A citation index bridging Hirsch’s h h and Egghe’s g g
Ruheyan Nuermaimaiti, Leonid V. Bogachev, Jochen Voss · 2025
Read A citation index bridging Hirsch’s h h and Egghe’s g g by Ruheyan Nuermaimaiti, Leonid V. Bogachev, Jochen Voss (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-20600.txt.
Introduction
Ruheyan Nuermaimaiti, Leonid Bogachev, and Jochen Voss introduce a citation score in 2025 that sits between two famous ones. The h-index counts a researcher's broadly cited papers; the g-index rewards a few huge hits more. Their new index, called nu, is proven to fall between the two. That makes it a bridge for comparing scholars whose records lean either way.
The idea extends into a family of scores indexed by a dial. At one end the family reproduces the h-index; at the chosen point it gives nu. At the far limit it depends only on the single most-cited paper. The paper offers a fresh lens for research evaluation debates.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ruheyan Nuermaimaiti, Leonid V. Bogachev, Jochen Voss |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 19 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-20600
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A citation index bridging Hirsch’s h h and Egghe’s g g Ruheyan Nuermaimaiti, Leonid V. Bogachev, Jochen Voss Abstract We propose a citation index ν \nu (“nu”) and show that it lies between the classical h h -index and g g -index. This idea is then generalized to a monotone parametric family ( ν α ) (\nu_{\alpha}) ( α ≥ 0 \alpha\geq 0 ), whereby h = ν 0 h=\nu_{0} and ν = ν 1 \nu=\nu_{1} , while the limiting value ν ∞ \nu_{\infty} is expressed in terms of the maximum citation. 1. Introduction Hirsch 2005 made a breakthrough in scientometrics by proposing for the first time a simple citation index (commonly referred to as h -index ), which had an advantage of aggregating the author’s productivity on the basis of both the number of published papers and their quality. Before that, only some extensive summary statistics were used, such as the mean number of citations per paper. Since then, the h -index has become a standard metric of authors’ reputation and productivity, for instance routinely taken into consideration in academic appointments and promotions. Specifically, the h -index is defined as the maximum number h of an author’s papers, each cited at least h times ( Hirsch 2005 ) . Therefore, this index only takes into account the fact of a relatively “high” citation of a paper, but the actual number of citations of such a paper is effectively ignored. To remedy such censoring of larger citations, the alternative citation index (referred to as g -index ) was proposed by Egghe 2006a , defined as the maximum number g of an author’s most cited papers, such that their total number of citations is at least g^{2} . From this definition, it is easy to see that h\leq g ( Egghe 2006b ) . These two (by now classical) indexes have attracted a lot of interest and generated ample research into their analytic properties and performance on real datasets, including their estimation in a variety of statistical models of count data (see, e.g., Egghe & Rousseau 2006 ; Egghe 2006b ; Egghe & Rousseau 2008 ; Yong 2014 ). Furthermore, many modifications and alternative variants of the h and g indexes have been proposed, focusing on certain features of the citation profile (see, e.g., Alonso et al. 2009 ; Guns & Rousseau 2009 ; Hirsch 2019 and further references therein). An up-to-date online resource SCI2S 2025 is especially useful by keeping track of the state-of-the-art in this domain. In the present work, we introduce a new citation index \nu (“nu”) aiming to bridge the mathematical definitions of Hirsh’s h and Egghi’s g . This idea was first coined in Nuermaimaiti 2023 . Namely, we start by observing that the h -index can be represented as a sum of certain indicator functions that censor papers to ensure a required minimum of citations. Building on this observation, our \nu -index essentially mimics the summative nature of the h -index but the new summation explicitly involves the citation numbers of the top papers. We are then able to show that our \nu is “sandwiched” between h and g ; more precisely, we prove the