Jets: Hard-soft correlation - Theory overview
\firstname Ismail \lastname Soudi \fnsep · 2025
Read Jets: Hard-soft correlation - Theory overview by \firstname Ismail \lastname Soudi \fnsep (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-20499.txt.
Introduction
Ismail Soudi gives a theory overview of hard-soft correlation in jets, the narrow sprays of particles made when heavy ions collide. The paper appeared in 2025 and sums up recent advances shown at the Hard Probes 2024 meeting. Hard processes are the violent, high-energy parts of a collision; soft processes are the gentle parts. How the two talk to each other shapes what detectors see, in big ion collisions and small systems alike. Soudi reviews the newest models linking the two regimes.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | \firstname Ismail \lastname Soudi \fnsep |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 13 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-20499
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Jets: Hard-soft correlation - Theory overview \firstname Ismail \lastname Soudi \fnsep Abstract Overview of recent theoretical advances presented at Hard Probes 2024 in the study of hard-soft correlation in heavy ion collisions and small systems. 1 Introduction The measurement of QCD jets have been one of the main driving force in the study of high-energy nuclear collisions. In p - p collisions, jets are used to understand fundamental properties of proton structure and to test perturbative QCD. In heavy-ion collisions, the observation of jet quenching is a strong signature of Quark-Gluon-Plasma (QGP) formation. By studying this modification of jets, we hope to probe the properties of the QGP. Due to the large momentum transfer, hard processes occur during short times scales, producing hard partons at early stages of the collision. These hard partons originate with high virtuality which lead to a vacuum-like fragmentation lowering their virtuality. While these fragments are directly detected as collimated jets in vacuum, in the presence of a medium, they must pass through the plasma before reaching the detector. This interaction with the medium leads to energy loss and modification of the jet structure. Since the formation of vacuum-like emissions is fast, they are expected to be factorized from medium interactions Caucal:2018dla . However, as the vacuum-like shower evolves, the resolution scale of the medium becomes more relevant. Several works have investigated how the medium can start to affect the vacuum-like shower at later stages of the shower evolution Caucal:2018dla ; Kumar:2019uvu ; Mehtar-Tani:2024jtd . It was shown that the precise moment at which medium interactions become significant is crucial for accurately describing both hard parton suppression and their azimuthal asymmetries Andres:2019eus . Once the parton virtuality scale becomes comparable to medium scales, the medium starts to resolve individual emissions. This leads to scattering with the medium which broaden the jet core. Moreover, due to multiple soft scattering with the medium, the hard partons are driven slightly off-shell which leads to medium-induced radiation. This radiation is the dominant mechanism for energy loss in the medium. In the literature, two primary approaches have been employed to describe jet-medium interactions: A strong coupling approach based on the AdS/CFT correspondence Liu:2006ug , and a weak coupling approach based on perturbative QCD (pQCD) which is the focus of this manuscript. The QGP undergoes a complex evolution with different stages throughout the collision. After reaching local thermal equilibrium, the QGP has been successfully described by hydrodynamical simulations. The energy and momentum deposited by the hard partons in the medium leads to perturbations on top of the hydrodynamical background. In small systems such as p - A and p - p collisions, recent measurements of v_{2} , the elliptic flow coefficient have observed signatures of collective flow reminiscent of heavy ion collisions ATLAS:2017hap ; ALICE:2014dwt ; CMS:2015yux . However, there has been no indication of jet quenching in these systems. Due to limited energy budget in small systems, understanding the correlations between the hard and soft sector is crucial to understanding these recent measurements. 