality and public interest in these topics is concerning because of their relevance to public affairs and modern culture. To quantify misalignment, Warncke-Wang et al., [55] propose that if a system is aligned, goods in the highest demand should be the highest quality while those in the lowest demand should be the lowest quality. When quality is low relative to demand, goods are described as underproduced . When quality is high relative to demand, they are overproduced . Although overproduction may not be harmful beyond the potential for wasted effort, underproduction can impact public knowledge goods and digital infrastructure [ 9 , 12 ] . 2.2 Motivation, Experience, and Task Selection To understand the sources of underproduction, we must consider why people participate in peer production. Studies have observed a range of motivations. Some are motivated to create public goods [ 8 ] , to address social issues [ 34 ] , to help other community members [ 58 ] , to enhance their own use of a public good [ 30 , 37 ] , to enhance their reputation or qualifications [ 49 , 60 , 39 ] , as an experience of self-efficacy [ 61 ] , as a professional responsibility [ 14 ] , for personal enjoyment and learning [ 14 ] , out of reciprocity [ 60 ] , for a class assignment [ 35 , 59 , 11 , 28 ] , or as part of their job [ 18 ] . The results of this body of literature suggest that contributor motivation in peer production tends to be complex and multidimensional and primarily, although not exclusively, intrinsic [ 6 , 43 , 4 , 31 ] . To the extent that peer production contributors do so because they are told to (e.g., by an employer or instructor in a class), extrinsic rewards and others’ interests may be primary motivators. For example, contributing to Wikipedia is an increasingly common assignment in college classes where instructors are driven by concerns about content gaps or their commitment to public goods [ 35 , 59 , 28 ] , or by a desire to have students engage with their coursework in public [ 17 ] . Firms may encourage their employees to contribute to FLOSS to enhance the firm’s use of the public good or to build their reputation [ 18 ] . Nonprofit organizations also encourage contributions to peer production projects as part of their missions. Examples include the Missing Maps project by the Red Cross and Doctors Without Borders encouraging contributions to OSM [ 21 ] , partnerships encouraging contributions to FLOSS projects targeting climate change, 2 2 2 e.g., Climage Triage https://perma.cc/9R8F-QQYY and galleries, libraries and museums partnering with Wikipedia [ 27 ] . Some non-profits seek to counter content and participation gaps in peer production. For example, WikiEdu supports instructors using Wikipedia in their course assignments to close content gaps [ 56 ] . The Outreachy initiative aims to increase diversity in open source [ 1 ] . Within this complex motivational landscape, contributor task selection varies across users and within users over time. In their examination of OSM contributors, Budhathoki and Haythornthwaite, [8] reported that high-volume contributors were likelier to seek community recognition, while low-volume mappers reported wanting to contribute to a free and open project. In contrast, Shah, [47] showed that FLOSS contributors describe their first contributions as directly related to personal skills, needs, and priorities, while longer-term participants report working for the good of the project. Likewise, Bryant et al., [7] found that while Wikipedia editors reported participating within their areas of expertise initially, they sought to build the Wikipedia community and serve the public good over time. Restivo and van de Rijt, [44] found that the highest-volume contributors produce more after receiving informal social rewards, while lower-volume contributors did not and may even respond negatively to the same awards.

Read the complete text