Simulating Heterogeneity within Elastic and Inelastic Discrete Mechanical Models

2025

Read Simulating Heterogeneity within Elastic and Inelastic Discrete Mechanical Models (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-20861.txt.

Introduction

Raisinger, Zhang, Bolander, and Eliáš compared two ways of building unevenness into computer models of materials in twenty twenty-five. Such models break a material into rigid blocks joined by contacts, and real materials are never perfectly uniform.

In the standard approach, the unevenness comes from the shapes and layout of the blocks themselves. In the second approach, the layout stays regular but each contact gets a randomly varied strength. The team compared both styles in stretch tests and in breaking tests. The random version could match the overall response after tuning, but the stress patterns inside and the way cracks formed stayed clearly different. The wavy stress pattern of the shaped layout could not be copied by random strengths. The authors say experiments on real materials are needed to judge which view is right.

Catalog record

YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE63 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-20861

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Simulating Heterogeneity within Elastic and Inelastic Discrete Mechanical Models Abstract Two approaches to incorporate heterogeneity in discrete models are compared. In the first, standard approach, the heterogeneity is dictated by geometrical structure of the discrete system. In the second approach, the heterogeneity is imposed by randomizing material parameters of the contacts between the rigid bodies. A similar randomization strategy is often adopted in continuous homogeneous models. The study investigates both the elastic and fracture behaviors of these model types, and compares their local and macroscale responses. It is found that the stress oscillations present in the standard discrete models built on heterogeneous geometric structures cannot be replicated by randomization of the elastically homogeneous discrete system. The marginal distributions and dependencies between the stress tensor components cannot be adequately matched. Therefore, there is a fundamental difference between these two views on discrete models. The numerical experiments performed in the paper showed that an identical response can be achieved at the macroscale by tuning the material parameters. However, the local behavior, fracturing, and internal dependencies are quite different. These findings provide insight into the potential for controlled random assignment of heterogeneity in homogeneous models. They also demonstrate the need for experimental data capable of verifying the correctness of such an approach. Journal: Engineering Fracture Mechanics \auth [1]Jan Raisinger \auth [2]Qiwei Zhang \auth [2]John E. Bolander \auth [1]Jan Eliáš A contact area \mathbf{c} vector from particle node to integration point \mathbf{C} covariance matrix d damage scalar \mathbf{e} strain vector \hat{}\mathbf{e} vector of eigenstrain E macroscopic elastic modulus E_{0} contact elastic parameter \mathbf{f} external forces f_{\mathrm{eq}} elastic limit in given straining direction f_{\mathrm{t}} tensile strength at mesoscale G_{\mathrm{t}} mesoscale fracture energy in tension \hat{}\mathbf{I} projection tensor l contact length \mathbf{n} unit vector of normal reference system \mathbf{t} traction vector \mathbf{u} displacement vector V rigid-body volume \mathbf{x} coordinates in global ref. system \alpha contact elastic parameter \bm{\upvarepsilon} macroscopic strain vector \bm{\mathcal{E}} Levi-Civita tensor \varepsilon_{V} volumetric strain \bm{\uptheta} rotation vector \bm{\uplambda} vector of eigenvalues \nu macroscopic Poisson’s ratio \bm{\upxi} vector of independent random number from standard normal dist. \bm{\upsigma} stress tensor \chi constitutive history variable \bm{\uppsi} matrix of eigenvectors 1 Introduction Discrete models, particularly particle-based lattice models, have been successful in modeling the complex fracture behavior of concrete and other materials with heterogeneous internal structure. There are many types of these models, starting from classical regular and irregular lattice models [ 46 , 45 , 59 ] and early particle-based models [ 6 , 29 , 9 , 40 ] , up to modern discrete systems with complex constitutive features [ 38 , 35 , 25 , 26 ] . The most prominent of them is arguably the Lattice Discrete Particle Model (LDPM), which has been successfully used for various structural configurations and loading scenarios [ 12 , 7 , 60 ] . Nowadays, discrete mechanical models are often coupled with other physical or chemical phenomena [ 37 , 36 , 57 ] . In contrast to continuum descriptions of material behavior, most particle-based discrete models use vectorial constitutive relations defined at the contacts between neighboring particles, which are assumed to be rigid. The irregular geometry and vectorial constitutive functions give rise to local stress oscillations [ 58 ] that can be considered beneficial or unfavorable depending on the goals of the analysis, as described hereafter. Tessellation of the domain into rigid bodies can be either (i) based on the actual or virtual heterogeneity of the material or (ii) done arbitrarily without consideration of material features. The former approach, called physical discretization in Ref. [ 8 ] , may be considered as the standard way of building these models. The stress oscillations are then viewed as an advantage allowing, for example, to realistically simulate the failure of concrete under general forms of loading, including compression [ 11 ] , which for some applications is an essential capability. Such models, however, cannot represent the condition of elastic uniformity and restrict the range of possible values of macroscopic Poisson’s ratio [ 17 ] . Moreover, the stress oscillations arising from the model heterogeneity have never been compared against any experimental data. The notion that they represent actual material behavior is yet to be validated. The latter, non-physical tessellation concept is not related to any material structure. It is understood as an artificial, purely numerical discretization. Therefore, any stress oscillations due to mesh geometry are inappropriate. Two main approaches, the volumetric-deviatoric decomposition of the constitutive functions [ 13 ] and the auxiliary stress projection method [ 3 , 2 ] , have been developed to eliminate the stress heterogeneity and accurately control the macroscopic Poisson’s ratio. Both approaches exploit information from the neighborhood of a given nodal site, differing from classical lattice models that involve only two node interactions. The resulting material is elastically homogeneous, which can be beneficial when modeling individual phases or fine-grained matrices of cement-based composite materials [ 27 ] , for example. However, the complexity of the model response and its ability to represent heterogeneous media are impaired. The material heterogeneity can be introduced by some form of randomization which can be advantageously controlled independently of the discretization strategy. This approach has been used in conjunction with finite element analyses of concrete materials and structures, where property variations are introduced on an elemental basis or at each integration point [ 10 ] . With respect to particle-based lattice models, heterogeneity in the form of stiffness variations was introduced for elastic stress analysis [ 58 ] . With sufficient grid resolution, the resulting stress fields are independent of the grid size and geometry. The present article extends this research to different forms of randomization, their properties, and potential implications for both elastic and fracture analyses. This latter modeling approach is identical to strategies employed in continuous homogeneous models that use randomization as a way to incorporate heterogeneous nature of the material. The two modeling approaches are conceptually very different and, as will be shown in the present paper, provide very different local results. Nevertheless, they exhibit identical, or at least similar, macroscopic behaviors so far. Essential questions arise: 1. What are the differences embedded in these representations of heterogeneity both in elastic and fracture domains? 2. Is it possible to control the imposed randomization in such a way that the stress oscillations correspond to those from the former approach? 3. If not, which of the approaches is closer to reality? The present paper elaborates on the first two questions only. The third question is not answered because decisive experimental data is not available. Comparisons with physical test results can follow when techniques for measuring the response quantities of interest, e.g., stress variations at the material scale, become accessible, and the corresponding data are sufficiently available. Answering these questions is not interesting only for discrete model users. As already mentioned, spatial randomization is also used in homogeneous continuous models to bring some form of material heterogeneity. Learning about correctness of such an approach in discrete models can be extended to finite element calculations. 2 Modeling framework The three-dimensional discrete models considered herein are built at the meso-scale, where the aggregate inclusions and cementitious binder are viewed as distinct phases of the composite material. Spherical aggregates are generated

Read the complete text