two-sided inequalities h\leq\nu\leq g^{*}, (1) where g^{*} denotes a modified (unconstrained) g -index, obtained if we are allowed to add fictitious zeros to the citation vector ( Woeginger 2008b ) . On the other hand, a “tempered” version \bar{\nu} of the \nu -index, modified so as to be not larger than the number of published papers, satisfies the inequalities h\leq\bar{\nu}\leq g. (2) We will finish off by introducing a more general family of citation indexes (\nu_{\alpha}) , where \nu_{\alpha} is a non-decreasing (integer-valued) function of a real parameter \alpha\geq 0 . Here, h=\nu_{0} and \nu=\nu_{1} , while the limiting value \nu_{\infty} can be expressed in terms of the maximum citation. Concluding remarks will touch upon evaluation of citation indexes in specific frequency models using the concept of limit shape ( Nuermaimaiti et al. 2021 ; Bogachev et al. 2023 ; Nuermaimaiti 2023 ; Yong 2014 ) . 2. The h and g indexes Let us fix some notation. Suppose that an author has published m\geq 1 papers, with the ordered numbers of citations x_{1}\geq x_{2}\geq\dots\geq x_{m} , where x_{i}\geq 0 are integers (possibly zero). We call \bm{x}=(x_{1},x_{2},\dots,x_{m}) the citation vector . Note that n=\sum_{i=1}^{m}x_{i} is the total number of citations. A zero vector \bm{0}=(0,\dots,0) represents the degenerate case of no citations (note that the variable dimension of this vector is determined by the number of published papers). We say that a vector \bm{x}=(x_{1},\dots,x_{m}) is dominated by a vector \bm{y}=(y_{1},\dots,y_{\ell}) (written as \bm{x}\preccurlyeq\bm{y} ) if x_{i}\leq y_{i} for all i\geq 1 ; more precisely, if m\leq\ell then x_{i}\leq y_{i} for i=1,\dots,m , but if m>\ell then x_{i}\leq y_{i} for i=1,\dots,\ell and x_{i}=0 for i=\ell+1,\dots,m . Effectively, these two cases imply that we complement the absent components of either \bm{x} or \bm{y} with fictitious zeros to equalize their dimensions, and then the dominance holds component-wise. The following natural conditions are commonly assumed to be satisfied by any reasonable citation index c(\bm{x}) (see Woeginger 2008b ; cf. Woeginger 2008a ): (C1) If \bm{x}=\bm{0} then c(\bm{x})=0 . (C2) If \bm{x}=(x_{1},x_{2},\dots,x_{m}) and \bm{y}=(x_{1},x_{2},\dots,x_{m},0) then c(\bm{x})=c(\bm{y}) . (C3) If \bm{x}\preccurlyeq\bm{y} then c(\bm{x})\leq c(\bm{y}) . Let us now recall the above verbal definitions of the h and g indexes and put them into an explicit mathematical formulation. Starting with the h -index, its definition can be expressed as follows, h\equiv h(\bm{x})=\max\left\{j\geq 1\colon\!\sum_{i=1}^{m}{\bf 1}_{\{x_{i}\geq j\}}\geq j\right\}\!, (3) where the indicator notation {\bf 1}_{A_{j}} is defined as {\bf 1}_{A_{j}}=1 if the condition A_{j} is satisfied, and {\bf 1}_{A_{j}}=0 otherwise. Note that the maximum in ( 3 ) is uniquely defined, since the sum on the left-hand side is a decreasing function of j , while the right-hand is strictly increasing. Thus, the sum in ( 3 ), for a given j , represents the number of papers with at least j citations, while the inequality requires that this number is not smaller than j . In particular, noting that the sum of indicators in ( 3 ) is not larger than m , it follows that the h -index is bounded by the number of papers: h\leq m. (4) In the degenerate case with x_{i}\equiv 0 (i.e., \bm{x}=\bm{0} ), the inequality in ( 3 ) is only satisfied for the value j=0 , which is excluded from the testing range; thus, the resulting set of suitable j ’s is empty and, according to the common convention, its maximum is set to be zero: \max\varnothing=0 ; hence h(\bm{0})=0, (5) so that property (C1) is automatically satisfied. It is also easy to see that (C2) holds (because h is insensitive to zero citations) and that (C3) is also true. Next, the definition of the g -index can be written mathematically as follows, g\equiv g(\bm{x})=\max\left\{1\leq k\leq m\colon\sum_{i=1}^{k}x_{i}\geq k^{2}\right\}\!. (6) Note that if \bm{x}=\bm{0} (i.e., all x_{i}=0 ) then the set under the max-symbol is empty, in which case, by the same convention, we define the maximum as zero. That is to say, the g -index for the zero citation vector equals zero: g(\bm{0})=0. (7) Also note that, because the testing range of