Cavity Field-Driven Symmetry Breaking and Modulation of Vibrational Properties: Insights from the Analytical QED-HF Hessian
Alberto Barlini, Andrea Bianchi, Jan Haakon Melka-Trabski, Julien Bloino, Henrik Koch · 2025
Read Cavity Field-Driven Symmetry Breaking and Modulation of Vibrational Properties: Insights from the Analytical QED-HF Hessian by Alberto Barlini, Andrea Bianchi, Jan Haakon Melka-Trabski, Julien Bloino, Henrik Koch (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-20707.txt.
Introduction
Alberto Barlini and co-authors study molecules inside optical cavities in a 2025 chemistry paper. When a molecule sits in a tiny mirrored space, it can couple strongly to the light field trapped there. That coupling can change how the molecule vibrates and even break its symmetry, opening new behaviours.
The team derived and coded a key calculation tool for this setting, the Hessian of a quantum electrodynamics method. With it, they analysed three molecules, from small formaldehyde to larger adamantane. The cavity shifted vibration frequencies and intensities in each case. It also switched on infrared transitions that symmetry normally forbids. The authors present strong coupling as a dial for tuning molecular properties without changing the molecule itself.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alberto Barlini, Andrea Bianchi, Jan Haakon Melka-Trabski, Julien Bloino, Henrik Koch |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 38 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-20707
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Cavity Field-Driven Symmetry Breaking and Modulation of Vibrational Properties: Insights from the Analytical QED-HF Hessian Alberto Barlini, Andrea Bianchi, Jan Haakon Melka-Trabski, Julien Bloino, Henrik Koch Abstract In this work, we present the analytical derivation and implementation of the quantum electrodynamics Hartree–Fock Hessian. We investigate how electronic strong coupling influences molecular vibrational properties, applying this framework to formaldehyde, p-nitroaniline, and adamantane. Our analysis reveals cavity-induced changes in vibrational frequencies and intensities. Additionally, we show how the quantum electromagnetic field breaks molecular symmetry, activating previously forbidden infrared transitions. Our findings highlight the potential of strong coupling as a method for controlling and modulating molecular vibrational properties. keywords American Chemical Society, L a T e X † † affiliation: Scuola Normale Superiore, Pisa, Italy † † affiliation: Scuola Normale Superiore, Pisa, Italy † † affiliation: Department of Chemistry, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, Norway † † affiliation: Scuola Normale Superiore, Pisa, Italy † † email: [email protected] † † affiliation: Department of Chemistry, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, Norway † † abbreviations: ab initio QED, polaritonic chemistry, QED response theory, strong coupling, molecular properties 1 Introduction Computing the analytical Hessian is essential for an accurate and numerically stable description of the vibrational properties and for identifying stationary points on the potential energy surface, enabling the detailed analysis of vibrational spectra and providing deeper insight into chemical reaction pathways. Significant effort has been directed towards developing theoretical methods and algorithms to evaluate the Hessian using various approximate wave function methods, which rely on the analytical second derivatives of the electronic energy Pulay 1969 ; Bishop and Randic 1966 ; Stanton and Gauss 2000 ; Handy et al. 1985 ; Harrison et al. 1986 ; Jørgensen and Helgaker 1988 ; Helgaker et al. 1989 ; Koch et al. 1990 ; Kállay and Gauss 2004 ; Gauss and Stanton 1997 ; Gauss and Stanton 2000 . In the strong light-matter coupling regime, interactions between molecules and confined electromagnetic fields form hybrid light-matter states known as polaritons. Theoretical descriptions of these effects are based on quantum electrodynamics (QED) extensions of electronic structure methods, including QED