To build or not to build: FCC personal input to the 2026 update of the European Strategy for Particle Physics

Aleksander Filip Żarnecki · 2025

Read To build or not to build: FCC personal input to the 2026 update of the European Strategy for Particle Physics by Aleksander Filip Żarnecki (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-20267.txt.

Introduction

Aleksander Filip Żarnecki wrote a personal contribution in 2025 to the 2026 update of the European Strategy for Particle Physics. The note concerns the Future Circular Collider, a proposed ring collider put forward as CERN's next flagship project. Żarnecki explains that after joining many discussions and contributing to official documents, he concluded those documents do not give the whole picture. His note sets out his concerns about how the strategy update process is being run. It questions the possible choice of the new collider as the field's leading project.

Catalog record

CREATORAleksander Filip Żarnecki
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE17 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-20267

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

To build or not to build: FCC personal input to the 2026 update of the European Strategy for Particle Physics Aleksander Filip Żarnecki Abstract This is my individual contribution to the discussions ongoing on the update of the European Strategy for Particle Physics. After participating in many discussions and contributing to a number of documents being prepared for the ESPP submission, I came to the conclusion that these “official” documents do not give the whole picture. I wanted to express my concerns about the strategy update process and the possible choice of FCC as the next flagship project at CERN. I do hope my short contribution is found relevant by those interested in the strategy update process. 1 Motivation Discussions on the European Strategy for Particle Physics (ESPP) are ongoing since over twenty years. The first Strategy Group was established in June 2004 and, after the community “Open Symposium” held in Orsay, the first strategy document was approved by the CERN Council in July 2006. I participated in the Orsay symposium, I also took part in the 2013 update of the ESPP as a member of the Preparatory Group (nominated by RECFA), contributing to the organization of the second Open Symposium in Krakow and to the strategy drafting session in Erice. I was involved in the preparation of the Polish community input submissions to the initial strategy document and the following updates, including the current one. I participated in numerous discussions on the European strategy at different meetings as well as in many informal ones. I decided to submit this document to share my observations, but also some concerns and objections to the way the strategy update process is ongoing, with other members of our community. I do hope they can also be of interest to people from outside our field, who would like to understand better the way the strategy decisions are made. I first came to the idea of writing this contribution at the seminar on “Future Perspectives in High Energy Physics” organised by the International Committee for Future Accelerators (ICFA) at DESY, Hamburg, in November 2023. During the main panel discussion, CERN Director General (DG) Fabiola Gianotti stated her reason for considering only the FCC as the next flagship project for CERN: “this is the only project which matches the size of CERN community”. I did know that the size of the FCC was one of the main reasons for its wide support at CERN, but I had never expected this to be confirmed so openly, admitting at the same time that the physics case was of secondary importance. Several projects have been presented as possible candidates for the future Higgs/electroweak/top factory. The most advanced are the two circular collider projects, the e + e - Future Circular Collider (FCC-ee) at CERN and the Circular Electron–Positron Collider (CEPC) in China, and the three linear ones: the International Linear Collider (ILC) in Japan, the Compact Linear Collider (CLIC) at CERN and the Cool Copper Collider (C 3 ) in the US. Combined vision of the Linear Collider Facility at CERN has been prepared as an input for the ESPP update [ 1 ] . Circular colliders are limited in the energy reach to about the top pair-production threshold, but their main advantage is the extremely high luminosity at the lowest energy, when running at the Z-pole. Linear colliders on the other hand, allow to extend the energy reach to the TeV scales with polarised beams. The physics case for the future e + e - Higgs factory is considered in many other submissions. I contributed myself to different studies addressing prospects of (linear) e + e - colliders, working in this field since over 20 years. I am convinced that the Linear Collider Facility at CERN [ 2 ] offers the best physics prospects, but I will not discuss it here. I do hope for many fruitful discussions on the subject at the Open Symposium in Venice. Research opportunities at different facilities are to be studied in detail by the Preparatory Group and described in the strategy “Briefing Book”. I do believe that the strategy discussions should focus on the physics case. We should try to make best use of the resources which are at our disposal to optimize the expected progress in our understanding of the Universe. Unfortunately, as I will also try to discuss in the following, the current strategy update process is not entirely based on this approach. 2 Physics case Previous update of the ESPP, adopted by the CERN Council in June 2020, confirmed that the “electron-positron Higgs factory is the highest-priority next collider” [ 3 ] . European Committee for Future Accelerators (ECFA) launched a series of workshops to further explore challenges of the Higgs factory project and bring together different communities, foster cooperation across various existing projects. Three working groups were formed to work on the Physics Potential (WG1), Physics Analysis Methods (WG2) and Detectors (WG3). One of the goals of the study was to extend our understanding of the physics potential of the e + e - machines, which had already been studied for the selected topics in the past, towards the unexplored areas. In 2023, after long discussions within WG1, a list of so called focus topics was defined, eventually published on arXiv in January 2024 [ 4 ] . Defined were high priority targets, where further studies were needed for full understanding of the physics potential of an e + e - Higgs/Top/Electroweak factory. These topics were also to act as “a vehicle for new engagement and collaboration”, extending the community interested in and working on the physics case for the future e + e - machine in general. This was quite an ambitious plan, as full simulation studies based on the K EY 4 HEP framework were strongly encouraged. Considered studies were expected to take up to two years and the final submission of the ECFA study report was planned in December 2025, which looked as a “reasonable assumption for the input date for the strategy process” [ 5 ] . In March 2024, the CERN Council launched the process for the third update of the Strategy. It is clear that Council members had to be informed about the timeline of the ECFA study. Nevertheless, the adopted schedule for the strategy update was much tighter than that assumed in the ECFA study timeline, shortened by almost a year. As a result, many research which were planned within the study, full simulation studies in particular, could not be completed or were completed only partially. Why was the CERN Council so determined to proceed with the fast update of the ESPP, not waiting for the final result of the ECFA study (launched in response to the recommendations of the previous strategy update)? This decision confirmed, in my opinion, that the physics case for the future e + e - machine was not considered very relevant for the strategy update. The other reason could be that the topics selected in the ECFA study were clearly pointing to the importance of the high energy reach. While one focus topic could only be addressed at the Z pole, all remaining ones could clearly

Read the complete text