The inner structure and thermodynamics of a thin accretion disc 2025 The inner structure and thermodynamics of a thin accretion disc – B
Amelia M. Hankla, Jason Dexter · 2025
Read The inner structure and thermodynamics of a thin accretion disc 2025 The inner structure and thermodynamics of a thin accretion disc – B by Amelia M. Hankla, Jason Dexter (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-21207.txt.
Introduction
Amelia Hankla and Jason Dexter probe thin discs of gas falling onto fast spinning black holes, in a study from 2025. They use large three dimensional models that track light and heavy gas parts on their own terms, with a rule for how the light parts cool.
The models show the cold thin disc turns into a thick hot flow at a point set by how fast mass falls in. At high rates the change sits close to the hole; at mid rates it sits farther out. Much cooling comes from above the disc face. The results bear on how X ray sources shift state and how spin is gauged.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Amelia M. Hankla, Jason Dexter |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 57 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-21207
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The inner structure and thermodynamics of a thin accretion disc 2025 The inner structure and thermodynamics of a thin accretion disc – B Amelia M. Hankla, Jason Dexter Abstract Using three-dimensional general relativistic magnetohydrodynamic simulations with electron and proton thermodynamics, we probe the inner radial and vertical structure of weakly magnetized geometrically thin accretion discs around rapidly spinning black holes. We find that the thin, cold disc transitions to a thick, hot accretion flow at a radius dependent on the mass accretion rate. At high accretion rates, the disc truncates close to the innermost stable circular orbit r ≈ 2 r g r\approx 2r_{g} , demonstrating that even in the canonical thin disc model, the plunging region should be treated with two-temperature physics. At intermediate accretion rates, the transition radius moves outward by a factor of two to r ≈ 5 r g r\approx 5r_{g} , forming a radiatively inefficient inner flow. The simulations also reveal extended cooling along the surface of the disc out to ∼ 10 r g \sim 10r_{g} , with 40% of the total cooling at intermediate accretion rates occurring above the disc body. These results have implications for X-ray binary state transitions and the physical origin of the X-ray corona. 1 Introduction Geometrically thin, optically thick accretion discs ( Shakura & Sunyaev 1973 ; Novikov & Thorne 1973 ) are generally thought to power luminous black hole X-ray binaries (XRBs) and active galactic nuclei (AGN). Thin disc models assume that the disc electrons efficiently radiate the viscously dissipated energy that heats both electrons and protons. The protons in thin disc models cool due to efficient Coulomb collisions with electrons enabled by high densities. Standard models often assume that the flow truncates abruptly at the innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO), with no dissipation or radiation inside of that radius. However, observations ( Fabian et al. 2020 ) , analytic models ( Gammie 1999 ; Agol & Krolik 2000 ) , and numerical simulations ( Noble et al. 2009 ; Zhu et al. 2012 ; Avara et al. 2016 ; Dhang et al. 2025 ) have suggested that magnetic torques may result in dissipation and non-negligible amounts of radiation coming from within the plunging region. These models have implicitly assumed that the electrons and protons remain well-coupled within the ISCO, despite hints to the contrary ( Zhu et al. 2012 ) . Analytic estimates showed that electrons and protons may decouple within the ISCO, potentially explaining the >10 keV tail observed in the soft state of XRBs ( Hankla et al. 2022 ) . Numerical simulations have attempted to realize global models of a thin accretion disc using general relativistic ideal magnetohydrodynamics (GRMHD). Since the disc cools by radiation, such simulations have either used approximate forms of radiative transfer ( Liska et al. 2022 ) or idealized the cooling as a source term that removes thermal energy from the gas ( Shafee et al. 2008 ; Noble et al. 2009 ; Penna et al. 2010 ) . These prescriptions often assume perfect coupling between electrons and ions by treating the gas as a single fluid. In some cases, radiation is then postprocessed onto the disc to calculate predictions for XRB spectra ( Kinch et al. 2020 ) . Two-temperature thin discs that evolve electrons as a separate fluid ( Ressler et al. 2015 ) have been mainly studied in the context of strong magnetic fields at high accretion rates, where magnetic torques cause the thin disc to transition to a hot flow at small radii ( Liska et al. 2022 ) . Proton-electron coupling through Coulomb collisions plays an important role in accretion-rate-dependent models for XRB state transitions. In the “disc truncation” model, the thin accretion disc transitions to a hot accretion flow at radii \gg r_{\rm ISCO} at intermediate accretion rates ( Esin et al. 1997 ; Done et al. 2007 ) . Whereas the soft state of XRBs is well described by a cold, thin disc, the hard state likely originates from photons Compton scattering off a geometrically thick, optically-thin accretion flow ( Narayan & Yi 1994 ; Yuan & Narayan 2014 ) . Geometrically thick, optically-thin accretion flows have low densities, inefficient Coulomb coupling, and therefore very little proton cooling. In these discs, the electron cooling does not influence the disc structure, motivating the evolution of a single-temperature flow whose proton-to-electron temperature ratio and thus radiation is calculated during postprocessing ( Mościbrodzka et al. 2009 ) . GRMHD simulations that treat radiation through Monte Carlo methods have previously suggested that electron dynamics become important at accretion rates higher than expected by analytic models ( Ryan et al. 2017 ) , potentially even collapsing the hot flow to a thin disc ( Dexter et al. 2021 ) . Because of the difficulty in treating both radiation and thermodynamics, the transition from thick to thin disc has only been studied in local context or with a pre-determined truncation radius. Radiation in particular becomes difficult to model in these intermediate accretion rate regimes. Monte Carlo methods become computationally intractable as the photon optical depth increases the number of scatterings, whereas treating radiation as a fluid in optically-thin regions may not accurately treat anisotropic and non-local Compton cooling. Therefore, numerical simulations have attempted to access this radial transition by putting in the transition by hand and examining the resulting structure ( Hogg & Reynolds 2017 ; Hogg & Reynolds 2018 ) . A complementary approach is to examine the vertical structure alone using local shearing box simulations. Although these simulations have found vertical decoupling of protons and electrons ( Bambic et al. 2024 ) , by their nature they cannot probe a radial transition in the accretion disc structure. In this work, we allow Coulomb collisions to determine the disc vertical and radial structure by treating radiation as an electron-only cooling function. By removing energy from the electron fluid rather than the total gas, protons cool exclusively through Coulomb energy exchange. This electron cooling function therefore forms a thin disc at high densities and a thick disc at low densities, allowing for the possibility of disc truncation. We describe the implementation of the electron cooling function and implicit treatment of Coulomb collisions in Sec. 2 . We then examine the impact of two-temperature thermodynamics on a canonical thin accretion disc, showing that even at high accretion rates, the plunging region decouples into a two-temperature flow (Sec. 3.1 ). Next, we introduce a suite of simulations that probe the accretion disc’s radial structure as a function of accretion rate, finding that the disc transitions to a thick flow at r\gtrsim r_{\rm ISCO} for intermediate accretion rates (Sec. 3.2 ). Finally, we discuss implications for observing emission from the plunging region in canonical thin discs, XRB state transitions, and the nature of the X-ray corona in Sec. 4 . 2 Methods The simulations in this work use nubhlight ( Miller et al. 2019 ) , an extension of the public GRMHD code ebhlight ( Ryan et al. 2015 ; Ryan et al. 2017 ) , which solves the general relativistic ideal magnetohydrodynamic equations using the HARM scheme ( Gammie et al. 2003 ; Noble et al. 2006