2 Jets in heavy ion collisions Jet-medium interactions can be described using an effective kinetic theory, where the partons are treated as on-shell quasi-particles. The evolution of the phase-space distribution is described by the Boltzmann equation Arnold:2000dr ; Arnold:2001ba ; Arnold:2003rq \displaystyle\left(\partial_{t}+\frac{\bm{p}}{|\bm{p}|}\bm{\nabla}_{x}\right)f_{a}(\bm{p},\bm{x},t)=C_{a}^{2\leftrightarrow 2}[\{f_{i}\}]+C_{a}^{1\leftrightarrow 2}[\{f_{i}\}]\;, (1) At leading order of pQCD, two main processes contribute to the energy loss of hard partons: number conserving elastic scatterings C_{a}^{2\leftrightarrow 2} and radiation induced by the medium which can be resummed into an effective collision term C_{a}^{1\leftrightarrow 2} Arnold:2000dr ; Arnold:2001ba ; Arnold:2003rq . In the weak coupling approach, the process responsible for energy loss are the same that drives the initial highly energetic plasma to local equilibrium Baier:2000sb . Accordingly, the evolution of the medium component f^{\rm med} can itself be described by the same Boltzmann equation. The phase-space distribution can be separated into medium and jet components \displaystyle f(\bm{p},t)=f^{\rm med}(\bm{p},t)+\delta f^{\rm jet}(\bm{p},t)\,. (2) Since the jet is dilute compared to the dense QGP, the jet distribution is treated as a perturbation on top of the medium distribution. The Boltzmann equation can be linearized around the medium, ignoring any subleading jet-jet interactions. Energy loss has typically been studied using MonteCarlo stochastic approaches Zapp:2012ak ; Zapp:2013vla ; Wang:2013cia ; He:2015pra ; Yazdi:2022bru ; Shi:2022rja . In order to describe medium response, one then needs to couple the jet evolution to a hydrodynamical simulations. By introducing a source term in the hydrodynamic simulation, the energy-momentum lost by the jet is deposited in the medium Stoecker:2004qu ; Casalderrey-Solana:2004fdk ; Chaudhuri:2005vc ; Betz:2008ka ; Tachibana:2020mtb . Another approach is to directly solve the linearized Boltzmann equation. This allows the treatment of the full energy cascade from the high energy partons \sim E to medium scales \sim T using the same framework Schlichting:2020lef ; Mehtar-Tani:2022zwf ; Zhou:2024ysb . Static background: Figure 1: Evolution energy distribution with a decomposition into different cone sizes R=0.16,0.32,0.62 and \pi . Figure from Ref. Mehtar-Tani:2024jtd . The evolution of the jet energy distribution D(x)=\int dp\delta(p-xE)p^{3}\delta f(p) , with initial energy E in static equilibrium background is depicted in Fig. 1 . The collinear emissions dominate the energy loss, leading to efficient transport of energy from the hard scales \sim E to the medium scales \sim T without deposition in the intermediate scales. The energy cascade can be described using Kolmogorov-Zakharov Zakharov:1992 wave turbulence characterized by a stationary solution in the intermediate scales D(x)\simeq 1/\sqrt{x} Blaizot:2012fh ; Blaizot:2014bha . Elastic scattering are responsible for the redistribution of the energy deposited in the medium out to large angle. Dynamic background: Recent works have studied the equilibration of jets in a dynamic background where the QGP distribution itself is equilibrating Zhou:2024ysb . Starting with highly occupied plasma, the QGP undergoes a non-equilibrium evolution approaching a viscous hydrodynamics description. The pressure anisotropy of the jet distribution A=\frac{\delta P_{T}-\delta P_{L}}{\delta e/3} is used to characterize the hydrodynamisation. Following jets with different initial momenta with angles \theta with respect to the initial QGP anisotropy. They find that the medium expansion leads to a rapid decrease of the longitudinal pressure P_{L} . The different jets approach the same hydrodynamical limit already at early times. If the medium is large, all the jet fragments will eventually thermalize with the medium at asymptotic times. The only signal of the hard parton will be a change of the thermodynamic variables (e.g. temperature, flow velocity,…). For the case of a static background, the asymptotic energy distribution is obtained by matching the leading order Taylor expansion in the thermodynamic variables of the equilibrium distribution Mehtar-Tani:2024jtd \displaystyle D^{(\rm eq)}_{a/jet}(x,\theta)\simeq \displaystyle\left(1+3\cos\theta\right)\partial_{T}n_{a}(xE)\;. (3) Here \theta is the azimuthal angle of the initial jet momentum and n_{a} is the equilibrium distribution of the medium. This leads to a boosted energy distribution along the jet direction. 3 Jets in small systems In heavy ion collisions, the energy carried by the soft sector is much larger than the hard partons’ energy. This allows the treatment of hard partons as a small perturbation on top of the medium. However, in small systems, the presence of a hard parton with energy \gtrsim 100 GeV significantly alters the remaining energy of the soft bulk. There have been no observation of suppression in