density functional theory (QEDFT/QED-DFT) Ruggenthaler et al. 2014 ; Pellegrini et al. 2015 , QED Hartree–Fock (QED-HF) Haugland et al. 2020 ; DePrince 2021 , strong coupling QED Hartree-Fock (SC-QED-HF) Riso et al. 2022 ; El Moutaoukal et al. 2024 , second-order QED Møller-Plesset perturbation theory (QED-MP2 and SC-QED-MP2) Bauer and Dreuw 2023 ; Moutaoukal et al. 2025 , QED complete active space configuration interaction (QED-CASCI) Vu et al. 2024 , QED density matrix renormalization group method (QED-DMRG) Matoušek et al. 2024 , and QED coupled cluster theory (QED-CC) Haugland et al. 2020 ; Mordovina et al. 2020 ; Pavosevic and Flick 2021 . These methods provide a framework for studying cavity-induced modifications to ground and excited-state molecular properties. Castagnola et al. 2025 Recent studies have explored cavity-induced effects on molecular geometries and infrared (IR) spectra under vibrational strong coupling (VSC) Schnappinger and Kowalewski 2023 ; Schnappinger et al. 2023 ; Huang and Liang 2025 and electronic strong coupling (ESC) Lexander et al. 2024 ; Lexander et al. 2025 . However, the theoretical framework and analytical evaluation of the QED-HF Hessian for polaritons remain unexplored. Here, we present the derivation and implementation of the analytical QED-HF Hessian and apply it to cavity-molecule systems to investigate how light-matter interactions influence vibrational properties and IR spectra under ESC. We choose three prototypical systems to explore different aspects of the cavity effects, starting from a planar system, formaldehyde, a standard benchmark molecule. p -nitroaniline (PNA) is a typical "push-pull" molecule with an electron-donor group NH 2 and an acceptor group NO 2 . Given the high sensitivity of this system due to its large dipole moment, we expect significant cavity-induced modifications in its vibrational properties. Finally, adamantane, with its rigid and spherical-top structure and T {}_{\text{d}} symmetry, provides an ideal system for exploring symmetry-breaking effects induced by the cavity field. As the quantum electromagnetic field modifies the electronic potential energy surface, nuclear motion is consequently altered, leading to changes in the IR spectra. Our results reveal how cavity interactions modify vibrational modes, leading to frequency shifts and intensity modulation in the IR spectra. This paper is organized as follows: in Section 2 , we derive the QED-HF Hessian expression. In Section 3 , we discuss its implementation and validation. In Section 4 , we report the results for the investigated systems. Finally, in Section 5 , we provide our concluding remarks. 2 Theory 2.1 QED Hamiltonian In the Born-Oppenheimer approximation, the interaction between light and matter in the dipole approximation is described by the Pauli-Fierz Hamiltonian, which, in its length-gauge form, is given by Mandal et al. 2020 ; Frisk Kockum et al. 2019 \displaystyle\begin{split}H_{\text{PF}}&=H_{\text{M}}+\sum_{\alpha}\omega_{\alpha}b^{\dagger}_{\alpha}b_{\alpha}+\sum_{\alpha}\sum_{pq}\sqrt{\frac{\omega_{\alpha}}{2}}(\bm{\lambda}_{\alpha}\cdot\mathbf{d})_{pq}(b_{\alpha}+b^{\dagger}_{\alpha})E_{pq}\\ &+\frac{1}{2}\sum_{\alpha}\sum_{pqr}(\bm{\lambda}_{\alpha}\cdot\mathbf{d})_{pr}(\bm{\lambda}_{\alpha}\cdot\mathbf{d})_{rq}E_{pq}+\frac{1}{2}\sum_{\alpha}\sum_{pqrs}(\bm{\lambda}_{\alpha}\cdot\mathbf{d})_{pq}(\bm{\lambda}_{\alpha}\cdot\mathbf{d})_{rs}e_{pqrs},\end{split} (1) where H_{\text{M}} denotes the molecular Hamiltonian \displaystyle H_{\text{M}}=T^{\text{nuc}}+V^{\text{nuc}}+H^{\text{el}}, (2) T^{\text{nuc}} is the nuclear kinetic energy, V^{\text{nuc}} is the nuclear repulsion energy, and H^{\text{el}} is the electronic hamiltonian \displaystyle H^{\text{el}}=\sum_{pq}h_{pq}E_{pq}+\frac{1}{2}\sum_{pqrs}g_{pqrs}e_{pqrs}, (3) with h_{pq} and g_{pqrs} denoting the one- and two-electron integrals, respectively. In eqs 1 and 3 , the electronic operators are defined as follows \displaystyle\begin{split}E_{pq}&=\sum_{\sigma}a^{\dagger}_{p\sigma}a_{q\sigma},\\ e_{pqrs}&=E_{pq}E_{rs}-\delta_{rq}E_{ps},\end{split} (4) where the indices p , q , r , and s refer to molecular orbitals, and a^{\dagger}_{p\sigma} and a_{p\sigma} are the creation and annihilation operators for an electron in orbital p with spin \sigma . The strong-coupling Hamiltonian in eq 1 includes the quantum electromagnetic field energy, the light-matter interaction explicitly correlating the field and electrons, and the dipole self-energy terms, which ensure the Hamiltonian is bounded from below Rokaj et al. 2018 . Here, the annihilation and creation operators b_{\alpha} and b^{\dagger}_{\alpha} are introduced for photons in mode \alpha , with frequency \omega_{\alpha} and polarization vector \bm{\lambda}_{\alpha} \displaystyle\bm{\lambda}_{\alpha}=\sqrt{\frac{2\pi}{\varepsilon_{r}V_{\alpha}}}\bm{\varepsilon}_{\alpha}, (5) where \varepsilon_{r} , V_{\alpha} , and \bm{\varepsilon}_{\alpha} are the relative permittivity, the quantization volume, and the polarization unit vector, respectively. The total dipole moment operator in eq 1 is defined as \displaystyle\sum_{pq}\mathbf{d}_{pq}=\sum_{pq}\left(\mathbf{d}^{\text{el}}_{pq}+\frac{\mathbf{d}^{\text{nuc}}_{pq}}{N_{e}}\delta_{pq}\right)E_{pq}, (6) where \mathbf{d}^{\text{el}}_{pq} and \mathbf{d}^{\text{nuc}}_{pq} represent the electronic and nuclear dipole moments, respectively, and N_{e} is the number of electrons. 2.2 QED-HF model In the QED-HF model, the wave function is expressed as \displaystyle\ket{\text{QED-HF}}=\ket{\text{HF}}\otimes\ket{\text{P}}, (7) where \ket{\text{HF}} denotes a single Slater determinant, and \ket{\text{P}} is the photon state defined as \displaystyle\ket{\text{P}}=\sum_{\mathbf{n}}\prod_{\alpha}\left(b_{\alpha}^{\dagger}\right)^{{n}_{\alpha}}\ket{0}c_{\mathbf{n}}, (8) where \ket{0} represents the photonic vacuum state, c_{\mathbf{n}} are the coefficients for the expansion in photon number states, and \mathbf{n}=(n_{1},n_{2},\ldots) corresponds to the state with n_{\alpha} photons in mode \alpha . The orbitals in the HF reference are optimized using an orthogonal transformation, defined as \exp(-\kappa) , where \kappa is an antisymmetric one-electron operator, and the QED-HF energy is minimized with respect to the photon coefficients by diagonalizing the photonic Hamiltonian through an orthogonal coherent state transformation Haugland et al. 2020 \displaystyle U=\prod_{\alpha}\exp\left(-\frac{\bm{\lambda}_{\alpha}\cdot\expectationvalue{\mathbf{d}}}{\sqrt{2\omega_{\alpha}}}\left(b_{\alpha}-b_{\alpha}^{\dagger}\right)\right), (9) where \displaystyle\expectationvalue{\mathbf{d}}=\matrixelement{\text{HF}}{\mathbf{d}}{\text{HF}} (10) is the expectation value of the total dipole moment operator \mathbf{d} . The transformation of the Hamiltonian in eq 1 gives \displaystyle\begin{split}H&=U^{\dagger}H_{\text{PF}}U\\ &=H^{\text{el}}+\sum_{\alpha}\omega_{\alpha}b^{\dagger}_{\alpha}b_{\alpha}+\sum_{\alpha}\sum_{pq}\sqrt{\frac{\omega_{\alpha}}{2}}(\bm{\lambda}_{\alpha}\cdot(\mathbf{d}-\expectationvalue{\mathbf{d}}))_{pq}(b_{\alpha}+b^{\dagger}_{\alpha})E_{pq}\\ &+\frac{1}{2}\sum_{\alpha}\sum_{pqr}(\bm{\lambda}_{\alpha}\cdot\mathbf{d})_{pr}(\bm{\lambda}_{\alpha}\cdot\mathbf{d})_{rq}E_{pq}-\sum_{\alpha}\sum_{pq}(\bm{\lambda}_{\alpha}\cdot\expectationvalue{\mathbf{d}})(\bm{\lambda}_{\alpha}\cdot\mathbf{d})_{pq}E_{pq}\\ &+\frac{1}{2}\sum_{\alpha}\sum_{pqrs}(\bm{\lambda}_{\alpha}\cdot\mathbf{d})_{pq}(\bm{\lambda}_{\alpha}\cdot\mathbf{d})_{rs}e_{pqrs}+\frac{1}{2}\sum_{\alpha}(\bm{\lambda}_{\alpha}\cdot\expectationvalue{\mathbf{d}})^{2}.\end{split} (11) In the coherent-state basis, the reference wave function becomes \displaystyle\ket{\text{R}}=\prod_{\alpha}\exp\left(-\frac{\bm{\lambda}_{\alpha}\cdot\expectationvalue{\mathbf{d}}}{\sqrt{2\omega_{\alpha}}}\left(b_{\alpha}-b_{\alpha}^{\dagger}\right)\right)\exp\left(-\kappa\right)\ket{\text{QED-HF}}, (12) and the QED-HF energy is invariant with respect to the choice of molecular origin, even for charged molecules. The energy expression may be written as \displaystyle E_{\text{QED-HF}}=E_{\text{HF}}+\sum_{\alpha}\sum_{ai}\left(\bm{\lambda}_{\alpha}\cdot\mathbf{d}_{ai}\right)^{2} (13) where the labels i and a indicate occupied and virtual orbitals,